The Righteous Men

Sam Bourne

HarperCollins/kMsAersThis novel is entirely a work of fiction. The names, characters and incidents portrayed in it are
the work of the author's imagination. Any resemblance to actual persons, living or dead, events or localities is entirely coincidental.

HarperCoIlinsPMMs/zers 77-85 Fulham Palace Road, Hammersmith, London W6 8JB
www.harpercollins.co.uk
Published by HarperCollinsPwWz's/zers 2006 1
Copyright © Jonathan Freedland 2006
The Author asserts the moral right to be identified as the author of this work
Lyrics to God used by permission. Words and Music by John Lennon D 1970 Sony/ATV Music Publishing (UK) Limited. All Rights Reserved. Lyrics to Big Yellow Taxi used by permission. Words and Music by Joni Mitchell © 1970 Sony/ATV Music Publishing (UK) Limited. All Rights Reserved.
A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library
ISBN-13: 978 0 00 720328 4 ISBN-10: 0 00 720328 4
Set in Meridien by Palimpsest Book Production Limited, Polmont, Stirlingshire
Printed and bound in Great Britain by Clays Limited, St Ives plc
All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted, in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise, without the prior
permission of the publishers.
For Sam, born into a family of love.
CHAPTER ONE
Friday, 9.10pm, Manhattan
The night of the first killing was filled with song. St Patrick's Cathedral in Manhattan trembled to the sound of Handel's Messiah, the grand choral master that never failed to rouse even the most slumbering audience. Its swell of voices surged at the roof of the cathedral. It was as if they wanted to break out, to reach the very heavens. Inside, close to the front, sat a father and son, the older man's eyes closed, moved as always by this, his favourite piece of music. The son's gaze alternated between the performers - the singers dressed in black, the conductor wildly waving his shock of greying hair - and the man at his side. He liked looking at him, gauging his reactions; he liked being this close. Tonight was a celebration. A month earlier Will Monroe Jr had landed the job he had dreamed of ever since he had come to America. Still only in his late twenties, he was now a reporter, on the fast track at The New York Times. Monroe Sr inhabited a different realm. He was a lawyer, one of the most accomplished of his generation, now serving as a federal judge on the second circuit of the US Court of Appeals. He liked to acknowledge achievement when he saw it and this young man at his side, whose boyhood he had all but missed, had reached a milestone. He found his son's hand and gave it a squeeze.

It was at that moment, no more than a forty-minute subway ride across town but a world away, that Howard Macrae heard the first steps behind him. He was not scared. Outsiders may have steered clear of this Brooklyn neighbourhood of Brownsville, notorious for its drug-riddled deprivation, but Macrae knew every street and alley. He was part of the landscape. A pimp of some two decades' standing, he was wired into Brownsville. He had been a smart operator, too, ensuring that in the gang warfare that scarred the area, he always remained a neutral. Factions would clash and shift, but Howard stayed put, constant. No one had challenged the patch where his whores plied their trade for years. So he was not too worried by the sound behind him. Still, he found it odd that the footsteps did not stop. He could tell they were close. Why would anybody be tailing him? He turned his head to peer over his left shoulder and gasped, immediately tripping over his feet. It was a gun unlike any he had ever seen - and it was aimed at him.
Inside the cathedral, the chorus were now one being, their lungs opening and closing like the bellows of a single, mighty organ. The music was insistent:
And the glory of the Lord shall be revealed, and all flesh shall see it together: for the mouth of the Lord hath spoken it.
Howard Macrae was now facing forward, attempting to break into an instinctive run. But he could feel a strange, piercing sensation in his right thigh. His leg seemed to be giving way, collapsing under his weight, refusing to obey his orders. I have to run! Yet his body would not respond. He seemed to be moving in slow motion, as if wading through water. Now the mutiny had spread to his arms, which were first lethargic, then floppy. His brain raced with the urgency of the situation, but it too now seemed overwhelmed, as if submerged under a sudden burst of floodwater. He felt so tired. He found himself lying on the ground clasping his right leg, aware that it and the rest of his limbs were surrendering to numbness. He looked up. He could see nothing but the steel glint of a blade.
In the cathedral, Will felt his pulse quicken. The Messiah was reaching its climax, the whole audience could sense it. A soprano voice hovered above them:
If God be for us, who can be against us?
Who shall lay anything to the charge of God's elect? It is God that justifieth, who is he that condemneth?

Macrae could only watch as the knife hovered over his chest. He tried to see who was behind it, to make out a face, but he could not. The gleam of metal dazzled him; it seemed to have caught all the night's moonlight on its hard, polished surface. He knew he ought to be terrified: the voice inside his head told him he was. But it sounded oddly removed, like a commentator describing a faraway football game. Howard could see the knife coming closer towards him, but still it seemed to be happening to someone else.

Now the orchestra was in full force, Handel's music coursing through the church with enough force to waken the gods. The alto and tenor were as one, demanding to know: O Death, where is thy sting? Will was not a classical buff like his father, but the majesty and power of the music was making the hairs on the back of his neck stand to attention. Still staring straight ahead, he tried to imagine the expression his father would be wearing: he pictured him, rapt, and hoped that underneath that blissful exterior there might also lurk some pleasure at sharing this moment with his only son.

The blade descended, first across the chest. Macrae saw the red line it scored, as if the knife were little more than a scarlet marker pen. The skin seemed to bubble and blister: he did not understand why he felt no pain. Now the knife was moving down, slicing his stomach open like a bag of grain. The contents spilled out, a warm soft bulge of viscous innards. Howard was watching it all, until the moment the dagger was finally held aloft. Only then could he see the face of his murderer. His larynx managed to squeeze out a gasp of shock - and recognition. The blade found his heart and all was dark. The mission had begun.
CHAPTER TWO
Friday, 9.46pm, Manhattan
The chorus took their bows, the conductor bowing sweatily. But Will could only hear one noise: the sound of his father clapping. He marvelled at the decibels those two big hands could produce, colliding in a smack that sounded like wood against wood. It stirred a memory Will had almost lost. It was a school speech day back in England, the only time his father had been there. Will was ten years old and as he went up to collect the poetry prize he was sure that, even above the din of a thousand parents, he could hear the distinct handclap of his father. On that day he had been proud of this stranger's mighty oak hands, stronger than those of any man in the world, he was sure. The noise had not diminished as his father, now in his early fifties, had entered middle age. He was as fit as ever, slim, his white hair cropped short. He did not jog or work out: weekend sailing trips off Sag Harbor had kept him in shape. Will, still applauding, turned to look at him, but his father's gaze did not shift. When Will saw the slight redness around his dad's nose he realized with shock that the older man's eyes were wet: the music had moved him, but he did not want his son to see his tears.

Will smiled to himself at that. A man with hands as strong as trees, welling up at the sound of an angels' choir. It was then he felt the vibrations. He reached down to his BlackBerry to see a message from the Metro desk: 'Job for you. Brownsville, Brooklyn. Homicide.'

Will's stomach gave a little leap, that aerobic manoeuvre that combines excitement and nerves. He was on the 'night cops' beat on the Times Metro desk, the traditional blooding for fast-trackers like him. He might be destined to serve as a future Middle East correspondent or Beijing Bureau Chief, ran the paper's logic, but first he would have to learn the journalistic basics. That was Times thinking. 'There'll be plenty of time to cover military coups. First you have to know how to cover a flower show,' Glenn Harden, the Metro editor would say. 'You need to learn people and you do that right here.'

As the chorus basked in their ovation, Will turned to his father with a shrug of apology, gesturing to the BlackBerry. It's work, he mouthed, gathering up his coat. This little role reversal gave him a sneaky pleasure. After years living in the glow cast by his father's stellar career, now it was Will's turn to heed the summons of work.

'Take care,' whispered the older man. Outside Will hailed a cab. The driver was listening to the news on NPR. Will asked him to turn it up. Not that he was expecting any word on Brownsville. Will always did this – in cabs, even in shops or cafes. He was a news junkie; had been since he was a teenager.

He had missed the lead item and they were already onto the foreign news. A story from Britain. Will always perked up when he heard word from the country he still thought of as home. He may have been born in America, but his formative years, between the ages of eight and twenty-one, had been spent in England. Now, though, as he heard that Gavin Curtis, the Chancellor of the Exchequer, was in trouble, Will paid extra attention. Determined to prove to the Times that his talents stretched beyond the Metro desk, and to ensure the brass knew he had studied economics at Oxford, Will had pitched a story to the Week in Review section on only his second day at the paper. He had even sketched out a headline: Wanted: A banker for the world. The International Monetary Fund was looking for a new head and Curtis was said to be the frontrunner. '. . . the charges were first made by a British newspaper,' the NPR voice was saying, 'which claimed to have identified "irregularities" in Treasury accounts. A spokesman for Mr Curtis has today denied all suggestions of corruption.' Will scribbled a note as a memory floated to the surface. He quickly pushed it back down. There were more urgent matters at hand. Digging into his pocket he found his phone. Quick message to Beth, who had picked up his British fondness for texting. With a thumb that had become preternaturally quick, he punched in the numbers that became letters.
My first murder! Will be home late. Love you.
Now he could see his destination. Red lights were turning noiselessly in the September dark. The lights were on the roofs of two NYPD cars whose noses almost touched in an arrowhead shape, as if to screen off part of the road. In front of them was a hastily installed cordon, consisting of yellow police tape. Will paid the fare, got out and looked around. Rundown tenements.
He approached the first line of tape until a policewoman strolled over to stop him. She looked bored. 'No access, sir.' Will fumbled in the breast pocket of his linen jacket. 'Press?' he asked with what he hoped was a winning smile as he flashed his newly minted press card.
Looking away, she gave an economical gesture with her right hand. Go through.
Will ducked under the tape, into a knot of maybe half a
dozen people. Other reporters. I'm late, he thought, irritated.
One was his age, tall with impossibly straight hair and an
unnatural dusting of orange on his skin. Will was sure he
recognized him but could not remember how. Then he saw
the curly wire in his ear. Of course, Carl McGivering from NY1,
New York's twenty-four-hour cable news station. The rest were
older, the battered press tags around their necks revealing their
affiliations: Post, Newsday, and a string of community papers.
'Bit late, junior,' said the craggiest of the bunch, apparently
the dean of the crime corps. 'What kept you?' Ribbing
from older hacks, Will had learned in his first job on the Bergen Record in New Jersey, was one of those things reporters
like him just had to swallow.
'Anyway, I wouldn't sweat it,' Old Father Time from Newsday was saying. 'Just your garden variety gangland killing.
Knives are all the rage these days, it seems.'
'Blades: the new guns. Could be a fashion piece,' quipped
the Post, to much laughter from the Veteran Reporters' Club
whose monthly meeting Will felt he had just interrupted. He
suspected this was a dig at him, suggesting he (and perhaps
the Times itself) were too effete to give the macho business
of murder its due.
'Have you seen the corpse?' Will asked, sure there was a
term of the trade he was conspicuously failing to use. 'Stiff,
perhaps.
'Yeah, right through there,' said the dean, nodding towards
the squad cars as he brought a cup of Styrofoam coffee to
his lips.
Will headed for the space between the police vehicles, a kind
of man-made clearing in this urban forest. There were a couple
of unexcited cops milling around, one with a clipboard, but no
police photographer. Will must have missed that.
And there on the ground, under a blanket, lay the body.
He stepped forward to get a better look, but one of the cops moved to block his path. 'Authorized personnel only from
here on in, sir. All questions to the DCPI over there.'
'DCPI?'
'Officer serving the Deputy Commissioner of Public Information.' As if speaking to a dim-witted child who had forgotten his most rudimentary times tables.
Will kicked himself for asking. He should have bluffed it out.
The DCPI was on the other side of the corpse, talking to the TV guy. Will had to walk round until he was only a foot or two from the dead body of Howard Macrae. He stared hard into the blanket, hoping to guess at the face that lay beneath. Maybe the blanket would reveal an outline, like those clay masks used by sculptors. He kept looking but the dull, dark shroud yielded nothing.

The DCPI was in mid-flow. '. . . our guess is that this was either score-settling by the SVS against the Wrecking Crew, or else an attempt by the Houston prostitution network to take over Macrae's patch.'

Only then did she seem to notice Will, her expression instantly changing to denote a lack of familiarity. The shutters had come down. Will got the message: the casual banter was for Carl McGivering only.
'Could I just get the details?'
'One African-American male, aged forty-three, approximately
a hundred and eighty pounds, identified as Howard
Macrae, found dead on Saratoga and St Marks Avenues at
8.27pm this evening. Police were alerted by a resident of the
neighbourhood who dialled 91I after finding the body while
walking to the 7-Eleven.' She nodded to indicate the store: over there. 'Cause of death appears to be severing of arteries,
internal bleeding and heart failure due to vicious and repeated
stabbing. The New York Police Department is treating this
crime as homicide and will spare no resources in bringing the
perpetrator to justice.'

The blah blah tone told Will this was a set formulation, one all DCPIs were required to repeat. No doubt it had been
scripted by a team of outside consultants, who probably wrote
a NYPD mission statement to go with it. Spare no resources.
'Any questions?'
'Yes. What was all that about prostitution?'
'Are we on background now?'
Will nodded, agreeing that anything the DCPI said could be used, so long as Will did not attribute it to her.
'The guy was a pimp. Well-known as such to us and to everyone who lives here. Ran a brothel, on Atlantic Avenue near Pleasant Place. Kind of like an old-fashioned whorehouse, girls, rooms - all under one roof.'
'Right. What about the fact that he was found in the middle of the street? Isn't that a little strange, no attempt to hide the body?'
'Gangland killing, that's how they work. Like a drive-by shooting. It's right out there in the open, in your face. No attempt to hide the body 'cause that's part of the point. To send a message. You want everyone to know, "We did this, we don't care who knows about it. And we'd do it to you."' Will scribbled as fast as he could, thanked the DCPI and reached for his cell phone. He told Metro what he had: they told him to come in, there was still time to make the final edition. They would only need a few paragraphs. Will was not surprised. He had read the Times long enough to know this was not exactly hold-the-front-page material.
He did not let on to the desk, to the DCPI or to any of the other reporters there that this was in fact the first murder he had ever covered. At the Bergen Record, homicides were rarer fare and not to be wasted on novices like him. It was a pity because there was one detail which had caught Will's eye but which he had put out of his mind almost immediately. The other hacks were too jaded to have noticed it at all, but Will saw it. The trouble was, he assumed it was routine. He did not realize it at the time, but it was anything but.
CHAPTER THREE
Saturday, 12.30am, Manhattan
At the office, he hammered the 'send' key on the keyboard, pushed back his chair and stretched. It was half past midnight. He looked around: most of the desks were empty, only the night layout area was still fully staffed - cutting and slicing, rewriting and crafting the finished product which would spread itself open on Manhattan breakfast tables in just a few hours' time.
He strode around the office, pumped by a minor version of the post-filing high - that surge of adrenalin and relief once a story is done. He wandered, stealing a glance at the desks of his colleagues, bathed only in the flickering light of CNN, on mute.
The office was open plan, but a system of partitions organized the desks into pods, little clusters of four. As a newcomer, Will was in a far-off corner. His nearest window looked out onto a brick wall: the back of a Broadway theatre bearing a now-faded poster for one of the city's longest-running musicals. Alongside him in the pod was Terry Walton, the former Delhi bureau chief who had returned to New York under some kind of cloud; Will had not yet discovered the exact nature of his misdemeanour. His desk consisted of a series of meticulous piles surrounding a single yellow legal pad. On it was handwriting so dense and tiny, it was unintelligible to all but the closest inspection: Will suspected this was a kind of security mechanism, devised by Walton to prevent any snoopers taking a peek at his work. He was yet to discover why a man whose demotion to Metro meant he was hardly working on stories sensitive to national security would take such a precaution.
Next was Dan Schwarz, whose desk seemed to be on the point of collapse. He was an investigative reporter; there was barely room for his chair, all floor space consumed by cardboard boxes. Papers were falling out of other papers; even the screen on Schwarz's computer was barely visible, bordered by a hundred Post-it notes stuck all around the edge. Amy Woodstein's desk was neither anally neat like Walton's nor a public health disaster like Schwarz's. It was messy, as befitted the quarters of a woman who worked under her very own set of deadlines - always rushing back to relieve a nanny, let in a childminder or pick up from nursery. She had used the partition walls to pin up not yet more papers, like Schwarz, or elegant, if aged, postcards, like Walton, but pictures of her family. Her children had curly hair and wide, toothy smiles and, as far as Will could see, were permanently covered in paint. He went back to his own desk. He had not found the courage to personalize it yet; the pin-board partition still bore the corporate notices that were there when he arrived. He saw the light on his phone blinking. A message.
Hi babe. I know it's late but I'm not sleepy yet. I've got a fun idea so call me when you're done. It's nearly one. Call soon. '

His spirits lifted instantly. He had banked on a tip-toed reentry into the apartment, followed by a pre-bed bowl of
Cheerios. What did Beth have in mind?
He called. 'How come you're still awake?'
'I dunno, my husband's first murder perhaps? Maybe it's just everything that's going on. Anyway, I can't sleep. Do you wanna meet for bagels?'
'What, now?'
'Yeah. At the Carnegie Deli.'
'Now?'
I'll get a cab.'
Will liked the idea of the Carnegie Deli as much as, perhaps more than, the reality. The notion of a coffee shop that never slept, where old-time Broadway comedians and now-creaking chorus girls might meet for an after-show pastrami sandwich; the folks reading first editions of the morning papers, scanning the pages for notices of their latest hit or flop, their cups constantly refilled with steaming brown liquid - it was all so New York. He wanted the waitresses to look harried, he liked it when people butted in line - it all confirmed what he knew was a tourist's fantasy of the big city. He suspected he should be over this by now: he had, after all, lived in America for more than five years. But he could not pretend to be a native. He got there first, bagging a table behind a noisy group of middle-aged couples. He caught snatches of conversation, enough to work out they were not Manhattanites, but in from Jersey. He guessed they had taken in a show, almost certainly a long-running musical, and were now completing their New York experience with a past-midnight snack.

Then he saw her. Will paused for a split second before waving, just to take a good look. They had met in his very last weeks at Columbia and he had fallen hard and fast. Her looks could still make his insides leap: the long dark hair framing pale skin and wide, green eyes. One look and you could not tear yourself away. Those eyes were like deep, cool pools - and he wanted to dive in.
He jumped up to meet her, instantly taking in her scent. It began in her hair, with an aroma of sunshine and
dewberries that might once have come from a shampoo, but combined with her skin to produce a new perfume, one that was entirely her own. Its epicentre was the inch or two of skin just below her ear. He only had to nuzzle into that nook to be filled with her.
Now it was the mouth that drew him. Beth's lips were full and thick; he could feel their plumpness as he kissed them. Without warning, they parted, just enough to let her tongue brush against his lips, then meet his own. Quietly, so quietly no one but him could hear it, she let out a tiny moan, a
sound of pleasure that roused him instantly. He hardened. She could feel it, prompting another moan, this time of
surprise and approval.
'You are pleased to see me.' Now she was sitting opposite him, shrugging off her coat with a suggestive wriggle. She saw him looking. 'You checking me out?'
'You could say that.'
She grinned. 'What are we going to eat? I thought
cheesecake and hot chocolate, although maybe tea would be good. . .' Will was still staring at his wife, watching the way her top stretched across her breasts. He was wondering if they should abandon the Carnegie and go straight back to their big warm bed.
'What?' she said, feigning indignation. 'Concentrate!'
His pastrami sandwich, piled high and deluged with
mustard, arrived just as he was telling her about the treatment he had got from the old-timers at the murder scene.
'So Carl whatsisname--'
'The TV guy?'

'Yeah, he's giving the policewoman all this Raymond Chandler, veteran gumshoe stuff--'
'Give me a break here, you know I got a lawyer friend downtown.' 'Exactly. And I'm Mr Novice from the effete New York Times--'

'Not so effete from what I saw a few minutes ago.' She raised her eyebrows.
'Can I get to the end?'
'Sorry.' She got back to her cheesecake, not picking at it like most of the women Will would see in New York, but downing it in big, hearty chunks.
'Anyway, it was pretty obvious he was going to get the inside track and I wasn't. So I was thinking. Maybe I should start developing some serious police contacts.'
'What, drinking with Lieutenant O'Rourke until you fall under the table? Somehow I don't see it. Besides, you're not going to be on this beat long. When Carl whateverhisnameis is still doing traffic snarl-ups in Staten Island, you're going to be covering the, I don't know, the White House or Paris or something really important.'
Will smiled. 'Your faith in me is touching.'
'I'm not kidding, Will. I know it looks like I am because I have a face full of cake. But I mean it. I believe in you.' Will took her hand. 'You know what song I heard today, at work? It's weird because you never hear songs like that on the radio, but it was so beautiful.'
'What was it?'
'It's a John Lennon song, I can't remember the title. But he's going through all the things that people believe in, and he says, "I don't believe in Jesus, I don't believe in Bible, I don't believe in Buddha", and all these other things, you know, Hitler and Elvis and whatever, and then he says, "I don't believe in Beatles. I just believe in me, Yoko and me." And it made me stop, right in the waiting area at the hospital. Because - you're going to think this is so sappy - but I think it was because that's what I believe in.'
'In Yoko Ono?'
'No, Will. Not Yoko Ono. I believe in us, in you and me. That's what I believe in.'
Will's instinct was to deflate moments like this. He was too English for such overt statements of feeling. He had so little experience of expressed love, he hardly knew what to do with it when it was handed to him. But now, in this moment, he resisted the urge to crack a joke or change the subject. 'I love you quite a lot, you know.'
'I know.' They paused, listening to the sound of Beth scraping her cheesecake fork against the plate.
'Did something happen at work today to get you--'

'You know that kid I've been treating?'
'Child X?' Will was teasing. Beth stuck diligently to the rules on doctor-patient confidentiality and only rarely, and in the most coded terms, discussed her cases outside the hospital. He understood that, of course, respected it even. But
it made it tricky to be as supportive of Beth as she was of
him, to back her career with equal energy. When the office
politics at the hospital had turned nasty, he had become
familiar with all the key personalities, offering advice on which
colleagues were to be cultivated as allies, which were to be
avoided. In their first months together, he had imagined long
evenings spent talking over tough cases, Beth seeking his
advice on an enigmatic 'client' who refused to open up or a
dream that refused to be interpreted. He saw himself
massaging his wife's shoulders, modestly coming up with the
breakthrough idea which finally persuaded a silent child to
speak.
But Beth was not quite like that. For one thing, she seemed
to need it less than Will. For him, an event had not happened until he had talked about it with Beth. She appeared able to
motor on all by herself, drawing on her own tank.
'Yes, OK. Child X. You know why I'm seeing him, don't
you? He's accused of - actually, he's very definitely guilty of
- a series of arson attacks. On his school. On his neighbour's
house. He burned down an adventure playground.
'I've been talking to him for months now and I don't think
he's shown a hint of remorse. Not even a flicker. I've had to
go right down to basics, trying to get him to recognize even
the very idea of right and wrong. Then you know what he
does today?'
Beth was looking away now, towards a table where two
waiters were having their own late-shift supper. 'Remember
Marie, the receptionist? She lost her husband last month;
she's been distraught, we've all been talking about it.
Somehow this kid - Child X - must have picked something
up, because guess what he does today? He comes in with a
flower and hands it to Marie. A gorgeous, long-stemmed pink
rose. He can't have just pulled it off some bush; he must have
bought it. Even if he did just take it, it doesn't matter. He
hands Marie this rose and says, "This is for you, to remember
your husband".
'Well, Marie is just overwhelmed. She takes the rose and croaks a thank you and then has to just run to the bathroom,
to cry her eyes out. And everyone who sees this thing, the
nurses, the staff, they're all just tearing up. I come out and
find the whole team kind of, having this moment. And there,
in the middle of it, is this little boy - and suddenly that's
what he looks like, a little boy - who doesn't quite know
what he's done. And that's what convinces me it's real. He
doesn't look pleased with himself, like someone who calculated
that "Hey, this will be a way to get some extra credit".
He just looks a little bewildered.
'until that moment, I had seen this boy as a hoodlum. I
know, I know - I of all people am meant to get past "labels" and all that.' She mimed the quote marks around 'labels',
leaving no doubt that she was parodying the kind of people who made that gesture. 'But, if I'm honest, I had seen him as a nasty little punk. I didn't like him at all. And then he does this little thing which is just so good. You know what
I mean? Just a simple, good act.'
She fell quiet. Will did not want to say anything, just in case there was more. Eventually Beth broke the silence. 'I don't know,' she said, in an 'anyway' voice, as if to signal that the episode was over.
They talked some more, their conversation noodling
between his day and hers. He leaned over several times to
kiss her, on each occasion hoping for a repeat of the openmouthed
treat he'd had before. She was denying him. As she
stretched forward, he could see the bottom of her back and
just a hint of her underwear, visible in the gap between her
skin and her jeans. He loved seeing Beth naked, but the sight
of her in her underwear always drove him wild.
'Check please!' he said, eager to get her home. As they
walked out, he slid his hand under her T-shirt, over the smooth
skin of her back and headed south into her trousers. She was
not stopping him. He did not know that he would replay that
sensation in his hands and in his head a thousand times
before the week was out.
CHAPTER FOUR
Brooklyn, Saturday, 8am
This is Weekend Edition. The headlines this morning. There could be help for homeowners after the Fed's quarter point rise in interest rates; the governor of Florida declares parts of the panhandle a disaster area thanks to Tropical Storm Alfred; and scandal, British style. First, this news . . .
It was eight am and Will was barely conscious. They had not fallen asleep till well past three. Eyes still shut, he now
Wretched an arm to where his wife should be. As he expected,
no Beth. She was already off: one Saturday in four she held
'a weekend clinic and this was that Saturday. The woman's
stamina astounded him. And, he knew, the children and their
parents would have no idea the psychiatrist treating them was operating on a quarter cylinder. When she was with them, she was at full strength.
v Will hauled himself out of bed and headed for the breakfast
table. He did not want to eat; he wanted to see the paper. Beth had left a note - Well done, honey. Big day today, let's have
a good night tonight - and also the Metro section folded open
at the right page. B3. Could be worse, thought Will. 'Brownsville
slaying linked to prostitution', ran the headline over less than
a dozen paragraphs. And, in between, was his by-line. He
had had to make a decision when he first got into journalism;
in fact, he had made it back at Oxford, writing for Cherwell, the student paper. Should he be William Monroe Jr or plain
Will Monroe? Pride told him he should be his own man, and
that meant having his own name: Will Monroe.
He glanced at the front page of the Metro section and then
the main paper to see who among his new colleagues - and
therefore rivals - was prospering. He clocked the names and
made for the shower.
An idea began to take shape in Will's head, one that grew
and became more solid as he got dressed and headed out,
past the young couples pushing three-wheeler strollers or
taking their time over a cafe breakfast on Court Street.
Cobble Hill was packed with people like him and Beth:
twenty- and thirtysomething professionals, transforming
what was once a down-at-heel Brooklyn neighbourhood
into a little patch of yuppie heaven. As Will made for the Bergen Street subway station, he felt conscious that he was
walking faster than everyone else. This was a working
weekend for him, too.
Once at the office, he wasted no time and went straight
to Harden, who was turning the pages of the New York Post with a speed that conveyed derision.
'Glenn, how about "Anatomy of a Killing: the real life of
a crime statistic"?'
I'm listening.'
'You know, "Howard Macrae might seem like just another
brief on the inside pages, another New York murder victim.
But what Was he like? What had his life been about? Why
was he killed?"'
Harden stopped flicking through the Post and looked up.
'Will, I'm a suburban guy in South Orange whose biggest
worry is getting my two daughters to school in the morning.'
This was not hypothetical; this was true. 'Why do I care about
some dead pimp in Brownsville?'
'You're right. He's just some name on a police list. But
don't you think our readers want to know what really happens
when someone gets murdered in this city?'
He could see Harden was undecided. He was short on
reporters: it was the Jewish New Year, which meant the Times newsroom was badly depleted, even by weekend standards.
The paper had a large Jewish staff and now most of them
were off work to mark the religious holiday. But neither did
he want to admit that he had become so tired, even murder
no longer interested him.
'Tell you what. Make a few calls, go down there. See what
you get. If it makes something, we can talk about it.'

Will asked the cab driver to hang around. He needed to be mobile for the next few hours and that meant having a car on stand-by. If he was honest, it also made him feel safer to have the reassuring bulk of a car close at hand. On these streets, he did not want to be completely alone.
Within minutes he was wondering if it had been worth the trip. Officer Federico Penelas, the first policeman on the scene, was a reluctant interviewee, offering only one-word Answers.
'Was there a commotion when you got down here?'
'Nah-uh.'
'Who was here?'
'Just one or two folks. The lady who made the call.' 'Did you talk to her at all?'
'Just took down the details of what she'd seen, when she'd seen it. Thanked her for calling the New York Police Department.' The consultants' script again.
'And is it your job to lay that blanket on the victim?' For the first time, Penelas smiled. The expression was one of mockery rather than warmth. You know nothing. 'That wasn't a police blanket. Police use zip-up body bags. That blanket was already on him when I got here.'
'Who laid it out?'
'Dunno. Reckon it was whoever found the dead guy. Mark of respect or something. Same way they closed the victim's eyes. People do that: they've seen it in the movies.'
Penelas refused to identify the woman who had discovered the corpse, but in a follow-up phone call the DCPI was more forthcoming - on background, of course. At last Will had a name: now he could get stuck in.
He had to walk through the projects to find her. A sixfoot-two Upper East Side guy in chinos and blue linen jacket with an English accent, he felt ridiculous and intensely white as he moved through this poor, black neighbourhood. The buildings were not entirely derelict but they were in bad shape. Graffiti, stairwells that smelled of piss, and plenty of broken windows. He would have to buttonhole whoever was out of doors and hope they would talk.
He made an instant rule: stick to the women. He knew this was a cowardly impulse but, he assured himself, that was nothing to be ashamed of. He had once read some garlanded foreign correspondent saying the best war reporters were the cowards: the brave ones were reckless and ended up dead. This was not exactly the Middle East, but a kind of war whether over drugs or gangs or race - raged on these streets
all the same.
The first woman he spoke to was blank, so was the next. The third had heard the name but could not place where. She recommended someone else until one neighbour was calling out to another and eventually Will was facing the woman who had found Howard Macrae.
African-American and in her mid-fifties, her name was Rosa. Will guessed she was a churchgoer, one of those black women who stop communities like this one from going under. She agreed to walk with him to the scene of the crime.

'Well, I had been at the store, picking up some bread and a soda, I think, when I noticed what I thought was a big lump on the sidewalk. I remember I was annoyed: I thought someone had dumped some furniture on the street again. But as I got closer, I realized this was not a sofa. Uh-uh. It was low down and kind of bumpy.'
'You realized it was a body?'
'Only when I was right up close. until then, it just looked
like, you know ... a shape.'
'It was dark.'
'Yeah, pretty dark and pretty late. Anyway, when I was
standing over it, I thought. That ain't a sofa, that ain't a chair.
That's a body under that blanket.'
'Sorry, I'm asking you to go back to what you saw right
at the beginning. Before the blanket was laid on the corpse.'
'That is what I'm describing. What I saw was a dark blanket
with the shape of a dead man underneath.'
'The blanket was already there? So you were not the first
to find him.' Damn.
'No, I was the first to find him. I was the one who called the police. Nobody else did. It was the first they'd heard of it.'
'But the body was already covered?'
That's right.'
'The police seem to think it was you who laid down the
blanket, Rosa.'
'Well, they're wrong. Where would I get a blanket from
in the middle of the night? Or do you think black folks carry
blankets around with them just in case? I know things are
pretty bad round here, but they're not that bad.' None of this was said with bitterness. 'Right.' Will paused, uncertain where to go next. 'So who did leave that blanket on him?' 'I'm telling you the same thing I told that police officer.
That's the way I found him. Nice blanket, too. Kind of soft.
Maybe cashmere. Something classy, anyway.'

'Sorry to go back to this, but is there any chance at all you were not the first there?'
'I can't see how. I'm sure the police told you. When I lifted that blanket, I saw a body that was still warm. Wasn't even a body at that time. It was still a man. You know what I'm saying? He was still warm. Like it just happened. The blood was still coming out. Kind of burbling, like water leaking from a pipe. Terrible, just terrible. And you know the strangest thing? His eyes were closed, as if someone had shut them.' 'Don't tell me that wasn't you.'
It wasn't me. Never said it was.'
'Who do you think did that - closed his eyes, I mean?' 'You'll probably think I'm crazy, what with the way they knifed that poor man to death, but it was kinda like . . . No, you'll think I'm crazy.'
'Please go on. I don't think you're crazy at all. Go on.'
Will was stooping now, an instinctive gesture. Being tall was
usually a plus: he could intimidate. But right now he did not
want to tower over this woman. He wanted to make her feel
comfortable. He bent his shoulders lower, so that he could
meet her eyes without forcing her to look up. 'Go on.'
'I know that man was murdered in a horrible way. But his
body looked as if it had been somehow, you know, laid to
rest.'
Will said nothing, just sucked the top of his pen.
'You see, I told you. You think I'm crazy. Maybe I am!'
Will thanked the woman and carried on through the projects.
He only had to walk a few blocks to get into real sleaze
country. The boarded-up tenements he knew served as crack
houses; the shifty looks of young men palming off brown
parcels to each other while looking the other way. These were
the people to ask about Howard Macrae.
Will had ditched his jacket by now - a necessary move on
this bright September day - but he was still encountering
major resistance. His face was too white, his accent too
different. Most assumed he was a plain-clothes cop, drugs
squad probably. For those who spotted it, the car following
a few blocks behind hardly helped. Most people started
walking the moment they saw his notebook.
The first crack in the ice came the way it always does from
just one person.
Will found a man who had known Macrae. He seemed
vaguely shifty but, above all, bored, with nothing better to
do than to while away a few daytime hours talking to a
reporter. He rambled on and on, detailing long gone and
wholly irrelevant local disputes and controversies as if they
would be of burning interest to The New York Times. 'You want
to put that in your paper, my friend!' he would say over and
over, with a bronchial, smoker's laugh. Heh-heh-heh. Humouring folks like this was, Will concluded, an occupational
hazard.
'So what about this Howard Macrae?' said Will, when his
new acquaintance finally took a breath during an analysis of
the flawed stop light system on Fulton Street.
It turned out he did not know Macrae that well, but he
knew others who did. He offered to hook Will up with them,
introducing the reporter each time with the priceless character reference: 'He's OK.'
Soon Will was forming a picture. Macrae was a certifiable, card-carrying low-life. No doubt about it. He ran a brothel; had done for years. The sleaze community seemed to have a high regard for him: apparently he was good at being a pimp. He ran a functioning whorehouse, kept it looking all right even took the girls' clothes to the Laundromat. Will got inside, to see the rooms for himself. The best he could say for it was that it was not nearly as disgusting as he had imagined. It looked a bit like a clinic in a poor neighbourhood. There were no needles on the floor. He even noticed a water-cooler. The whores told him the same story. 'Sir, I can't tell you anymo' than what the lady already told you: he sold ass. Tha's what he did. He collected the money, gave some to us, and kept the rest for hisself.'
Howard seemed to have been a contented sort of pimp. The brothel was his domain and he was obviously a genial host. At night, Will discovered, he would put on loud music and dance.
It was late in the evening before Will found what he had been looking for all day: someone genuinely mourning the death of Howard Macrae. Will had contacted the undertakers, who were waiting for the body to be transferred to them from the police morgue. He got the cab to drive over to the funeral home, a rundown place that was depressing even by the standards of the rest of the neighbourhood. Will wondered how many of these 'garden-variety gangland killings' they had to clear up. Only the receptionist seemed to be around, a young black woman with the longest, most outlandishly decorated nails Will had ever seen. They were the only spot of brightness in the entire place.
He asked if anyone had been in touch to organize a funeral for Howard Macrae. Any relatives? No, none. The girl on the desk had the impression Macrae had no family. Will tutted: he needed more personal detail, more colour, if this piece was to work out.
Will pushed harder. Had no one been in touch about Mr Macrae, no one at all? 'Oh, now that you mention it,' said Nail Girl. At last, thought Will. 'There was one woman, called in around lunchtime. Asked when we were going to have the funeral. Wanted to pay her respects.'
She found a Post-it with the woman's details. Will dialled the number there and then. When a woman answered, he said he was calling from the funeral home: he wanted to talk about Howard Macrae. 'Come right over,' she said.
In the cab, Will instantly reached for his BlackBerry, tapping out a quick email to Beth. There was a rhythm to all this electronic communication: BlackBerry by day, when he knew his wife was near a computer terminal, text message by night when she was not.

Quick psychology lesson needed. Need to get interview with woman who knew the victim. Have led her to believe I work for funeral company. Will now have to reveal truth: how do I do that without getting her so angry she throws me out of her house? Need yr considered opinion asap, am just few mins away, xx W
He waited; but there was no reply.
It was twilight when Will tapped on the screen door. A
woman poked her head out of the upstairs window. Early
forties, Will guessed; black, attractive. Her hair was straightened, with an auburn hue. 'Coming right down.'
She introduced herself as Letitia. She did not want to give
her last name.
'Look, my name is Will Monroe and I apologize.' He began
babbling that this was his first big story, that he had only lied
because he was desperate not to let his bosses down, when
he noticed that she was neither doing nor saying anything.
She was not throwing him out, just listening to him with a
faintly puzzled expression. His voice petering out now, he
gave her a pre-cooked line: 'Look, Letitia. This may be the
only way the truth about Howard Macrae will ever come
out.' But he could see it was not needed. On the contrary,
Letitia seemed rather glad to have the chance to talk.
She gestured him away from the front door towards a
living room cluttered with children's toys.
'Were you related to Howard?' he began.
'No,' Letitia smiled. 'No, I only met that man once.' That man. Here we go, thought Will. Now we're going to get the real dirt on this Macrae. 'But once was enough.' Will felt a surge of excitement. Maybe Letitia knows a secret about Macrae dark enough to explain his murder. I'm ahead of the police.
'When was this?'
'Nearly ten years ago. My husband - he'll be back soon was in jail.' She saw Will's face. 'No! He hadn't done anything. He was innocent. But we couldn't pay the bail to get him out. He was in that prison cell night after night. I couldn't bear it. I grew desperate.' She looked up at Will, her eyes hoping that he understood the rest. That she would not have to spell it out.
'Everyone knows there's only two ways to make quick
money round here. You sell drugs or . . .'
Now Will got it. 'Or you sell ... or you go see Howard.'
'Right. I hated myself for even thinking about it. I grew
up singing choir in the AME church, Mr Monroe.'
'Will. I understand.'
'I was raised right. But I had to get my husband out of
that jail. So I went to ... Howard's place.'
Without looking down, Will scribbled in his notebook. Eyes glittering. 'I was going to sell the one thing I owned.' Now she was
tearing up. 'I couldn't even go in, I was sort of hiding in the shadows, hesitating. Howard Macrae spotted me there. I think he had a broom in his hand, sweeping. He asked me what I wanted. Kind of, "Can I help you?" I told him what I wanted. I told him why I needed the money. I didn't want him to
think, you know. And then this man, who I never met before, did the oddest thing.'
Will leaned forward.
'Right there and then, he marched off to what I guessed
was his own room in that . . . place. He unlocked it and,
straight away, he starts stripping the bed.'
'Stripping the bed?'
'Uh-huh. I was scared at first, I didn't know what he was
about to do to me. He put these blankets in a pile, and then he gets to work on his bedside table. Starts packing it up.
Starts unplugging his CD player, takes off his watch. It all goes in this big pile. And then he begins moving all this stuff, shooing me out of the way. Now this bed is one of those
really good ones, big with a deep, strong mattress, like a topof-the-range bed. So it's heavy but he's dragging it and lugging
it, till it's outside. And then he opens up his truck, a real
beat-up old thing, and he loads up the bed - pillows and all
- into the back. Then all the rest of it. I swear, I had no idea what in God's name the man was doing. Then he winds down the window and tells me to meet him just around the block, on the corner of Fulton Street. 'See you there in five,' he
says.
'Well, now I'm mystified. So I walk round the block, just
like the man said. And I see his truck, parked outside a pawn shop. And there's Howard Macrae pointing at all the stuff, and men are coming out the shop and unloading it, and the boss is handing Macrae cash. And next thing I know, Macrae is giving the money to me.'
'To you?'
'Uh-huh. You got it. To me. It was the strangest thing. I
wondered why he didn't just give me some cash, if that's
what he wanted to do, but no, he insists on making this big sacrifice, like he's selling all his worldly goods or something. And I'll never forgot what he said to me as he did it. "Here's some money. Now go bail your husband - and don't become a whore." And I listened to what the man said. I bailed my husband and I never did sell my body, not ever. Thanks to
that man.'
There was a sound at the front door. Will looked around.
He could hear several voices drifting through: three or four young children and a man.
'Hiya honey.'
'Will, this is my husband, Martin. And these are my girls,
Davinia and Brandi and this is my boy - Howard.' Letitia gave Will a firm stare, silencing him. 'Martin, this man is from the newspaper. I'm just seeing him out.'
As they reached the front door, Will whispered. 'Your husband doesn't know?'
'No, and I don't plan on telling him now. No man should know such a thing about his wife.'
Will was about to say he believed the opposite, that most men would be honoured to know their wives were prepared to make such an extreme sacrifice, but he thought better of it.
'And yet his son is called Howard.'
'I told him it was because I always liked the name. But / know the real reason, and that's good enough. Howard is a name my boy can wear with pride. I'm telling you Mr Monroe: the man they killed last night may have sinned every day of his God-given life - but he was the most righteous man I have ever known.'
CHAPTER FIVE

Saturday, 9.50pm, Brooklyn
That night in the kitchen where they did all their talking,
Will followed traditional custom. Beth was cooking pasta, he
was tagging along behind her, washing each pan and spoon
as she finished with them. This was smart strategy, he reckoned:
forward planning, prevent the washing-up mountain
after dinner. Will was talking Beth through his day.
'The guy's a scumbag pimp, but when he sees this woman
in distress, he sells his most personal possessions to help her.
A woman he doesn't even know. Isn't that incredible?'
Beth was stirring, saying nothing.
'I'm not sure what Glenn will make of it, but this woman,
Letitia, felt Macrae had saved her life. That he had saved her. That's something isn't it? I mean, that will make a piece.'
Beth seemed faraway. Will took that as a sign of success,
as if his point had struck home, stunning his wife into contemplative
silence.
'Anyway, enough about that. How was your day?'
Beth looked up, her stirring hand stilled. She held him in
a long, cold gaze.
'Oh Christ, I just realized--' Beth's note from this morning. Big day today. He had read it and forgotten it. Instantly.
Beth said nothing, just waited for him to explain himself. I went straight to work and then I got stuck into this story.
I must have had my phone on silent while I was interviewing
that woman. Did you call?'
'"I just realized." How can you say that? You can't "just
realize" this, Will. That's not how it works. Not this.'
She was speaking with that voice of iron calm which almost
scared Will. It was reserved for when Beth was truly furious.
He imagined she had acquired this kind of steel as part of
her psychological training: never lose your cool. He admired
it in the abstract, but could not bear to be on the receiving
end.
'I've been thinking about nothing else for weeks and you
"just realized". You completely forgot!' Now the volume was
rising. 'You had all day--'
'I was working--'
'You're always working or thinking about work. You don't
even remember what should be the most important thing in
our lives, and I can't eat or sleep or shower or do anything
without thinking about it.' Her eyes were reddening.
'Tell me what they said.'
'You don't get off that easy, Will. If you wanted to know
what they said, you should have come to the hospital with
me. You should have been there with me.'
Each of those last four words were heavy as anchors. Of
course he should. How could he have forgotten? It was true
what she said: he had thought about nothing but this story
from the moment he woke up.
He knew he needed to break out of this procedural stage
of the conversation - why had he missed the appointment?
- and move fast onto the substance: what had the doctors
said? But how to make the shift? There was only one person
he knew who would instantly understand how to pull off
such a conversational manoeuvre, what psychological trick
to play. That person was Beth.
w

'Babe, I am completely in the wrong. I can't believe I
missed that appointment. And I don't deserve to know what
happened. But I really want to. We will talk about this whole
other thing - me obsessing about work I promise. But, right
now, I think you should just tell me what happened.'
She was sitting now, still holding the wooden spoon. In a
barely-audible whisper, as if the air had been sucked out of
her, she finally spoke. 'They didn't examine me; it was just a
"chat". And they said we should keep trying for another three
months before they'll consider treatment.' She sniffed deeply,
reaching for a tissue. 'They said we are both perfectly healthy,
we should give it more time before "taking the next step".'
'That's good news, isn't it?' said Will, half-aware that this
was a tactical error - the premature move into cheer-up mode
before the silent, listening phase was complete. Rationally,
he knew that what Beth needed most was to talk, to get it
all out. Not to have to argue, explain or defend anything. He
knew that in his head, but his mouth had had different ideas,
instantly wanting to make things better.
'No, as it happens, I don't think it is good news, Will. I
don't think it's good news at all. It just makes it more fucking
mysterious. If my eggs are so perfect and your sperm is so
fucking tip-top, why the hell CAN'T WE HAVE A BABY?'
She threw the wooden spoon at the wall, where it splattered tomato sauce into a Jackson Pollock pattern, turned
and fled for the bedroom. Will chased her, but she slammed
the door. He could hear her crying.
How could he have screwed up so badly? He had promised
they would go to the clinic together, that he would take
an hour or two out during the afternoon. Instead he had
gone to work and clean forgot about everything else for the
rest of the day. He had even sent a BlackBerry message about
work - to Beth at the time of the appointment. He
knew what his psychologist wife thought. That he was
throwing himself into his career to avoid dealing with the
real issue: four years of marriage, two years of unprotected sex and one year of serious 'trying' - and still Beth was not pregnant. Will knew it looked like that, but she was wrong. This was not some new phase. He had always been ambitious. Even at college, he had worked hard: when he was
not editing Cherwell he was trying to hawk tales of university life to Fleet Street. That was what he was like.
The phone rang.
'Will?'
'Oh, hi, Dad.'
'I was just calling to see if you enjoyed the concert.' 'Yes, of course. I loved it,' Will said, running his fingers through his hair and facing the floor. How could he have been so stupid? 'I should have called. Amazing choir.' 'You sound subdued.'
'No, just tired. It's been a long day. Remember that thing I was called out on after the concert, that killing? I had this idea to take what everyone thinks is a bog-standard murder and see what really happened. "Portrait of a crime statistic", the life behind the death, that kind of thing.'
Beth's presence behind the slammed door of their bedroom was burning up the apartment. Surely he should be going over there, talking through the door, coaxing her back out. Or at least coaxing his way in.
'That's good thinking. What did you find out?'
'That he was a low-life pimp sleazeball.'
'Well, I guess that's no great surprise. Not in that place. Still, I can't wait to read your IMF piece: much more you, I suspect. Listen, Will, Linda's gesturing. It's a dinner for Habitat
- "you know who" is here - and we're expected to mingle. Speak soon/
Even on his nights off, thought Will, his father and his 'partner' - a word Will could not bring himself to utter except in quotation marks - were doing something morally worthwhile. Habitat for Humanity was one of his father's favourite charities. 'I like the idea of a cause that asks you to give your time and your labour, not just your money,' Monroe Sr had said, more than once. 'They ask you to open your heart, not just your pocketbook.' Hanging in the judge's chambers was a photograph of himself and the former president - 'you know who' - each midway up a ladder, both clad in lumberjack shirts, the ex-president holding a hammer. They were taking part in one of Habitat's trademark events: building a house for the homeless in a single day. In Alabama or somewhere. He
wondered about all this great do-gooding fervour of his father's. In fact, he was suspicious of it. The most cynical reading was that it was merely a career move, designed to burnish William Monroe Sr's image as a man of fine character, eminently suited to a place on America's highest bench. More specifically, Will wondered if his father was trying to improve his chances with the evangelical Christian
constituency that were such key players in the nomination of judges to the Supreme Court. Some of his father's rivals were committed, vocal Christians. A secular liberal like William Monroe Sr could not match that, but if he could smooth out some of his hard, godless edges, it could only help. That, at least, was his son's guess.
Will tiptoed over to the bedroom, creaking the door open just a crack. Beth was fast asleep. He closed the door; recovered what was left of the pasta and ate it from the saucepan. He felt as if a high wall had just appeared in their apartment
- and he and his wife were on opposite sides of it.

He reached for the remote and jabbed on his default
channel: CNN.
'International news now, and more trouble in London for
Britain's finance minister, Chancellor of the Exchequer Gavin Curtis, today under fire from the Church. The Bishop of
Birmingham took to Britain's House of Lords to step up the
pressure.'
Will sat up to take a close look. Curtis looked harried and much older than Will had remembered him. He had come to Oxford when Will was a student. Curtis was then in opposition, shadowing the environment department. He had come up to act as lead speaker in an Oxford Union debate: 'This House believes the end of the world is nigh.' Will was then the news editor on Cherwell - and he had given himself the plum assignment of interviewing the visiting politician. He had not thought about it in years, but at the time Curtis had left quite a mark. He had taken Will seriously, treating him as a real journalist when Will could not have been much more than nineteen. The funny thing was Curtis had not seemed like a politician at all, more like a teacher. He had constantly peppered their conversation with references to books and films, wondering if Will had read some obscure Dutch theologian or seen a new and controversial Polish movie. Will had left their conversation feeling inadequate but also convinced Curtis was destined for oblivion: he seemed too intellectual for the blood sport of high politics. As his former interviewee had risen through the
Cabinet, Will became embarrassed by his own lack of political foresight.
CNN was now showing a clip of a white-haired cleric in a grey suit with just a slice of purple showing underneath. The bishop's face, flushed with wrath, seemed to be trying to match the colour of his shirt. CNN identified him as the leader of the British equivalent of America's Church of the Reborn Jesus, a fiercely moral wing of Christian evangelism. 'This is a sinful man!' he was saying of the Chancellor, to the murmured rhubarb of agreement and disagreement in the chamber. If it is true that he has been embezzling from the public purse, he must be cast out!'
Will turned it off and went to the computer. Beth would sleep till morning now. He thought about waking her up so they could talk some more. They had a rule: never go to bed on a fight. But she was so deeply asleep he would hardly
score any points by disturbing her now. He had seen how
she looked. She could wear a dozen different expressions
in the course of the night: serene, brow furrowed, even
ironic amusement. More than once, Will had been woken by the sound of his wife laughing in her sleep at some secret
joke. But just now, even with her autumn-brown hair falling
over most of her face, he spotted what he feared was a
worry line in her forehead, as if she was concentrating hard.
He imagined smoothing it away, with just a touch of his hand.
Perhaps he should go back in and do just that. No, he thought.
What if she woke up and their row reopened? Better to leave
it be.
Might as well pull an all-nighter instead, write up the
Macrae story and deliver it first thing. At least that would
impress Harden. And it would be an excuse not to go into
the bedroom.
At the keyboard, his mind kept wandering away from
Letitia, Howard and the streets of Brownsville. He knew what
Beth wanted and biology, or something, was standing in their
way. He had been encouraged by the hospital's attitude: give
it time. But Beth was not used to being a patient. She liked
to sit in the other chair. And she wanted clarity: a diagnosis,
a course of action.
Besides, he knew, getting pregnant was only part of the
story. Beth had become irritated by his professional singlemindedness, his determination to make his mark. When they
first met, she would say how much she liked his drive; she
found it sexy. She admired his refusal to coast along, to trade
on his father's prestige. He had made things difficult for himself
- he could have gone back to America when he turned
eighteen and used the family name to breeze into Yale - and
she admired that. Now, though, she wanted the ambition to
cool down. There were other priorities.
He finally crashed out just after four am. He dreamed he
was on a boating lake, pushing a punt like some cheesy gondolier. Facing him, twirling a parasol, was a woman. It was
probably Beth but he could not quite see. He tried squinting, determined to make out the face. But the sun was in his eyes. CHAPTER SIX

Monday, 10.47am, Manhattan
The good sinner: the story of a New York life - and death.
Will stared at it, not on B6 or Bl I or even B3 but Al: the
front page of The New York Times. He had stared at it on the
subway into work, looked at it some more as he walked to
the office and had spent most of the time at his desk pretending
not to look at it.
He had arrived to a bombardment of congratulatory email,
from colleagues sitting three feet away and old friends living
in different continents, who had learned of his feat via the
paper's online edition. He was receiving a plaudit by phone
when he felt a surge move through his little desk-pod, a silent
movement of energy like the magnetic force that passes
through iron filings. It was Townsend McDougal, making a rare descent from Mount Olympus to walk among the troops.
Suddenly backs were stiffened; rictus smiles adopted. Will
noticed Amy Woodstein reflexively reaching round to the back of her head to plump up her hair. The veteran City Life
columnist sought to tidy his desk with a single back-sweep
of his arm, thereby despatching a couple of crumpled Marlboro
packets into his pencil drawer.
The high command at The New York Times was still getting
used to McDougal: appointed as executive editor only a few
months earlier, he was an unlikely choice. His immediate
predecessors had been drawn from that segment of New York
society that had produced so many of the city's best known
names and given it so much of its humour and language:
liberal Jews. Previous New York Times editors looked and
sounded like Woody Allen or Philip Roth.
Townsend McDougal was a rather different proposition. A
New England aristocrat with Mayflower roots and Wasp
manners, he wore a panama hat in summertime and tasselled
loafers in winter. But that was not what had made Times veterans anxious when his appointment was announced. No,
what made the editor and The New York Times an unlikely fit
was the simple fact that Townsend McDougal was a born
again Christian.
He had not yet made Bible study classes compulsory, nor
did he ask reporters to link hands in prayer before each
night's print run. But it was a culture shock for a temple of
secularism like The New York Times. Columnists and critics on
the paper were used to a tone that was not quite mocking
but certainly distant. Evangelical Christianity was something
that existed out there, in flyover country - in the vast midwest
or the deep south between the coasts. None of them
would ever say so explicitly, still less write it, but the undeclared
assumption was that born-again faith was the preserve
of the simple folk. 'Trust in Jesus' was for the women in
polyester trousers watching Pat Robertson on the 700 Club,
or for recovering alcoholics who needed to 'turn around' their
lives and declare their salvation in a bumper sticker. It was
not for Ivy League sophisticates like themselves.
Townsend McDougal unsettled every one of those presumptions.
Now Times journalists had to check the default arithmetic
that stated that secular equalled smart. From now on,
religion would no longer be cast as a matter of poor taste,
like big hair or TV dinners. It was to be treated with respect.
The change, in articles from the fashion pages to the sports section, became apparent within weeks of McDougal's arrival. The new executive editor had not sent out a memo. He did not have to.
Now he was walking among the Metro staff, with his gaze aimed in only one direction.
'Look, I better go,' Will said into the phone in what he hoped was a low whisper. As Will replaced the receiver, McDougal began.
'Welcome to the Holy of Holies, William. The front page of the greatest newspaper in the world.' Will felt himself blush. It was not embarrassment at the compliment, nor even McDougal's klaxon of a voice, bellowing his praise all around the office in an accent that was so Brahmin as to be almost English, though that was embarrassing enough. It was the 'William' that did it. Will thought his father had reached an understanding with McDougal: that there was to be no public acknowledgement of the friendship between them. Will knew he would be resented as it was - the hotshot young journo on the fast track - without his colleagues assuming he was the beneficiary of that old-fashioned career-enhancing drug, nepotism.
Now it was out there; McDougal's decibels had seen to that. The internal emails would be flying: Guess who's on first-name terms with the boss? As it happened, Will had applied for this job the same way as everyone else: sending in a letter and turning up for an interview. But no one would believe that now. He could feel his neck becoming hot. 'You've made a good start, William. Taking some
unpromising raw material and turning it into something worthy of page one. I sometimes wish some of your more mature colleagues would show similar degrees of industry and verve.'
Will wondered if McDougal was deliberately setting out to make his life hell. Was this some kind of initiation rite practised by the Skull and Bones set at Yale, where he and
his father had first become such pals? The editor might as
well have painted a target on Will's back and handed crossbows
to each of his colleagues.
'Thank you.'
I shall be expecting more from you, William. And I shall
be following this story with interest.'
With that, and a swish of his finely tailored grey suit,
Townsend McDougal was gone. The collective posture of the
reporters who had previously been sitting to attention now
slumped. The City Life columnist opened up his top drawer,
reached for his cigarettes and headed for the fire escape.
Will had an equally instant urge. Without thinking, he
dialled Beth's number. After the second ring, he abandoned
it. A call about a triumph at work would confirm everything she had said about him. No, he still had to do penance.
'Now, William.' It was Walton, his chair swivelled round
to face the common space that linked them with Woodstein
and Schwarz. He was looking upward, the lower half of his
face covered with a supercilious smile. He looked like a
malevolent schoolboy.
Despite being nearly fifty years old, there was something
infantile about Terence Walton. He had the unnerving habit
of playing hi-tech computer games while he worked, rattling
the keys as he zapped various alien life forms to 'proceed to
the next level'. His fingers seemed to be in constant search
of distraction; the moment he had finished one phone call,
he would be onto the next. He was always fixing up extracurricular
activities, a radio appearance here, a well-paid
lecture there. His work from Delhi had been highly praised
and he was in fairly regular demand as an expert. His book, Terence Walton's India, was credited with introducing the
American public to a country they barely knew.
Inside the building, Walton was held in slightly lower
esteem. That much. Will had picked up. The seating arrange
ments alone confirmed it: a returned foreign correspondent
placed alongside the Metro staff's newest recruit. It was hardly
star treatment. Quite what Walton had done to deserve this
slight Will did not yet know.
'We were just discussing your front-page triumph. Good
job. Of course, there will be doubters, sceptics, who wonder
what greater light this tale shed, but I am not one of them. No, William, not me.' 'Will. It's Will.'
'The executive editor seems to think it's William. You might
need to have a word with him. Anyway, my question is this:
why, I wonder, should this little story be on the front page?
What larger social phenomenon did it expose? I fear our new
editor does not yet fully understand the sacred bottom left
slot. It's not just for amusing or interesting vignettes. It should
serve as a window onto a new world.'
'I think it was doing that. It was correcting a stereotype
about urban life in this city. This man seemed like a sleaze
ball but he was, you know, better than that.'

'Yes, that's great. And well done! Tremendous job. But
remember what they say about beginner's luck: very hard
to pull off that trick twice. I doubt even you could find too
many "tales of ordinary people"--' he was putting on a
cutesy, Pollyanna-ish voice '--that would interest The New York Times. At least not The New York Times I used to work for. Once counts as an achievement, William; twice would
be a miracle.'
Will turned back to his computer, to his email inbox. Woodstein, Amy. In the subject field: Coffee?
Five minutes later Will was in the vast Times canteen, all
but deserted at this morning hour. He paced up and down
by the glass cases which housed Times merchandise: sweatshirts,
baseball caps, toy models of the old Times delivery
trucks. Amy materialized beside him, clutching a cup of herbal
tea.
'I just wanted to say sorry about all that just now. That's the downside of working here: lot of testosterone, if you know what I mean.'
'It was fine--'
'People are very competitive. And Terry Walton especially.' 'I got that impression.'
'Do you know the story with him?'
'I know he used to be in Delhi and that he was forced to come back.'
'They accused him of expenses fraud. They couldn't prove it, which is why he's still here. But there's certainly some trust issues.'
'About money, you mean?'
'Oh no, not just about money.' She gave a bitter chuckle. 'What else then?'
'Well, look, you didn't hear this from me, OK? But my advice is to lock up your notebooks when Terry's around. And talk quietly when you're on the phone.'
'I don't get it.'
'Terry Walton steals stories. He's famous for it. When he was in the Middle East they called him The Thief of Baghdad.' Will was smiling.
'It's actually not that funny. There are journalists around the world who could talk all night about the crimes of Terence Walton. Will, I'm serious: lock away your notebooks, your documents, everything. He will read them.'
'So that's why he writes like that.'
'What?'
'Walton has this very tiny handwriting, completely indecipherable. That's deliberate, isn't it? To make sure no one
reads his notes.'
'I'm just saying, be careful.'
When he arrived back in the newsroom he found Glenn Harden sticking a Post-it to his screen. 'Come up and see me some time.'
'Ah, here you are. I have a message from National. Go west young man.'
'I'm sorry?'
'To Seattle. Bates's wife is in labour and National need us to cover. Apparently they don't have any reporters of their own, so they've put out the begging bowl.' Harden raised his voice. 'I scraped the bottom of the barrel and offered them Walton, but he's come up with some lame-assed excuse and suggested you.' Walton was on the phone, not listening. 'Talk to Jennifer, she'll fix you a flight.'
'Thank you,' Will stammered, a smile beginning to break on his face. He knew this was a major break, a serious vote of confidence. Sure, it was only cover, only temporary. But Harden would not want Metro disgraced in the eyes of what he regarded as the Ivy League snobs over at National: he would want to show Metro's best face. Will gulped at the thought: that was him.
'Oh and pack your galoshes.'
CHAPTER SEVEN
Tuesday, 10.21am, Washington State
And I have shown you, Jesus Christ is the light and the way. We have seen a miracle today . . .
Christian radio, along with country music, was the one staple you could always rely on: even the remotest backwater, where there were no other stations on the dial, would always be favoured with the word of the gospel, beamed through the air. The mountain passes of Washington State were no different.
He was getting closer to the flood scene, he could tell. The roads were becoming clogged and soon he began to see the flashing lights of emergency teams. Then, most reassuring of all, a fleet of white, liveried satellite trucks: local TV, confirmation that he had arrived at the site of the story.
He hooked up with a photographer who seemed to know what he was doing. For one thing, he had all the right equipment. Not just the regulation photographer jacket, with enough pockets to store the possessions of a nuclear family, but industrial-strength, thigh-high Wellington boots, waterproof trousers, polar ice-cap socks and gloves that
looked as if they were custom-designed by NASA.
Will waded into the flood water after him, conscious of
the chill creeping up his trouser leg. Before long they had
hitched a ride on a police dinghy and were ferrying from
submerged home to submerged home. He saw one woman
winched to safety carrying the thing she valued most: her
cat. Another man was standing, sobbing by his store front,
watching a lifetime's investment wash away like leaves in a
gutter.
A few hours of that and Will was back in the rental car,
soaked and hunched over his keyboard. 'The people of the
Northwest are used to nature's temper - but her latest mood
swing has them reeling,' he began, before detailing the individual
tales of woe. A couple of quotes from officialdom and
a nice closing line about the fickleness of the climate, spoken
by the man who had lost his stationery shop, and it was
done.
Once back in the hotel room, he called Beth. She was
already in bed. She talked about her day; he uncoiled the
full story of his sodden journey into the flood lands. Both of
them were too exhausted to restart the conversation they had never really finished. He flicked on the local news: pictures of the Snohomish
floods; Will picked out faces he recognized. His heart went
out to the reporter doing the live-shot: that meant he was
still there.
'Next up, more on the murder of Pat Baxter. After these
messages.' Will turned back to his computer, only half listening
to the words coming out of the TV.
The victim, fifty-five, found dead and alone in his cabin ... police
suspect a botched break-in . . . much damage, but nothing stolen . . . Baxter had been under surveillance for years . . . was briefly prime suspect in Unabomber case . . . no family, no relatives . . .
Will wheeled around. One word had leapt out. Will Googled
'Unabomber', getting an instant refresher course on a bizarre case which had foxed the FBI for two decades. Someone had sent mail bombs to corporate addresses on the East Coast, leaving behind a trail of obscure clues. Eventually, the culprit released a 'manifesto', a quasi-academic tract which seemed to be the work of a loner with a deep suspicion of technology. He also seemed to harbour a profound loathing of government. There was a piece on The Seattle Times website, just posted.

That sentiment put the Unabomber in tune with an entire
1990s movement, one in which the late Pat Baxter had been a
reliable player. For this was the age of the gun-toting militias - Americans arming themselves against what they believed
was an imminent onslaught by the US government. They
eventually spread throughout America, but they began in the
Pacific Northwest.

Will started working his way through The New York Times' online archive. He was struck by the first pieces that
appeared: quite benign, depicting the militia men as
'weekend soldiers', overweight, overgrown schoolboys
huffing and puffing their way through war games. But soon
the tone changed.
The 1992 stand-off at Ruby Ridge, where a white
supremacist lost his wife and child in a Shootout with federal
agents, like the siege at Waco, Texas a year later, revealed
a world that most Americans - certainly those in media offices in New York - had never heard of. It saw Washington
as the centre of a shadowy, new world order, embodied by
the hated United Nations, which was determined to enslave
free people everywhere. How else to explain the mysterious
black helicopters spotted over rural America? What other
meaning could there be to the numbers on the back of road
signs; surely they were coded co-ordinates that would one
day help the US army herd their fellow citizens into concentration camps?
The more Will read, the more fascinated he became. These civilian warriors believed the craziest theories - about freemasons, the Federal Reserve, coded messages printed on dollar bills, mysterious connections with European banks. Some of them were so sure the jackbooted bureaucrats of the federal government were out to get them that they had retreated into the hills, hiding in mountain cabins in remotest Idaho or wooded Montana. They had severed their links with the government in all its forms: they carried no drivers' licences, they refused to sign any official paper. Some moved, quite literally, off the grid - generating their own power, rather than living off the national electricity system.
And they were not playing games. On the second anniversary of the conflagration at Waco, the Alfred P Murrah federal building in Oklahoma City had shattered into dust, broken up by a mighty car bomb, killing 169 people. The culprits turned out to be not Islamist extremists but all-American boys whose heads had been filled with loathing of their own government.
The Seattle Times had an archive picture of Baxter at a rally in Montana in 1994. Except it looked more like a trade fair, down to the stands where exhibitors showed their wares. Baxter was pictured manning a stall that sold MREs military-style, 'meals ready to eat'. Apparently, he did a fairly
brisk trade in dried foods, portable tents and the like:
survivalist gear that would keep the freedom-loving American in food and shelter during the coming confrontation. In the remote world of the anti-government movement, Baxter was, if not a celebrity, then a fixture.
'He was a great patriot and his death is a great blow to all those who love liberty,' said Bob Hill, a self-styled commandant of the Montana militia.
Wednesday, 9am, Seattle
Worryingly, the phone had not rung. When he finally awoke at nine - noon New York time - he saw that his cell phone was recording no missed calls at all. He reached for his BlackBerry; just some unimportant email. This was not right. He reached for his laptop, pulling it down from the table and onto the bed, stretching its cable to breaking point. He checked the Times site: no sign of his story. He clicked down to the National section: links to stories out of Atlanta, Chicago and Washington, DC. He clicked and clicked. Here was something, datelined Seattle. But it was only an Associated Press
wire story, written that morning. No sign of his own piece. He phoned Beth. The hospital had to page her.
'Hi babe, have you seen the paper today?'
'Yes, I'm fine thank you. How kind of you to ask.'
'Sorry, it's just - have you got it there?'
'Hold on.' A long pause. 'OK, what am I looking for?'
'Anything by me.'
'I looked this morning. I couldn't see anything. I thought maybe you were going to do more work on it today.'
Will tutted silently: of course he wasn't going to work on it today. It was an on-the-day news story, about weather for Christ's sake: there was no more perishable commodity in journalism than a weather story.
'You checked the National section inside? Each page?' 'I did, Will. I'm sorry. Does this mean they didn't use it?' That was exactly what it meant: his story had been spiked. He braced himself for a call to the desk. If anyone but Jennifer, the news clerk, answered, he would hang up. He dialled.
'National/ Jennifer.
'Hi, Jennifer, it's Will Monroe here, out in Seattle.'
'Oh hi. Wanna speak to Susan?'
'No! No. No need. You know that piece I filed yesterday, from the floods? Do you know what happened to it?'
Jennifer's voice suddenly dipped.
'Kind of. I heard them talking about it. They said it was very nice and all, but that you hadn't talked about it with them first. If you had, they'd have told you they didn't need a story yesterday.'
'But I did speak . . .' Of course. He had only talked with Jennifer, told her his co-ordinates and his plans. He had assumed they wanted him to file. Had Harden not told him to pack his galoshes?
Now he realized: he was in Seattle just in case. He was keeping Bates's seat warm. All that soaking effort yesterday had been in vain. He felt embarrassed, like an over-eager intern. It was a stupid mistake.
'Hold on, Susan wants a word.'
Three time zones away, Will readied himself for a roasting. 'Hi, Will. Listen, I think the rule ought to be no filing unless we've talked about it first. OK? Maybe just find something that interests you, poke around a bit and see what it's worth. As for spot-news, keep your phone on and we'll call you if we need anything.'
Will ate a glum breakfast. He had screwed up and screwed up badly. By now Jennifer would have spread the word among the tiny circle of Times staffers in their twenties: they would be having a good laugh at his expense. The golden boy with a big-shot daddy had come down to earth.
There was only one solution. He would have to reel in a proper story. Somehow, from this far-off patch of snow, timber and potatoes, he would have to eke out a tale that would prove to New York that they had not made a mistake. He knew exactly where he would go.
CHAPTER EIGHT

Wednesday, 3.13pm, Washington State
The flight across Washington State had been brief, if bumpy,
and the drive from Spokane gorgeous. The mountains were
almost painfully beautiful, each cap dusted with a snow that
looked like the purest powdered sugar. The trees were as
straight as pencils, lines of them, so densely packed, the light
almost seemed to strobe.
He was driving east, soon crossing the state line into Idaho
-- or at least the long, slender upper part of the state where
the United States appears to be giving the finger to its northern
neighbour, Canada. He drove past Coeur d'Alene, which sounded like a Swiss skiing village but which was most famous
as the home of a racist movement known as the Aryan
Nations. Will had seen the pictures in the cuttings: the men dressed in quasi-Nazi uniforms, the 'whites only' sign at the
entrance. It would make a fascinating stop, but Will did not
leave the road. He had somewhere to go.
His destination lay across the Idaho finger, in the western
part of Montana. The roads were small, but Will did not get
frustrated. He loved driving in America, the land of the endless
road. He loved the billboards, promoting furniture stores
thirty-five miles away; he loved the Dairy Queen rest-stops;
the bumper stickers, advising him of the politics, religion and sexual preferences of his fellow drivers. Besides, he was planning his attack.
He had spoken already to Bob Hill, who was expecting him. Dutifully, Hill had conformed to the media caricature of a backwoods gun-nut. He asked to have Will's full name and social security number: 'That way I can check you out. Make sure y'are who y'say y'are.' Will tried to imagine what Hill's research would turn up on him. Brit? That would be OK. Americans usually liked Brits. Even if they hated limp-wristed, faggot Europeans, Brits were OK: they were kind of honorary Americans. Father a federal judge? That could be problematic; federal officials were despised. But judges were not always lumped in with the rest of the hated bureaucrats who represented 'the government'. Some were even seen as the protectors of liberty, fending off the encroaching hand of the
politicians. If Hill looked, though, he would find plenty in Judge Monroe's record that was bound to offend. Will hoped his host was not going to dig too deep.
What else? Parents divorced: that might rile the militia men. Mind you, this wasn't Alabama; the survivalists were not the same as the Christian right. There was some overlap, but they were not identical.
The daydream ended the moment he saw the signs.
'Welcome to Noxon, Population: 230'. He looked down at the scribbled note perched on his lap: Hill's directions. He had to turn left at the gas station, down a road that would become a path. The SUV began rocking from side to side, over the ruts of mud, earning, or so Will liked to think, the extra charge he, and therefore the Times, had had to pay for it. Soon he reached a gate. No sign. He was about to call Hill, as arranged, but he was halfway through dialling the number when a man became visible in his windshield. Early sixties, jeans, cowboy boots, old jacket; unsmiling. Will got out. 'Bob Hill? Will Monroe.'
'So you found us OK?'
Will went into a hymn of praise for Hill's directions, seeking to break the ice with some shameless flattery. His host grunted his approval as he trudged up a hard mud bank, heading in the direction of what seemed to be a thick patch of forest. As they got closer, Will began to make out a glow of light: a cabin, rather brilliantly camouflaged.
Hill looked to his waist, where a thick jailer's ring of keys was weighing down one of his belt loops. He let them in. 'There's a chair there. Make yourself comfortable. I've got something to show you.'
Will used the few seconds he had to look around: a metal shield on the wall, bearing a vaguely military insignia. He squinted: MoM. Militia of Montana. There were a few framed photographs, including one of his host holding the head of a dead stag. On the metal shelves, a box of leaflets. Will peered inside: 'The New World Order: Operation Takeover.' 'Help yourself, take a copy.' Will whisked around to find Bob Hill right behind him. Ex-marine, Vietnam; of course he would know how to creep up on a mere civilian like Will. 'Wrote it myself. With the help of the late Mr Baxter.' 'So he was . . . deeply involved?'
'Like I told you on the phone, a fine patriot. Ready to do whatever it took to secure the liberty of this nation - even if his nation was too duped, its brains too addled by the propaganda of the Hollywood elite, to realize its liberty was under threat.'

'Whatever it took?'
'By whatever means necessary, Mr Monroe. You know who said that, don't you? Or was that before your time?' 'It was before my time, but I do know. That was the slogan of the Black, Panthers.'
'Very good. And if that was good enough for them in their struggle against "white power" then it's good enough for us in our struggle to keep America free.'
'You mean violence? Force?'
'Mr Monroe, let's not get ahead of ourselves. You can ask me all the questions you like, I got plenty of time. But first, I have something to show you. See if this interests the great East Coast intellectuals of The New York Times.'
By now Hill was seated, behind a battered old metal desk, one that would not have looked out of place in the office section of an auto-repair shop. He handed Will, who was still standing, two sheets of paper, stapled together.
It took a few seconds for Will to work out what he was looking at. The notes on the autopsy performed on the body of Pat Baxter.
'Missoula faxed it over this morning.' Missoula, the nearest big town.
'What does it say?'
'Oh, don't let me spoil it for you. I think you should read it for yourself.'
Will felt a twinge of panic: this was the first autopsy report he had ever seen. It was almost impossible to decipher. Each heading was written in baffling medicalese; the handwriting beneath was just as inscrutable. Will found himself squinting through it.
Finally, a sentence he understood. 'Severe internal haemorrhaging consistent with a gunshot wound; contusions of
the skin and viscera. General remarks: needle mark on right thigh, suggestive of recent anaesthesia.'
'He was shot,' Will began, uncertain. 'And he seems to have been anaesthetized before he was shot. Which does seem very odd, I grant you.'
'Ah, but there's an explanation. Read on, Mr Monroe.' Will's eyes scoured the document, looking for clues. Scribbled handwriting, sent through a fax, did not make it easy. 'Second page,' Hill offered. 'General remarks.'
'Damage to internal organs: liver, heart and kidney (single) severe. Other viscera, fragmented.'
'What leaps out at you, Mr Monroe? I mean what word there friggin' jumps out and grabs you by the throat?' Will wanted to say 'viscera', simply because the word was so undeniably powerful. But he knew that was not the answer Hill was looking for.
'Single.'
'My my, you Oxford boys are as bright as they say you are.' Hill had not been kidding about his research. 'That's right. Single. What do you think's going on here, Mr Monroe? What strange set of facts do we have here which Montana's finest have so far chosen to overlook? Well, I'll tell you.' Will was relieved; the guessing game was making him sweat. 'My friend, Pat Baxter, was anaesthetized before he was killed. And his body is found minus one kidney. Put two and two together and what do we get?'
Will muttered almost to himself, 'Whoever did this removed his kidney.'
'Not only that, but that's why they killed him. They wanted it to look like a robbery, a "break-in gone badly wrong" they're saying on the TV. But that's all a smokescreen. The only thing they wanted to steal was Pat Baxter's kidney.' 'Why on earth would they want to do that?'
'Oh, Mr Monroe. Don't make me do all the work here. Open your eyes! This is a federal government that has been doing experimentation with bio-chips!' He could see that Will was not following. 'Bar codes, implanted under the skin! So that they can monitor our movements. There's good evidence they're doing this with new-born babies now, right there in the maternity ward. An electronic tagging system, enabling the government to follow us from cradle to grave - quite literally.' 'But why would they want Pat Baxter's kidney?'
'The federal government moves in mysterious ways, Mr Monroe, its wonders to perform. Maybe they wanted to plant something inside Pat's body and the plan went wrong. Maybe the anaesthetic wore off and he began resisting. Or perhaps they put something inside his body years ago. And now they needed to get it back. Who knows? Maybe the feds just wanted to examine the DNA of a dissident, see if they could discover the gene that makes a real freedom-loving American and work to eradicate it.'
'It does seem a little far-fetched.'
'I grant you that. But we're talking about a military-industrial complex that has spent millions of dollars on mind-control techniques. You know, they had a secret Pentagon project to see if men could kill goats, simply by staring at 'em? I am not making this up. So it may be far-fetched. But I have come to learn that far-fetched and untrue are two very different things.' Eventually Will steered Hill towards saner shores, seeking the biographical details of Baxter's life that he knew he would need. He got some, including a back story about the dead man's father: turned out Baxter Sr was a Second World War veteran who had lost both his hands. Unable to work, he had grown desperate; he could barely feed his family on his GI pension. Hill reckoned Baxter was a son who grew up resenting a government that could send a young man to kill and die for his country and then abandon him when he came home. When history repeated itself with Baxter's own generation in Vietnam, the bitterness was complete.
That would do nicely, serving as the easy-to-digest, psychological key needed for all good stories, in newspapers no less than at the movies. The piece was beginning to take shape. He asked Hill to take him to Baxter's cabin. They used Will's car, its engine revving as it climbed further up the rutted path. Soon, Will could see colour - the yellow tape of a police cordon. 'This is as far as we can go. It's a crime scene.' Will reached into his pocket. As if reading his mind, Hill added, 'Even your fancy New York press card won't get you in here. It's sealed.' Will got out anyway, just to get a feel. It looked to him like a shed: a bare log cabin, the kind a well-off family might use to store firewood. The dimensions made it hard to believe a man had made this his home.
Will asked Hill to describe the interior as best he could. 'That's easy/ his guide said. 'Almost nothing in there.' A narrow, metal-frame bed; a chair; a stove; a shortwave radio. 'Sounds like a cell.'
'Think military accommodation; that'll get you closer to it. Pat Baxter lived like a soldier.'
'Spartan, you mean?'
'Yes, sir.'
Will asked who else he should talk to; any friends, any family. 'The Militia of Montana was his only family,' Hill shot back, a little too fast Will thought. 'And even we hardly knew him. First time I ever saw that cabin was when the police had me round there. Wanted me to identify which clothes were his and which might have been left behind by the killers.'

'Killers, plural?'
'You don't think someone starts performing major surgery like that on their own, do you? They would have needed a team. Every surgeon needs a nurse.'
Will gave Bob Hill a ride back to his own cabin. He suspected that, though Hill's office might have been basic, his house was elsewhere - and not nearly so spare as Baxter's. The dead man was clearly an extreme kind of extremist.
They said their goodbyes, exchanged email addresses, and Will began the long drive on. Bob Hill was obviously a nut
- DNA for dissidence indeed - but this business with the kidney was definitely strange. And why would Baxter's killers have given him an injection?
He pulled off Route 200 to fill up the car and his stomach. He found a diner and ordered a soda and a sandwich. A TV was on, tuned to Fox News.
'. . . Dateline London now and more on the scandal threatening to topple the British government.'
There were pictures of a harried-looking Gavin Curtis emerging from a car to an explosion of flash bulbs and television lights.

'According to one British newspaper today, Treasury records show clear discrepancies which can only have been authorized at the very top. While opposition politicians demand a full disclosure of accounts, Mr Curtis's spokesman says only that "there has been no wrongdoing"

Without thinking, Will was taking notes, not that he would ever need them: Curtis's chances of heading up the IMF were surely slim to non-existent now. Watching the pictures of Curtis being shepherded past the baying press mob - a classic 'goatfuck' as the TV guys called them - Will's mind wandered onto trivial terrain. How come his car is so ordinary? This Gavin Curtis was meant to be the second most powerful man in Britain, yet he was driven around in what looked like a suburban sales rep's car. Did all British ministers live so modestly - or was this just a Gavin Curtis thing?
Will called the sheriff's office for Sanders County and was told that, for all the federal investigations and Unabomber inquiries, Baxter had no criminal record whatsoever. He had been under heavy surveillance, but it had yielded nothing: a couple of unexplained trips to Seattle, but no evidence of illegality. He had never been convicted of anything. Will flicked back through his notebook. He had scribbled down all he could of the autopsy report, including the name at the foot of the document. Dr Allan Russell, Medical Examiner, Forensic Science Division, State Crime Lab. Maybe this Dr Russell would be able to tell him what Mr Baxter's militia comrades had not. How had Pat Baxter died - and why?
CHAPTER NINE

Wednesday, 6.51pm, Missoula, Montana
He had got there too late; the crime lab was shut for the day. No amount of cajoling could alter that fact; the staff had gone home. He would have to come back tomorrow. Which meant he would have to spend the night in Missoula.
He was briefly tempted by the C'mon Inn, if only because the joke was too good to resist. But Will realized, he could still tell people about it in New York: he did not actually have to stay there. So he played safe and checked into the Holiday Inn for a third night of room service, the remote control and a phone call with Beth.
'You're making this too complicated,' she said, audibly getting out of the bath.
'But it is complicated. The guy has a kidney missing.'

'You need to see a medical history. Maybe - what's his name again?'
'Baxter.'
'Maybe Baxter had a history of renal problems. Any reference to that or to dialysis or kidney trouble of any kind, and that will give you an explanation.'
Will was silent.
'I'm ruining it, aren't I?'
'Well, if we're talking news value, the choice between the death of an old man with a past history of renal failure and an attempted kidney-snatching is very close. But, yeah, you might be right: the kidney-snatching probably just edges it.' Will was relieved they were back into banter mode. Several days now stood between them and the row; the wound seemed to be closing.

Thursday, 10.02am, Missoula, Montana
The next morning, Will was ushered into Dr Russell's office. He saw it straight away, a certificate on the wall carrying an emblem Will recognized: an open book, inscribed with Latin words, topped off by two crowns.
'Ah, you were at Oxford. Like me. When were you there?' 'Several centuries before you, I suspect.'
'That can't be true, Dr Russell.'

'Call me Allan.'
At last, a lucky break. 'You know, Allan, I'm not even sure
I'll write about it for the paper, but this Pat Baxter business
does intrigue me, I must confess,' he began, as if settling
down for an agreeable chat at high table. Will noticed his
own English accent had become more pronounced.
'Let me have a look here,' Russell was saying, as he turned
to his computer. 'Ah yes, "Severe internal haemorrhaging
consistent with a gunshot wound; contusions of the skin and
viscera. General remarks: needle mark on right thigh, suggestive
of recent anaesthesia".'
'Now, how are you defining "recent" there, Allan?' Will hoped his tone was saying, Purely out of academic interest . . .
'Probably contemporaneous.'
'You see this, I have to say, is what intrigues me. Why
would anyone anaesthetize someone before they kill them?'
'Perhaps they were trying to reduce the victim's pain.'
'Do murderers do that? It makes no sense. Unless--'
'Unless the killer was a medical man. Trained to give a shot
before any procedure. Force of habit perhaps.'
'Or if he wanted to do something else before the murder. Perform some other operation.'
'Like?'
'Well, I understand that Baxter was found minus one kidney.'
Russell began to laugh, in a way Will struggled to find funny. 'Oh, I see what you're driving at.' Russell was grinning. 'Tell me, Will. Have you ever seen a dead body?'
Instantly, Will remembered the corpse of Howard Macrae, under a blanket on that street in Brownsville. His first. 'Yes. In my work it's hard to avoid.'
'Well, then you won't mind seeing another one.'

It was not as cold as he expected. Will imagined a morgue to be a giant fridge, like those cold storage rooms at the back
of large hotels. This was more like a hospital ward.
The orderlies were moving a gurney into a curtained-off
zone which Will took to be the examination area. With not
even a moment's warning, Russell pulled back the sheet.
Will felt his stomach tighten. The body was stiff and waxy,
a yellowish green. The stench was rancid; seeming to come
his way in waves. For a second or two he would think it had
passed, or that at least he had got used to it, and then it
would strike again - inciting Will to empty his guts out on
the floor there and then.
'It can take some getting used to. Apologies. Now take a
look at this.'
Will moved closer. Russell was gesturing towards something
in the stomach area, but Will was transfixed by Pat
Baxter's face. The papers had run photos, but they were
grainy - 'grabs' from TV footage mainly. Now he saw the
weathered cheeks, chin, eyes and mouth of a man he would
have identified as middle-aged, poor and white. He had a
longish beard that, in a different context, might have looked
elegant, even statesmanlike. (The face of Charles Darwin popped into Will's head). But the effect here was to give Pat Baxter the appearance of a homeless man, one of the winos found sleeping by trash cans in a park.
Russell was pulling back the sheet around Baxter's torso. Will could tell he was trying to conceal one thing, probably the bullet wounds, and reveal something else. 'Look closely. Can you see it?'
Will leaned forward to see Russell's finger tracing a line on the dead white flesh. That's a scar.'
'In the area of the kidney?'
'I would say so.'
'And that can't be from that night, right? I mean, it takes ages to form a scar.'
Russell pulled back the sheet, stripped off his latex gloves and headed for a basin in the corner of the room. He began scrubbing, talking over his shoulder. He was enjoying this. 'Well, of course, it's hard to be certain, what with the
severe trauma to the skin and viscera.'
'But what's your professional opinion?'
'My opinion? That scar is, at the very least, a year old.
Maybe two.'
Will felt his heart sink. 'So it didn't happen that night? The killers didn't take out Baxter's kidney?'
'I'm afraid not, no. You look disappointed, Will. I hope I haven't spoiled your story'
But you have, arsehole, was Will's first thought. All this chasing for nothing. Then he remembered what Beth had said on the phone last night.
'There is one last thing that might help. Do you think we could check Pat Baxter's medical records?'
Russell gave him a mini-lecture about patient-doctor confidentiality, but soon relented. Back in his office, he pulled up
the file.
'What are we looking for?'
The date Pat Baxter had his kidney removed.'
Russell paused, scanning the pages. Finally: That's odd. There's no record of a kidney operation.'
Will perked up. He remembered Beth's briefing on the phone last night. 'Anything there about a history of kidney problems, any disease, any references to renal failure, dialysis, anything?'
A longer pause now. And then, with a hint of puzzlement, 'No.'
Will sensed he and the doctor now had something in common. They were equally baffled. 'Does the history speak of any medical problems at all?'
'Some trouble with his ankle, associated with war damage. Vietnam, apparently. Apart from that, nothing. I just assumed he was a renal patient who had to have his kidney out. This certainly appears to be a complete record. And yet there's nothing about a kidney. I've got to admit, this has me foxed.'
There was a light knock on the door. A woman, introduced by Russell as the media relations officer for the crime lab, opened it.
'Sorry to interrupt, Dr Russell. It's just we're getting a ton of calls on the Baxter case. Apparently, an associate of the deceased called a talk radio station today saying that he believed Mr Baxter was a victim of some kind of organ snatching plot?'
Bob Hill, thought Will. So much for his exclusive.
'Sure, I'll be with you in a minute,' Russell said, his brow tensing.
Will waited for the door to close to ask what Russell would tell the press. 'Well, we can't give the most simple explanation, that Baxter had a history of kidney problems. Not now.' It was Will's fault: he knew too much. 'We'll think of something. I'll show you out.'
Will was pulling out of the driveway when he heard the pounding on his car window. It was Russell, still in his shirtsleeves and breathless.
'I just got this call. She wants to talk to you.' He passed his cell phone through the window.
'Mr Monroe? My name is Gene vie we Huntley. I'm a surgeon at the Swedish Medical Center in Seattle. I saw the reports about Mr Baxter on the news and Allan has just explained to me what you know. I think we need to talk.'
'Sure,' said Will, scrabbling to find his notebook.
'I'm going to need some assurances from you, Mr Monroe. I trust The New York Times and I hope that trust will be repaid. What I am about to tell you I vowed never to repeat. I only tell it now because I fear the alternative is worse. We can't have people scaring themselves senseless about some organ snatching ring.'
'I understand.'
'I'm not sure you do. I'm not sure any of us do. What I ask is that you treat what I tell you with honour, dignity and respect. For that is what it deserves, Mr Monroe. Do I make myself clear?'
'Yes.' Will could not imagine what he was about to hear. 'OK. Mr Baxter's greatest request was anonymity. That was the one thing he asked of me in return for what he did.' Will was silent.
Pat Baxter came to Swedish about two years ago. He had come a long way, we found out later. When he turned up, the nurses assumed he was an ER case: he looked like a bum off the streets. But he said he was in perfect health, he just needed to talk to a doctor in our transplant unit. He said that he wanted to give up one of his kidneys.
'We immediately asked who he wanted to give the kidney to. Was there a sick child involved? Maybe a family member needed a transplant? "No," he said. "I just want you to give my kidney to someone who needs it." My colleagues immediately assumed that, frankly, there must be some mental
health issues involved. Such nondirected operations are
almost unheard of. Certainly the first one we had ever dealt
with.
'I sent Mr Baxter away. I told him this was something
we couldn't consider. But he came back and I sent him
away again. The third time we had a long talk. He told me
that he wished he had been born rich. That way - I
remember his words - that way, he said, he might have
known the pleasure of giving away vast amounts of money.
He said there were so many people who needed help. I
remember, he asked me, "What does the word philanthropy mean? It means love of your fellow man. Well, why should
only rich people be allowed to love their fellow man? I
want to be a philanthropist, too." He was determined to
find another way to give - even if that meant giving away
his own organs.
'Eventually I concluded that he was sincere. I ran the tests
and there was no medical objection. We even ran psychological
tests and they confirmed he was of completely sound mind, totally able to make this decision.
'There was only one condition, imposed by him. He swore
us to complete secrecy, complete confidentiality. The recipient
patient was not to know where his or her new kidney
had come from. That was very important. He didn't want
that person to feel they owed him. And not a word to the
press. He insisted on that. No glory.'
Quietly, almost meekly, Will asked, 'And so you went
ahead with it?'
'We did. I performed the operation myself. And I tell you,
in my whole career there was no operation that made me
prouder. All of us felt it: the anaesthetist, the nurses. There
was an extraordinary atmosphere in theatre that day; as if
something truly remarkable was happening.'
'And did all go smoothly?'
'Yes it did, it did. The recipient took the organ just fine.'
'Can I ask what kind of recipient we're talking about?
Young, old, male, female?'
'It was a young woman. I won't say any more than that.'
'And even though she was young, and he was old, it all
worked out?'
'Well, this was the strangest thing. We tested that kidney, obviously, monitored it very closely. And you know what?
Baxter was in his fifties, but that organ worked like it was
forty years younger than he was. It was very strong,
completely healthy. It was perfect.'
'And it made all the difference for that young woman?'
'It saved her life. The staff and I wanted to have some kind
of ceremony for him, after the operation, to thank him for
what he'd done. It won't surprise you to hear that never
happened. He discharged himself before we'd even had a
chance to say goodbye. He just clean disappeared.'
'And was that the last you heard from him?'
'No, I heard from him once more, just a few months ago.
He wanted to make arrangements for after his death--'
'Really?'
'Don't get too excited, Mr Monroe. I don't think he knew
he was about to die. But he wanted to be sure that everything,
his entire body, would be used.' Huntley gave a rueful
chuckle. 'He even asked me what would be the optimal way
for him to die.'
'Optimal?'
'From our point of view. What would work best, if we
wanted to get his heart, say, to a recipient. I think he was
worried, because he lived so far away, that if he was killed
in a road accident, for example, by the time he got to a
hospital, his heart would be useless. Of course, the one
scenario he didn't count on was a brutal murder.'
'Do you have any idea--'
'I have no idea at all who could have wanted this man
dead, no. I said the same to Dr Russell just now. I can only
think it was a completely random, awful crime. Because no one who knew him would want to murder such a man. They couldn't.'
She paused and Will chose to let the silence hang. One thing he had learned: say nothing and your interviewee will often fill the void with the best quote of the entire conversation. Eventually
Dr Huntley, with what Will thought was a crack
in her voice, spoke again. 'We discussed this when it happened and we discussed it again today and my colleagues and I agree. What this man did, what Pat Baxter did for a person he had never met and would never meet - this was truly the most righteous act we have ever known.'
CHAPTER TEN

Friday, 6am, Seattle
He woke at six am, back now in his Seattle hotel room. He
had filed his story from Missoula and then made the long
journey cross-country. As he wrote the piece, he was powered
by a single, delicious thought: Eat this, Walton. What had that prick said? 'Once counts as an achievement, William; twice would
be a miracle.'
Will prayed he had pulled it off. His greatest fear was that
the desk might find it too similar to the Macrae story, another
good man among knaves. So he had played up the militia
angle, thrown in lots of Pacific Northwest colour and hoped
for the best. He even toyed with ditching the quote about
Baxter's action being 'righteous', the very same word that
woman had used about Howard Macrae. It might look
contrived. Still, it would be more contrived to ignore it.
He reached for his BlackBerry, whose red light was winking
hopefully: new messages.
Harden, Glenn: Nice job today, Monroe. That was what he
wanted to hear. It meant he had avoided the spike; if only
he could see Walton's face. The next email looked like spam;
the sender's name was not clear, just a string of hieroglyphics.
Will was poised to delete it when the single word in the
subject field made him click it open. Beth. He had not even read all the words when he felt his blood freeze.

DO NOT CALL THE POLICE. WE HAVE YOUR WIFE. INVOLVE THE POLICE AND YOU WILL LOSE HER. DO NOT CALL THE POLICE OR YOU WILL REGRET IT. FOREVER.
CHAPTER ELEVEN

Friday, 9.43pm, Chennai, India
The nights were getting cooler. Still, Sanjay Ramesh preferred to stay here in the air-conditioned chill of the office than risk the suffocating heat of the city. He would wait till the sun had fully set before heading for home.
That way he might avoid not only the clammy heat, but the ordeal of the stoop. Every night it happened, his mother trading gossip and health complaints with her friends as they sat outside until late. He found himself tongue-tied in such company; in most company as it happened. Besides, September might be cool by the standards of Chennai but it was still punishingly hot and sticky. Inside this room, an aircraft hangar of an open-plan office, filled by row after row of sound-muffling cubicles, the conditions were just right. For what he needed to do, it was the perfect environment. It was a call centre, one of thousands that had sprung up across India. Four storeys packed with young Indians taking calls from America or Britain, from people in Philadelphia anxious to pay their phone bill or travellers in Macclesfield wanting to check the train times to Manchester. Few, if any, of them ever realized their call was being routed to the other side of the world.
Sanjay liked his job well enough. For an eighteen-year-old
living at home, the money was good. And he could work odd
shifts to fit in with his studies. The big draw, though, was
right here inside this little cubicle. He had everything he
needed: a chair, a desk and, most important of all, a computer
with a fast connection to the world.
Sanjay was young, but he was a veteran of the internet.
He discovered it when both he and it were in their infancy.
There were only a few hundred websites then, maybe a thousand.
As he had grown, so had it. The worldwide web
expanded like a binary number sequence - 1, 2, 4, 8, 16, 32,
64, 128 - apparently doubling its size with each passing day, until it now girdled the globe many times over. Sanjay had
not matched that pace physically of course - if anything he
was a slight, skinny lad - but he felt his mind had kept up.
As the internet grew, he grew with it, constantly opening up
whole new areas of knowledge and curiosity. From his upstairs
bedroom in India, he had travelled to Brazil, mastered the
disputed border politics of Nagorno-Karabakh, laughed at
Indonesian cartoons, gazed inside the world of the Scottish
caravan enthusiast, scanned the junior fencing league tables
of Flanders and seen what really motivated the tree-growers
of Taipei. There was no corner of human activity closed off
to him. The internet had shown him everything.
Including the images he had not wanted to see, the ones
that had prompted the project he had completed just twenty
four hours earlier. He was a late developer as a computer
hacker, coming to it when he was fifteen: most started before
they were teenagers. He had played the usual tricks - hacking
into the NATO target list, coming within one click of shutting
down the Pentagon system - but each time he had held
back from pressing the final button. Causing mayhem held
no appeal for him. It would only give people a lot of grief
and, his surfing of the web had taught him, there was plenty
of that in the world already.
Now he felt the urge to laugh, partly at his own genius, partly at the joke he had played on those he had designated as his enemy. It had taken him months to perfect, but it had worked.
He had devised a benign virus, one capable of spreading through the computers of the world just as rapidly as any of the poisonous varieties hatched by his fellow boy-geniuses, those whose malign purpose made them, in the argot of the web, crackers rather than hackers.
At this moment, it was his method, rather than his objective, which delighted him. Like most viruses, his was designed to spread via ordinary desktop computers, those that were connected to the internet all the time. While people in Hong Kong or Hanover were tapping away, emailing their friends or doing their accounts, or even fast asleep, his little baby was inside their machine, hard at work.
He had given it a target to look for and, just like everyone else, it used Google to find it. Invisible to the user, below the screen, it got back its results and used them to compile what Sanjay thought of as an enemies list. These would be the sites to feel the virus's wrath. All of them, like any other site, would have some bug or glitch in their software: the challenge was to find it. For that, hackers (and crackers) would devise a set of 'exploits', designed to trigger the glitch. It might mean sending it a little nugget of data the software was not expecting; even one rogue symbol, a semi-colon perhaps, might do the trick. You never knew until you tried. Sanjay imagined it like medieval warfare: you would fire hundreds of arrows at a castle, knowing that only one might find the slit in the stone and get through. Each castle would have a different gap in the armour, a different weakness. But if your list of exploits was long enough, you would find it eventually. And once you had, you could take down the site and the server that was hosting it. It would be gone, just like that. And these sites certainly deserved to disappear. But Sanjay had taken his war against them a stage further. Most hackers stored their list of exploits on a single server, usually salted away in the bandit country of the internet, a place out of the reach of the regulators. Romania and Russia were favourites. This method carried with it a fatal weakness, however: once the attacked sites realized the source of the enemy fire, they could simply block access to the server containing the exploits. The raids would stop.
Sanjay had found a solution. His virus would get its arsenal of exploits from a variety of sources and would even carry some of this payload itself. Better still, he had programmed it to retrieve extra exploits every now and then, to improve itself. He had created a magician constantly able to replenish his bag of tricks. And creation was the right word, for Sanjay felt he had conceived a living creature. In technical language, it was a 'genetic algorithm' a piece of coding that was able to change. To evolve.
His virus would alter its list of exploits, even its method of distribution - sometimes through email, sometimes through bulletin boards, sometimes through bugs in web browsers as it spread throughout the infinite universe that was the internet. In this way, the virus would reproduce itself, but its 'children' would not be identical either to the original virus or to each other. They would mutate, by picking up new exploits and new methods of propagation from sources all over the virtual world. Some of these sources would be servers in the internet badlands of eastern Europe, some would be found by scanning security bulletin boards - where people would discuss how to thwart the very tricks Sanjay was deploying. Sanjay was proud of his creation, travelling across the globe, imitating and bettering itself in a million different ways - thereby making itself all but impossible to track down and eliminate. Even if he never touched a computer again, they would continue without him. Still a teenager, he felt like a proud father, or rather, a great-great-grandfather - the founder of a vast dynasty. His progeny were everywhere.
And they were engaged in noble work. Scanning the results
now, he could see he had set the parameters sufficiently
narrowly that only the target sites were collapsing. Within a
matter of hours, every one of the world's websites dedicated
to child pornography would dissolve. Sanjay was laughing
because he could see that the final command he had
programmed into the virus was also now taking effect. Each
of the sites that once displayed violent and pornographic
images of children was now replaced by a single picture: a 1950s, Norman Rockwellstyle drawing of a son on his
mother's knee. Below it ran a simple, four-word message: Read to your kids. Sanjay headed home, grinning at his joke - and his accomplishment.
No one needed to know what he had done; he
knew and that was enough. The world would be a better
place.
Even at night Chennai was a noisy city, as raucous as it
had been when it was Madras. Perhaps that, and the fact that
his mind was racing with his success, is why he did not hear
the footsteps behind him. Perhaps that is why he saw and
suspected nothing until he was walking down the side alley
to his own house, when he felt a handkerchief over his
mouth and heard his own muffled screams. There was a sharp
pricking sensation on the side of his arm and then a woozy
slide downward into sleep.
When Mrs Ramesh found her only son dead on the ground,
she screamed loud enough to be heard three streets away. It
gave her no comfort that her boy - who had dreamt of one
day doing something 'for children' and who had been
murdered before he had a chance to do anything - had been
killed by some apparently painless injection. Police admitted
they were baffled by the murder; they had seen none like it
before. There was no sign of violence or, God forbid, abuse.
And there was the odd demeanour of the body. As if it had
been handled with care. 'Laid to rest was how the policeman had put it. 'It must mean something, Mrs Ramesh,' he had said. 'Your son's body was draped in a purple blanket. And, as everyone knows, purple is the colour of princes.' CHAPTER TWELVE

Friday, 6.10am, Seattle
Will felt his face pale, the blood draining from it. His head
seemed light, insubstantial. He read the message again,
scouring it for some clue, some indication that it was a cruel
hoax. He looked to see if he had been 'bcc'd', which would
make this spam, sent out to millions. Maybe the Beth subject
line was a coincidence. But there were no such signs. He
looked for a 'signature' at the foot of the page. Nothing but
junk. His palms were sweating as he turned on his cell phone.
He scrolled down to B and pressed Beth, the first one to pop
up.
Please answer. Please God let me hear her voice. The phone rang and rang, with one tone suddenly shorter than the rest: it
was diverting to voicemail. Hi, you 'we reached Beth ... He crumpled as he heard her voice, surrendering as a memory floated
into his head. The very first time he had asked her out, it
had been via a message on her answering machine. 'Unless
it would be wildly inappropriate,' he had begun, 'I wondered
whether you'd like to have dinner on Tuesday night.' 'Wildly
inappropriate' had been his way of checking that she was
single.
'Hello, this is Beth McCarthy and the answer is no,' came
the reply, also left via voicemail, 'it would not be wildly inappropriate for us to have dinner on Tuesday. In fact, it would
be lovely.' Will had replayed that message a dozen times when he had first got it. Just as he replayed it now, in his head.
He stopped the call, his hands now quivering as they
punched in the number of the hospital. 'Hello, please page Beth Monroe. It's her husband. Please.'
Hold-music by Vivaldi; he was begging it to stop, praying for it to be broken by the sound of someone picking up and for that someone to be Beth. Please let me hear her voice. But the music played on. Eventually: 'I'm sorry, sir, there seems to be no response to that page. Is there another doctor who can help?'
A sudden realization. She might have been gone for hours. Perhaps she had been snatched from their bedroom in the dead of night. They had spoken just before twelve her time. Maybe the kidnappers broke in at five? Or six? Or just now? He was a continent away, fast asleep when he should have been protecting his wife.
He looked at the email again, his heart shrinking as he saw those words. He tried to focus, to look at the top of the
message, among those strange, garbled characters. There were some numbers, today's date and a timestamp which said 1.37pm, even though that was several hours away. That gave no clue.
Of course, he should call the police. But these people, these bastards, seemed so adamant - as if they really would not hesitate to kill Beth. Uttering the word, even if only as a thought in his own head, made him recoil. He regretted formulating the idea, as if expressing it made it real. He wished he
could take it back.
In a moment of childish need, he realized he wanted his
mother. He could call her - it would only be mid-afternoon in England now - and it would be such a comfort to hear her voice. But he knew he would not. She would panic; she
might have an anxiety attack. She certainly could not be
trusted not to phone the police, or at least talk to someone
who would talk to someone who would. The simple truth
was, she was too far away for him to manage and his mother
was a person who needed managing. (He realized that word
was a Beth-ism. It made sense that she was one of the very
few people who knew how to handle Will's mother.)
He was slowly beginning to see that there was only one
person he could ask, only one person who might know what
to do. His hand shook as he reached for the hotel phone,
something telling him this was not a call to be made on a
cell.
'The office of Judge William Monroe, please.' A click.
'Janine, it's Will. I need to speak to my father right away.'
Something in his voice cut through all social convention,
conveying to his father's secretary that this was indeed an
emergency. She dispensed with her usual small talk. She
simply cleared out of the way, like a car making room for an
ambulance. I'll patch you through to his car now.' A cell
phone, thought Will, worriedly. He would have to let it pass:
more important now just to get through.
It was a relief to hear his father pick up. The child in him
felt glad, like a boy who persuades his dad to come kill a
spider. Good, now an adult was going to take over. Doing his
best to hold his voice steady, he told his father what had
happened, reading the email out slowly, twice.
Monroe Sr's voice instantly dipped; he did not want to be
overheard by his driver. Even in a whisper his voice had the
deep authority that made him such a presence on the bench.
Now, as he would in court, he asked all the pertinent questions,
pressing his son to tell him everything he could work out about the sender. Finally, he delivered his ruling.
'It's obviously an attempt at extortion. They must know
about Beth's parents. It's a classic ransom demand.'
Beth's parents. He would have to tell them. How would he even utter the words? 'I want to call the police,' said Will. 'They know how to handle these things.'
'No, we mustn't do anything too rash. My understanding is that kidnappers usually assume the victim's family will go to the police: they factor it into their planning. There must be a reason why these people are so determined to avoid the police being involved.'
'Of course they don't want the police to be involved! They're fucking kidnappers, Dad!'
'Will, calm down.'
'How can I calm down?' Will could feel his voice about to break. His eyes were stinging. He did not dare try speaking again.
'Oh, Will. Listen, we're going to get through this, I promise. First, you need to get back here. Immediately. Go to the airport right away. I'll meet you off the flight.'

Those five hours in the air were the hardest of Will's life. He
stared out of the window, his leg oscillating in a nervous tic
that used to strike him during exams. He refused all food and
drink, until he noticed the cabin attendants were eyeing him
suspiciously. He did not want them thinking he was poised
to blow up the plane, so he sipped some water. And all the
time he was imagining his beloved Beth. What were they
doing to her? He began to picture her tied to a chair, while
some sadist dangled a knife-
It took all his strength to stop such thoughts before they
had picked up speed. His guts were turning over. How could I not have been there? If only I had phoned earlier. Maybe she called
the cell phone when I was asleep . . .
Throughout he held the BlackBerry in the palm of his
hand. He hated everything about this accursed machine. Even
to glance at it brought those chilling words right back. He
could see them now, hovering in the air in front of him:
INVOLVE THE POLICE AND YOU WILL LOSE HER.

He looked at the device, so small yet now containing so much poison. It was sleeping: no signal at this height. He kept watching the icon at the top right that would tell him when it was back within range. As the plane began its descent, he stole peeks at it. He did not want the flight attendants reminding him that they had asked that all 'electronic devices be turned off until the aircraft has come to a complete stop'.

At last he could see the sparkle of New York City in mid
afternoon. She's down there. The bridges, the highways, the
flickering necklaces of light criss-crossing the whole vast metropolis. She's there somewhere.
He glanced down at the BlackBerry, moist with his own
palm-sweat. The icon had changed; it was back in range. Now
the red light was flashing. Will's heart began to pound. He
looked at the new messages flowing in, each one taking its
place like passengers in a bus queue. Some round-robin
cinema listing; an internal message from work about a lost
notebook. There was a news-alert from the BBC website.

Tributes have been pouring in for the Chancellor of the Exchequer, Gavin Curtis, found dead this evening, apparently from a drugs overdose. Police say he was found by a cleaner in his Westminster flat, with an excess of a sedative drug in his bloodstream. It's believed that the police are not looking for anyone else in connection with Mr Curtis's death . . .

Will was staring out of the window, just imagining the media frenzy back in London. He had grown up there: he knew what the British press was like when its blood was up. They had been gunning for this guy for days and now they had got their scalp. Will could not remember the last time a politician had actually topped himself: when it came to taking responsibility, resignation was usually as far as they would go, and even that had become pretty rare. This Curtis must have been guilty as hell.
And then one more message popped into the BlackBerry. the same hieroglyphic string that refused to reveal itself. Subject: Beth.
Will clicked it open.
WE DO NOT WANT MONEY. CHAPTER THIRTEEN
Friday, 2.14pm, Brooklyn
'It must be a bluff.'
'Dad, you've said that three times. Tell me, what do you
think we should do? Should we offer them money anyway?
What should we fucking do?'
'Will, I don't blame you at all, but you must calm down.
If we're to get Beth back we need to think as clearly as we
can.'
That 'if stopped Will short.
They were in Will and Beth's apartment. There was no sign
of a break-in; everything was how he had last seen it. Except
now a chill seemed to be coming off the walls and ceilings:
the absence of Beth.
'Let's think through what we know. We know that their
first priority is that the police not be involved: they said it in
their very first message. We also know that they say it's not
about money. But if this is not about ransom, why else would
they care so much about keeping the police out of it? They
must be bluffing. Let's think about your email address. Who
has it?'
'Everyone has it! It's the same pattern for the whole Times staff. Anyone could work it out.'
A phone rang; Will pounced on his, frantically pressing
buttons, but the sound kept coming. Calmly, his father
answered his own phone. Nothing to do with this, he mouthed
silently, disappearing into another room for a hushed conversation. His
father was proving no help. The aid he was offering
was defiantly of the masculine variety, practical rather than
emotional, and even that was not getting anywhere. Suddenly
Will realized how much he missed his mother. Ever since he
had been with Beth, that sentiment had become rarer and rarer: his wife was his confidante now. But, for a long while,
that role had belonged to his mother.
In England, they had been a team, united by what he
suddenly thought of as their loneliness. In his mother's version
of the story, at least, she and Will had been abandoned by
his father, leaving the two of them to fend for themselves.
He knew there were alternative accounts, not that his father
was in too much of a hurry to share his. The fate of his
parents' marriage was a long-running puzzle to Will Monroe.
He was never completely sure what happened.
One version said Monroe Sr had chosen his career over
his family: over-work broke the young marriage. Another
theory cited geography: wife was desperate to return to
England, husband was determined to advance through the
US legal system and refused to leave America. Will's maternal
grandmother, a silver-haired Hampshire lady with a severe
expression that frightened the young boy the first time he
saw her, and for years afterwards, once spoke darkly of 'the
other great passion' in his father's life. When he was old
enough to inquire further, his grandmother shrugged it off.
To this day, he did not know if that 'great passion' was
another woman or the law.
Will's own memories offered little help; he was barely
seven years old when his parents began to come apart. He
remembered the atmosphere, the gloom that would descend
after his father had stormed out, slamming the door. Or the shock of finding his mother, red-faced and hoarse after another fierce round of shouting. He once woke up from sleep to hear his father pleading, 'I just want to do what's right.' Will had tiptoed out of bed to find a place where he could watch his parents unseen. He could not understand the words they were saying but he could feel their force. It was at that moment, hearing his British mother and American father at full volume, that the seven year old boy developed a theory: his mummy and daddy could not love each other because they had different voices.
Once they were back in England, his mother gave few clues as to what had brought them there. Even raising the topic carried the risk of turning her into a bitter, ranting woman he hardly recognized and did not like. She would mutter about how her husband became 'a different man, utterly different'. Will remembered one Christmas, his mother speaking in a way which frightened him; he could not have been much older than thirteen. The detail had faded now, but one word still leapt out. It was all 'his' fault, she kept saying; 'he' had changed everything. The intonation made clear that this 'he' was a third party, not his father, but Will could never figure out who it was. His mother was coming off like a paranoid, raving in the streets. Will was relieved when the storm passed and he was not brave enough to mention it again.
Friends, and his grandmother for that matter, were quick to analyse Will's return to the United States after Oxford as a response to all this. He was 'choosing' his father over his mother, said some. He was trying to reconcile the two, in the manner of many children of divorce, with himself as the bridge; that was another pet explanation. If he subscribed to any theory, which he did not, it would have been the journalistic one: that Will Monroe Jr went to America to get to
the truth of the story that had shaped his early life.
But if that had been the purpose of his American journey, he had failed. He knew little more now than he did when he first arrived, aged twenty-two. He knew his father better, that was true. He respected him; he was a hugely accomplished lawyer, now a judge, and seemed an essentially decent man. But as to the big mystery, Will had gained no great insights. They had talked about the divorce, of course, during a couple of moonlit evenings on the veranda of his father's summer house at Sag Harbor. But there had been no flash of revelation.
'Maybe that is the revelation,' Beth had said one night when he came back inside after one of these father-to-son chats. They were spending a long Labor Day weekend with Will's father and his 'partner', Linda. Beth was lying on the bed, reading, waiting for Will to come back in.
'What is?'
'That there is no big mystery. That's the revelation. They were two people whose marriage didn't work. It happens. It happens a lot. That's all there is.'
'But what about all that stuff my mother says? And that grandma used to say?'
'Maybe they needed to have some grand explanation. Maybe it helped to think that some other woman stole him--' 'Not necessarily another woman,' Will muttered. '"The other great passion" was the phrase. Could have been anything.'
'OK. My point is, I can see why a rejected wife and her very loving mother would need to invent a larger explanation for the departure of a husband. Otherwise it's a rejection, isn't it?'
She had not been his wife then, just the girlfriend he had met in his closing weeks at Columbia. He was in journalism school; she was doing a medical internship at the New York Presbyterian Hospital; they had met at a Memorial Day weekend softball game in the park. (He had left the message on her answering machine that same evening.) Those first few months were bathed in his mind in a permanent golden glow. He knew the memory could play tricks like that, but he was convinced the glow was a genuine, externally verifiable phenomenon. They had met in May, when New York was in the midst of a glorious spring. The days seemed to be lit by amber; each walk they took sparkled in the sun. It was not just their lovestruck imaginations; they had photographs to prove it.
Will realized he was smiling. This daydream was the first time he had thought of Beth, rather than Beth gone. Which was what he remembered now, with the jolt of a man who wakes up to realize that, yes, his leg has been amputated and, no, it was not all a horrible dream.
His father had come back into the room and was saying something about contacting the internet company, but Will was not listening. He had had enough. His father was not thinking straight: the moment they made any move like that, they risked alerting the police. The internet service provider would surely take a look at the kidnappers' emails and feel obliged to notify the authorities.
'Dad, I need some time to rest,' he said, gently shepherding his father to the door. 'I need some time alone.'
'Will, that's all very well, but I'm not sure rest is a luxury you can afford. You need to use every minute--'
Monroe Sr stopped. He could see his son was in no mood to negotiate; there was a steel in Will's eyes that was ordering his father to leave, no matter how polite the words coming out of his mouth.
When the door was closed, Will sighed deeply, slumped into a chair and stared at his feet. He allowed himself no more than thirty seconds like that, before he breathed deeply, pulled his back up straight and girded himself for his next move. Despite what he had just said, he was neither going to rest nor be alone. He knew exactly what he had to do. CHAPTER FOURTEEN

Friday, 3.16pm, Brooklyn
Tom Fontaine had been Will's first friend in America, or rather the first friend he had made since coming to the country as an adult. They had met in the registration office at Columbia: Tom was just ahead of Will in the queue. Will's initial feeling towards Tom was frustration. The line was moving slowly enough already, but he could see the lanky guy in the old-man's overcoat was going to take forever. Everyone else had their forms ready, most of them neatly printed out. But the overcoat was still filling his in as he stood. With a fountain pen that had sprung a leak. Will turned to the girl behind him, raising his eyebrows as if to say, 'Can you believe this guy?' Eventually the two of them started talking out loud about how irritating it was to be stuck behind such a sap: they were emboldened by the permanent presence in the sap's ears of a pair of white headphones. Finally, he had rummaged in his schoolboy satchel enough times to find a dog-eared driver's licence that had lost its laminate and a letter from the university. These somehow convinced the official that he was indeed called Tom Fontaine and that he was entitled to be a student at Columbia. In philosophy.
As he turned around, he gave Will a smile: 'Sorry, I know how irritating it is to be stuck behind the college sap.' Will blushed. He had obviously heard every word. (Will would later discover that the headphones in Tom's ears were not connected to a Walkman - or anything else. Tom just found it useful to have headphones on: that way, strangers rarely bothered him.)
They met again three days later in a coffee shop, Tom hunched over a laptop computer, headphones on. Will tapped on his shoulder to apologize. They started talking and they had been friends ever since.
He was quite unlike anyone Will had ever known. Officially, Tom Fontaine was apolitical but Will considered him a genuine revolutionary. Yes, he was a computer geek - but he was also a man with a mission. He was part of an informal network of like-minded geniuses around the world determined to take on - maybe even take down - the software giants who dominated the computer world. Their beef against Microsoft and its ilk was that those corporations had broken the original, sacred principle of the internet: that it should be a tool for the open exchange of ideas and information. The key word was open. In the early days of the net, Tom would explain
- patiently and in words of one syllable to Will who, like plenty of journalists, relied on computers but had not the first idea how they worked - everything was open, freely available to all. That extended to the software itself. It was 'open-source', meaning that its inner workings were there for all to see. Anybody could use and, crucially, adapt the software as they saw fit. Then Microsoft and friends came along and, motivated solely by commerce, brought down the steel shutters. Their stuff was now 'closed-source'. The long strings of code which made it tick were off-limits. Just as Coca-Cola built an empire on its secret recipe, so Microsoft made its products a mystery.
That hardly bothered Will, but for net idealists like Tom it was a form of desecration. They believed in the internet with a zeal that Will could only describe as religious (which was especially funny in Tom's case, given his militant atheism). They were now determined to create alternative software search engines or word-processing programmes - that would be available to anyone who wanted them, free of charge. If someone spotted a fault, they could dive right in and correct it. After all, it belonged to all the people who used it. It meant Tom earned a fraction of the money that could have been his, selling just enough of his computer brainpower to pay the rent. He did not care; the principles came first.
'Tom, it's Will. You home?'
He had answered on his mobile; he could be anywhere. 'Nope.'
'What's that music?' He could hear what sounded like the operatic voice of a woman.
This, my friend, is the Himmelfahrts-Oratorium by Johann Sebastian Bach, the Ascension Oratorio, Barbara Schlick, soprano--'
'What are you, at a concert?'
'Record store.'
The one near your apartment?'
'Yup.'
'Can I meet you at your place in twenty minutes?
Something very urgent has come up.' He regretted that straight away. On a cell phone.
'You OK. You sound, you know, panicky.'
'Can you be there? Twenty minutes?'
'K.'
Tom's place was odd, the embodiment of the man. There was almost nothing in the fridge but row after row of mineral
water, testament to his rather peculiar aversion to drinks of
any kind, hot or cold. No coffee, no juice, no beer. Just water.
And the bed was in the living room, a concession to his
insomnia: when Tom woke up at three am, he wanted to be
able to get straight back online and to work, falling down
again when he next felt tired. Usually these quirks would
spark some kind of lecture from Will, urging his friend to join
the rest of the human race, or at least the Brooklyn branch
of it, but not today.
Will strode right in and gestured to Tom to close the door.
'Do you have any weird gadgets attached to your computer,
any microphones or cell phones or speakerphones or anything
weird that might mean that what we're saying now could in
some way that I don't understand get on to the internet?'
'Excuse me? What are you talking about?'
'You know what I mean. One of your techie things that I
can't even find the words for; do you have anything that
could be recording our conversation and saving it as some
audio file that you won't even realize has happened till later?'
'Er, no.' Tom's voice and face were crinkled into the expression
that says, Of course not, you psycho.
'Good, because what we are about to talk about is terrible
and it is also one hundred per cent secret and cannot, underline cannot, be discussed with anyone - especially not the
police.'
Tom could see his friend was in deadly earnest and also
desperate. Permanently ashen-faced, Tom paled to a shade of
light porcelain.
'Is this on?' Will said, gesturing at one of several computers
on the work bench, picking the one that looked most like
his own. It was a silly question. When were Tom's computers
ever off? 'Is this a browser?' This much internet language
Will could manage. Tom nodded; he looked scared.
Will did not ask if Tom's computers were secure: he knew
there were none safer. Encryption was a Fontaine specialism.
Will typed in the address to access his web mail, then,
when the page appeared, his name and password. His inbox.
He scrolled down and clicked open the first message.

DO NOT CALL THE POLICE. WE HAVE YOUR WIFE. INVOLVE THE POLICE AND YOU WILL LOSE HER. DO NOT CALL THE POLICE OR YOU WILL REGRET IT. FOREVER.

Tom, who was standing, reading over Will's shoulder, almost jumped back. He let out a low moan, as if he had been struck. Only now did Will even think of it: Tom was crazy about Beth. Not romantically - he was no rival - but in an almost childlike way. Tom would often walk the few blocks over to their apartment to eat - a contrast with the sushi-in-a-box consumed in front of his screen that constituted the rest of his diet - and seemed to gain nourishment from Beth's attention. She chided him like an older sister and he took it; he even let her buy him a stylish jacket that he wore, briefly, in place of the dead-man's coat that seemed glued to his back. Will had not banked on this: Tom having feelings of his own about Beth's disappearance.
'Oh my God,' he was saying softly. Will said nothing, giving him a moment to absorb the shock. He decided to short-circuit the next stage by summarizing all the conclusions he, along with his father, had drawn so far. He showed Tom the second email, to establish the fact that the kidnappers seemed more interested in secrecy, and the non-involvement of the authorities, than in any ransom. The explanation was entirely mysterious, but there could be no question of telling the police.
'Tom, I need you to do whatever it takes to work out where these emails have come from. That's what the police would do, so that's what you have to do.'
Tom nodded, but his hands barely moved. He was still dazed.
'Tom, I know how much Beth means to you. And how much you mean to her. But what she needs from you right now is for you to be the laser-beam-focus computer genius. OK?' Will was trying to smile, like a father cheering up a toddler son. 'You need to forget what this is about and imagine it's just another computer puzzle. But you have to crack it as fast as you can.'
Without another word, the two swapped places. Will paced up and down while Tom started clicking and clacking at the machine.
He offered one revelation straight away. The hieroglyphics that had appeared on Will's BlackBerry now looked completely different.
'Is that--'
'Hebrew,' said Tom. 'Not every machine has access to that alphabet. That's why it looked weird on yours. Using obscure alphabets is an old spammer trick.'
Now Will noticed something else. After the long string of Hebrew characters, he could see some English ones in brackets. It was as if they had fallen off the screen on his own computer, but here they were visible, spelling out a regular email address: info@golem-net.net.
'Golem-net? Is that what their name is?'
'Apparently.'
'Isn't that some Lord of the Rings thing?'
'That's Gollum. Two l's.'
Suddenly the screen was black with just a few characters winking on the left. Had the system crashed?
Tom saw Will's face. 'Don't worry about this. This is a "shell". It's just an easier way of issuing commands to the computer than GUI.'
Will looked baffled.
'Graphic User Interface.' Tom could see he was speaking a foreign language, yet he had the strong feeling Will wanted him to say something. He realized his friend was like a taxi passenger in an urgent hurry: ultimately it might make no difference, but it felt better to be moving than to be stuck in traffic, Psychologically, he knew Will was in the same state: he needed to feel they were making progress. A running commentary might help.
'I'm going to ask the computer who it was who just emailed us.'
'You can do that?'
'Yep. Look.'
Tom was typing the words 'Whois golem-net.net'. It always surprised Will when, amid all the codes and digits, a computer (or computer geek, which amounted to the same thing) used plain, conversational English, albeit with an eccentric spelling. Yet, it turned out, this was a bona fide computer instruction.
Whois golem-net.net
Tom was waiting for the screen to fill up. There was nothing you could do in these moments, as the lights flickered and the egg-timer graphic ticked away. You could not hurry the computer. People always tried to. You saw them by ATM machines, their hands in position, like a crocodile's mouth poised over the dispenser, waiting to catch the cash as it came out, ensuring that not even the split second it would take to move across to collect it should be wasted. You saw it in offices, where people would drum pencils or play their thighs like bongos: 'Come on, come on,' urging the computer or printer to stop being so damned slow - forgetting, of course, that five, ten or fifteen years ago the task in question might have taken the best part of a working day.
'Ah. Well, that's interesting.'
There on the screen was the answer, clear and unambiguous. No
match for golem-net.net
'They made it up.'
'Now what?'
Tom went back to the email itself and selected an option Will did not know existed: 'View Full Header'. Suddenly several lines of what he would have dismissed as garble filled
the screen.
'OK,' said Tom, 'what we have here is a kind of travelogue.
This shows you the email's internet journey. That line at the
top is its final destination and that at the bottom is its point
of origin. Each server en route has its own line.'
Will looked at the screen, each sentence beginning
'Received . . .'
'Hmm. These guys were in a hurry.'
'How do you know that?'
'Well, you could make up "received lines". But that takes
time - and whoever sent this didn't have time. Or didn't
know how to do it. These received lines are all genuine. OK,
this is the thing we need. Here.' He was pointing to the bottom line, the point of origin. Received from info.net-spot.biz
'What's that?'
'Every computer in the world, so long as it's connected to
the internet, has a name. That one there is the computer that
sent you the email. All right. That means there's one more
move I need to make.'
Will could see that Tom felt uncomfortable. This was not
the way he liked to do things. Will remembered one of their
earliest conversations, when Tom explained the difference
between hackers and crackers, white hats and black hats. Will
liked all the names; thought it might make a magazine piece.
His memory was sketchy. He remembered his surprise at
discovering that hacker was a widely misused term. In the
outside world, it was often applied to the teenage nerds who
broke into other people's computers - other people being Cape
Canaveral or NATO - and wrought mayhem. Among technofolk,
hacker had a milder meaning: it referred to those who
played on other people's virtual lawns for fun, not malice.
Those who were up to no good - spreading viruses, taking
down the 911 emergency phone system - were known by
aficionados as crackers. They were hackers for havoc.
The same distinction applied to white hats and black hats. The former would snoop around where they were not wanted
- inside the system of one of America's biggest banks for example - but their motives were benign. They might peek at customers' account numbers, even uncovering their PIN codes, but they would not take their money (even though they could). Instead they would email the head of security at the bank with a few examples of their plundered wares. A typical white hat message, waiting in the inbox of the luckless official in charge, might read 'If I can see your data, then so can the bad guys. Fix it.' If the recipient was really unlucky, the email would be cc'd to the CEO.
Black hats would do the same but with darker purpose. They would bust into a maximum security network not on the Everest principle - because it's there - but in order to cause some damage. Sometimes it was theft, but more often the motive was cyber-vandalism: the thrill of taking down a big target. The headline-grabbing viruses of the past - I Love You and Michelangelo - were considered artistic masterpieces in the black hat fraternity.
Of course Tom's hat was as white as they came. He loved the internet, he wanted it to work. He had barely hacked, let alone cracked. He believed it was essential that the world grow to trust the web, that people felt secure on it - and that meant restraint on the part of those, like him, who knew where to find the gaps in the fence. But this was an exceptional situation. Beth's life was on the line.
Will began to pace. His legs felt weak, his stomach queasy. He had eaten nothing since first sight of that email, now some seven hours ago. He wandered over to Tom's fridge: multiple Volvic and a box of sushi. Yesterday's. Will took it out, smelled it and decided it was still just about edible. He wolfed it, then felt guilty for having any appetite at all when his wife was missing. As he swallowed, Beth came back to him. The very idea of food seemed to trigger an association with his wife. The evenings together making dinner; her unabashed appetite. Whatever he imagined, warmth, hunger or satiation, he could only think of her.
He paced some more. He flicked through the computer periodicals and obscure literary journals that Tom had in a stack by the couch.
'Will, come here.'
Tom was staring at the screen. He had done a 'whois . . .' for netspot-biz.com and had got an answer.
'You don't seem happy,' said Will.
'Well, it's good news and bad news. The good news is I now know exactly where the email was sent from. The bad news is, it could be anybody who sent it.'
'I don't get it.'
'Our path ends in an internet cafe. People are in and out of those places all the time. How stupid can you get!' Tom slammed his fist on the desk. He seemed furious. 'I thought we were going to get a nice, neat home address. Dumb ass!' Will realized Tom was addressing no one but himself. 'Where is this internet cafe?'
'Does it matter? New York is a pretty big fucking city, Will. Millions of people could have passed through there.' 'Tom.' Sternly now. 'Can you find out where it is?'
Tom returned to the screen, while Will stared. Finally he spoke.
'There's the address. Trouble is, I'm not sure I believe it.' 'Where is it?' said Will.
Tom looked him straight in the face for the first time since Will had shown him the kidnappers' email. 'It's from Brooklyn. Crown Heights, Brooklyn.'
'That's fairly near here. Why don't you believe it?'
'Look at the map.' Tom had done an instant MapQuest search, showing with a red star the exact location of the internet cafe. It was on Eastern Parkway. 'Do you realize where that is?'
'No. Come on, Tom. Stop fucking around. Tell me.' 'This message was sent from Crown Heights. That's only the biggest Hassidic community in America.'
The red star stared at them without blinking. It looked like the X on a treasure map, the kind that used to feature in Will's boyhood dreams. What lay under it?
'Despite the location, it's possible that it's not them who sent it.'
'Tom, the email was in Hebrew, for Christ's sake.' 'Yeah, but that could be a cover. The real name was golem.net.'
'Look it up.'
Tom keyed golem into Google and clicked on the first result. It brought up a page from a website of Jewish legends for children. It told the story of the Great Rabbi Loew of Prague, who used a spell from kabbala, ancient Jewish mysticism, to mould a man from clay: a vast, lumbering giant they called the Golem. Will's eye raced to the end: the story climaxed in violence and destruction, with the Golem running amok. The Golem seemed to be a Hassidic precursor of Frankenstein's monster.
'All right,' said Tom finally. 'I admit it, it does seem to be them. But it makes no sense. Why on earth would these people take Beth?'
'We don't know it's "these people". It might be one psycho who just happens to be Hassidic.' Will grabbed his coat. 'Where are you going?'
'I'm going there.'
'Are you crazy?'
'I'll pretend I'm reporting. I'll start asking questions. See who's in charge.'
'You're out of your mind. Why don't you just tell the police you've traced the email? Let them handle it.'
'What, and guarantee these lunatics kill Beth? I'm going.' 'You can't just go charging in there, with your notebook and English accent. You might as well wear a fucking sign.' I'll think of something.' Will did not say, though he thought it, that he was getting quite good at this kind of amateur detective work. His triumphs in Brownsville and Montana had left him pumped: in both cases he had found out a hidden truth. Now he would find his wife.
CHAPTER FIFTEEN

Friday, 4.10pm, Crown Heights, Brooklyn
His first reaction was confusion. He got off the subway at Sterling Street and walked straight into what looked to him like a black neighbourhood: Ebony, Vibe and Black Hair on sale at the news-stand, murals on every other wall, knots of young black men standing around in baggy combat clothes.
But once he crossed New York Avenue, he felt his pulse quicken with a reporter's sense that he was getting nearer to the story. Signs appeared in Hebrew. Some of the words were written in English characters, though their meaning was no less opaque. Chazak V'Ematz! promised one, enigmatically. Another word appeared several times, on bumper stickers, on fly posters, even on notices collared to lampposts, like flyers seeking lost cats. Will soon learned to recognize the word, though he had no idea how to pronounce it: Moshiach.

Next he passed a black man the size of a large refrigerator, with a little girl in one hand and a cigarette in the other. Will's confusion returned. He was now on Empire Boulevard, noticing Indian restaurants and vans decked out in the national flag of Trinidad and Tobago. Was he in the Hassidic neighbourhood or wasn't he?
He turned off, into residential streets. The houses were
large brownstones or made of a firm, red brick, as if once,
in a long-ago Brooklyn, they had been positively posh. Each
had a few steps up to the front door, which sat alongside a porch. In other American homes, Will guessed, these porches
might feature a swing chair, perhaps a few lanterns, certainly
a pumpkin at Hallowe'en and very often, the Stars and
Stripes. In Crown Heights they looked mainly unused,
though even here Will spotted that word again - Moshiach
- on window stickers, and once on a yellow flag with the
image of a crown, which Will took to be some kind of local
symbol.
Directly above each porch, one storey up, was a veranda,
complete with wooden balustrade. Will thought of Beth, held
behind one of these front doors: his legs suddenly tensed with
the urge to run up the stairs of each house and knock down
door after door, until he had found his wife.
Coming towards him was a group of teenage girls in long
skirts, pushing strollers. Behind them were perhaps a dozen,
maybe more, children. Will could not tell if these girls were
older sisters or exceptionally young mothers. They looked
like no women he had ever seen before, certainly not in New
York. They seemed to be from a different era, the 1950s
perhaps or the reign of Queen Victoria. No flesh was exposed,
the sleeves of their white, prim blouses covered their arms;
their skirts fell to their ankles. And their hair: the older women
seemed to wear it in a preternaturally neat bob, one that
barely moved in the wind.
Will did not look too hard; he did not want anyone to
think he was staring. Besides, he no longer needed confirmation.
This was Hassidic Crown Heights, all right. As he
walked, he honed his cover story. He would say he was a
writer for New York magazine doing a piece for its new 'Slice
of the Apple' slot, in which outsiders wrote dispatches from
different segments of New York's wonderfully diverse
community, blah, blah. He would pose as the safari-suit
explorer, sent to note down the curious ways of the natives.
And this was certainly an alien landscape. Will searched
desperately for something that might give him a handle - an
office perhaps, where he might discover who ran this place.
Maybe he could explain what had happened and they would
help him. He just needed a foothold, something in this strange
place he at least understood.
But there was nothing. Every bumper sticker seemed to
convey a message that might be worth decoding, but was indecipherable. Light Sabbath candles and you 'II light up the world! There was an ad for a show: Ready for Redemption. Even the
shops seemed to be part of this religious fervour. The Kol Tov
supermarket carried a slogan: It's all good.
He kept walking, stopping at a store front whose window
was full of notices rather than goods. One leapt out at him
straightaway.

Crown Heights is the neighbourhood of the Rebbe. Out of respect to the Rebbe and his community we request that all women and girls, whether living here or visiting, adhere at all times to the laws of modesty, including:
Closed neckline in back, side and front. (Collarbone should remain covered)
Elbows covered in all positions
Knees covered by dress/skirt in all positions
Proper cover of the entire leg and foot
No slits
Girls and women who wear immodest garments, and thereby call attention to their physical appearance, disgrace themselves by proclaiming that they possess no intrinsic qualities for which they should garner attention . . .

So that explained the dress code. But the word that leapt out at Will had nothing to do with necklines or slits. It was 'Rebbe'. This sounded like the man Will had to meet. He looked up to get his bearings, noticing for the first time the street sign. Eastern Parkway. He had barely walked ten yards when he saw another sign: Internet Hot Spot. He had arrived.

His stomach heaved as he walked in. This was surely the scene of the crime. Someone had sat at one of these cheap blondwood desks, surrounded by fake wood panelling and grey floor tiles, and typed the message announcing the theft of his wife.
He stared hard at the room, hoping his would suddenly become a superhero's gaze, magically able to absorb every detail, seeing with X-ray vision the clues that must be here. But he only had his own eyes.
The room was a mess, not like the latte-serving internet cafes he knew from Manhattan or even his own patch of Brooklyn. There was no espresso or mocha here, no coffee of any kind in fact. Just bunches of exposed wires, peeling signs on the wall, including a picture of an elderly, white bearded rabbi - a face Will had now seen at least a dozen times. The desks were arranged haphazardly, with flimsy partitions attempting the separation into individual workspaces. At the back were a stack of empty computer cartons, still leaking their Styrofoam packaging, as if the owners had simply bought the equipment, unloaded it and opened for business the same day.
Will got a few upward glances as he came in, but it was not nearly as bad as he had feared. (He had visions of his occasional student forays into out-of-the-way pubs in big English cities, places so hostile the locals seemed to fall into an instinctive, sullen silence the moment a stranger was among them.) Most of the customers in the Internet Hot Spot seemed too preoccupied to be interested in Will.
He tried to assess each of them. He noticed the two women first, both wearing berets. One was sitting side-saddle on her
stool, allowing her to keep one hand on her pram, rocking
her baby to sleep as she typed with the other. Will ruled her
out immediately: a pregnant woman could surely not have
kidnapped his wife. He eliminated the other woman just as
quickly: she had a toddler on her lap and wore perhaps the
most exhausted expression he had ever seen.
The rest of the terminals were either empty or used by
men. To Will, they all looked the same. They wore the same
rumpled, dark suits, the same open-necked white shirts, and
the same wide-brimmed black trilby hats. Will looked hard
at each one in turn - Did you kidnap my wife? - hoping that
a guilty conscience might at least send one of them blushing
or rushing out of the door. Instead they kept staring at the
computer screens and stroking their beards.
Will paid his dollar and sat at a screen himself. He was
tempted to log onto his own email, so that anyone checking
him out and reading over his shoulder would immediately
know who he was. He half-wanted them to know that he
was here, that he was onto them.
Instead, he took time to absorb what was in front of him.
Each terminal was programmed to show the same home
page, the website of the Hassidic movement. There was a
tracker on the left of the screen, scrolling birth announcements:
Zvi Chaim born to the Friedmans, Tova Leah to the
Susskinds, Chaya Ruchi to the Slonims. At the top of the
screen was a banner, showing the same face that hung on
the wall, though this time it appeared to be dissolving into a
picture of the Jerusalem skyline. Underneath ran the slogan: Long Live the Rebbe Melech HaMoshiach forever and ever.
Will read the line three times, as if trying to crack a cryptic
crossword clue. He had no idea about melech but Moshiach was now very familiar, even if he had not seen it in this form.
The word that mattered was Rebbe. The man in the picture
that hung everywhere - an ancient rabbi with a biblical white
beard and a black trilby pressed firmly on his head - was their leader, their Rebbe.
To Will, it felt like a breakthrough. All he had to do was find this man and he would get some answers. A community like this, he was sure, would be hierarchical and disciplined: nothing would happen without the nod of the top
man. He was like a tribal chief. If Beth had been taken by the men of Crown Heights, the Rebbe would have given the order. And he would know where she was now.
Will left hurriedly, anxious to find this Rebbe as quickly as he could. As he got back onto the street, he noticed that others were moving at similar speed; everyone seemed to be in a rush. Maybe something was going on? Maybe they had heard about the kidnapping?
Within a block or two he found what he was looking for: a place where people gathered to eat or drink. For reporters, cafes, bars and restaurants were essential locations. If you needed to talk to strangers, where else could you start? You could hardly knock on people's front doors; stopping people in the street was always a last resort. But in a cafe, you could start a conversation with almost anybody - and find out plenty.
There were no cafes here, no bars either, but Marmerstein's Glatt Kosher would do. It was more of a dining room than a restaurant. It looked like a canteen, with hot food at a counter served by large, grandmotherly women. Their customers seemed to be gaunt, pale men, wolfing down chicken schnitzel, gravy-soaked potatoes and iced tea as if they had not eaten for twenty-four hours. It reminded Will of the refectory at his public school: big women feeding thin boys.
Except this scene was much more bizarre. The men might have stepped out of a picture book of seventeenth-century eastern Europe and yet several of them were yammering away into cell phones. One was simultaneously tapping into a BlackBerry and reading the New York Post. The collision of
ancient and modern was jarring.
Will queued up to get his own plate, not that he felt like
eating; he just needed an excuse to be there. He hesitated
over his choice of vegetable, overcooked broccoli or overcooked carrots, and was soon upbraided by one of the
babushkas behind the counter.
'Hurry, I want to get home for shabbos,' she said without
a smile. So that explained the rush: it was Friday afternoon
and the Sabbath was coming. Tom had mentioned something
about that as Will left, but he had not taken it in: he literally
did not know what day it was. This was bound to be bad
news. Crown Heights would surely close down in the next
hour or two; no one would be around and he would find
out nothing. He had no choice; he would have to move fast,
starting right now.
He found what he needed: a man sitting alone. There was
no time for English circumlocution. He would have to deploy
the instant, American approach: Hi, how you doing, where do you come from? His name was Sandy and he was from the West Coast. Both
of which facts caught Will by surprise. He had, half-consciously, assumed that these men with their beards and black hats would
bear alien names and speak with thick Russian or Polish accents. That had been part of the culture shock of the last hour, the
realization that a corner of what could have been medieval
Europe lived and breathed in the here and now, in twenty
first century New York. He felt like a novice swimmer who
discovers he can no longer touch the bottom.
'You Jewish?'
'No, I'm not, I'm a journalist.' Ridiculous thing to say. 'I
mean, the reason why I'm here is that I'm a journalist. For New York magazine.' 'Cool. You here to write about the Rebbe?' He pronounced
it Rebb-ah.
'Yes. Well, among other things. You know, just writing
about the community.'
Sandy turned out to be relatively new to Crown Heights.
He said he had been 'a surfer dude' on Venice Beach, 'hanging
out, taking a lot of drugs'. His life had been a mess until six
years ago, when he had met an emissary of the Rebbe who
had established an outreach centre right on the oceanfront.
This Rabbi Gershon gave him a hot meal one Friday night
and that was how it started. Sandy popped in there for the
next Sabbath and the next; he stayed overnight with Gershon's
family. 'You know what was best, better even than the food
and the shelter?' said Sandy, with an intensity Will found
awkward in a man he had just met. 'They didn't judge me.
They just said that HaShem loves every Jewish soul, and that
HaShem understands why we sometimes take a roundabout
path. How sometimes we get lost.'
'HaShem?'
'Sorry, that's God. HaShem literally means "the Name". In
Judaism, we know the name of God, we can see it written
down, but we never say it out loud.'
Will gestured for Sandy to carry on. He explained that he
had put his life in the hands of the Rebbe and his followers.
He started dressing like them, eating kosher food, praying in
the morning and evening, honouring the Sabbath by
abstaining from all work or commerce - no shopping, no
using electricity, no riding the subway - from sundown on
Friday to sundown on Saturday.
'And did you do anything like that before?'
The? You gotta be kidding. Man, I didn't know what shabbos was! I ate everything that moved: lobster, crabs, cheeseburgers.
My mom didn't even know what was kosher and what was treif;
'And what does she think about, you know, this?' Will
gestured at Sandy's clothes and beard.
'You know, it's kind of a process?' Upspeak, even here.
'She found the kosher thing hard; me not being able to eat with her when I visit with her in her home. And now that I have kids, that gets kind of tricky. But the toughest thing for her, without a doubt? When I became Shimon Shmuel, rather than Sandy. She couldn't get her head round that.' 'You changed your name?'
I wouldn't really call it changing my name. Every Jew has a Hebrew name already, even if he doesn't know what it is. It's the name of our soul. So I like to say that I discovered my real name. But I use both. When I visit my mom, or when I meet, you know, someone like you, I'm Sandy. In Crown Heights, I'm Shimon Shmuel.'
'So what can you tell me about this Rebbe, then?'
'Well, he is our leader and he is a great teacher and we all love him and he loves us.'
'Do people do whatever he tells them to do?'
'It's not really like that, Tom.' (Will had had to think quickly. In all his preparation he had forgotten to make up a pseudonym. So he had borrowed Tom's first name and his mother's maiden name: Sandy thought he was talking to a freelance reporter called Tom Mitchell.) 'The Rebbe just knows what's right for all of us. He's like the shepherd and we're his flock. He knows what we need, where we should live, who we should marry. So, yes, we listen to his advice.' Will's hunch was being confirmed. This guy pulled every lever.
'And where does he live?'
'He is right here in this community, every day.'
'And can I meet him?'
'You should come to shul tonight.'

'Shut?'
'Synagogue. But it's more than that. It's our headquarters, our meeting house, our library. You'll find out all you need to know about the Rebbe there.'
Will decided to stick with Sandy. He needed a guide and Sandy would be ideal. Not much older than Will, he was not a rabbi or scholar, not some authority figure who would
require ingratiation, but a burned-out hippy who, Will
guessed, had simply cried out to be rescued. If the Moonies
had got there first, Sandy would have gone with them; he
was a man who needed someone to catch him when he fell.
They talked as they walked the few blocks to Sandy's first
stop.
'Tell me something, Sandy. What's the deal with this
clothing? How come you all dress alike?'
'I admit, I was pretty freaked by that at first. But you know
what the Rebbe says? We are more individual because we
dress this way.'
'How does he work that out?'
'Well, what makes us different from each other is not the
designer shirt we wear or an expensive suit, something on
the outside. What makes us different from each other is what's inside: our true selves, our neshama, our souls. That's
what shines out. If the outside becomes irrelevant, if we all
look the same, then people can truly start to see the inside.'
By now, they had arrived at a building Sandy referred to
as the mikve and which he translated to Will as 'ritual bath'.
They joined the line paying a dollar to the attendant at the
door, Will handing over an extra fifty cents to get a towel,
and headed downstairs into what seemed to be a large
changing room.
As soon as Sandy opened the door, they were hit by a
cloud of steam. The air itself seemed to be dripping; Will had
to blink three or four times to adjust his eyes. When he finally
regained his vision, he stepped back as if he had been punched.
The room was packed with men and boys who were either
naked or about to be. There were bony teenagers, large
bellied men in their fifties, their beards frizzing in the humidity,
and wrinkled geriatrics - all of them removing every last piece
of clothing. Will had been to the gym enough times, but there
the age range was narrower, there were fewer people and
nothing like this volume of noise. Everyone in here was
talking; if they were kids, they were screaming.
'We have to be entirely unadorned when we enter the mikve,' Sandy was saying, 'if we are to become pure for shabbos. Our skin must make total contact with the rainwater that's
collected in the mikve. If we wear a wedding ring, we have
to take it off. We must be as we were the day we were born.'
Will looked at his own finger, at the band that Beth had
given him. At their wedding ceremony, she had placed it on
his finger whispering a vow that was for his ears only. 'More
than yesterday, less than tomorrow.' It referred to the depth
of their love for each other.
Now he was standing surrounded by naked men, some
taking off tasselled vests - which Sandy explained were worn
by order of a religious commandment: a reminder of God,
even under your shirt - others putting them on, where they
instantly became stained with the moisture of skin not yet
dried, several muttering prayers in a language Will did not
understand. How strange the world is, Will thought surveying this scene, that my love for Beth could bring me to this place and
this moment.
'Coming?' Sandy was gesturing towards the pool.
Something told Will that if he was going to win this man's
trust, he would have to show respect and go along with whatever
ritual the hour called for.
'Sure,' he said, taking off his own clothes; even the wedding
ring. Gingerly he followed Sandy, reminded of his school days
and the walk to the communal shower after a winter afternoon
of rugby practice. Then, as now, he felt self-concious,
taking care to cover his private parts with his hands. The setup
here looked a lot like those old school baths, down to the
puddles of blackening water and the random pubic hairs on
the white-tiled floor. There was a sign: love your neighbour,
take a shower before the mikve. Will took his lead from
Sandy, who stood under the jet of water for just a few seconds.
Then to the mikve itself. It was like a small plunge pool and plunging was what you did. Down the stairs, wade a step or two and then down - a complete dunk, so that not a hair on your head remained dry - then twice more and out. The temperature was comfortable but no one lingered. They were not having a dip or a Jacuzzi, they were there to be purified. As Will sank below the surface, holding his breath, he was filled with an unexpected anger. Not at the men around him, not even at Beth's captors, but at himself. His wife was missing, in who knew what kind of danger, and here he was, butt naked. He was not where he should be, in a New York Police Department command centre, surrounded by flickering computer terminals manned by kidnap specialists, each of them working round the clock to trace phone calls and decode emails using state-of-the-art encryption technology, until finally one officer turns around and announces to the room
- 'We've got him!' - prompting everyone to pile into squad cars and a couple of helicopters, surrounding the criminals' den with a SWAT team of marksmen who then emerge with a trembling Beth, wrapped in a blanket, and her evil abductor in handcuffs or, better still, a body bag. All this raced through Will's mind as he held his breath in the rainwater that was meant to sanctify his body. I've seen too many movies, he thought as he came up, breathed deep and shook the water from his hair. But the core feeling persisted. He should be hunting for Beth and here he was instead, bathing with the enemy. As he dried off and put his clothes back on, he could not help but see the men around him differently. What dark secrets did they carry? Were they blamelessly ignorant of this plot or were they all in on the snatching of his wife? Was it some kind of conspiracy, starting with the Rebbe but involving all of them? He looked at Sandy, fidgeting with hairclips as he returned the black yarmulke to his head. He certainly came across as a wide-eyed innocent, but maybe that was just a skilful pose.
Will thought back to their first conversation at the diner.
Will imagined he had sought out Sandy, but maybe it was
the other way around. What if this 'Sandy' had been following
Will since he had arrived at Crown Heights, contriving to be
sitting alone in Marmerstein's at just the right moment? It
would not be such a hard trick to pull off. After all, weren't
these people famous for their cunning . . .
Will stopped himself right there. He could see what was
happening; he was panicking, allowing a red mist to descend
when he needed clarity. Hoary old stereotypes were not going
to rescue Beth, he told himself sternly. He needed to use his head. Be patient, stay polite and you will get to the truth.
They popped in briefly to Sandy's house which, Will
guessed, had simply been allocated to him. It was decorated
in a style that belonged to their grandparents' generation:
white Formica cupboards which would have looked modern
in 1970, a linoleum floor which seemed to hail from the
Kennedy era. The kitchen had two sinks and there was a
large, industrial-looking urn of boiling water, complete with
its own dispensing tap, in the corner. On every wall, in
varying expressions, were photographs of the man Will now
knew to be the Rebbe.
The living room provided the only clue that young people
were in residence. It was dominated by a play pen, and cluttered
with the bright red and yellow plastic of children's toys.
A toddler was among them, wheeling a dumper truck. Close
by, sitting in the corner of a very basic couch was a woman
bottle-feeding her baby.
Will was gripped by a feeling he had not expected: envy.
At first, he thought he was envying Sandy for having his
home intact, his wife still safe. But that was not it. He was
envious of this woman for having children. It was a new
sensation, but now, as if on Beth's behalf, he coveted this
baby and toddler: he saw them through Beth's eyes, as the
children she wanted so badly. Perhaps for the first time he
understood his wife's need. No, it was more than that. He felt it. The woman's hair was covered by a small white hat that was singularly unflattering. Underneath was a dark, thick bob
- the same style worn by every woman in Crown Heights as far as Will could see.
'This is Sara Leah,' Sandy said distractedly, heading for the stairs.
'Hi, I'm Tom,' Will said, leaning forward to offer a hand. Sara Leah blushed and shook her head, refusing to offer a hand of her own. 'Sorry,' Will said. Clearly, these rules about women and modesty went beyond the simple matter of clothing.
'OK, we're going to shulV Sandy was shouting as he raced back downstairs. He sized up Will. 'You won't need that,' he said, gesturing towards the bag Will had slung over his shoulder.
'No, that's OK, I'll just keep this with me.' Inside were his wallet, BlackBerry and, crucially, his notebook.
'Tom, I don't want you to be uncomfortable in shul and it's shabbos and we don't carry on shabbos.'
'But this is just keys, money, you know.'
'I know, but we don't have those things with us in shul or anywhere on Friday night.'
'You don't carry house keys?'
Sandy pulled up his shirt to reveal the waistband of his trousers. Around it was a string, threaded through the belt loops, carrying a single silver key. Will needed to think fast. 'You can leave your bag here. You're having shabbos dinner with us, I hope: you can pick it up then.'
Will could agree, dump the bag and just hope that Sara Leah did not take a peek: one glimpse of his credit cards and she would know that he was no Tom Mitchell. She would discover that he was Will Monroe and it would not take much detective work to know that he was the husband of the kidnapped woman, whose fate all these people were surely
aware of. She would alert the Rebbe or his henchmen and
Will would doubtless be hurled into a dungeon just like Beth.
Calm down, that's not going to happen. Everything's going to be OK. 'That's fine. I'll leave it here.' Will took off his bag, placed
it alongside the pile-up of shoes and strollers by the front
door, slipped his notebook into his breast pocket and followed
Sandy out the front door.
They walked just a few blocks to reach the synagogue.
Clusters of men in twos and threes, friends or fathers with
sons, were heading in the same direction.
The building had a kind of piazza in front of it but was
entered by walking down a couple of stairs. Just outside, a
man sucked heavily on a cigarette. 'Last one before shabbos,' Sandy explained, smiling. So even smoking was banned for
the next twenty-four hours.
Inside was what Will would have described as the very
opposite of a church: it resembled a high school gym. At the
back were a few rows of benches and tables, backing on to
bookshelves. In this area, like a large schoolroom, every seat
was taken and the noise was rising. Will soon realized this
was not a single class, but rather a cacophony of different
conversations. Pairs of men were debating with each other
across the tables, each man hunched over a Hebrew book.
They seemed to be rocking back and forth, whether they were
speaking or just listening. Next to them might be an eavesdropper
or, more likely, another pair engaged in equally
intense dialogue. Will strained to listen.
It was a mixture of English and what he took to be Hebrew,
all delivered in a sing-song rhythm that seemed to match the
rocking motion, beat for beat. 'So what are the Rabonim trying
to tell us? We learn that even though we might wish we
could study all the time, that this is the greatest mitzvah and
greatest pleasure we could ever know, in fact HaShem also
wants us to do other things, including working and making
a living.' That last word was on a down note. Now the tune
was about to go up again. 'Why would HaShem want this?
Why would HaShem, who surely wants us to be full of wisdom
and Yiddishkeit, why would He not want us to study all the
time?' The voice was getting high-pitched. 'The answer--'
and a raised finger, pointing at the ceiling emphasized the
point '--is that only by experiencing darkness do we appreciate
the light.'
Now it was the turn of his friend, his study partner, to pick
up the thread - and the tune. 'In other words, to fully appreciate
the beauty of Torah--' Toy-ra '--and learning, we have
to know life away from learning. In this way, the story of
Noach is telling every Hassid--' Chossid '--that they cannot
spend their whole life in the yeshiva, but must fulfil all their
other duties, as a husband or father or whatever. This is why
the tzaddik is not always the most learned man in the village;
sometimes the truly good man is the simple cobbler or tailor, who knows and really understands the joy of Torah because
he knows and understands the contrast with the rest of his
life. Such a Jew, because he is one who knows darkness, truly
appreciates the light.'
Will could barely follow what he was hearing; the style
of it was so unlike anything he had ever heard before.
Perhaps, he thought, this was what monasteries were like
back in the Middle Ages, monks poring over texts, frantically
trying to penetrate the word of God. He turned to
Sandy. 'What are they studying? I mean, what's the book
they're looking at?'
'Well, usually in the yeshiva, you know, the religious
academy, people will study the Talmud.' Will looked puzzled.
'Commentary. Rabbis debating the exact meaning of each
word of the Torah. A rabbi in the top left of a page of Talmud
will pick a fight with one at the bottom right, over the two
dozen meanings of a single letter of a single word.'
'And is that what they are reading now?' Will indicated
the two men whose teach-in he had been following. Sandy craned his neck to check what book they were using. 'No, these are commentaries written by the Rebbe.' The Rebbe, thought Will. Even his words are studied with the fervour of holy writ.
While they spoke, the room was filling up, people arriving in big numbers. Will had been at a synagogue once before, for the bar mitzvah of a schoolboy friend, but it had been nothing like this. On that occasion, there had been a single central service and a degree of quiet (though not the pin drop silence he was used to in church). Here there seemed to be no order at all.
Strangest of all, he could only see men. There seemed to be thousands of those white shirts and dark suits, unbroken by so much as a splash of female colour.
'Where are the women?'
Sandy pointed upwards, at what looked like the balcony of a theatre. Except you could see no one sitting down, because the view was blocked by an opaque plastic window. You could just make out the outline of the people behind, like glimpsing a projectionist in his booth. But they seemed to be shadows, revealed only in the small gap below the Perspex window. Will stared hard, trying to make out a face. Giving up, he realized that he had been searching for Beth.
It gave him the creeps. He felt as if he was being watched, as if these blocked-off, unseen women were spectral spectators, observing the antics of the men below. He imagined their vantage point: he would stand out in an instant. The one man not in black-and-white, but in chinos and blue shirt.
From nowhere, a hand-clap began. Rows of men were forming into two lines, as if clearing a path for a procession. The rhythm became faster as the men started singing. Yechi HaMelech, Yechi HaMelech
Sandy translated. Long live the King.
Now people were stamping their feet, some were swaying, others were actually jumping in the air. It reminded Will of that old, archive footage of screaming girls waiting for the Beatles. But these were grown men, working themselves into a frenzy of anticipation. One man, his face flushed, was jerking from side to side, inserting two fingers in his mouth to make a wolf-whistle.
Will took in all the faces, crushed in the crowd before him. They were not identical after all. He guessed several were Russian; a few more, their clothes somehow less formal, were dark and looked Israeli. He noticed one man, his beard wispy, whom he took to be Vietnamese. Sandy followed Will's stare. 'Convert,' he explained concisely, his voice rising to be heard above the din. 'Judaism doesn't exactly encourage conversion, but when it happens the Rebbe is really
welcoming. Much more than most Jews. He says any newcomer is as good as someone born Jewish, maybe even better because they chose to be a Jew--'
Will missed the rest, as he was squeezed between two men pressing forward, part of a large, surging huddle which, without cue or instruction, was now turning. The children seemed to be pointing the way. Several boys, who could not have been more than eight years old, were on their fathers' shoulders, waving their fists in the same direction, again and again. They looked like underage football hooligans, pointing the finger at a reviled ref. But they were not looking at a person. Their energies were directed instead at a throne. That was the word that came to mind, without prompting. It was a large chair, covered in plush red velvet. In a Spartan room like this, it stood out as an item of lavish luxury. There was no doubt, this seat was being venerated.
Yechi Adoneinu Moreinu v'Rabbeinu Melech HaMoshiach Volam va 'ed.
The crowd were singing this one line, over and over, with a fervour Will found both exhilarating and terrifying. He leaned into Sandy's ear, shouting to be heard. 'What does it mean?'
'Long live our master, our teacher, the Rebbe, King Messiah forever and ever.'
Messiah. Of course. That's what this word daubed everywhere meant. Moshiach was Messiah. How could he have been so slow? These people regarded their Rebbe as nothing less than the Messiah.
Now Will was desperate to raise himself to full height, to see above the crowd who were all staring so intently at the throne, their voices hoarse with anticipation. Surely the Rebbe would make his entrance any second now, though how his followers would top their current levels of ecstasy to mark his arrival, Will could not imagine.
The noise was becoming deafening. Will tried to find Sandy's ear again, but he had been shoved forward in the melee. Will's face was now uncomfortably close to a different man, who smiled at him, recognizing the humour of their sudden intimacy. What the hell, thought Will.
'Excuse me, can you tell me, when does the Rebbe come in? When does everything begin?'
'Excuse me?'
'When does everything begin?'
At that moment and before the man had a chance to respond, Will felt a hand clamp tightly on his shoulder. In his ear, a deep, baritone voice.
'For you, my friend, it all ends right here.'
CHAPTER SIXTEEN

Friday, 8.20pm, Crown Heights, Brooklyn
The hand left his shoulder only to be replaced by two more on each of his arms. He was flanked by two men who he guessed were no older than twenty but were both taller, and stronger, than him. One had a reddish beard, the other just a few wisps of chin hair. Both looked straight ahead as they frogmarched him away through the crowd. Will was too shocked to shout; no one would have heard him anyway. In the crush, he knew people would barely take a second look at a trio of men jammed together, especially since two of them were now singing along with enthusiasm.
He was being led away from the throne, back towards the library area, where the crowds were marginally thinner. Will was no good at guessing numbers - not enough experience covering demos - but he reckoned this room must have had two or three thousand people crammed into it, all of them chanting so furiously that his captors could have killed him there and then and nobody would have noticed.
Suddenly his handlers turned behind some shelves and down a narrow, scuffed corridor. The redbeard opened one door, then another until finally they were in what seemed to be a small classroom: more of those dark-wood benches and tables, more shelves lined with leather books, whose titles were in gold-lettered Hebrew. He was deposited firmly in a stiff, plastic chair in the middle of the room, the Hassidic heavies planting him to the spot by taking a shoulder each.
'I don't understand what's happening,' Will said weakly. 'What's going on here? Who are you?'
'Wait.'
'Why have you brought me here?'
'I said wait. Our teacher will be here soon. You can talk to him.'
The Rebbe. At last.
The noise from next door was still throbbing. Maybe the Rebbe had finally made his entrance; perhaps he was working the room before he came in here to work over Will. The clamour was certainly thumpingly loud; the ground was moving like the walls of a club, shaken by bass. But whether it had suddenly got louder, as if the Rebbe had arrived while Will was dragged out of the room, he could not tell. 'OK, let us begin.'
That same baritone voice, again from behind. Will tried to turn around, but the hands came down to clamp his shoulders tight.
'What's your name?'
Tom Mitchell.'
'Welcome Tom and good shabbos. Tell me, why do we have the pleasure of your company in Crown Heights?'
'I'm here to write a story for New York magazine about the Hassidic community. It's for a new slot: "Slice of the Apple".' 'Cute. And why have you come here this weekend of all weekends?'
'They only commissioned me to do it this week so I came the first weekend I could.'
'You didn't call ahead, you didn't want to make an arrangement maybe?'
'I just wanted to look around.'
'See how the natives live in their natural habitat?'
'I wouldn't put it like that,' Will croaked. The force of two
men pressing their hands down on his shoulders was starting
to take its toll. 'I hope I'm not being rude, but why are you
holding me like this?'
'You know, Mr Mitchell, I'm glad you asked me that because
I wouldn't want to give you the wrong impression of Crown
Heights or its people. We welcome guests here, we really do.
We invite visitors into our homes. We are not even hostile
to the press; reporters have come here often. We have had no less than The New York Times pay us an occasional visit.
No, the reason for this,' he paused, 'unusual reception is that
I don't believe you're telling us the truth.'
'But I am a reporter. That is the truth.'
'No, the truth, Mr Mitchell, is that somebody has been
prying into what is strictly our business and I am wondering
if that somebody is you.' The voice, briefly raised, paused to
recover its equilibrium. 'Let's relax a bit, shall we? It's shabbos, we've all had a hard week. We've worked hard. Now we rest.
So let's take it slow and calm down. Back to my question.
You've been talking to Shimon Shmuel for a while, so I'm
sure you've picked up a few things about our customs already.'
They've been following me.
'You're an intelligent man. You've realized by now that
observance of the Sabbath is one of our strictest rules.'
Will said nothing.
'Mr Mitchell?'
'Yes, I understand that.'
'You know we are forbidden from carrying on the Sabbath,
don't you?'
'Yes, Sandy told me. Shimon Shmuel.' He regretted that
late addition of Sandy's Hebrew name: it sounded like an
attempt at ingratiation.
'He may not have mentioned that on the Sabbath, we are
forbidden to carry but not only to carry: we are also barred
from using electricity of any kind. The lights that are on now
were switched on before shabbos began and they will stay on
all day until after shabbos ends tomorrow night. Those are
the rules: no Jew is allowed to turn them on or off. Moreover,
you'll have noticed that there were no cameras out there just
now. And there have never been cameras out there, not on shabbos. What you saw just now has never been photographed
or filmed. Never, and that's not through lack of requests. Do
you see where I'm heading, Mr Mitchell?'
Now that he had heard the voice speaking for longer, he
began to form a picture of the speaker. He was an American,
but his accent was not the same as Sandy's. It was more,
what, European? Something. Will could not quite identify
what it was: certainly more New York, almost musical. It
contained a kind of shrug, a recognition of the absurdity of
life, sometimes comic, usually tragic. In split, fractional seconds
he saw the face of Mel Brooks and heard the voice of Leonard
Cohen. He still had no idea what the man speaking to him
looked like.
'Mr Mitchell, I need to know whether you understand
what I'm saying.'
'No, I don't have a camera, if that's what you're asking.'
'As it happens, I wasn't thinking about that. More on the
lines of a recording device.'
Again, Will was in the clear. Despite his age, he did things
the old-fashioned way: notebook and pen. This was not down
to some technophobic Luddism on his part, but sheer laziness.
Transcribing recordings was just too much hassle: you did an
interview for half an hour, then spent an hour writing it up.
The mini-disc recorder was saved only for set-piece interviews
where every word was likely to count: mayors, police chiefs,
that kind of thing. Otherwise he opted for paper and ink.
'No, I haven't recorded anyone. But why would it be a
problem--'
He suddenly felt himself jerked forward and then up, the darker, younger man at his left side apparently taking the lead. The pair of them had looped their arms under Will's armpits and levered him upward, ensuring he did not turn around. Next, the dark man swung around to face him, avoiding Will's eye while he first stretched Will's arms up and out, then reached under his jacket, moving his hands over Will's shirt, around his back and under his armpits. He was like a zealous airport security guard.
Of course. Recording device. They weren't looking for a reporter's Dictaphone. They were looking for a wire. They were worried that he was the police or the FBI. Of course they were: they were kidnappers and they feared Will was an undercover cop. The questions he had been asking, the snooping around with no warning.
'No wire,' the dark man was saying, in an accent that confirmed him as at least Middle Eastern if not Israeli. 'But there is this.' It was the redbeard, whose task during this two-man body search, which had continued up and down Will's legs when it was not focused on his back, had been to examine the captive's every pocket - including the one on the inside left of his jacket. His secrets offered little resistance: his Moleskine notebook always made a neat bulge in his left breast pocket. Redbeard took it out and offered it to the unseen hand behind. Will, shoved back down into his seat, could hear the pages being turned.
The blood seemed to drain from him. His mind rewound back to Sandy's house, when his host urged him to leave his bag behind. And Will thought he was being so clever. He had left his bag behind all right - but only after he had slipped out his notebook and zipped his wallet into what he liked to think was a concealed compartment. He had not wanted Sara Leah prying. Now the book was in the Rebbe's hands. What a fool!
Will girded himself for the explosion. The longer the silence lasted, punctuated only by the sound of turned pages, the slicker the moisture on Will's palms.
His mind was racing, trying to remember what was in that book that might give him away. Luckily, he was not organized enough to have written his own name on the first page or anywhere else. Walton did that, a neat inscription on the cover of each pad he used. Some reporters even used those nerdy address labels. On that score at least, Will was saved by his own inefficiency.
But what about the reams of words inside, including the copious notes he had taken today, right here in Crown Heights? Maybe those would be OK; they would at least confirm his Tom Mitchell cover story. But had he not scribbled down all that computer stuff at Tom's earlier? Surely he had written down something about the kidnappers' email? The seconds lurched by, like a record playing at the wrong, too-slow speed. A hope took root. Could it be that his bastard shorthand, his unique speedwriting scrawl, was about to rescue him? He had developed this hybrid non-system of note-taking first at Columbia and then at the Record. It worked for him, though he always feared the day he was asked to produce notes for the editor, or worse still a judge in court. He imagined a defamation trial, turning on the accuracy of his written account of a conversation. He would need teams of graphologists to verify that he was as good as his words. The upside, at least at this moment, was that Will knew his notes would be all but indecipherable.
'You've broken our rules, Mr Mitchell. I don't mean our rules, as in us, the people of Crown Heights. What do we matter in the great scheme of things? We are ants! But you've broken HaShem's rules.'
A sentence surfaced that instant in Will's head. Thou shalt not bear false witness. It was, Will realized, as if he was the mere recipient of the thought rather than its source, one of the ten commandments. He knew that Jews and Christians had those in common - and that was surely what the Rebbe
had in mind. This was the preamble to an accusation of lying.
He was undone.
'I think you know that we're serious about these rules: no
carrying on the Sabbath. No carrying. No wallets, no keys.
No notebooks.'
'Yes.'
'We take these rules very seriously, Tom. They apply to our
guests as much as they apply to us. I'm sure you understand
that. Yet here you are, with a notebook.'
'Yes, but that's the only thing I took. I left the rest of the
stuff behind; I left my bag.' Will was addressing a book case:
his interrogator was behind him, his captors at his side.
'Besides, I'm not Jewish. I didn't think, you know, that these
rules applied to me.' That sounded much more lame out loud
than it had in Will's head. It sounded like schoolboy special
pleading: the dog ate my homework. But it was the truth.
Sure, he should be respectful to others while he was in their
community, but this was crazy. They could not be this angry about a Sabbath infraction, could they? He was almost
relieved: if this was the charge, it meant the Rebbe had found
nothing to pursue in the notebook.
'You're not Jewish?'
'No, I told Sandy, Shimon that already. I'm not Jewish. I'm
just a reporter.'
'Now that surprises me. I've got to admit, that I did not
expect.'
Will was baffled, but also distracted. Redbeard had vanished.
Will's sole custodian was now this Israeli: he looked young.
The Times magazine had run a piece about the Israeli army
only a couple of weeks back. With a half-memory of that as
his source, Will knew that an Israeli man needed only to be
aged twenty-one to have done a full three years in the Israel
Defence Forces. God knows what he had learned there: this
guy might look like a kid, but chances were he had steel in
his veins. Why else had the Rebbe picked him to turn the screws on Will? He vaguely remembered from the same piece that many ultra-orthodox eighteen-year-olds were given exemption from army service so that they could devote their lives to studying the Torah. But not all of them: something told him this was one of the guys who swapped his prayer book for a rifle.
'You know, Mr Mitchell - or should I call you Tom? - I'm not sure we're making that much progress here. Something is missing from this encounter.'
There it was again, that sardonic, world-weary inflection, as if there was humour in every situation, even this one. Will could not get the measure of this man at all: his voice was warm, avuncular even. Yet the room was humid with menace and it was all coming from him, from behind Will's back. 'I propose that we relocate.'
Clearly he had given some kind of nod, because the Israeli swiftly placed a blindfold on Will; not like the childhood variety, where some light always leaks through, but a complete cover, one that seemed to choke the eyelids, stopping them breathing. He felt himself being yanked upward again, out of the chair. Except this time it was not for another standing search, but to be led away.
Will decided he would not panic. He would not give in to the feeling that, with each step, he was leaning into a dark, empty space, plunging off a cliff into an abyss. He would focus on the ground beneath his feet; each time he lifted one leg, he would remember how near the ground remained. Perhaps he should scrape his shoes along, to maintain constant contact? Maybe that was why you always saw handcuffed prisoners shuffling: it was not because they were depressed, but because they needed the reassurance that the earth was still there, right under their shoes.
He was aware of passing through another corridor, getting further away from the clamour of the synagogue which, Will realized, had begun to fade into a loud hubbub a while back. He chided himself for not having noticed exactly when; that detail was surely important in tracking the Rebbe's movements. What
was truly strange, though, was the feeling of dependency on the Israeli now gripping his right arm with painful force. Will was relying on him as a guide, aware that he must now look the way blind men always look: Stevie Wonder or Ray Charles, his head moving randomly, untethered to logic. This man was his captor but, Will thought, he was also his carer. Now he felt the cold. They had moved outside, but only for a few steps. He heard the creak of a swing door, like a garden gate, and then felt the change of temperature. As if they were in an enclosed space, though not quite outdoors. There was an echo.
'No one likes this, I'm afraid, Mr Mitchell. Tom. But I'm going to have to take a look at you.'
It was in the next few seconds that Will decided that this was not some ghastly incident that would soon resolve itself, but actually something rather terrifying. until now, he had clung to the idea that this might be an error or even an ironic send-up of the interrogation scene from a thousand movies. He had been hoping that it would all be revealed as a hideous mistake; or that, at least, he would soon know the identity of his inquisitor; or that he would make progress; or that this would simply stop. Now he felt sure these strange people who had stolen his wife were about to torture and kill him, probably in a way so sadistic as to chill the blood. Worse than that, and this thought turned his bowels to mush, they had doubtless already done whatever they were going to do, or worse, to Beth.
'No!' Will shouted, but it was too late. He felt his arms being pinned back while someone unbuckled his trousers. There was a hand over his mouth, too. This could not be the work of the Israeli, all alone. But where were these extra hands coming from? Who did they belong to? And then, without warning, his underpants were down.
'Stop.' He heard the word and was shocked to discover the voice was not his own. The Rebbe had spoken. 'You're telling the truth. You're not Jewish.'
Will could only guess what was happening: the Rebbe must have been standing in front of him, looking at his penis and concluding, rightly, that it was not circumcised.
'You're not Jewish,' the Rebbe repeated. And then, to his assistant or assistants: 'Cover him up.' A pause. 'Well, this is good news, Mr Mitchell. I now believe that you are not a federal agent or a law enforcement official. I suspected you were, prowling around with all your questions. But I know those people and, first, they would have had you wired and, second, they would have sent a Jew. Not only that, but they would have considered themselves very smart for doing that. Oh, yes, regular geniuses for giving Agent Goldberg a call and saying "This is a job with your name on it." That's how they think. Send an Arab to infiltrate a Muslim terrorist gang, send a Jew to us. But you're not a Jew, so you're not working for them. That I now believe.'
Will's trousers were back on, his belt was buckled up and he was off a hook if not the hook: he was not an undercover federal agent. All that combined to reduce the terror of a few moments ago. His body, the pounding of his heart, the moisture on his palms was at code orange, rather than red, where it had been seconds earlier.
'You look relieved, Mr Mitchell. I'm glad. The trouble is, if you're not a fed, you must be working for someone else. And that, I fear, is infinitely more serious.'
CHAPTER SEVENTEEN

Friday, 9.22pm, Crown Heights, Brooklyn
He did not have long to be confused. After the Rebbe had spoken, perhaps a beat passed before Will felt his back pushed forward, making him buckle at the waist. His arms were now gripped like levers, pushing his head and shoulders down and forward.
His nose felt it first, as it filled with water; then his scalp, as it shrank from the cold. His throat gurgled and gagged. He was choking and gasping at the same time.
Will's head and neck had just been submerged in freezing cold water, the blindfold still on. He could feel his chest contract with the shock of it, his heart racing. He had been shoved with some force, in the darkness and therefore without warning, into that icy liquid. He was there for five or six seconds, his shoulders held down to prevent him coming up for air. It was long enough to fill his nostrils, for the water to travel down his sinuses and into his brain. Or that's how it felt - like asphyxiation.
Once out, he gulped in air even as he coughed, a double reflex like vomiting. But then the hands were pushing again and he was under once more.
This time it was the temperature. His eyes seemed to shrivel in their sockets, recoiling from the cold; he was sure he could hear his whole system, veins, arteries and blood vessels, screaming with the trauma of the sudden radical change in temperature.
What was this? A pond? An icebox? The edge of a river? A toilet? The blindfold was soaked but not loosening; if anything it seemed now to be welding itself onto Will's eyelids, sealed in by ice.
'Now, Tom,' the voice was saying, its timbre distorted by the frozen water in Will's ears. 'Shall we start talking honestly?' By way of response, Will spat out a mouthful of the water, emptying himself for the next, inevitable dunk.
'I believe this is your second time at the mikve today. You're becoming a regular frummie, aren't you Tom? And I'm sure Shimon Shmuel explained to you the purpose, the meaning of the mikve. This is a place of purification, a place of sanctification. We enter coated in the sins of our regular lives and
emerge tahoor, pure. And in this state we are untainted by any sins, be they lies or deceits. Do you follow me, Tom?' Will was now shivering. His shirt was soaked and he could feel rivulets of liquid chill running down his back and chest. His teeth were about to start chattering.
'What I am saying is that I now insist on the truth. And
if two or three dips in this outdoor mikve, filled only by purest rainwater, cannot find the truth in you then maybe four or five or six or seven submersions will. We are patient men. We will keep plunging you into that water until you deal with us plainly and straightforwardly. Do you understand?' There must have been a silent nod, because down Will
went again. The cold was now biting into him, seeping below his skin and into his bones. They too seemed to contract, as if they could hide from the cold by making themselves smaller. 'Who do you work for, Tom? Who sent you here?'
'I'm a journalist,' was all Will could manage, in a voice he hardly recognized, querulous with cold.
'You've said that, but who wants you here? Why are you
here?'
I've told you.'
And down he went again, this time shoved so that his
whole upper body was submerged. He felt the water travel
below his waist, trickling into his shorts, spreading an icy
damp around his groin.
He had no idea what to say. He wanted desperately for this
to end, but what could he do? If he told the truth, he would
endanger himself and Beth. The kidnappers had been clear:
no involvement of the police. That surely extended to vigilante
rescue missions as well. These were serious, violent
people and he would be admitting he had defied their instructions.
He would also be confessing that he had indeed been
lying. As for Beth, they had kidnapped her for some purpose
- which he could not fathom - but one thing he knew: his
presence here was not part of their plan. If they had not
already done great harm to her, his appearance would all but
guarantee it.
Yet to carry on insisting that he was Tom Mitchell seemed
doomed. He could not give them any more information
because there was no more; Mitchell was a fiction. On this
the Rebbe's instincts were right. Even if Will had the strength to withstand this weight, he would eventually crack because
his story would crack: it had to. These were his thoughts as
the weight on his hands and shoulders came again, plunging
his body deep into the cold.
'Enough,' Will said. 'No more.'
'Maybe I need to explain a little about Judaism,' the voice
was saying as he was finally allowed back up for air.
He could hardly make out the words, so loud was the
explosion generated by his own lungs as he gulped for oxygen.
'Judaism holds the harshest possible view of murder. "Thou
shalt not kill" is the sixth commandment. It means that murder
is never allowed.' There was a long pause, as if the Rebbe
expected Will to react. Will could not; he was still drawing
in loud, urgent breaths.
'I don't know if you're familiar with one of our most famous
teachings, Mr Mitchell. "To save a single life is to save the
whole world." Really, the whole world. That's how much
each life matters to HaShem. In each individual person is
contained the whole world. Because we are all created in
God's image. This is the meaning behind the phrase "sanctity
of life", Mr Mitchell. Now it is a cliche. People just say
it without even thinking. But what do those words really
mean?' The voice had a hint of the music he had heard
before, back in the synagogue - that sing-song, up-and-down
rhythm, by turns questioning and answering, all in a single
monologue. 'They mean that life is sacred, because it is part
of the divine. To kill a human being is to kill an aspect of the
Almighty. Which is why we are forbidden to kill. Except in the most exceptional circumstances.'
Will felt the cold bite deeper into his flesh.
'Self-defence is the obvious example, but it is not the only
one. You see, in Judaism we have a beautiful concept known
as pikuach nefesh. This refers to the saving of a soul. Now,
there is no more sacred duty than pikuach nefesh: almost
anything is allowed if it will save a soul. Rabbis are often
asked, "Can a Jew ever eat pork?" The answer is yes! Of
course he can! If he is on a desert island and the only means
to survive is to slay a pig and eat it, then not only is the Jew
allowed to do that, he must do it! He must. It is a religious
commandment: he must save his own life. Pikuach nefesh.
'Let's take a more difficult case.' The man was speaking as
if this was a tutorial at Balliol College, a one-to-one class with
Will as his pupil. The fact that Will was kneeling, his hands
now tied, his body drenched and frozen, barely broke his stride.
'Would we be allowed to kill, if that would save a life?
No. The rules of pikuach nefesh prohibit murder, idolatry and
sexual immorality even to save a life. If someone tells you
to commit murder, just to save your own skin, you cannot do it. But let's say a known killer is on the loose. He is on his way to murder a family of innocents. We know that if we kill him, their lives will be saved. Is it right to kill in that situation? Yes, because such a man is what we call a rodef. If there is no other way to stop him, he can be killed with impunity.
'But let's sharpen the dilemma. What if the man we are discussing is not necessarily a killer, but if he stays alive, one way or another, innocent people will die? What should we do then? Can we hurt such a man? Can we kill him? This is the sort of question our sages discuss at great length. Sometimes our Talmudical debates can seem to be obsessed with detail, even trivia: how many cubits in length should an oven be, that kind of thing. But the heart of our study is reserved for what you would call ethical dilemmas. I have thought about this particular one in great depth. And I have reached a conclusion that, in fairness, I think I ought to disclose to you. I believe that it is permissable to inflict pain and even death on a man who may not himself be a killer - but whose suffering or death would save lives. I think there is no other way of understanding our sources. That is what they are telling us.
'To get to the point, Mr Mitchell, if I conclude that you are, in effect, a rodef, and that to end your life would save others, I would not hesitate to see that it ended. Perhaps you need a moment to reflect on that.'
The pressure came a half-second later, as if, once again, the Rebbe had given his silent cue. The cold bit deep, still shocking. Will counted, to get himself through. Usually he was lifted out after around fifteen seconds under. Now he counted sixteen, seventeen, eighteen.
He flexed his shoulders, to give his captors a signal that it was time to let him breathe. They pressed down harder. Will began to struggle. Twenty, twenty-one, twenty-two. Was this the meaning of the Rebbe's little lecture?
Something not abstract or complex, despite the convoluted exposition, but rather simple: we are now going to kill you. Thirty, thirty-one, thirty-two. Will's legs were kicking, as if they belonged to someone else. His body was panicking, sent into a survival reflex. Did not the movies always show this, as the murderer smothered his victim with a pillow, or tightened a stocking around her neck, the legs moving in an involuntary dance?
Forty, forty-one. Or was it fifty? Will had lost count. His head seemed to flood with dull colour, like the patterns you detect under your eyelids just before sleep. He wanted to weep for the wife he was about to leave behind and wondered if it was possible to weep underwater. Thought itself grew faint. At last they let go, but Will did not burst out of the water with the gasping energy of before. Now the men had to pull him out, letting him collapse onto the ground. He lay there, his chest rising and falling fast but as if unconnected to the rest of him. He heard distant breathing and could not be certain if it was his own.
Slowly he felt his ears unblock and strength return to his arms and legs. He stayed slumped on the ground, unable to face hauling his body upright. If they wanted him to sit to attention, they would have to drag him up themselves. Lying there, he detected a change, another person in the group around him. There was new activity, whispered exchanges. The new member of the circle seemed to be breathing heavily, as if he had just been running. He could hear the Rebbe's voice, though he seemed to be distracted, his voice aimed downwards, as if he was looking at something, reading.
'Mr Mitchell, Moshe Menachem, who was with us a few moments ago, has just completed an errand.' Redbeard. 'He ran from here to Shimon Shmuel's house. He has returned with a wallet. Your wallet.'
They had rummaged through his bag; now it was surely over. His wallet would give him away. What was in there? No business cards; he was too low down the food chain at the Times to have any. No credit cards either; he kept those in a separate wallet, zipped into a pocket of its own in his bag. He had left them in there, calculating that even if Sara Leah could not resist a peek at his belongings, she would hesitate before doing a full probe.
What else was in there? Tons of cab receipts, but anything with his name on it? He had kept all the hotel bills and credit card slips from the Northwest in a separate envelope, for a later expenses claim. Maybe he would be OK. Maybe he would get away with it.
Take the blindfold off. Let go of his hands. Lead him back into the Bet HaMidrash.' Will could feel the confusion in his own adrenal gland: was this a cue to produce yet more adrenalin, ready for the ordeal to come or, at last, a sign that the danger was receding? Was this good news or bad news? He could feel hands fussing behind his head and then an increase in light as the sodden cloth covering his eyes was removed. Instinctively he shook off the drops as he opened his eyes. He was outside, in a small area surrounded by a wooden fence - the kind of space large buildings use to keep their trash. There were a few pipes and, at his feet, the glint of water. He barely had a chance to look, his two handlers were already turning him away. But he guessed that this was the housing for some kind of outdoor storage tank, a big vat used to collect rainwater.
Now he was heading through a door and back inside, though something told Will this was not the way they had come out. It seemed to be quieter for one thing, away from the crowds. Will guessed that this was a separate building, perhaps a house adjoining the synagogue.
Inside it did not look that different: the same functional floors and rabbit warren of classrooms and offices. With Redbeard, Moshe Menachem, and the Israeli flanking him, they headed into one of them and Will heard the door shut behind him.
'Let him sit down. Untie his hands and give him a towel. And find a dry shirt.'
The Rebbe's voice; still behind him. The blindfold was off, but clearly Will was not going to see everything. 'OK, we should begin again.'
Will braced himself.
'We need to have a talk, Mr Monroe.'
CHAPTER EIGHTEEN

Friday, 7.40pm, Rio de Janeiro, Brazil
It was the end of an exhausting week; Luis Tavares could feel the fatigue spreading through his joints. Even so, he would climb one more level: there were other people to see.
Some money had just come in. He could see that all around him. Suddenly this street was paved, the asphalt fresh enough to smell. Kids were buzzing around a TV set, visible through the open, doorless entrance to a shack. Luis smiled: his pestering of the authorities had worked. Either that or
someone had bribed the power company to connect this row of huts to the city grid. Or a few people had clubbed together to find a cowboy electrician who would do it for a few reais. Luis felt a familiar spasm of ambivalence. He knew he was meant to advocate respect for the law and condemn all forms of theft. Yet he could not help but admire these outlaws, these entrepreneurs of the favelas, who did whatever it took to provide for their communities. He applauded their determination to provide a stretch of road or desks for a classroom.
Could he condemn them for breaking the law? What
kind of pastor would deny people who had next to nothing the little that makes life bearable?
He wanted to rest, but he knew he would not. Even the briefest pause made Luis feel guilty. He felt guilt when he
awoke: how much more work could he have done if he had
not slept? He felt guilt when he ate: how many more people
could he have helped in that half hour he had spent feeding
his face? And in Favela Santa Marta there was never any
shortage of people needing help. The poverty was unstoppable,
insatiable, like waves on a beach. And Luis Tavares
was the local Canute - standing on the shore, raging at the
sea.
He continued upward, heading for the view he knew would
stun him, even after all these years. From that vantage point,
he would be able to see both the city and the ocean, stretching
out ahead. On nights like this, he liked to gaze at the glittering
carpet of light, the sparkle of other favelas in the
distance. Best of all, he was close to the sight that had made
Rio de Janeiro famous: the giant statue of Jesus Christ, watching over the city, the country and, as far as Luis was
concerned, the whole world.
As he climbed, the pastor noted for the thousandth time
how the housing deteriorated with the altitude. At the bottom
of the hill, there were homes that were recognizable as homes.
The structures were solid; they had walls, a roof and glass in
the windows. Some had running water, a phone line and
satellite TV. But as you moved up the hillside, such sights
became rarer. The places he passed now barely qualified even
as shelters. They were thrown together, perhaps a wall made
of rusty steel, a sheet of corrugated plastic serving as a roof.
The door was a gap; the window a hole. They were jammed
together, one leaning on the other like a house of cards. This
was one of the main shantytowns near Rio's wealthy beach
district and it was abject.
He had been here for twenty-seven years, ever since he
first graduated from divinity school. Baptist clergy were always
meant to see some searing deprivation early in their career,
but not all became transfixed by it as he had. He would not
learn its lessons and move on. He would stay and fight it, no matter how unequal the struggle. He knew poverty on this scale was like a garden weed: you might banish it today, but it would be back tomorrow.
Even so, he refused to feel that what he had done here was futile. There were dose to ten thousand people crammed on this hillside, each one of them a soul created in the image of God. If even one had a meal he would otherwise not have eaten, or slept under a roof rather than in a tiny, fetid alleyway
- there was no room for anything so grand as a street - then Luis's entire life's work would have been justified. That was how he saw it, at any rate.
He felt frustrated that he was not engaged in that kind of activity this evening: the direct business of care - ladling out soup to a hungry woman, draping a blanket over a shivering child - where a change is made every second. No, his task tonight was to gather evidence for a report he had been asked to submit to a government department.
That they even wanted to see a report counted as an
achievement, the result of nine months of Luis's lobbying. Government - federal, state and municipal - had given up on places like Santa Marta years ago. They did not visit them, they did not police them. They were no-go areas where the writ of the state did not run. So if people wanted something
- a hospital, say, or a yard where the kids could play football
- they either organized it themselves or they had to
harangue and nag government until it finally paid attention. Which is where Luis came in. He had become Santa Marta's advocate, lobbying the state bureaucracy one week, a foreign charity the next, demanding they do something for the people of the favela, for the kids who grew up sidestepping sewage in the alleys or scavenging food from the trash mountains nearby. His favourite tool was shame. He would ask people to look at Lagoa, the neighbourhood just over the hill which was proud to be one of the wealthiest districts in Latin America. Then he would show them a Santa Marta child who ate less in a week than a Lagoa chihuahua nibbled in a day. Tonight he was gathering testimony, talking to residents of one of the favela's toughest stretches. They would explain to him why they needed a clinic, what it should provide and where it should be, and he would pass that information on to officialdom as part of his submission. These days Luis even used a video camera, ensuring that the people of the favelas could speak for themselves.
Now he was at the first address, not that there were any numbers on this or any other house. He went inside and was surprised to see several unfamiliar faces: all young men. Perhaps Dona Zezinha was not around.
'Should I wait?' he asked of one of the group. But there was no reply. 'Is this your home?' he said to another, a wolf faced boy who seemed nervous, avoiding Luis's gaze. Finally, 'What's going on?'
As if to answer the pastor's question, the wolf-boy produced a gun. Luis's instant thought was that the weapon looked vaguely comic; it was too large for the lad's hand. But then the gun was aimed at him. Before he had a chance to realize he was going to die, the bullet had torn his heart wide open. Luis Tavares died with a look of surprise rather than terror on his face. If anything, it was his killers who looked scared. They hurriedly covered the corpse with a blanket, just as they were told, then ran through the streets, agitated, rushing to meet the man who had ordered this job done. They took the money from him quickly, their eyes feverish. They did not listen as he thanked them. They barely heard him as he praised them for doing the Lord's work.
CHAPTER NINETEEN

Friday, 10.05pm, Crown Heights, Brooklyn
'I see that we have both made a mistake here. Your mistake is that you have lied to me and lied consistently, even under immense pressure. Under the circumstances, I now understand that and even find it admirable.' Will could hardly hear the words over the sound of his own heart throbbing. He was scared, much more terrified than he had been outside. The Rebbe had discovered the truth. Something in the wallet had betrayed him, doubtless one loose credit card receipt or a long-forgotten Blockbuster membership card. God only knew what pain lay in store for him now.
'You are here to look for your wife.'
'Yes.' Will could hear the exhaustion in his own voice. And the anguish.
'I understand that, and I hope that I would do the same in your position. I am sure Moshe Menachem and Tzvi Yehuda agree.' Now both the thugs had names. 'It is a duty for all husbands to provide for and protect their wives. That is the nature of the marriage commitment.
'But I am afraid the usual rules cannot apply in this case. I cannot let you come charging in here, no matter how heroically, and rescue your wife. I cannot allow it.'
'So you admit that you have her here?'
'I don't admit anything. I don't deny anything. That is not the purpose of what I am saying to you, Mr Monroe. Will. I am trying to explain that the usual rules don't apply in this case.'
'What usual rules? What case?'
'I wish I could tell you more, Will, I really do. But I cannot.' Will was not sure if he had just been ground down by the ordeal of the last few - what was it: hours, minutes? - or whether he was simply relieved that it was over, but he was sure he heard something different in the Rebbe's voice. The menace had gone; there was a sadness, a sorrow in it that Will heard as sympathy, maybe even compassion for himself. It was ridiculous: the man was a torturer. Will wondered if he was succumbing to Stockholm Syndrome, the strange bond that can develop between a captive and his captor: first depending on the Israeli as if he was a guide dog for the blind rather than a violent brute, and now detecting humanity in his chief tormentor. This was surely an irrational reaction to the end of the ducking-stool treatment: rather than feeling anger that it had happened at all, he was feeling gratitude to the Rebbe for ending it. Stockholm Syndrome, a classic case. And yet, Will rated himself a good judge of character. He reckoned he had always been perceptive and he was sure he could hear something real in that voice. He gambled on his hunch.
'Tell me something which I have a right to know. Is my wife safe? Is she . . . unharmed?' He could not bring himself to say the word he really meant - alive - not because he feared the Hassidim's reaction so much as his own. He feared his voice would crack, that he would show a weakness he had so far kept hidden.
'That is a fair question, Will, and yes, she will be safe - so long as no one does anything reckless or stupid, and by "no one" I am referring chiefly to you, Will. And by "anything reckless or stupid" I am speaking chiefly of involving the
authorities. That will ruin everything and then I can make
no guarantees for anyone's safety.'
'I don't understand what you could want from my wife.
What has she done to you? Why don't you just let her go?'
He had not meant to, but his mouth had taken the decision
for him: he was begging.
'She has done nothing to us or anyone else, but we cannot
let her go. I'm sorry that I cannot say more. I can imagine
how hard this is for you.'
That was the Rebbe's mistake, that last line. Will could
feel the blood rushing to his face, the veins on his neck
rising.
'No, you fucking CANNOT imagine how hard this is. You
have not had your wife kidnapped! You have not been
grabbed, blindfolded, shoved into freezing water and threatened
with death by people who never so much as show their
face. So don't tell me you can imagine anything. You can
imagine NOTHING!'
Tzvi Yehuda and Moshe Menachem almost sprang back,
clearly as shocked by this outburst as Will himself. The anger
had been brewing since he got to Crown Heights - in fact,
long before. Since the moment that message popped into his BlackBerry: We have your wife.
'You said it was time for plain dealing. So how about some
plain dealing? What the hell is this about?'
'I can't tell you that.' The voice was softer than it had been,
almost dejected. 'But this is about something much bigger
than you could possibly know.'
'That's ridiculous. Beth is a shrink. She sees kids who won't
talk and girls who starve themselves. What bigger thing could
involve her? You're lying.'
'I'm telling you the truth, Will. The fate of your wife
depends on something much larger than you or her or me.
In a way it hangs on an ancient story, one that no one could
ever have imagined would have turned out this way. No one
ever predicted this. There was no contingency plan. No preparation
in our sacred texts, or at least none that we have found
so far. And believe me, we are looking.'
Will had no idea what this man was talking about. For the
first time, he wondered if these Hassidim might simply be
delusional. Had he not seen them earlier this evening, swept
up in an ecstatic frenzy in adoration of their leader, worshipping
him as their Messiah? Was it not possible that they had
fallen into a state of collective madness, with this man, their
leader, the maddest of all?
'I wish I could say more, but the stakes are too high. We
have to get this right, Mr Monroe, and we don't have long.
What day is it today? Shabbos Shuva? We have just four days.
That is why I cannot afford to take any risks.'
'What do you mean, the stakes are too high?'
'I don't think it will be helpful for me to say any more on
this, Will. For one thing, my guess is you won't believe a
word I say.'
'Well, if you mean I'm unlikely to trust a man who's nearly
killed me, you're right.'
I see that. And one day, and I suspect it will be very soon,
you'll understand why we had to do what we just did. All
will become clear. That is the way of these things. And I
meant what I said. I feared you were a federal agent and,
when I confirmed that you were not, I feared you were something
much worse.'
'What would you have to fear from a federal agent? And
what would you fear even more than that? What are you up
to here?'
'I can see why you're a journalist, Will: always asking questions.
You'd do well in our line of work, too: that is what
Torah study is all about, asking the right questions. But I'm
afraid I think we have done all the Q & A we're going to do tonight. It's time for us to say goodbye.'
'That's it? You're going to leave it at that? You're not going to tell me what's going on?'
'No, I cannot risk that. So I'm going to leave you with a few things for you to remember. You can write them down later if you like. The first is that this is much bigger than any of us. Everything we believe in, everything you believe in, hangs in the balance. Life itself. The stakes could not be higher. 'Second, your wife will be safe unless you endanger her life by your recklessness. I urge you not to do that, not just for your own sake, but for the sake of all of us. Everybody. So even though you love her and want to protect her, I plead with you to believe me that the best thing you can do for her, as a loving husband, is to stay away. Back off and don't meddle. Interfere and I can offer no guarantees, not for her, not for you, not for any of us.
'And third, I don't expect you to understand. You have wandered into all this quite by accident. Perhaps it's not an accident, but a series of steps fully understood only by our Creator. But this is the hardest thing of all. I'm asking you to believe things that you cannot comprehend, to trust me just because I ask you. I don't know if you're a man of faith or not, Will, but this is how faith operates. We have to believe in God even when we have not the barest inkling of what he has in mind for the universe. We have to obey rules that seem to make no sense, simply because we believe. Not everyone can do it, Will. It takes strength to have faith. But that is what I need from you: the faith to trust that I and the people you see here are acting only for the sake of good.' 'Even when that means nearly drowning an innocent man like me?'
'Even when the price is very high, yes. We are determined to save lives here, Will, and in that cause almost any action is permitted. Pikuach nefesh. Now I must say goodbye. Moshe Menachem will give you back your things. Good luck, Will. Travel safely and, please God, all should be well. Good shabbos.' At that moment, as he imagined the Rebbe lifting himself up out of his chair and shuffling towards the door, he heard an interruption. Someone else had come into the room; barged in, by the sound of it. He seemed to be showing the Rebbe something; there was muttered conversation. The new voice was highly exercised, a raised whisper. They need not have worried: even at that volume, all Will could establish was that they were not speaking English. It sounded like German, with lots of phlegmy 'ch's and 'sch's'. Yiddish.
The exchange ended; the Rebbe seemed to have gone. Redbeard, Moshe Menachem, now left his sentry position at Will's side and stood in front of him. His eyes were sheepish as he handed to Will the bag he had left at Shimon Shmuel's. I'm sorry about, you know, before,' he mumbled.
Will took the bag, seeing that his notebook had been put back inside, too. His phone was still there, and his BlackBerry, untouched. He took out his wallet, faintly curious to see which stub or ticket had given him away. It was as he expected, full of anonymous cab receipts. He opened up the series of slots made to carry credit cards, a feature he never used. In one, a book of standard US postage stamps; in another, a business card of a long-forgotten interviewee. In the third, a passport sized photograph - of Beth.
A bitter smile passed across Will's face: it was his bride who had betrayed him. Of course they would recognize her. She had given him this picture about six weeks after they met; it was summer and they had spent the afternoon boating off Sag Harbor. They passed a photo booth and she could not resist: she mugged for the automated camera there and then. Will turned the picture over and there it was, the message which had left no doubt. love you, Will Monroe!
Will looked up, his eyes wet. Before him was a new face; he guessed it was the man who had briefly clashed with the Rebbe a few moments ago. His face was soft and round, his cheeks chipmunk-full, framed by a jet-black beard. He was tubby, with a round head atop a round tummy. Will guessed
he was in his early twenties.
'Come, I'll show you out.'
As Will got up, he saw at last the chair where the Rebbe
had sat during the inquisition. It was no throne, just a chair.
Next to it was a side table, the kind a lecturer might use to
keep his notes and a glass of water. What was on it made
Will jolt.
It was a copy of that day's New York Times, folded, very
deliberately, to highlight Will's story about the life and death
of Pat Baxter. So that was what the round-faced man had
shown the Rebbe; that was what they had argued about. Will
could guess what the young man had been saying: This guy's from The New York Times. He's never going to keep this quiet. We
should keep him here, where he can't shoot his mouth off.
By now they were outside, Will holding the clean white
shirt the Hassidim had given him but which he was not yet
wearing: he had not wanted to undress in front of his inquisitors.
He had been humiliated enough already.
They stood on the street, outside the shul. Men were still
coming in and walking out. Will looked at his watch: 10.20pm.
It felt like three am.
'I can only repeat our apologies about what happened in there.'
Yeah, yeah, thought Will. Save it for the judge when I sue your
Hassidic asses for false imprisonment, assault, battery and the whole fucking shebang. 'Well, better than an apology would actually
be an explanation.'
'I can't give you that, but I can give you a word of advice.'
He looked around, as if making sure that he was not being
watched or overheard. 'My name is Yosef Yitzhok. I work to
bring the Rebbe's word into the world. Listen, I know what
you do and here's my suggestion.' He lowered his voice into
a conspiratorial whisper. 'If you want to know what's going
on, think about your work.'
'I don't understand.'
'You will. But you have to look to your work. Go on, leave.' This Yosef Yitzhok seemed agitated. 'Remember what I said. Look to your work.'
CHAPTER TWENTY

Friday, 11.35pm, Brooklyn
Tom answered his phone within one ring. He told Will, who had been stumbling through the streets of Crown Heights looking for the subway, to hail a cab and head straight over to his apartment.
Now he lay on Tom's couch, fit to pass out with tiredness, kept awake only by a kind of fever. He was wearing nothing but three thick towels. Tom had shoved him in a hot shower the minute he walked through the door, determined that his friend not succumb to a cold, a fever or even pneumonia. He knew they had no time to waste with illness.
Will did his best to tell him what had happened, but most of it was too bizarre to take in. Besides, Will spoke like a man just woken trying to remember a dream: new bits of information, new characters, new descriptions and phrases kept
popping up. There were so few items of normality for Tom to cling to, he gave up making sense of it after a while. Bearded men, a near-drowning, a sign telling women to cover their elbows, an unseen inquisitor, a leader worshipped as the Messiah, a rule preventing people from carrying even keys for twenty-four hours. He wondered if Will had gone to Crown Heights at all, rather than to the East Village to score some particularly strong acid and embark on one of the more surreal trips in recent hallucinogenic history.
Harder to resist was the urge to say, 'I told you so.' This was precisely the outcome Tom had feared: Will charging into Crown Heights, under-prepared and out of his mind with anguish, clumsily walking into the hands of his enemies. Not only did Will expect Tom to follow his account of the last, baffling few hours, he also wanted his help in trying to decode it. What was that reference to his work? What did the Rebbe mean about an ancient story, about saving lives, about having just four days to go?
'Will,' Tom said after his friend had spoken for nearly fifteen uninterrupted minutes, trying to break his flow. 'Will.' No luck; he kept on talking. Finally, Tom had to break with his own iron rule and raise his voice. 'WILL!'
At last, he stopped.
'Will, this is too serious for us to keep flailing around like amateurs. We need expert help now.'
'What, the police?'
'Well, we should think about it.'
'Of course I've fucking thought about it. I thought about it when I had my head in the deep freeze. But I don't think I can risk it. I saw these people, Tom. They were ready to kill me tonight, on some hunch. Because I wasn't wearing a wire and because I do have a foreskin. Or some such crazy nonsense. They were going to drown me. The guy gave me the full, theological justification - all this stuff about Peking Nuff-said or whatever it was. Essentially, you can take a life if it will save lives - and the life they were thinking of taking this evening was mine. And maybe Beth's. So yes, I've thought about it, but what I think is, the risk is too great. From the very beginning they've said it: if we go to the police, she's not safe. And now, having seen them - or not seen them I think they mean it. They're serious people. They're not messing about.'
'OK, so we need some other kind of help.'
'Like what?'
'Like Jews.'
'What?'
'We need to talk to someone Jewish who can begin to make sense of everything you saw and heard. We know nothing. All we've got is what you heard underwater and what we can get off the internet. It's not enough.'
Will recognized the logic. It was true. He had been bluffing his way through in that typically English way. They taught it in the best public schools: bullshit studies. Learn to get by on native wit and charm. Never be anything so boring as a qualified expert; be the gifted amateur. That's what he had done by marching into Crown Heights in his bloody chinos with his bloody notebook. As if it would all fall into his charming English lap. They needed help.
'Who?'
'What about Joel?'
'Joel Kaufman?' He had been in the journalism programme with Will at Columbia; he was now writing for the sports pages of Newsday. 'He's Jewish but only technically. He barely knows more than I do.'
'Ethan Greenberg?'
'He's in Hong Kong. For the Journal.'
'This is pathetic. We're in New York. We must know some Jews!'
'I actually know plenty of Jews Will said, thinking
suddenly of Schwarz and Woodstein in the pod at work, which in turn reminded him that he had made no contact with the office all day. He had ignored Harden's email. He would have to do something; he couldn't just go AWOL. But it was too much to think about; he shoved the thought aside, telling himself he would deal with it as soon as he left Tom's apartment. 'The
trouble is, I can't start blabbing about this situation
to just anyone. The risk is too great. It has to be someone who is not just Jewish but who's smart enough to know Jewish things, who might know about this world,' he gestured towards the screen, still flickering with the map of Eastern Parkway, 'and who we can trust. I can't think of anyone who falls into that category.'
I can,' said Tom, though his face registered no pleasure at the fact.
'Who?'
'to:
'You can't be serious. TO? To help Beth?'
'Who else can do it, Will? Who else?'
Will fell back onto the couch, clenching his jaw, the muscle inside his cheek tightening on and off as if pulsing with an alternating current. Once again, Tom was right. TO checked all the boxes. She was Jewish, smart and would never betray a secret. But how could he make that phone call? They had not spoken in more than four years.
For nearly nine months, from the start of Columbia to that Memorial Day weekend, they had been inseparable. She was a fine art student and Will had fallen for her before either of them had said a word. He could not lie: it was lust. She was the woman on campus everyone noticed, from the diamond stud in her nose to the ring that pierced her belly button; from the flat, constantly exposed midriff to the tint of blue running through her hair. Most women over the age of sixteen could not carry off that look, but TO had enough natural beauty to get away with it.
They had started dating straight away, becoming virtual recluses in his tiny apartment on 113th and Amsterdam. They would have sex in the daytime, eat Chinese food, see movies and have more sex until it was morning again.
Appearances were misleading. People saw the blue hair and the navel ring and assumed TO was a wild, free spirit one of those girls in movies who leap onto the roof to dance in the moonlight or take spontaneous rides to the shore to
see the fishing boats. Despite the piercings and torn jeans, TO was not like that. Underneath that neo-hippy exterior,
Will soon discovered a precise, analytical brain that could be
terrifying in its demand for exactitude. Conversation with TO was a mental work-out: she let Will get away with
nothing.
She seemed to have read everything - citing plot lines from
Turgenev one moment, the central doctrinal tenets of
Lutheranism the next - and have absorbed it all. The only
crack in her armour, again defying all expectations, was
popular culture. She could get by on the most recent stuff,
but dip into the childhood memories she and Will were meant
to share and she would become clueless. Mention Grease and
she assumed you meant Greece; refer to 'Valley Girls' and
she would ask, 'Which valley?' Will found it endearing;
besides, it was reassuring to know there was one area where
the human database he was dating had a defect. He concluded
the two facts were related: when kids like him were watching
mindless TV and listening to trashy pop, TO had been reading,
reading, reading.
Mind you, all that was a guess. TO only spoke about her
childhood in the vaguest terms. (Even her name remained a
mystery: a nickname she had got as a toddler, she said, its
origins forgotten.) He had never met her parents or siblings:
that would be impossible. Despite her own aggressively irreligious
life - she made a point of ordering jumbo shrimp and
sweet and sour pork - she explained that her family were
still fairly traditional and they would just not accept a Gentile
boyfriend. 'But we're not getting married!' he would say. 'It
doesn't matter,' would be the reply. 'Even the theoretical
possibility that one day we might, that we are together at all,
is bad enough. For them.'
They went through all the arguments. He would accuse her
unseen parents - and he never even glimpsed a photograph
of them - of racism, as bad as the prejudice of any anti-Semite who would bar his daughter going out with a Jew. She would then walk him through the long, bloody course of Jewish history. Knowledgeable as ever, she would tell how, across continents and down the centuries, Jews had been tormented, clinging only perilously to their lives and the civilization they had created. Jewish culture could not survive, people like her parents believed, if it gradually dissolved, through intermarriage and assimilation, into the general population - like a
drop of blue hair-dye in an ocean of clear water. 'So that's what your parents believe,' Will would say. 'What about you? What do you believe?'
Her answers were never clear enough, not for Will. The
arguments became too tiring. And, while the forbiddenness of their romance had been a thrill at first, making them coconspirators in the Manhattan winter, by the spring it had
begun to pall. He did not like feeling that their fate was being decided by a vast, external force - five thousand years of history - of which he knew so little and over which he had no influence. By the time he met Beth, he knew he and TO had run out of road.
It ended very badly. He had been a coward and started
seeing Beth before breaking off properly from TO: she had found a digital picture of the new girlfriend on his computer. That was bad enough, but she was furious that what they had come to call 'the Jewish thing' had proved so decisive. She was angry with him for allowing that to be an obstacle
- for rejecting her because of 'a fact about myself I cannot change' - but he always had the feeling the fury was not
only directed at him. He could see she was raging at a heritage, a culture,' that she had mostly abandoned but which had pulled her apart from a man she had loved. Their last conversation was a shouting match. His last image of her was a face
raw with tears. Occasionally, he wondered who had won out: the uptight parents or the blue-streaked world of art and
adventure that had so enthralled the girl he had fallen in love with.
Now Tom was suggesting he get in touch. Tonight, at nearly midnight. He had her cell phone number; but what would he say? How would he explain that the only reason he was making contact was because he needed something - and that was for the sake of the woman who had stolen him from her? How would he make that call? And why would she do anything but slam the phone down, vowing never to speak to him again?
And yet, he was desperate and Tom was right. She was the closest thing to the expert they needed. He would have to do it. He would have to put aside his own emotions, including his cowardice, and dial that number. Now. He paced up and down the room for a while, mentally scripting his opening. It was like writing for the paper: once he had his first line, he had the courage to plunge in, hoping instinct would take care of the rest. To increase his chances for success, or at least to prevent immediate failure, he also played a cheap trick.
He reckoned that if TO's number was still stored on his phone, there was at least a possibility that his lived on in her SIM card, too. He imagined the sight of his name flashing up on her screen. So he called from Tom's line, knowing his number would be wholly unfamiliar. It was an ambush call.
'Hello, TO? It's Will.' Loud noise in the background. A club? A party?
'Hi.'
'Will Monroe.'
'I don't know any other Wills, Will. Not before, not since. What's up?'
He had to hand it to her: as an instant response, with barely a second's thinking time, that was not bad. And entirely typical: the hint of a put-down, the reference to their past, the rapid-fire formulation. The only bum note was that 'what's up?' It was not her kind of phrase, the lightness in it too forced. In those words, he heard the strain of speaking to a man whom she had loved and who had rejected her. 'I need to see you very soon. You know I wouldn't trouble you like this unless it was very important. And this is very important. I think it's a matter of life and death.' He swallowed on that last word and he knew TO had heard him.
'Is something wrong with your mom? Is she OK?' 'It's Beth. I know--' He could not complete that sentence: he was not sure what came next. 'I need to see you right away.'
She did not ask any more questions. She just gave him her address. Not her home, but her work: a complex of artists' studios in Chelsea. She said it would be nearer, but Will suspected there was another motive. Maybe she was with someone else; perhaps she was ashamed still to be alone; or maybe she just could not face the intimacy of having Will in her apartment.
Artists' studios. Even in that nugget of information, there was a whole story. It meant she had made good her promise: she had dreamed of being an artist, they talked about it through those long, bed afternoons. But he, and even she, had wondered whether she had the nerve to go through with it. He was glad she had done it. More than glad; proud.

Less than an hour later he found himself stepping out of a service elevator, an old-style one complete with concertina iron gate. He suspected this was not a mechanical necessity, but a bohemian affectation: the artists' colony in their converted factory. He emerged on the fourth floor, silent and dark. He could just make out a corner reserved for a sculptress who seemed to specialize in female bellies. He turned past what looked like a metal workshop, but was in fact the workspace of a man who created installations using neon. Finally he saw a photocopied notice: TO. Just those two letters, no first or last name. Smart branding, Will thought as he knocked lightly on the partition door to announce his arrival. Instinctively he had decided that male, English politeness would be his defence against her female, all-American fury. He had only a second or two to take it all in: walls covered with paintings, three more on easels, yet more covered in bubble-wrap, leaned up against the walls. A plain, battered table covered with clutter. On a counter that ran the length of the back wall, artists' materials - bottles of white spirit; oil paints in bent, metal toothpaste tubes; glue; knives; various rusty scrapers; string and, unaccountably, a cookery book which seemed to have lost all its pages.
Towards the back of the room, on a threadbare red velvet couch, TO. She was smaller than he remembered but nothing else was diminished: she was still a woman who made you stare. Her hair was now shoulder length, where once it had been punkily short. Most of it was a natural brown but for that trademark streak of blue, still there. Taking in her flimsy, vaguely vintage shirt, above tight jeans, torn at the knees, he could see the shape that had once made him weak. In the semi-dark he spotted a glint of metal: the navel ring, still in place.
This had been the moment he was most uncertain of:
should he hug her, kiss her on the cheek, shake hands or do nothing? But she made the decision for him, standing up and opening her arms as if welcoming back a prodigal son. He fell into a hug and tried, through the positioning of his arms and hands, to make it somehow - what was the word - fraternal. 'What's the problem, Will?'
He told her as methodically and briefly as he could: the email, Tom's tracing of it to Crown Heights, Will's visit, the interrogation, the trial by mikve.
'You've got to be kidding,' she said when that last detail dropped, her face giving a smirk that was either disbelief, nervous tension, schadenfreude or a little bit of all three. The semi-smile vanished when she saw Will's reaction. She could see this was deadly serious. 'Will, I feel for you, I really do. And my heart goes out to Beth's family.' Beth. He had never heard TO say her name before. 'But what exactly do you need from me?'
'I need to know what you know. I need you to explain to me what I heard. I need you to translate for me.'
She responded with a small, wan smile that somehow
made her look older. At that moment, Will realized ageing was not chiefly about lines or wrinkles, though those things played their part. The years really showed in expressions like the one he had just seen. Suddenly TO's was a face of years; of knowledge.
'OK. Very slowly and with as much detail as you can
remember, you have to tell me everything that happened. Every street you walked, every person you met, every word they used. I'll put some coffee on.'
Will fell back in the wicker chair TO had pulled up for him. For the first time in sixteen hours, he let his muscles relax. He was so relieved: TO was on side. He was filled with a sentiment he had never had when they were together; he felt
that TO was going to look after him.

She was, Will soon realized, a skilful interviewer, patient but methodical, demanding that he be precise about each detail, going back over episodes to ensure he had not missed anything. She pointed out contradictions too, in that old forensic way of hers. 'Hold on, you said there was only you and two others in the room. Who is this new person?' 'What did he say exactly? Did he say, "I will" or "I might"?' Her precision exhausted him. By way of a break, he let his eyes wander towards her work, scattered around the room. Large canvasses depicting classic Americana - naturalistic paintings of a yellow cab or a vintage diner - and, much as he admired their technical skill, he found himself wondering if TO was not in the wrong line of work. She had too clear a mind, too linear and logical, to be an artist. Surely with a brain like hers she should be a scholar or a lawyer or, on current form, a police officer? Wisely, he thought, Will did not say any of this.
By the time he had got to the end, he realized TO had so far explained nothing. Each time she had opened her mouth, it was only to seek clarification from him or to ask supplementary questions. He knew no more now than he had when
he left Crown Heights. He began to feel impatient. But he did not dare voice his frustration; he had to keep TO as an ally. Besides, he was nearly faint with fatigue; his words were starting to slur.
He woke when his elbow slipped off the chair arm. He could tell from the taste in his mouth that he had fallen into a brief but deep sleep. He had dreamed of chants and dances, with Beth at the centre, surrounded, like a tribal queen, by men in white shirts and black suits.
Will looked at his watch; two-thirty am. So this was not a nightmare, just a terrifying long day and night that seemed never to end. It had begun when he powered up his
BlackBerry some eighteen hours ago. And now, incredibly, he was half-asleep in TO's wicker chair and it was still going on.
'Hi, you're back,' she said, suddenly looking up from an artist's sketch pad that rested on her knees. Her forehead was crinkled in a way, Will remembered, that meant she had been concentrating hard. 'Here's what we've got. The first fact is they say Beth is safe - so long as you back off. Second, they seem to admit that she's done nothing wrong and maybe even nothing at all, but they cannot let her go. They acknowledge that this seems baffling now but, they promise, it will all become clear. We know from their emailed notes to you that they don't want money. They just want you to go away.
That's it.
'What this adds up to is one very weird kind of kidnapping.
It's like they somehow want to borrow her for some unspecified
time and some unspecified reason - and they expect you
just to take it. We need to work out why.' Will found that we comforting, even if the rest of the puzzle - and the fact that TO had not instantly cracked it - was anything but. 'So what do we have on motive? A clue is surely that they
feared you were a fed. The charitable explanation for that is
that they feared the feds were coming after them simply
because of the kidnapping. The uncharitable view is that their
fear was separate from the kidnapping, that they are involved
in some other criminal activity and had long worried that the
authorities were onto them. Kind of like those weirdo cults
who lie in wait for the feds to come and take their guns
away.'
Will had a flash of memory back to Montana, Pat Baxter
and his chums. Christ, that was only a few days ago; it felt
like years.
'But then they rule that out, for fairly rational reasons. I
don't know about the wire, but I reckon they're right about
the undercover Jew thing: that is what the feds would do.
Yet, your not being a federal agent does not reassure them.
Quite the opposite. It's once they've ruled that out that they
get really heavy, nearly drowning you. That also makes some
sense: they wouldn't dare mistreat you if they thought you
were law enforcement. Once you weren't, they felt free. The
question, though, is why? What could be, to use their phrase,
"infinitely worse"? A rival Hassidic sect? A rival kidnapping
cartel?'
Will detected a glint of mischief in TO's eye, as if she was
still taken by the humour of Hassidim up to no good. It irritated
him; and she still had not come up with anything he
did not know already.
'What about all the Jewish stuff I heard, what does that
all mean?' He wanted to get her back on track.
'Well, the phrase you heard as "Peking Nuff-said" is actually pikuach nefesh. The safeguarding of a soul. It is usually
used benignly, to forgive various infractions of religious law
in order to do good. You know, you'll hear the Israelis invoke pikuach nefesh to explain why ambulances are allowed to run
on the Sabbath. But by mentioning it alongside all that stuff
about a rodef, they were obviously using it to threaten you to
imply that Jewish law might allow them to kill you. Or
Beth.'
Will winced.
'As for "Shabbos something" that's real. What you heard
was Shabbos Shuva, the Sabbath of repentance, the most important
Shabbat of the year. That's today, as it happens. It's the
one between Rosh Hashana, the New Year, and Yom Kippur,
the Day of Atonement. We're in the middle of the Ten Days
of Penitence, the Days of Awe. This is a big time for Jews.
For the ultra-orthodox especially. But what did your questioner
mean by "we have only four days left"? It's true there
are only four days till Yom Kippur, but, judging from what
you said, he meant it as some kind of deadline. He can't mean
just four days left to repent, though they would think that.
This must be connected to the wider thing he mentioned:
you know, "everything hangs in the balance", "the stakes
could not be higher", "the ancient story".'
'And as far as all that stuff is concerned, we haven't got a
clue, have we?'
TO had her head down, consulting her sketch pad. He could
see she was desperate to find something that would unlock
this mystery. She had corralled all the facts as best she could,
organized a coherent set of questions. But that's all she had:
questions. 'No,' she said quietly. 'We haven't.'
'What about the Rebbe?'
'Ah, yes. Now I need you to think hard on this one. Did
he ever say his name to you? Did he ever introduce himself to you?'
'I told you, he never let me see his face.'
'So why are you so certain he was the Rebbe?'
'Because they were all chanting and stamping and waiting for him inside the synagogue. Then I get led away. These thugs say they can't talk to me until their "teacher" arrives. Then, when he does, they do whatever he tells them to do. He was obviously the boss.'
'When you were in the synagogue and you felt a hand on your shoulder, and the voice said, "For you my friend, it's all over" or whatever he said, that voice was the same one who interrogated you later?'
'Yes, same voice.'
'So if that was the Rebbe how come the crowd was not facing in that direction, looking towards him? If that were him, surely every face in the room would have been looking just past your shoulder, going nuts for the guy who is within whispering distance of your ear. But they weren't, were they?'
'Maybe he was just hidden from view, crushed in that huge crowd.'
'Come on, Will. You said it yourself: they worship this guy as if he's the Messiah. They're not going to just let him wander around, getting mashed by the foot soldiers. Think hard, did he ever announce himself as the Rebbe?' Will realized with embarrassment that his tormentor had never said any such thing. Now that he thought about it-

'Did you ever address him as Rebbe?'
TO had read his mind. Throughout the ordeal, Will had assumed he was speaking to the Rebbe. Inside his own head, he referred to him as Rebbe. But had he ever used the term out loud?
'So you're sure that man who nearly had me killed tonight was not the Rebbe?'
'I know it.'
'How? How can you be so certain?'
'I'm certain, Will, because the Rebbe of Crown Heights has been dead and buried for two years.'
CHAPTER TWENTY-ONE

Saturday, 6.36am, Manhattan
They were in a baking hot country, on a wide bed covered by a vast white net. It was a suite in an old colonial hotel. Sounds were floating up from the street below, car horns and traders; a mosquito buzzed lazily. It was the afternoon and he and Beth were making fevered love, their bodies slick with sweat . . .
Will's heart thumped; the shock of waking from a dream. He looked down to see a bed that was narrow - and empty. Except it was not quite a bed. He had fallen asleep in TO's studio, on her red velvet sofa. It turned out she had a camp bed of her own behind a partition at the side of the studio. 'Sometimes I work nights,' she had said.
He reached instantly for his BlackBerry. Nothing more from the kidnappers; two emails from Harden; several from his father, begging him to get in touch and complaining of his desperate worry. His phone would not switch on: the battery must have died when he was at Tom's.
He tiptoed over to TO's workbench, where he was relieved to see she had the same brand of phone as him. There would be a charger here somewhere. While looking, he spotted the sketch pad from last night. He turned it the right way up and saw that TO had not been taking notes, but doing what seemed
to be an elaborate doodle. It formed a geometric pattern:
circles linked by straight lines, like one of those molecular
diagrams. Was TO an expert chemist on the side? It would
not have surprised him.
Seeing her Hebrew doodles brought back with a thud the
night's biggest, and most baffling, revelation. The Rebbe was
dead. Despite the pictures on every wall in Crown Heights,
the websites covered with his face, the constant references
to him in the present tense, the sheer fervour aroused by the
mere sight of his chair - despite all this, TO had been adamant
that the Grand Rabbi of the Hassidic sect, the Rebbe, was
deep in the ground.
He had died in his sleep two years earlier, plunging his
entire community and thousands of followers worldwide
into abject grief. In the last years of his life, the belief had
grown that the Rebbe was not just an extraordinary leader
but something more. 'Judaism holds that each generation
includes one person who is the candidate to be the Messiah,' TO had explained. 'That doesn't mean he actually is the
Messiah. But if God decided the time had come, that it was
time for the Messianic era to begin, then this person, this
candidate, would be the one. He would be revealed as the Moshiach.' 'And so they started thinking the Rebbe was the candidate?'
'Exactly.
That's how it began. Just that he was the
candidate for this age. But then things started getting more
intense. People started saying this was not some remote, abstract
possibility but that the Messianic days were imminent, that the
moment was approaching. Truth be told, I think the Rebbe
encouraged it. He whipped up this fervour.'
'What, was he on some major ego trip?'
'I don't know if it was that. He was an amazingly modest
man in most ways. He lived frugally, in a few Spartan rooms
in Crown Heights. After his wife died, he confined himself to his study. He'd sleep in there, but only for an hour or two at night; the rest of the time, the light would be on and he'd be working, working, working. Dictating letters mostly; offering advice to his people all over the world. You've got to realize, this is a billion-dollar, global organization. They have centres in almost every city of the world, even in really obscure places where there are hardly any Jews, just in case there are Jewish travellers nearby who might feel the urge to have a Sabbath meal. He would tell one of his emissaries, "You're needed in Greenland" and they'd go to Greenland. The Rebbe was like a cross between the CEO of some huge multi-national corporation and the Commandante of a revolutionary army.' TO grinned. 'He was Bill Gates and Che
Guevara, all rolled into one. And aged ninety-something.' Will thought back to the picture of the twinkling old man with the snow-white beard. An unlikely revolutionary.
'Anyway, then he died and most people assumed that would be the end of that. After all, he couldn't exactly be the
Messiah if he was dead, could he?'
'I guess not.'
'Well, you guess wrong. The hardcore devotees started camping out at the graveside. When people asked them what on earth they were doing, they said, "Waiting". They wanted to be ready to welcome the Rebbe when he rose from the dead.'
'Are you sure these guys aren't Christians?'
'I know; it's weird isn't it? There's some serious debate
going on about that, in fact. There are plenty of Jews who say Crown Heights is effectively taking itself outside Judaism, that it is becoming another faith. The argument is that
Christianity was once just a form of Judaism which believed the Messiah had come; now Crown Heights is making the same move.'
'The difference is they're still waiting. Mind you, Christians are still waiting for the second coming. Everybody's waiting.' This lot certainly are. They're waiting for their leader to reveal himself, for him to rise from the dead and tell them it's all going to be OK.'
'You're taking the piss, aren't you?'
'Kind of. Look, theologically speaking, they might be right. It is quite true that, in the Messianic age, Judaism says the dead will live again. And there's nothing written that says the Messiah can't be one of them; you know, one of the dead. So they might be right. It's just, I don't know, it just seems kind of sad to me. Like this is a group of children who've lost their daddy or something. As the therapists would say, "they're hurting".'
Will tried to square TO's account - a cult traumatized by the loss of their leader, stirring themselves to a Friday night fury as if desperately summoning him back from the dead with the gang who had nearly killed him a few hours earlier. He found sympathy did not come easily. 'How come you know so much about them?'
'I read the papers,' she said quickly; an instant scold. 'It's all been in the Times.'
Will kicked himself. His haste at Tom's meant he never did the thorough Google search that would have told him all this
- or at least that the Rebbe was dead. More galling was the certain knowledge that all this had, just as TO said, been in the paper but that he had skimmed over it: weirdo religious news, not relevant.
That was last night. This morning's thunderbolt came once he finally found the phone charger, near the coffee pot. He plugged it in and his mobile came silently to life. (He always set his to 'silent': you never knew when a loud, synthetic chime would embarrass you.) The voicemail messages declared themselves first: four from his dad, three, increasingly sarcastic ones from Harden, the last saying, 'You better be on a story so good that I win a Pulitzer for running it,' before telling him he would be on 'the first boat back to Oxford' if he did not report for duty soon. Two others that Will skipped after a few words, deeming them non-urgent.
Next came the texts. One from Tom, wishing him luck. And then:
Foot runs. B Gates.
He pressed the button marked 'Details' but the phone yielded nothing. For number, it said 'Withheld Private Caller'. For the time, it uselessly gave the hour, minute and second Will had switched on the phone. He had no idea who had sent it or when. Given that the meaning was utterly opaque, that made the blank complete.
By now, TO was up, emerging from her mini-bedroom with a sleepy stretch. Even in man's-style boxer shorts and a thin strapped white vest, she looked sumptuous. The navel ring was fully exposed now. Will felt a tremor of movement in his groin, followed by a thump of guilt. To lust after your ex girlfriend was appalling under any circumstances. To do so when your wife was a hostage in fear of her life was contemptible. He gave TO only the merest acknowledgement, looked back at his cell phone and reflexively tucked in his pelvis - as if to staunch the flow of erection-threatening blood before it passed the point of no return.
To his relief, TO kept some spare clothes behind the partition and she now disappeared to put them on. When she emerged, Will handed her his phone. 'Now this,' he said. TO fumbled for her glasses; it was too early for lenses. 'Hmm,' she said, staring at the words.
Will briefed her on his early lines of inquiry. 'I reckon this must be from them, the Hassidim. They obviously got my number off the phone when they had my bag.'
'No, they wouldn't have done that. It breaks Shabbat. And they wouldn't send a text message for the same reason. Both violate the Sabbath.'
'What, and dunking an innocent man into freezing water is OK?'
Technically, yes. They didn't use any electricity, any fire. They didn't write anything down, didn't use any machinery.' 'So what they did to me was all perfectly kosher.'
'Look, Will, don't give me a hard time. I don't make up these rules. All I'm saying is, they would only break the Sabbath if there was no alternative. So far they avoided that.' 'But what about pikuach nefesh, you know the saving a soul thing?'
'You're right. If they felt it was justified, they would do it. OK, so it could be them. What does it mean?'
'Like I know. But I was wondering if perhaps foot means ending or conclusion. You know how you told me Rosh Hashana means literally "head of the year" so maybe foot is the end.' Will smiled hopefully, like a pupil expecting praise. TO did not smile. 'And runs?'
'You know, "it goes on". It runs on. Or "the end approaches". Maybe Foot runs is a coded way of saying that the operation is nearing its end. And the B Gates thing is just a sign off. You know, Bill Gates. Mickey Mouse.'
TO did not react. She just took the phone over to the couch, sat down and stared at it. 'Can you pass me the pad? And a pen.' Will sat next to her, so he could see what she was doing. He felt awkward as soon as he had done it; his legs so near hers. She was writing down a new message.
GPPU SVOT
'OK, so that doesn't work. Let's try it the other way.'
ENNS QTMR
'Nor does that,' she said, not disappointed so much as challenged. 'What are you doing?'
'It's kiddie code-breaking stuff. Each letter stands for the one after it - so that F is really G, O is really P - or, alternatively, the one before it - so that F is really E and O is really N. That way foot is either gppu or enns. Which means that neither of those is the code. Let's try another one.'
TO began to write, very fast, the alphabet across the page. Then, underneath it, she did the same in reverse, so that Z, Y, X, appeared directly under A, B, C.
ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQRSTUVWXYZ
ZYXWVUTSRQPONMLKJIHGFEDCBA
'Now we can read off and see what we get.' Her finger scanned along the line, then she started scribbling.
ULLG IFMH
'Shit,' Will hissed. 'I am getting so tired of these fucking games. What the hell does this mean?'
'We're not thinking logically. Not many people send text messages by phone like this.'
'Brits do.'
'Yeah, but most Americans don't. And it would have been just as easy to communicate by email. But they didn't do that. Why not?'
'Because they know that we can trace their emails. They must know that I worked out where their last one came from.' 'Sure, but that might not be a bad thing from their point of view. They might want you to know it was a message from them. No, I reckon they chose a different method for a reason. Can you pass me your phone?'
She grabbed it eagerly, instantly finding the messaging programme. She hit 'Create message' and began typing with her thumbs. Will had to huddle even closer to see what she was doing. He could smell her hair and had to fight the urge not to breathe deeply: in an instant, her scent had carried him back to those long hot afternoons together.
That in turn jogged another sense memory, the perfume of
Beth. He liked it best when it was strongest: when she dressed
up to go out for the evening. She might have got her outfit
just right; he would want to rip it all off, to ravish her there
and then. Later, at the party, he would spot her across the
room and find himself looking at his watch: he wanted to get
her back home. He was suddenly flooded with memories, of TO and of Beth, and they were arousing him. He felt confused.
TO was typing the word foot. Now her thumbs searched
for the button; she pressed it twice, and a smile began to form around her lips. The display changed, showing the word
foot, then font then don't, then enou, then emot, then donu
and finally ennu before going back to foot. TO wrote down
the word don't.
Next she keyed in runs, which showed up on the screen
as sums, suns, puns, stop, rump, sump, pump, as well as stor,
sunr and quor. She wrote one of those down, too.
'There,' she said, with the satisfaction of a bookish schoolgirl
who had just completed her algebra homework in record
time. The two-word nonsense of foot runs now appeared as
a clear message of encouragement.
don't stop.
It was not really a code at all, thought Will. Just a neat use of
the 'predictive' language function on most cell phones: every
time you tried to punch in a word, the phone offered possible
alternatives using the same combination of buttons. You pressed
3,6,6,8 to mean foot, but you might have meant don't so the machine cleverly offered you that option. Whoever sent this
message had found a novel use for the function.
The satisfaction of TO's handiwork was brief. True, they
had decoded the message, but they hardly knew what it meant
and they still had no idea who had sent it.
'So who the hell is Bill Gates?'
'Let's have a look,' said TO, picking up the phone again. 'Well, B could be C or A.' She keyed in the word gates. 'And that could be hates or haves or haver or hater.'
'So what would that mean?' said Will. 'A hater? A hater of what? Or is it B Haves as in "behaves"?'
'Or maybe it's the opposite of "a hater",' said TO, suddenly excited.
'The opposite?'
'The opposite of a hater. A friend.'
'But it doesn't say that. It's just gates or hates or haves or hates.'
'Or haver. Haver is the word for friend in Hebrew. B Gates is A Haver. This message says, "Don't stop, a friend."' She began circling, staring at the floor. 'Who would want to stiffen your resolve now? Who would think there was a chance you would give up?'
'The only people who even know about this are you, my father, Tom and the Hassidim themselves.'
'You're sure there's no one else. No one who's aware this is happening?'
With a stab, Will thought of Harden and the office: he would have to do something about that eventually. 'No. No one knows. And since neither you, nor Tom, nor my Dad need to contact me anonymously that leaves the Hassidim. I think we may have a bit of a split on our hands.' 'What do you mean?'
Will enjoyed the novelty of TO being a pace behind him for once. Politics never was her strongest suit.
'A split. A split in the ranks of the enemy. The only person who could have sent this would be somebody who heard the Rebbe, I mean the rabbi I spoke to yesterday, telling me to back off. They must want me to ignore that advice. They must disagree with what the rabbi's doing. This person doesn't want me to stop. And I think I can guess who it is.' CHAPTER TWENTY-TWO

Saturday, 8.10am, Port-au-Prince, Haiti
These days he came down to check only once a week. The Secret Chamber now seemed to run itself, needing only the lightest supervision. These visits of his were less practical than sentimental: it gave him pleasure to see his little invention working so well.
He had designed things before of course. Down at the docks, he had come up with a new roll-on, roll-off method for unloading the boats that came in from Latin America and went on to the US. He had not planned it this way, but his new system was said to have revolutionized the country's drugs trade. He had only been trying to improve the efficiency of import-export. But thanks to him, cocaine could come in from Colombia and be bound for Miami with the shortest possible turnaround. From there, and in a matter of hours, the parcels of white powder would spider out to America's cities - Chicago, Detroit, New York. Haiti's drugs bosses boasted that if ten lines of coke were snorted into the nostrils of a US citizen at any given moment, it was certain that at least one had passed through Port-au-Prince. In his social circle, that gave Jean-Claude Paul prestige. Among the well-heeled dollar millionaires of Petionville, each in their armour-fenced, high-walled villas, no one fussed too
much as to the ethical origins of one's wealth. That you could
drive a Mercedes and send your wife to Paris to replenish
her wardrobe and re-tint her highlights was enough. When
the Americans invaded in 1994 they called the mansion
dwellers of Petionville MREs - morally repugnant elites - and
Jean-Claude was classed among them.
Maybe that was why his brain had come up with the Secret
Chamber, as a way to make amends. He could not imagine
where else the idea could have come from: it seemed to arrive
in his head fully formed, nothing to do with him.
The chamber was, in fact, a single-storey building, painted
white. It looked like a glorified hut, no more noticeable than
a bus shelter. Crucially, there were entrances on all four sides
which were open at all times.
The system was simple. At any moment, the rich could
come in and leave money inside the chamber. And, also at
any moment, the poor could come in and take what they
needed.
The beauty of it was its anonymity. The doors operated on
an automatic-locking system that ensured only one person
could be inside the chamber at any one time. That way a
giver and a receiver were guaranteed never to meet. The
wealthy would not know who had benefited from their
largesse; the deprived would not know who had helped them.
Port-au-Prince's well-off would not get the chance either to
lord it over their beneficiaries or to judge them insufficiently
needy. And the city's impoverished would be spared the sense of indebtedness that can make charity so humiliating.
The four doors were the finishing touch. It meant that
there could never arise, not even informally, a givers' entrance
or a receivers' entrance; it was too random for that. And so,
if you saw someone walking in or out, you had no idea what
kind of errand they were on.
There was only one more thing Jean-Claude had to do to
make it work. He had to exploit a Haitian national trait, one that applied as much to the SUV-drivers of Petionville as the searingly poor of Cite Soleil: superstition.
He spoke to the healers and voodoo priests whose writ ran among the MREs, slipping a few dollars to those with a knack for spreading the word. Before long the wealthiest folk in Port-au-Prince came to believe that they would be cursed if they did not visit the Secret Chamber and do the right thing. So Jean-Claude smiled as he stood inside the chamber now, looking at a bowl filled with US dollars as well as local currency and even the odd item of jewellery. Those outside assumed he was another visitor; his own role in setting up the chamber had remained unknown to all but the handful of holy men whose PR skills he had enlisted.
He was picking up a discarded food wrapper from the floor when the lights flickered and went off. With all four doors closed, the room was now in complete darkness. Jean-Claude silently cursed the electric company.
But it did not stay dark for long. Someone struck a match, just behind him. The power failure must have short-circuited the automatic locks, allowing this man to gain access. I'm sorry, sir. Only one at a time, that's the rule.'
'I know the rule, Monsieur Paul.' The voice was unfamiliar; speaking French not Creole.
'Well, perhaps I'll leave and then you can do what you need to do.' Tor that I need you here.'
'No, no. It's all private and confidential, my friend. That's why we call this the Secret Chamber. It's secret.'
The match had burned out now, shrouding the chamber once more in perfect black.
'Hello? Are you still here?'
There was no answer. Not a sound, in fact, until the gasp of Jean-Claude's own breath as he felt two strong hands on his neck. He wanted to protest, to ask what he had done wrong, to explain that this man could take all the money he needed - there were no restrictions, no maximum. But the air would not come. He was rasping, a sandy, dry exhalation that barely sounded human. His leg was trembling, his hand clinging onto the forearm of this man who was strangling him.
But it was no good; darkness came upon darkness. He slumped to the floor. The stranger lit a new match, crouched down and closed the dead man's eyes. He murmured a short prayer, then straightened himself up and shook the dust off his clothes. He headed for the door he had used to come in, taking care to reconnect the circuit he had broken a few minutes earlier. And then he stepped out into the night, anonymous and unseen, just as Jean-Claude Paul had intended.
CHAPTER TWENTY-THREE

Saturday, 8.49am, Manhattan
When they talked in the night TO had not been that interested in Yosef Yitzhok. She was focused on the rabbi and on everything that happened inside the classroom and later at the mikve. Now, though, she trained the full beam of her intellect on the encounter that had concluded Will's brief and unhappy stay at Crown Heights.
'You're wrong about one thing,' she told Will rapidly. It doesn't make sense for Yosef Yitzhok to have brought in the paper just to make the point that you work for The New York Times, and therefore they've got to be careful. They already knew you worked for the Times. They sent that very first email to your Times address. That much they had worked out. So as soon as they realized you were not Tom Mitchell but were Will Monroe, they knew exactly who they were dealing with. Beth's husband. A reporter for the Times.' 'So why did they have a copy of my story laid out? Why had Yosef thingy brought it in?'
'You don't know he brought it in. Might have been in there throughout.'
'No, I definitely--' Will stopped himself. After the Rebbe fiasco, there was nothing he knew for definite. He thought he had heard the arrival of a new person in the room, the rustling of paper and a row - but he had not seen that. He might have just got it wrong.
'So what did Yosef Yitzhok - we'll call him YY, it'll save time. What did YY say to you outside?'
'He apologized for what had happened inside. At the time I thought that was bullshit and I ignored it. But maybe that was his way of telling me he disagreed with what was happening. Maybe he's a dissenter! Perhaps he can help. You know, from the inside.'
'Will, I know you're stressed out but we really have to keep it cool and calm. This is not the movies. Just tell me what he actually said.'
'OK, so there's the apology. And then there's this stuff about my work. 'If you want to know what's going on, look to your work.'
'Hmm.' TO began pacing, stopping by a painting she had done of the Chrysler Building apparently melting in the twilight rain. 'So he's seen your story in the paper; he knows what you do. It's possible he didn't know that until that moment.'
'I thought you said they knew the moment they emailed me.'
'That's true. They knew. The rabbi and whichever one of his techie helpers sent you the email knew. But this guy might not be inner circle. It may have been news to him.' 'So it's possible that he was steaming in there, warning them that I was a reporter and could make trouble.' 'It's possible. But something about it doesn't feel right. If he's in the room, he must be trusted enough to know what's going on. It must be something else. But OK, let's say you're right. He doesn't like what's happening and so he breaks Shabbat to tell you urgently that you must not give up. Why would he do it in code? You know, foot runs?'
'Just in case someone read it over his shoulder. Or saw it
in his "Sent messages".'
'All right. I'll buy that. And I suppose the thing he said to
you last night - "look to your work" - is related. Perhaps he's
telling you to do what you do in your work: to keep looking,
keep asking questions.'
'I reckon that's it. Don't stop, keep probing.'
'Good. So that's what it is. OK.' Will could see she was
only partly persuaded. 'What do you want to do now? Are
you going to reply?'
Will had not even thought of that, but she was right. He
should just hit Reply, send a message of his own and see
what happened. Who are you? That might scare YY off. What
do you want me to do? He needed to get this right. 'What do
you think?'
'I think I need some coffee.' She flicked on the machine and, clearly out of habit, flicked on the radio at the same
time. It was big, old-fashioned and splattered with paint; a
builder's radio. Except hers was not programmed to KROC
or Kiss FM, but WNYC, New York's public radio channel.
Will fell back into the sofa, willing himself to have a brainwave.
He had to think of something that would end this
ordeal. Beth had now spent a night as a captive. God only
knew where she was and in what conditions. He had seen
how hard these men could be, nearly freezing him into unconsciousness. What pain were they inflicting on Beth? What
strange rules would allow them to hurt a woman who, they
admitted, had done nothing wrong. He imagined how frightened
she was. Think, he urged himself. Think! But he just
stared at the cell phone, bearing its message of bland, coded
encouragement - Don't stop - and at the BlackBerry which
had, so far, brought only bad news. One in each hand, they
yielded nothing.
The radio was burbling with a signature tune, announcing
the top of a new hour. Will looked at his watch: 9am.
'Good morning, this is Weekend Edition. The President promises a new initiative in the Middle East. The Southern Baptist conference gets underway with a promise to make war on what it calls "Hollywood sleaze". And in London, more revelations on the scandal of the year

Will spaced out for most of it, but he caught the latest on Gavin Curtis. It turned out that the red-faced cleric Will had seen on TV the other night was right: Curtis had been siphoning off colossal amounts of public money. Not just millions, which would have made him fantastically rich, but hundreds of millions at a time. Apparently the money had been diverted into a numbered account in Zurich. The humble Chancellor Curtis, riding around the British capital in a modest sedan car, had made himself one of the richest men in the world.
In his current mood, Will found even this news depressing. It was confirmation on a grander scale of everything the last twenty-four hours had been saying. You could trust no one; everyone was up to no good. Then, as if to reproach himself, he thought of Howard Macrae and Pat Baxter. They had both done something good - but they were the exceptions. 'Will, listen.'
TO had turned the volume all the way up. Will recognized the voice: WNYC's anchor, giving the local news.

'Interpol have made a rare trip to Brooklyn this morning, with the mainly Hassidic neighbourhood of Crown Heights the scene. Officials from the NYPD say they are working with police from Thailand on a murder inquiry. NYPD spokesperson Lisa Roderiguet says the case relates to the discovery in the Hassidic sect's Bangkok centre of the body of a leading Thai businessman. He'd been missing for several days, believed kidnapped. The rabbi in charge of the Bangkok centre is now under arrest and the Thai authorities requested, via Interpol, that the NYPD investigate the world headquarters of the Hassidic movement, here in New York, to further their inquiries.
'The weather: in Manhattan, another chilly day . . .'

TO looked pale. 'I need to get out of here,' she said suddenly.
She seemed choked, claustrophobic. She moved across the
room, picking up essentials - purse, phone - until Will realized
this was not a negotiation. They were leaving. Watching her frightened him. There was no mistaking TO's
reaction: she thought Beth had either been murdered or was
about to be. He had not realized it, but TO's earlier calmness,
almost insouciance, had been a comfort as well as an irritant.
Now, with TO slamming the steel concertina door of the
elevator after her, jabbing the buttons to make the damn
thing go faster, he was robbed of that illusion. He felt his
palms grow damp: while he had been dicking around playing
amateur sleuth, his beloved Beth, his partner in life, might
have been strangled or drowned or shot . . . His eyes closed in dread. More than yesterday, less than tomorrow.
They were outside, TO grabbing him by the wrist, not so
much walking alongside him as leading him, like a mother
escorting a reluctant child to nursery. 'Where are we going?'
he asked.
'We're going to play them at their own game. See how
they like it.'
They had only walked a couple of blocks when she strode
into NetZone, an internet cafe which actually served coffee.
There were copies of The New York Times, including the Sunday
magazine and Arts and Leisure section, traditionally released
twenty-four hours in advance, piled up invitingly by the fashionably
shabby arm chairs. The Internet Hot Spot on Eastern
Parkway felt very far away.
TO was not here to sip cappuccino. She was on a mission,
first handing cash over and then planting Will at a free
terminal.
'OK, log on.'
Will suddenly remembered what going out with TO had
been like. He had always felt as if he were somehow the
junior partner and she the person in charge. He used to think
that was because she was the native New Yorker while he
was the outsider, that he deferred to her because she knew
her way around what was for him a foreign land. But he had
been in America for six years now and she was still at it. He
realized TO was plain bossy. 'Hold on,' he said. 'Let's talk
about this first. What exactly are you suggesting I do?'
'Log on to your email and I'll show you.'
'Why do we have to do this here? Why don't we just use
the BlackBerry?'
'Because I can't think using my thumbs. Now come on.
Log on.'
He relented, typing in the string of letters that enabled Times staffers to access their email remotely. Name, password and he
was in: his inbox. There were no surprises, just the same list
of messages he had already seen on his BlackBerry.
'Where's the last message from the kidnappers?'
Will scrolled down until he found it, the string of garble
in the 'name' field and the subject: Beth. He opened it, seeing
the unblinking words anew.
WE DO NOT WANT MONEY
The news from Thailand made this sentence look positively cruel. If it was not money they were after, what motivated them: the simple, sick pleasure of killing? Will could feel his blood rising, in anger - and desperation.
'OK, hit Reply.'
Will did as he was told, before TO nudged him aside and shared the seat with him, so that their bodies touched from their knees to their shoulders. She grabbed the keyboard and began two-finger typing furiously.
I am on to you. I know you must be guilty of what happened in Bangkok because I know you are doing the same here in New York. I plan to go to the police and tell them what I know. That will implicate you in at least two very serious crimes, to say nothing of your assault and false imprisonment of me. You have till nine pm tonight to give me my wife back. Otherwise I talk.

Will read the words twice over, stopping once to look at TO whose face stayed fixed on the computer screen. Her profile
was just inches away from his, a minute diamond stud
sparkling in her nose. He had seen this face from this angle
so many times before; it seemed strange not to be kissing it.
'Christ,' he said eventually. 'That's pretty strong.' He
wondered if it was too explicit, mentioning his treatment the
previous night. He remembered a slew of recent trials, in the
US and in Britain, where journalists' emails had been
produced. What would they make of this one, issuing direct
threats and proposing obstruction of justice - and all from a New York Times address? Fuck it, was all he could think. His
wife was in dire danger; anything was permitted. TO's note
was sharp and hit the target directly. He was about to press
Send when something caught his eye.
'Why till nine pm? Why's that the deadline?'
'They might not read this till after the Sabbath is finished;
we've got to give them time to reply.'
The insanity of the situation had not faded with time. The
notion of pious killers, happy to murder but queasy about
turning on a computer before the appointed hour was too
bizarre for Will to get used to. TO had explained that the
Sabbath did not officially conclude until a specific minute on
Saturday evening. Nothing so imprecise as 'sunset' or 'once
it's dark'. It was 7.42pm. If you did not have a watch, you could check by looking outside your window: tradition held
that once you could see three stars, you knew the Sabbath
was over and the normal working week had resumed.
Will had no idea how the Hassidim would respond. TO had moved so fast, her desire for action meshing perfectly with his fury at the kidnappers who, he now knew, were capable of murder, that he had barely thought through the consequences of what they had just done. Surely these were strange, unpredictable people; who knew how they would react? Will's tone
of angry defiance might push them over the edge: they could decide this was provocation enough to finish Beth off. They could kill her and it would be his fault - for following the whim of, of all people, his ex-girlfriend. He imagined the pain of future years, learning to live with such a weight of guilt. And yet, what had he got to lose? Playing nice had brought no results. He had to get their attention, force them to realize that there would be a price to pay for killing Beth. This email told them they needed his silence - and that they should spare her life to buy it.
Besides, it felt good to be fighting back. He recalled how he had felt the previous evening, when he immersed himself in the warm water of the pre-sabbath mikve as Sandy stood close by. He had been ashamed of his nakedness, his willingness to strip himself bare to ingratiate himself with men
whom he should have fought as enemies. Well, now he was clothed and pulling himself up to his full height and taking them on. With this message, he was fighting for his wife and acting like a man.
He pressed Send.
'Good,' said TO, giving Will's thigh a firm squeeze. 'Good job.'
TO's elation was infectious; for Will it translated into relief. He had done something at last; he had made his move. The urge to fall into one of the cafe's roomy armchairs was strong; Will was exhausted. But TO was already chivvying him to get up and out. She was not just edgy, Will realized; she was making a calculation. Of course. TO was worried that Will himself could be a target for the Hassidim. If she had
had her initial doubts, now she was convinced: the men of
Crown Heights were not to be messed around. It was the
news from Bangkok that converted her. Once a sceptic, she
was now a believer.
As they left, Will's mobile stirred. He waited till they were
outside before he even looked at it: DadHome. Poor guy, he'd
been calling for hours and Will had not sent him so much as
a text message.
'Hello?'
'Thank God for that. Oh Will, I've been worried sick.'
'I'm fine. I'm exhausted, but I'm OK.'
'What the hell's been happening? I've wanted so much to
call the police, but didn't dare until you and I at least had a
chance to talk. Really, Will, I was this close - but I held off.
It's such a relief to hear your voice.'
'You haven't told anyone have you? Dad?'
'Of course I haven't. But I've wanted to. Just tell me, have
you heard from Beth?'
'No. But I know where she is and I know who's got her.'
TO was gesturing at Will's phone, then wagging her finger
across her face like a school mistress. Will got the message.
'Dad, maybe we should talk about this when I'm on a landline. Can I call you later?' 'No, you have to tell me now! I'm going out of my mind
here. Where is she?'
'She's in New York. She's in Brooklyn.'
Will instantly regretted his revelation. Cell phones were
notoriously leaky: he knew that much from the scanners on
the Metro desk, where police radio transmissions were easier
to get than NPR. For those who knew how, plucking cellular
calls out of the air was a breeze.
'But, Dad, I'm serious. There can be no vigilante rescue
attempts here. No calls to the police commissioner who you
knew at Yale. I mean it: that would truly fuck everything up
and could cost Beth her life.' His voice was wobbling. Will
could not tell if he was about to scream at his father or break
down and cry. 'Promise me, Dad. You're not going to do
anything. Promise.'
His father gave a reply but Will could not hear it. A word
went missing, drowned out by the sound of a beep on the
line.
'OK, Dad, I'm going to say goodbye. We'll speak later.'
There was no time for niceties; he needed his father off the
line so he could take this incoming call.
Will pressed the buttons as. fast as he could, his thumbs
trembling with tiredness, but there was no call. The beep he
had heard had announced instead the arrival of a text message.
Will could feel TO leaning on his upper arm, straining to
see his phone as they stood together on the street.
'Read message?' the phone asked dumbly. Of course I want to read it, idiot! Will hit the Yes button, but found the keypad
was locked. Damn. More buttons to press, forcing him to go
the long way around, choosing text messages then his inbox,
then a long wait while the display promised that it was
'opening folder'. Finally, the message appeared: five words,
short, simple - and utterly mysterious.
CHAPTER TWENTY-FOUR
Saturday, 11.37am, Manhattan
2 down: Moses to Bond
Now that TO had broken the code, this message was not baffling - he knew it would be solved within a few moments
- but it was frightening. This string of nonsense might be about to tell him anything. What if one of those words translated as Beth?
TO grabbed the phone and began punching numbers, only to stop suddenly. '2 could be A or B or C. But the only alternative for "down" is "down". It must be a different system.' 'It's a crossword clue.'
'What?'
'2 Down. You know, 4 Across, 3 Down. It's a crossword clue.'
'All right. So what's moses to bond? It implies some sort of motion: we're meant to take Moses to Bond somehow. But what the hell is Bond anyway?'
'James Bond? Could be a number. You know, 007.' TO looked blank. 'Maybe it's two down from seven. Which would be five.'
'Which could be the five books of Moses. But that's not much of a clue. Listen, I'm cold.' They were still standing on the street. 'There.' She pointed at a McDonalds.

With a bacon breakfast bun in one hand and a pencil in the
other, TO was scribbling - combinations of letters and numbers. 'What about Bond Street?' said Will, pacing around her.
'Take Moses to Bond Street?'
TO looked up at Will, her eyebrows raised.
'OK, OK.'
'Let's think this through,' she said, scoring a long line
through everything she had written down. 'What did you say
in your reply to him?' Will, his mouth now full, froze just as
his hands were about to claw a clump of fries. 'I didn't.'
'Sorry?'
'I meant to. I was about to. But then we heard the news
from Bangkok and everything got forgotten.'
Will was almost waiting for TO to pick him up on that lapse
into what she used to call the cowardly passive. 'Everything
got forgotten,' was the cowardly way of saying that Will
himself had forgotten. (TO coined the term in honour of an
old flatmate who, despairing at the state of the kitchen they
shared, but too meek to accuse TO directly, announced, 'Dishes have been left.' Hence, and thereafter, the cowardly passive.) That thought brought back a memory Will had not dredged
up for years: the alternative grammar he and TO had devised to reflect the way language was really used, the way emotions really worked. There was, of course, the passive aggressive
and, Will's favourite, the past too-perfect, deployed by those
consumed with nostalgia. The pressure caused by gift-giving, particularly pronounced at Christmas, was, inevitably, present tension. We must have been so obnoxious, thought Will now, reconstructing in his mind the world of smart-aleck, private
jokes that he and TO had once inhabited together.
'Well, that makes this even more intriguing,' TO said, letting
Will off despite his error. 'It's not a reply. It's a second message, sent voluntarily. It suggests Yosef Yitzhok felt a degree of urgency: two messages in one morning.'
'The first one could have been last night. But, OK. Why would this be urgent?
'I don't know.' TO's voice had dropped; she was distracted. She had grabbed Will's phone back and was staring at it, taking occasional slurps from her chocolate shake without once breaking her gaze. She broke from the meditation only to murmur, 'He was in a hurry.' She began tapping the keypad, then scribbling, then tapping again. A small smile of satisfaction, followed by a crinkled brow.
There. She shoved the sheet of paper across the table.

TWO DOWN. MORE'S TO COME.
They both stared in silence, the pleasure derived from the act of decoding now giving way to the pain of further bemusement.

'He's playing games with us,' said Will. '"Right, you've deciphered two of my messages; I'll send more". So long as we do ... what?'
'We need to let him know we understand, but we need more information. We don't want to piss him off. If he's trying to help, we need to keep him happy. Send a message back.' Will took the phone, glancing up at TO with eyes that said, 'I hope you're right about this.'
Thank you. I won't stop. And I want to hear more. Can you tell me anything? Please.
All they could do now was wait. TO was convinced that McDonalds made a sufficiently anonymous hiding place. Will suspected there was another motive: TO did not want Will in her home.
But they had to wait somewhere. If the Hassidim were not going to reply till sundown, or when the three stars appeared, or whatever way these jokers had of telling the time, there was nothing else to do - save waiting for Yosef Yitzhok to give them another tantalizing, veiled message.
It came nearly an hour later, at first sight as nonsensical as the others.
Wet nose debugs rooro
This time Will pressed the buttons, jotting the results instantly onto his pad. By the time he got to the third word he felt his stomach churn. TO was craning to look and once she saw the notepad, she gasped.
Vet more deaths soon CHAPTER TWENTY-FIVE
Saturday, 11.53am, Manhattan
Everyone was either staring at them directly or pretending not to look. TO was attempting to calm Will who had just pounded the table and then thrown a cup of coffee at the wall. A cleaner had appeared with a mop.
'We've got to try and think straight,' TO was saying. 'How can I think straight? It's a fucking death threat.' 'He might be trying to warn us.'
'Warn us? He's saying they're going to kill Beth.' Will looked up, his eyes red.
The phone buzzed again. TO grabbed it first, before Will had a chance. For the first time, a straight sentence.
He who hesitates is lost
TO looked at it for only a second, before trying out the
text alternative. It made no sense. No, she concluded, this
was a different kind of clue. Maybe it was not even a clue.
Perhaps it was merely a warning. Hurry, there is no time to
waste. She turned the display to Will for his inspection. It
somehow calmed him: there was no direct menace here. It sounded more like a call to action.
TO peered at it a while, then wrote it down on the top
page of her sketchpad, just below the first three messages.
Will saw that she had neatly written the first, coded version
on the left and then the second, deciphered one on the right.
For an instant, Will imagined TO at school: the kind of girl
who always kept a clean, well-stocked pencil case.
While TO chewed her pen and did her best to stare the
latest riddle into submission, Will tried to while away the
afternoon. He picked at junk food, bit his nails, drummed his
fingers on the table; tried reading the paper but could not
concentrate. He could hear a couple arguing. 'I don't believe
you,' the woman was saying to the man. The instant he heard
the words, he sat bolt upright, remembering that night in the
Carnegie Deli. Beth had said a beautiful sentence to him without irony, even if he had tried to pierce the moment
with a joke. 'I believe in you and me,' she had said. He
suddenly wished he had repeated the words back to Beth.
For it was true. She was his faith.
The cell phone beeped.
He that knows nothing doubts nothing
This time Will read it out loud. He knew the answer to his
next question, but he asked it anyway: 'Did you work out
the first one, "He who hesitates is lost"?'
'Not yet. He that knows nothing doubts nothing. What could that mean?' TO was pencilling the words down, in the corner
of a page already marked with drawings.
'I don't get it,' Will said, chiefly for the sake of saying something. 'It's a contradiction. In the first message, he's telling
us not to hesitate. Just to get on with it. Now he's saying
that it's good to doubt. You know, only a moron doesn't experience doubt.'
'Doubting's not the same as hesitating.'

'What's the difference?' 'I don't fucking know. I'm trying to think. He wants to tell us something. You know, "move it". Or "think things through". I don't know. But he sounds like he wants to help.' 'No. If he was trying to help he wouldn't be talking in fucking riddles.' Another beep.
Opportunity seldon knocks twice
As soon as Will read it out, TO began murmuring. 'Twice is interesting. Perhaps he's telling us to multiply something. Maybe we're looking at this all wrong. Maybe he wants us to look at the letters as numbers!'
'What?'
'You know, like the way text messages work, only reversed. They're letters and words formed from numbers. Maybe this is the reverse. We're meant to take the letters and think of them as numbers.'
'What are you talking about?'
'Well, one thing could be to count the number of letters in each clue. That number could be significant. Or perhaps each letter has a numeric value. You know, A is one, B is two.'
Will was baffled, but TO was ignoring him. She was scribbling away frantically on her sketchpad, wildly computing one sum after another.
More beeping; perhaps a minute after the previous one.
a friend in need is a friend indeed
Will was becoming more irritated with each message. If
this was help, why did it have to be so damned opaque? Will
felt like shaking young Yosef Yitzhok by his lapels: If you want to help, then just help! 'What is this, Cliche Night? A friend in need is a friend indeed. What the hell is that? How on earth
does he expect us to solve these so fast?'
'Look, cool down Will. Right now this is all we have. He's all we have. Maybe he's suddenly in a place where he can
text without being seen; he might want to get all his messages
out while he can.'
It was plausible; Will bit his lip. He did not want to set off
a whole row with TO now, not while she was concentrating
so hard on her role as unofficial cryptographer.
Will began to pace around, letting his pores fill up with
the fat and grease of a burger joint - which this place was,
even if it did now sell salads. He strode into a seating area
where a single TV monitor was playing. Set to NY 1, the
local news channel, it now flashed pictures of the Bangkok
arrest of a Brooklyn rabbi on murder charges. The suspect
was in the trademark garb - beard, white shirt, black suit,
trilby hat - as he was handcuffed and led away by two
young and scowling Thai policemen. His face seemed to
be determinedly aimed downward, in shame or to avoid
recognition, Will could not tell. Altogether, the sight could
not have been more incongruous. That sequence was
followed by footage of NYPD officers arriving on foot in
Crown Heights, eschewing their usual squad cars in a
gesture of 'sensitivity' apparently ordered by the mayor's
office.
Those pictures renewed an argument Will and TO staged
several times that long afternoon.
'I should go back there, right now.'
'And do what? Get dunked again?'

'No. I would tell them what I, what you, wrote in that email. That I know what they're up to and that they should cut a deal.'
'Too risky., You might say just the wrong thing and escalate the whole situation. The virtue of email was that we could control exactly what was said.' Was said, the cowardly passive again. TO was obviously reluctant to admit that she had put those words in Will's mouth.
'I can't just leave Beth there. Who knows what they might do now that they're under siege. They might panic. One of those thugs could tighten the screw a bit too hard, or keep her head in water ten seconds too long--'
'You're doing it again. Getting into a panic. I told you, this is like climbing a mountain: you mustn't look down. You mustn't think about any of that. Besides, the place is crawling with police today: they wouldn't dare do anything while they're around. The whole vibe of those text messages from Yosef Yitzhok is that everything's still to play for. Nothing has changed, nothing terrible has happened.'
'Except you don't think they're from Yosef Yitzhok.' 'I'm not sure, that's all.'
That's how it went, several times over, ending inconclusively with both TO and Will falling into a sullen or drained silence. Afterwards, Will would reflect on the fact that Beth and he never bickered. They argued but never bickered; he and TO had turned it into an Olympic sport.
Interruption came whenever a message landed. These texts, which once made Will's chest pound with nervous anticipation, were becoming routine. Even boring. Will clicked to see the latest.
To the victor the spoils
That sounded menacing, as if the Hassidim were registering a claim on Beth: if we win, we will keep her. Will felt his hatred rising. 'Now they're threatening us.'
'To the victor the spoils,' TO repeated slowly once Will had read it out, as if she were taking dictation.
Will glimpsed what looked like a grid on TO's sketch pad, neatly filled in with each new line from YY. 'What have you got?'
'The numbers things didn't work out, so I've been looking at anagrams for each one. And I can get something but nothing that hangs together. There's no pattern. I've tried running it as an acrostic--'
'A what?'
'An acrostic. Where the first letter of each sentence provides a letter of the hidden word. You know, "Roses are red" gives you R, "Violets are blue" gives you V. There are some psalms laid out like that. Put together the first letter of each line and you get another line of prayer. It was a trick: a twelve-line poem with an invisible thirteenth line.'
'I get it. So what do we get if we do that?'
'So far? We have H, H, O, A, T. If we skip the indefinite article - so it's "Friend in need" not "A friend in need" - we get H, H, O, F, T. Not much better.'
'What the hell is he playing at? Hang on.' Another one was coming through.
Goodness is better than beauty
Will was beginning to feel swamped. TO was having to think like a grandmaster at one of those chess exhibitions, moving around the room, playing a hundred games on a hundred different boards at once. It had taken a long time to decode just one message. Now she had six.
'Look, Will. There's no way to work out what this is till it stops. Whenever I try one theory, it's blown out by the next message. We need to have the full set and then see what this guy's trying to say.'
'YY.'
'If it's him, yes.'
'Who the fuck else could it be?'
'Leave me alone, Will.'
He couldn't blame her for being exasperated. He knew he was being insufferable, taking out his rage, grief and sheer fatigue on her. She didn't have to take this from him. She could walk away - and he would be stranded.
He wanted to say sorry, but it was too late. She had turned her back on him, wisely preventing any escalation in hostilities. Pity neither of them had ever been so shrewd when they were lovers.
No more than two minutes later, another message arrived:
a man is known by the company he keeps
Was this some way of urging Will to think about the people around the rabbi who had interrogated him last night? Forget about him, start thinking about his henchmen. Was that what this clue was trying to say?
And then, perhaps thirty seconds later:
From little acorns nighty oaks grow
Christ, this guy was annoying. What was this, some oblique reference to fathers and sons? The effort he was putting into these messages, hammering out long texts when all he had to do was send a few, simple words: the address where Beth was held. The ire was rising through Will's body, reaching the veins in his neck.
He had not even shown TO the latest message when he began texting back:
Enough of these horseshit games. You know what I need.
The instant he had sent it, Will regretted it. What if he scared Yosef Yitzhok off? TO was right: he was all they had. Worse, what if Will's message was somehow intercepted by the Crown Heights hardliners, who would instantly realize what YY was up to, that he was in communication with the enemy, and punish him? Will imagined YY in an alleyway, just off Eastern Parkway, huddled over his cell phone, maybe using his prayer shawl as a canopy, when two men grab him
from behind, snatch away his phone and drag him off for an
impromptu meeting with the rabbi.
And yet, Will felt a release of cathartic energy flow through
him. He could not stand the passivity of his situation, sitting
there, hands outstretched, waiting for clues to fall like crumbs
from the Hassidim's table. It felt good to fight back.
Finally, the sky began to darken. Will started pacing, his
right hand gripping the BlackBerry, turning it clammy. At
7.42pm exactly TO nodded, telling him that the Sabbath had
now ended. Will glanced down immediately, expecting a red
light to flicker on within seconds. No, no, advised TO: they
should give it at least thirty minutes before expecting a reply.
There were things to do after the sabbath, including the Havdalah ceremony which used wine, spices and a plaited
candle to bid a final farewell to the day of rest. Then there
was the walk back from synagogue to make Havdalah at
home. Most men would probably want to freshen up after
that. Even if the Hassidim read Will's message on a computer
in a home or office, they would not want to reply from there:
too traceable. Not by Will of course, but by the police in some
future investigation. So they would have to go back to the
Internet Hot Spot - all of which could take at least an hour.
Even this scenario was optimistic, TO warned. Will knew he
had sent them an email, but they did not. They were not
expecting one, so why would they rush to check?
On the other hand, maybe today was different. Crown
Heights was crawling with detectives investigating a murder
under instruction from Interpol. The rabbi who had grilled
Will would not be able to stick to his usual ritual. He would
be answering questions and they would not be about the
correct dimensions of a Talmudic stove. He would be under
interrogation - and under pressure. (The thought of that role
reversal pleased Will.) If that was the atmosphere, Will reckoned
they would have a hundred reasons to check email as
soon as they could. Even if they were not waiting for word from him, they would need to communicate with their people in Bangkok. Will guessed they would be powering up their laptops the moment it was theologically decent.
At eight o'clock Will's hunch was confirmed. Twenty
minutes after sundown, the red light on his BlackBerry
blinked. Will clicked the track wheel and saw that same, hieroglyphic script, the characters he now knew to be Hebrew. Re: Beth.
You are out of your depth. Do not drown. CHAPTER TWENTY-SIX
Saturday, 8.01pm, Manhattan
He had no time for a seminar with TO. He replied instantly, his thumbs working furiously.
I could call the police right now. What do I have to lose? He waited, while TO sat opposite him, curled into a ball, rocking herself backward and forward. Will wondered if he had ever seen her in this position, so nervous she was foetal. The crowd at McDonalds had changed. The bums and homeless mutterers now mostly replaced by twenty-something men about to fuel up before a night hitting the bars. The red light came on.
You have everything to lose. You could lose her.
Again, Will did not wait. This, he realized, was what he had wanted since that first message: a direct confrontation with the kidnappers. When they had met last night, Will was pretending to be someone else. He had had to be polite. Now it was out in the open, he could take them on.
You touch her and you will be guilty of two murders. My evidence will send you down. Release her or I start nailing you. The delay was longer this time, excruciating. The red light flashed, Will pouncing on the little blue machine.
Low price pharmacy for all your medical needs. We deliver. Spam. More minutes and then:
Call now on 718-943-7770. Do not use a recording device. We will
know if you try.
Will imagined how this was working at the other end.
Doubtless, one of the monkeys, Moshe Menachem or Tzvi
Yehuda, was at the Internet Hot Spot, reading and typing the
emails, taking direct instruction from the boss on the end of
a phone. Now the boss had something to say that he did not
want committed to email, even one as disguised as this. Good, thought Will, sensing his opponent was weakening a little.
He looked at TO: having consumed her nails, she was now
gnawing at her cuticles.
He pulled out his cell phone, dialling the number slowly,
as if he was performing surgery. His hands were trembling.
He realized that this man frightened him.
It rang only once. He could hear the phone had been
answered but no one spoke: he was going to have make the
first move.
'This is Will Monroe. You asked me to call.'
'Yes, Will, I did. First, let me apologize for what happened
yesterday. A bad case of mistaken identity, partly compounded
by the fact that you made the mistake of concealing your
identity.' Will wondered if he was meant to laugh at this little
bit of wordplay. He did not. 'I think it's right that we talk
about the current situation.'
'You're damn right we need to talk about it. You need to
give me back my wife or else I will implicate you in a double
murder.'
'Now calm down, Mr Monroe.'
'I'm not feeling very calm, Rabbi. Yesterday you nearly
killed me and you have abducted my wife for no reason. The
only reason I have not gone to the police so far is because
of your threats to kill my wife. But now I can go to them
and confirm your guilt in the Bangkok case by saying you
have already performed a kidnap right here in New York city.
If you kill her then, that will only compound your guilt.' Will
was pleased with how that had come out; it was more coherent
than he had expected.
'All right, I am going to make a deal with you. If you say
nothing and talk to no one, we will do our best to keep Beth
alive.' Beth. It sounded strange coming from this baritone
voice, whose timbre had only barely altered in the metallic
compression of the phone.
'What do you mean, "do our best"? Who else is there?
You've done this, you should take responsibility for it. Either
you will guarantee her safety or you won't.' That sentence, unplanned, prompted a thought, one he voiced out loud
before it was fully formed in his own mind. 'I want to speak
to my wife.'
'I'm sorry.'
'I want to speak to her right now. I want to hear her voice.
As proof that she is still . . . safe.'
'I don't think that's a good idea.'
'I don't care what you think. As I'm only too happy to
explain to the police. I want to hear her voice.'
'That will take some time.'
'I'm calling you back in five minutes.'
Will put the phone down and exhaled as if he had been
holding his breath; the blood seemed to be pounding through
his veins. His own firmness had taken him by surprise. And
yet it had seemed to work; the rabbi had not refused.
Will counted the minutes, staring at the second hand as it
swept across the face of his watch. TO could say nothing.
A minute passed, then two. Well felt an ache in his forehead;
the muscles of his face had been tensed so long, they
hurt. The top of the plastic pen he had been chewing came
apart in his mouth.
Four minutes gone. Will stood up and stretched, tilting his
head toward one shoulder, then the next. It made a loud
crack. He looked down at the phone and, four minutes and
fifty five seconds after he had hung up, he redialled the
number.
'It's Will Monroe. Let me speak to her.'
There was no reply, just a series of clicking sounds, as if
his call were being transferred. The sound of breath and then:
'Will? Will, it's Beth--'
'Beth, thank God it's you. Oh my love, are you OK? Are
you hurt?'
Silence, and then three more clicks. 'Beth?'
'I'm afraid I had to cut off the line. But now you have heard her voice; you know she is--' 'For God's sake, you barely gave us a second.' Will smashed
the table with his fist, making TO leap back in fright. He felt
himself flood with emotion. For less than a second he had
felt such relief, such joy: it was Beth's voice, no mistaking it.
Just the sound of it made him weak. And then it had disappeared,
cut short before he had even had a chance to tell her
he loved her.
'I couldn't risk any more time. I'm genuinely sorry. But I
did what you asked: you have heard your wife's voice.'
'You have to promise me NOW that nothing is going to
happen to her.'
'I tried to explain this to you last night, Will. This is not
entirely in our hands, not in mine, not in yours. Much bigger
forces are in play. This is something mankind has feared for
millennia.'
'What the hell are you talking about?'
'I cannot blame you for not understanding. Not many
would, which is why we cannot explain this to the police,
much as all of us might like to. They would certainly not
understand. For some reason, HaShem has left this in our
hands to resolve.'
'How do I know you're not tricking me to stay quiet? How
do I know that you don't plan to kill my wife the way you
killed that man in Bangkok?'
A pause. Then: 'Ah, nothing grieves me more than what
happened there. Every Jewish heart will cry out in despair
at the pity of what happened there.' He paused again. Will
let the silence hang. Wait for the interviewee to fill the void
... 'I am going to take a risk, Mr Monroe. I hope you take
it as it is meant, as a gesture of good faith on my part. I am
going to let you into a secret which you could easily use
against me. By revealing it to you, I will be showing a degree
of trust in you. As a result I hope you will feel better able to
trust me. Do you understand?'
'I understand.'
'What happened in Bangkok was an accident. It is true
that we wanted to take Mr Samak into custody, just as we
have with your wife, but we certainly had no intention of
killing him. God forbid.' TO had moved round to sit next to
Will, pressing her ear against the back of his cell phone.
'What we did not know, what we could not have known,
was that Mr Samak had a weak heart. Such a strong man,
but a terribly weak heart. The . . . steps we had to take to
bring him into custody were, I'm afraid, more than he could
take.'
For a brief moment, Will thought like a journalist: he had wrung a confession from this man. Not of murder, perhaps,
but of manslaughter. In a spasm of professional pride, Will
guessed that, despite hours of intense questioning, New York's
finest had not yet achieved quite so good a result.
'That is what happened, Mr Monroe and, though it will
amaze you to hear it, I have only told you the truth in all
our encounters so far. I repeat that I have taken a great risk
in speaking so candidly. But something tells me you will take
my gesture the right way and you will not spurn me. I have
trusted you and now, I hope, you will trust me. Do it for
your own reasons, Will. Do it because I have told you that I
will do my best to keep your wife alive. But do it also because
of what I told you yesterday and repeat again today: that an
ancient story is unfolding here, threatening an outcome mankind has feared for thousands of years. Your wife matters to you, Mr Monroe, of course she does. But the world, the creation of the Almighty, matters to me.'
Now the rabbi was leaving the silence, waiting for Will to fill it. He knew what was happening, but he could not help himself.
'What are you asking me to do?'
'To do nothing, Mr Monroe. Nothing at all. Just to stay out of this and to be patient. There are perhaps a couple of days left and then we will all know our fates. So even though you are desperate to see Beth again, I urge you to wait. No meddling, no amateur detective work. Just wait. I hope you will do what's right, Will. Good night. And may God turn his face to shine upon all of us.'
The phone clicked off. Will looked at TO, who seemed to be trembling with him.
'It's so strange to hear his voice,' she was saying, in little more than a whisper. 'After we've talked about him so much, I mean.'
Will had scribbled the odd note while the rabbi was talking so that he and TO could deconstruct his meaning. But it was the tone that was most striking. If Will was briefing Harden on the conversation he had just had, that would be his headline. The rabbi had sounded conciliatory but something else, too - almost regretful.
The silence was not allowed to last. The cell phone had another text to disgorge. a chain is no stronger than its weakest link And then a moment later:
Safety in numbers. No more.
Will read them out, pausing as TO demanded clarification of the location of the period in that sentence. There were two full stops, Will replied. Was he sure? He was sure. He was having trouble concentrating. He was hearing Beth's voice, over and over: Will? Will, it's Beth.
'OK,' TO was saying. 'Let's assume that he means what he says, that there will be no more. This is the full set.' In front of her, laid out on the table, were ten neat squares of paper, one message written on each.

He who hesitates is lost
He that knows nothing doubts nothing Opportunity seldom knocks twice
A friend in need is a friend indeed
To the victor the spoils
Goodness is better than beauty
A man is known by the company he keeps From little acorns mighty oaks grow A chain is no stronger than its weakest link Safety in numbers. No more.

TO was glaring at them, her sketchbook on her lap, surveying the pattern she had arranged. The messages were in three groups. Encouragement, warnings, enigmas. TO now laid the pad onto the table, alongside the scraps of paper. It was almost dark with ink: she had filled the page. All over it were words or half-phrases crossed out, written backwards or in diagonals. She had written out the messages in every possible order, each time underlining the first letter of each line: attempting the acrostic. Will could see the results: HHOATGAFAS followed by a list of random variations using the same letters. All of them spelled gibberish.
As if reading his mind, TO turned the page of her sketchbook to show the one underneath, its surface no less covered with calculations and abortive anagrams. She peeled that away to show the one below and the one below that. She had been breaking her head to solve this puzzle for hours.
Will felt a surge of gratitude: he knew how lonely he would have been without her. But there was no getting away from it. Despite all her efforts, despite their combined intellect, they still had not cracked this riddle in ten parts. It had defeated them.
'I can't believe I am that dumb.'
'What?' Will looked up from the table to see TO leaning back in her chair, hands on her head and eyes fixed on the ceiling.
'I cannot believe I am so stupid.' She was smiling, shaking her head in disbelief.
'Please tell me precisely what you're talking about,' Will said, in a voice that even he recognized as excessively polite and English, a voice he often used when trying to stay calm. 'It was so obvious and I made it so complicated. How many hours have I spent on this thing now?'
'You mean, you've worked it out?'
'I've worked it out. What has he sent us? "A friend in need." "From little acorns." He's sent us proverbs. Ten proverbs.' 'Right, so ... Sorry, you're going to have to tell me. I can see he's sent us ten proverbs. The trouble is, we don't know what they mean.'
'They don't mean anything. They're not meant to mean anything. He's sent us ten proverbs. Because that's where we're meant to look. Proverbs, 10.'
CHAPTER TWENTY-SEVEN

Saturday, 8.27pm, Manhattan
He had been there as long as they had and had been muttering just as loudly. He was on his own, middle-aged and no doubt homeless, with a face that seemed swollen through exposure to the elements. In the course of the afternoon Will had seen him eat half an apple pie, handed to
him by a guy wearing an iPod (who did not take the earphones out), and perhaps a bag and a half of fries; and at intervals he had read aloud from the black, plastic-bound bible he held in his right hand.
Will had found these random sermons an irritation during the afternoon, as had the succession of customers who took pains not to sit too near. Now, though, he could not have been more grateful. With a hot cup of coffee in his hand, he approached gingerly.
'Sir, I wonder if perhaps you'd like a cup of coffee. It's freshly made.'
The man,looked up, his eyes watery. The whites were yellow.
'If it had not been the Lord who was on our side - let Israel now say - if it had not been the Lord who was on our side, when our enemies attacked us, then they would have swallowed us up alive, when their anger was kindled against us--'
'Yes, sir, I'm sure that's quite right,' Will tried, in the short moment the man drew breath. But it was no good; he was off again. 'Then the flood would have swept us away, the torrent
would have gone over us; then over us would have gone the raging waters.'
'Sir, I'm sorry to trouble you, but I wondered if I could borrow your bible.'
'Blessed be the Lord, who has not given us as prey to their teeth. We have escaped like a bird from the snare of the fowlers; the snare is broken, and we have escaped.'
'That's truly what I pray for, too, sir. But if I could just
take a peek at your bible.' Will bent down and tried to take the book from his hand. The man's grip was surprisingly strong. He would not let go.
'Our help is in the name of the Lord, who made heaven and earth.'
'Yes, yes, that's what I think too. So if you'd just let me glance at the holy book.' The man's hand gnarled itself even more tightly. Will tugged but the man tugged back, still muttering.
Will looked up; TO had arrived. By now he was almost sitting next to the tramp, pulling horizontally at the book. He knew he looked ridiculous: he was mugging a tramp for his bible. 'Sir,' TO said softly. 'Do you think we could pray together?' Suddenly the man stopped talking. TO continued, her voice a gentle stream of pure reason. 'Can I suggest we take as our text, the Book of Proverbs, Chapter 10?'
Without complaint, the man opened up the book, thumbing through its tissue-thin, closely printed pages. Within a few seconds, he began his recitation: 'The proverbs of Solomon. A wise son maketh a glad father: but a foolish son is the heaviness of his mother.'
Will tried to peer over his shoulder, to skim the rest of the ancient text at top speed. To him, it looked like the usual
biblical mix of profundity and obscurity. Scripture always had
this effect on him: the words might make stirring music, but
their precise meaning only ever became clear through great
effort. Most of the time, in church or at morning prayers at
school, the sounds just washed over him. As they did now,
in this odd, spontaneous prayer meeting.
Their leader was onto Verse 2: 'Treasures of wickedness
profit nothing: but righteousness delivereth from death.'
Eyes down, Will was racing ahead. Confronted now with
verse after verse of the stuff, he found his eye lighting upon
anything either immediately intelligible or, better still, familiar.
One word stood out, again and again. It had appeared in
Verse 2 and was there again in Verse 3. The Lord will not suffer
the soul of the righteous to famish: but he casteth away the substance of the wicked.
And again in Verse 11. The mouth of a righteous man is a well
of life: but violence covereth the mouth of the wicked.
And in Verse 16. The labour of the righteous tendeth to life: the
fruit of the wicked to sin.
Verse 2I had it too. The lips of the righteous feed many: but
fools die for want of wisdom.
Wherever Will looked, the word seemed to jump off the
page. In his sleep-deprived state, he could almost hear voices,
angry male voices, shouting the word at him. There it was
again, in Verse 24. The fear of the wicked, it shall come upon him:
but the desire of the righteous shall be granted.
Listening to the rambling murmur of the homeless man,
he pictured the Rabbi of Crown Heights swaying as he read
Verse 25, his bearded disciples swaying along with him. As
the whirlwind passeth, so is the wicked no more: but the righteous
is an everlasting foundation.
The word refused to let go. Verse 28 had it - The hope of
the righteous shall be gladness: but the expectation of the wicked
shall perish - and so did Verse 30: The righteous shall never be
removed: but the wicked shall not inhabit the earth.
It was even there at the very end, in the final verse. The lips of the righteous know what is acceptable: but the mouth of the
wicked speaketh perversity.
The tramp now had his eyes shut, incanting the words
from memory. But Will had heard enough. He stood up and
moved round, so he could whisper in TO's ear.
'I'm going.'
He knew they could have discussed it for hours, parsing
every clause for multiple meanings like a pair of the sharpest
Talmudical scholars. But sometimes you just have to go with
your first instinct. Journalism was like that. You would be at
a press conference, handed some voluminous document, and
somehow you would have to whip through it in five minutes,
decide what it was all about, ask your question and go. In
truth, the document could not be read properly in less than
four or five hours, but journalists liked to think such strictures
were for lesser mortals.
So Will trusted his judgment. Besides, he was sick of talking,
deciphering and interpreting. He wanted to move, to go somewhere.
He had been inside for hours, inhaling air made sweet
and sickly by fast food.
He had heard what he needed to hear. He knew exactly
where he had to go - and he knew he would have to go
there alone.
CHAPTER TWENTY-EIGHT

Saturday, 9.50pm, Manhattan
A long line of elevators, maybe ten of them, and barely a
soul to elevate. All big offices were probably like this on the
weekends: still functioning, still with a guard at the front desk
and lights on in the canteen, but skeletal versions of their
weekday selves.
The lobby of The New York Times building looked especially
bereft. On Monday at 10am, this space would be jammed, as
circulation managers jostled with graphic designers to cram
into elevators, half of them clutching steaming cups of overpriced
coffee. Now the same space was empty and silent, with
only the rarest 'ping' to announce that an elevator had moved
up a few floors and come back home again.
Will nodded a hello to the guard on duty who gave him
the merest glance. He was watching a ball game on a TV
monitor that Will was sure was supposed to be tuned to closed
circuit pictures of the fire escape or rear entrance or something.
Will swiped his card and headed to the newsroom.
He was glad to be here. He had not worked at the Times for long, but this office felt familiar. And he could not face
going home. Just the thought of closing the front door and
hearing the silence made him shudder. The pictures on the
wall; Beth's clothes in the cupboard; her smell in the bathroom.
Even imagining it scared him.
Besides, was this not what Yosef Yitzhok had told him to
do in person, before he began communicating by texted
riddle? Look to your work. Now, via Proverbs 10, he had been
more specific.
Will's pace quickened as he walked into the newsroom,
deliberately avoiding eye contact with anyone who might
spot him. At this time of night it was mainly production staff,
not friends of his, but still Will kept his peripheral vision
switched off, focused only on reaching his desk.
As he got nearer, glimpsing something over the flimsy
partition wall, his heart thumped. There was a box, placed
on his seat. Could this be what YY had been talking about? Had he been perfectly literal? Go to your office, it's all there waiting for you. A box containing all the answers? Will knew it was pure fantasy, but he could not help himself.
He sprinted the last yard or two, grabbed the box, feeling its
weight and tearing it open all at the same time. It was much
lighter than its size had suggested and hard to open too. Finally
the two top leaves came apart, Will stuck his arm inside and
felt something soft and fleshy, like a fruit. What the hell was
this? He dug in deeper; it felt moist. He hooked his fingers
through some kind of opening and, using it as a handle,
pulled up the entire object.
A Hallowe'en pumpkin. Will had poked his fingers through
an eye socket.
Attached was a card.
The Better Relations Company invite you to a special evening . . .
Some bullshit PR freebie. Invitations for promotional events
in New York had become increasingly absurd and excessive:
FedEx packages arriving at great expense, containing a silver
key which turned out to be the ticket for the launch of the
new Ericsson cell phone. The English Puritan in Will balked
at such conspicuous waste. He picked up the pumpkin and
hurled it across the pod towards a dustbin; it landed and split open by Schwarz's desk. He'll hardly notice.
He glanced at the rest of the post: circulars and press releases.
A few seemed to be new deposits - an invite for a party at the
British Consulate in New York; a flyer for a convention hosted
by some evangelical outfit, the Church of the Reborn Jesus;
a notice about the Times healthcare scheme - otherwise, the
pile of paper was just as he had left it on Monday, the last
day he had been in the office.
That was nearly a week ago; it felt like a lifetime. It seemed
like an earlier, golden era - life before the kidnap. How lucky
he had been, flying out of New York, then bombing down
the backroads of Montana with nothing more grave on his
mind than the fickle tastes of the National desk. Of course
he had not appreciated it: he had even been idiotic enough
to feel glum about his cock-up on the floods story. As if any
of that mattered. One of Beth's favourite songs floated into
his head, or rather just one line of it. You don't know what
you've got till it's gone . . . After a second or two, he was not
hearing Joni Mitchell's voice but Beth's. She loved singing
and he loved to listen to her. Gathering dust in the corner
of their living room was an old acoustic guitar, a memento
of student days when she would strum old songs of love and
loss to herself. She sang only rarely these days; Will would
have to bribe her to do it. But when she did, his heart would
soar.
Will could feel his eyes stinging. He wanted very badly to
cry, to give into this memory of his wife that had caught him
unawares. He wanted to fall into a chair, make a pillow of
his arms and prolong the memory, to hold on to it the way
a child wants to catch a bubble, never letting it burst.
Instead he began searching for the notebook he had left
here five days ago, the one he had filled up in Brownsville,
writing on both sides of the pages.
It was not under the press release pile, nor in the stack of
magazines and papers Will had already begun to accumulate, waiting to be clipped. (A job he liked in theory but never got
around to doing.) He checked the drawers, which he had
loaded on his first day with Post-its, a handful of contacts'
business cards, batteries and an old cassette machine in case
his mini-disc recorder broke down. Not there. He looked back
at the desk-chair and on the floor and then rummaged through
the papers all over again.
He looked around the pod, his eye stopping on the photo
of Amy Woodstein's toddler son apparently wrestling with
his mother, pushing her over from the side. They were both
smiling, Amy wearing an expression of relaxed joy that neither
she, nor anyone else, ever displayed in this newsroom.
Suddenly he heard Woodstein's voice in his head. My advice is to lock up your notebooks when Terry's around. And talk quietly
when you 're on the phone.
Will turned himself around slowly. Neat as ever, Walton's
desk seemed to carry no excess paper. Just the single yellow
legal pad.
Will inched closer, his eyes instinctively darting left and
right to check no one was around. He ran his hands along
the desk, as if to confirm through touch that it really was as
clear and empty as it looked. Nothing there. He checked
below the yellow pad, to see if there was another stashed
underneath. No.
Now his hand was moving towards the desk drawer. Still
scoping the room, he began to pull. It was locked.
Will sat himself in Terry Walton's chair, ready to mount
the search for the key. He was sure it would be here somewhere:
no one kept the key to a desk-drawer on a ring, did
they? Will ran his hand underneath the desk, hoping to find
it taped in place. Nothing.
He sat back in the chair. Where could it be? The desk held
only the yellow pad and a couple of lame mementos of
Walton's glory days as a foreign correspondent: a bust of
Lenin and, most bizarre, a snow-dome in which the winter
scene was not children sledging or reindeer riding but a
fatherly-looking Saddam Hussein, his arms outstretched,
reaching out to a young boy and girl running towards him.
Ba'athist kitsch, doubtless picked up when Walton covered
the first Gulf War. Without thinking, Will picked it up to give
it a shake, to watch the blizzard fall on the great Iraqi tyrant.
As the first flakes fell, he saw it. Stuck to the underside of
this plastic bauble - a thin, silver key.
'Good evening, William.'
Will could feel his muscles seize up. He had been caught.
He swivelled his chair around.
The man was barely visible, standing in the half-light. Still,
Will recognized his profile before he could even make out
the features. It was Townsend McDougal, Executive Editor of The New York Times. 'Oh, hello. Good evening.' Will could hear the nerves, the
exhaustion and the panic in his own voice.
'I've heard of eagerness and dedication, William, but this
is surely beyond the call of duty: spending Saturday night
toiling not only at your own desk, but at that of a colleague.
Most industrious.'
'Ah, yes. Sorry. I was ... I was looking for something. I
think I might have left my notebook here. On Terry's desk,
I mean.'
McDougal made a show of craning his neck and peering
at the desk, as if searching it was a difficult task, when in
fact it was uncluttered and visibly empty.
'Doesn't seem to be here, does it, William?'
'No, sir. It doesn't.' Will was embarrassed by that 'sir'. He
was also aware of sitting so far back in his - Walton's - chair,
he risked falling over. Like a man held at gunpoint.
'We didn't see you in the office yesterday, William. Harden
wondered if you had been kidnapped.'
Will felt a feverish chill run along his neck, as if he was
fighting a severe flu. He was so tired. 'No, I was... I've been working on something. On a story.'
'What kind of story, William? Do you have another unlikely
hero for us? Another "diamond in the rough" like your saintly
crack dealer? Another organ-giving gun nut?'
Will had a dread thought. The editor was either mocking
him or, much worse, voicing scepticism. The paper had been
burned before by young men in such a hurry to make their
mark that they had written works of short fiction rather than
journalism, which The New York Times had swallowed whole
and published on page one. People still spoke of the Jayson
Blair scandal, which had toppled one of Townsend's predecessors.
Will
realized what he now looked like. Unshaven and
twitchy - and, unaccountably, in the newsroom late on a
Saturday night at someone else's desk. 'It's not what you
think, sir.' Will could hear his own voice slurring with fatigue.
His mouth was dry. 'I just wanted to check something about
the Brownsville story. I was looking for my notebook and I
thought maybe Walton--'
'Why would Walton want your notebook, William? Be
careful not to believe everything you hear in the newsroom.
Remember, journalists don't always tell the truth.'
There it was again, another coded dig at Will and his stories.
Was he accusing him of faking the Macrae and Baxter tales,
albeit in the genteel language of a New England Brahmin?
He may have had the accent and erect posture of a Massachusetts
aristocrat, but McDougal's unblinking expression was the
poker face of a consummate office politician.
'No, I was not believing anything. I just want to go through
my notes.'
'Is there something about the story you're not sure of,
William?'
Damn. 'No, I've just been wondering if there's more there
than I first realized.'
'Oh, I would certainly assume that.'
Another dig.
'You need to be very careful, William. Very careful.
Journalism can be a dangerous business. Nothing more important than the story, that's what we always say. And that's
almost true. But not completely. There is always something
far more important than the story, William. Do you know
what that is?'
'No, sir.' He was back in the headmaster's study.
'It's your life, William. That's what you have to look out
for. So, mark my words. Be very careful.' He left a long pause
before speaking again. 'I'll tell Harden you're getting some
rest.'
With that, the editor withdrew back into the semidarkness
and began his stately glide towards the National
desk. Will fell back into Walton's chair and let out what he
knew was an audible sigh. The editor thought he was a
junkie, about to go off the rails and ready to take The New York Times with him. And now he was 'getting some rest'. It sounded like a
management euphemism for suspension, while they investigated
the veracity of the Macrae and Baxter stories. Was that
why the notebook was missing? Had Townsend taken it as
evidence?
His fingers were still balled around the Saddam snow-dome,
now misted over with clammy hand-moisture. He had held
it tight throughout the entire conversation with Townsend.
That would have looked great: not only wild-eyed, but his
hand a permanent fist. As his fingers uncurled, he saw it
again - the plain, thin key that would surely open Walton's
desk drawer. He knew it was madness to try it, having received
an all but formal warning from the most senior man in US
journalism. But he had no choice. His wife was a hostage
and that notebook surely held the clue to getting her back.
Will glanced left and right and back again to see if anyone
was nearby. He turned a complete circle, mindful that
Townsend had surprised him from behind. Then, in a single rapid movement he ripped the key from its sticky tape, ducked
down and slid it inside the lock. One jiggle and it turned.
Inside were multiple neat, fawn-coloured files. Between
them, hardly concealed, was the tell-tale white metal spiral
of a reporters' pad. Will pulled it out and saw the scribble on
the thick, front cover.
Brownsville.
Jesus. Woodstein was not kidding: Walton had stolen his
notebook. God only knew why. The story had already been
published. There was no scoop to be scooped. What possible
use could it be to him? Will put it out of his mind: there
were enough puzzles to be solved without adding Walton's
bizarre strain of journalistic kleptomania to the pile.

Will wanted to start flicking through it right away, but he knew he had first to close the drawer, lock it, replace the key and return to his own desk - all without being spotted. Exactly what possibility he was guarding against, he was not sure. He had already been caught by the editor; the damage was done.
Even so, Will made sure he was hunched over his own desk before he so much as opened the book. He devised a method. First, a rapid-fire search for something alien: a note stashed inside that he had failed to see, a scrawled message in a hand other than his own. Perhaps, through some sorcery that remained utterly opaque, Yosef Yitzhok had smuggled a message onto these pages. Look to your work.
Will moved through it fast, scanning the lines in search of the unfamiliar. There was nothing, just his own scrawl. The newsroom was so quiet, CNN on Saturday evening mute, he could hear the pages turn. He could hear his own brain.
Briefly, he became excited by a couple of lines that leapt out, clearly written by someone else, but they turned out to be contact details for Rosa, the woman who had found
Macrae's body, scrawled onto the page in her own hand. Will
now remembered that he had promised to send her a copy
of the piece once it was published.
There was no mystery phone number, no smuggled message
- not that there could have been with this notebook stashed
in Walton's filing cabinet since who knew when.
Instead he would have to stare very hard at the one clue
he knew this book did contain, the thing that had brought
him here. There it was, on one of the last pages, boxed and
ringed with asterisks: the quote that had made the piece,
from Letitia, the devoted wife who had contemplated prostitution
rather than let her husband rot in jail. The man they killed last night may have sinned every day of his God-given life but
he was the most righteous man I have ever known.
In an instant, Will was back in Montana, talking to Beth
on the cell phone. It was, he realized, the last conversation
they had had before she was taken. He was telling her about
his day spent reporting the life and death of Pat Baxter. He
could hear his own voice, speaking animatedly, before realizing
that Beth was miles away.
'You know what's weird. It hit me straight away because
no one uses this word, or hardly ever: the surgeon who operated
on Baxter used the same word as that Letitia woman.
Righteous. They even used it the same way: "the most righteous
person," "the most righteous act." Isn't that strange?'
He had not pursued the point. He had rapidly realized Beth
was elsewhere, preoccupied with the issue that should have
been preoccupying him: their failure to have a baby. He felt
his throat go dry: the thought that Beth might die never
having known motherhood.
He pushed the notion away, staring down at his own handwriting
on the page. The most righteous man I have ever known.
He had flirted with pointing out this uncanny echo when
he wrote up the Baxter story but had ruled it out almost
immediately. It would seem too self-regarding, noting a similarity between two stories whose only real common link was his own by-line. Baxter and Macrae lived at opposite ends of the country; their deaths were obviously unrelated. To notice a reverberation between one random murder and another only made journalistic sense if both cases were well-known, their details lodged in the public mind. That was emphatically not the case here, so Will had dropped it! He had not
thought about it again until that evening, as he and TO stood either side of the homeless preacher in McDonalds. Every verse of Proverbs 10 he had incanted seemed to contain this same word, repeated too often to be a coincidence. Righteous. But these murders could not possibly be connected. Black pimps in New York and white crazies in the Montana backwoods did not mix in the same circles or have the same
enemies. They had lived and died worlds apart.
And yet, there was something oddly similar about these two eccentric tales. Both involved men who seemed suspect and yet had done a good deed. Or rather an extraordinarily good deed. Righteous. And both had been murdered, with no suspect yet arrested in either case.
Will swivelled round to face the computer screen. He logged on to the Times website and found his own story on Macrae. He would read it forensically, looking to see if there was anything else to go on.
'... Police sources spoke of a brutal knife attack, with multiple stab wounds puncturing the victim's abdomen. Local residents say the style of the killing fits with the latest in gangland fashion, as in the words of one, "knives are the new guns".'
The method of killing was entirely different. Baxter had been shot; Macrae stabbed. Will opened another window on the screen, allowing him to call up his Baxter story. He scrolled down, looking for the paragraphs with the forensic detail, time and method of death. Finally he came to the line he was looking for.
Initially, Mr Baxter's militia comrades suspected a macabre act of organ theft lay behind the murder. Unaware of his earlier act of philanthropy, they assumed Mr Baxter lost his kidney on the night of his death. As if to add weight to that theory, there were signs of recent anaesthesia - a needle mark - on the corpse.

Will read on, looking for more, as if he had never read the story before. Now he wanted to curse whoever had written it: there was no more on the mystery injection. It had just been left hanging.
He dug into his bag to retrieve his current notebook, the one he had taken to Seattle. He riffled through the pages to find the interview with Genevieve Huntley, the surgeon who had removed Baxter's kidney. He remembered the conversation, sitting in the front seat of his rental car, cradling a cell phone to his ear. He had just let her talk, wary of interrupting the flow. According to the scrawl in front of him, he had not even asked about the recent needle mark. Looking back, he knew why. He had dismissed the whole business once the surgeon had told him about Baxter's kidney op. The story had changed, from organ-snatching gore to righteous man and that inconvenient detail had got forgotten. He had forgotten it. Besides, Huntley had said there had been no more surgery so the recent injection idea did not fit. Yet, now he flicked a few pages back in the notebook to see his encounter with the medical examiner and Oxford man, Allan Russell. 'Contemporaneous' was his verdict on the needle mark. It was strange but inescapable: Baxter's killers had anaesthetized him first.
Will clicked back on to the Macrae story. No talk of injections there. Just a frenzied stabbing. He sat back in his chair. Another hunch was evaporating. He had thought he was going to prove these two deaths were somehow connected. Not just by the odd coincidence of the word 'righteous' but something physical. A real tie that might suggest a pattern. But it was not there. What had he got? Two deaths which
had good-guy victims in common. That was it so far. In one
case, Baxter's, there had been a weird twist: he had been
sedated before he was killed. That was not true of Macrae.
Or rather, Will had no idea if it was true or not. The police
had never mentioned it - but he had never asked. He had
not seen Macrae's body; he had not met the coroner. It had
not been that kind of story. And if he had not asked, then
no one had. After all, the Macrae death had hardly been a
big deal. Apart from a few briefs written on the night, no
paper had run much on it - until Will's story in The New York
Times, of course.
Will reached instantly for his cell phone, punching at the
internal phonebook. There was only one person who could help. He hit J for Jay Newell. CHAPTER TWENTY-NINE

Saturday, 10.26pm, Manhattan
'This is Jay.'
'Jay, thank God I got you.' Newell was the member of Will's Columbia set who had taken the least likely career route. He was a fast-tracker at the New York Police Department, leapfrogging over all the old doughnut-munchers on his way to becoming a big city commissioner before he was forty. Jay was as resented by the old guard cops as Will was by the aged newsmen.
'It's Will. Yeah, I'm fine. Well, I'm in a bit of a jam but I can't explain it now. I need you to do me a very large favour.' 'OK.' But the word was drawn out.
'Jay, I need you to check out something. I wrote a piece in the paper this week--'
'About that pimp guy? Saw it. Well done on making the front page, big fella.'
'Yeah, thanks. Look, I never checked autopsy reports or anything. Do you have access to those?'
'It's the weekend, Will. I'm kind of, you know.'
Will looked at his watch. It was late on a Saturday night; Jay was a single guy with a lot of girlfriends. Will guessed he had called at a spectacularly inconvenient moment. 'I know. But I bet you have the authority to see whatever you want,
whenever you want.' The old flattery manoeuvre. Jay would not want to admit that, as it happened, he did not have that kind of access.
'What do you want to know?'
'I want you to see if there were any unusual marks on the
victim's body.'
'I thought the guy was stabbed like a million times.'
'He was, but he was still in one piece. I want you to see
if there was anything like a needle mark on him.'
'Some pimp scumball from Brownsville, you kidding? The
amount of drugs these guys are whacking into their veins,
he probably looked like a pincushion.'
'I don't think so. None of the people I spoke to said anything
about injecting drugs. In fact, no one said he used drugs at
all.'
'OK, my man. Whatever you say. I'll check it out. This the
right cell for you?'
'Yeah. And I need whatever you've got really fast. Thanks,
Jay. I owe you.'
Suddenly he could hear voices, followed by a burst of
laughter. It seemed to be a knot of men, walking in this direction.
And then, louder than the others, the unmistakable
intonation of Townsend McDougal, talking newsroom talk.
'Can we hold it for twenty-four hours? Do we have this
to ourselves?'
Will had no idea why they would be heading towards this
barren part of the third-floor landscape: they had no shortage
of meeting rooms at their end. Oh God. Maybe McDougal was
looking for Will, coming with a posse of senior executives
this time, to begin the inquisition right away.
He could not risk that, not now. At top speed, with too
little time to check what he was doing, Will shoved the essentials
- cell phone, notebooks, pen, BlackBerry - off his desk
and into his bag, wheeled around and headed away from the
McDougal ambush. The only perk of this faraway corner of
the office, Will realized at that very moment, was its proximity
to the back stairway. He had never used it before, but
now was the time.
Once outside, Will gulped in the Saturday night air. He let
his eyes close in relief, leaning backwards against the wall,
the Times clock just above his head.
It was late, and quiet. In normal circumstances, Will liked
this vibe. Working at a time when the rest of the city was
not; leaving a half-empty office and walking into the
Manhattan evening. It was such a contrast with the usual
throng that bustled down this street. No one around, save a
lonely tourist in sleeveless body-warmer and baseball hat
peering into one of the Times display windows, doubtless
looking at an antique printing press or a framed photograph of the late Mr Sulzberger shaking hands with Harry Truman
or something. He must be cold, standing around outside. But
Will was in a hurry to get away. He barely saw him.
CHAPTER THIRTY

Saturday, 11.02pm, Manhattan
TO's room was just how he would have imagined it and, he realized now, he had indeed imagined it. Perhaps a dozen times since his marriage to Beth he had thought about TO not just for a second or two, but in long, extended sessions. Daydreams, really, in which he had brought back to himself her face, her voice, her smell. In these reveries of thought sometimes staring out of an aeroplane window, sometimes
during a night drive while Beth slept in the passenger seat next to him - he had followed TO out of the past they had shared and into the present he could only imagine. He would work hard to conjure her face, four years older. Or to see her at work. Or to picture the man she was with now.
And in these wonderings, he saw the front door of her
apartment opening to afford a view of bookshelves and cream coloured couches and a neglected, small-screen TV. He would have to push himself - though not too hard, lest the effort break the spell - to update TO's taste. It was too easy to put her in a grad student's digs, as if she had stayed frozen in their Columbia winter romance. He wanted to imagine his former girlfriend as she would be now.
He had done a good job. The room was less bohemian than the studio where he had seen TO the previous night. Much of the furniture was vaguely ethnic - dark wood tables that Will guessed were from India or Thailand; a pair of Moroccan window-shutters in distressed blue wood, not attached to a window but hung on the wall, like a painting. Mementos, Will guessed, from some serious travelling: TO had been a fearless explorer, even when he knew her.
Still, there were no incense sticks, no batiks flung over couches. Instead the place was uncluttered, almost minimalist in its preference for clean space. He knew that TO had been reluctant to let him in here, but when Will phoned from outside the Times office, she explained that she had grown tired of cafe-hopping. She needed to shower, to sleep in her own bed - and to hell with the risk. Will, who had earlier fired off a text accusing YY of 'horseshit games,' knew exactly how she felt. He simply asked for her address and said he would come straight over. He reckoned it was easier on both of them if she had no chance to say no.
When he came in, she tried to pretend it was no big deal. There was no ceremonial flinging open of the front door, no tour of the apartment. Instead, she let him find her kneeling on the floor in the main room surrounded by yellow Post-it notes. On each one was written a biblical verse. Will recognized them: Chapter 10 of the Book of Proverbs.
TO was in the middle of them, her sketchbook on her lap, surveying the pattern she had arranged. He crouched down to look at the ink-covered page, and at the Post-its arranged around the hardwood floor, and felt sudden powerful surge
- gratitude for this woman who was offering not only emotional sustenance but a razor-sharp intellect. He felt as if she was saving him.
In a gesture that was almost involuntary, he reached out to touch the back of TO's neck, so that his palm touched her skin and his knuckles brushed against her hair. Her head was down, as if she was a coy schoolgirl receiving a prize but now it came up to meet his gaze. Again without conscious thought, a pulse of energy went through Will's hand, pressing slightly
on TO's neck as if to bring her closer towards him.
She moved and he moved and now their lips were touching
in the lightest of kisses. He could smell her skin, an aroma
that made his muscles weaken and his blood race at the same
time. It was a familiar feeling, one he had known with TO a
thousand times before. His innards seemed to melt, even as
his loins hardened.
She stopped suddenly, gripping his arm with an urgency
he knew was not lust. Her mouth was away from his.
'Shhh. What's that?'
It was a metallic rattle, now repeated. It seemed to be
coming from inside the apartment. They froze, neither risking
movement. Will saw his hand still cupping the back of TO's
head, his fingers in her hair, and caught himself. What the
hell was he doing? Beth was a hostage in some God-forsaken
jail and he was making out with his ex-girlfriend on the floor
of her apartment. The shame seemed to congeal somewhere
in his guts; he sickened himself.
He pulled his hand away and pushed back out of the
embrace. He was exhausted, he told himself, his spirits sunk.
It was a reflex, a cry for help, the act of a desperate man, a
grasping for human comfort; it was gratitude for all TO had
done, it was the familiarity of a former lover, it was a lapse,
a moment of madness, the unhappy by-product of a crisis.
All these explanations coursed through his mind and he
knew they were all true. But they would not convince
anybody, least of all him.
TO tensed again, gripping Will's arm tighter. The buzzing
had returned, a grinding, jangling sound. Was someone inside
this flat, carrying an electric saw, attempting to muffle it
inside a blanket?
Will now leapt to his feet, striding over to the couch by
the front door where he had dumped his coat. He shoved his
hand into the side pocket and held up his phone for TO to
see: set on silent, it had vibrated against his keys.
'Damn, we missed a call.'
Will dialled his voicemail. You have one new message. His
chest began pounding. What if it was some vital clue? What
if it was Beth herself, having wriggled out of her chains and
somehow crawled on hands and knees to a phone, only for
her husband's number to ring out - because he was too busy
necking with his ex-girlfriend? Will appalled himself.
At last the message was playing.
'Hey, big fella.' It was Jay Newell. 'Don't know what this
is all about and my ass would be in the wringer if anyone
knew I had so much as farted in your direction, so this stays
strictly in the vault, OK. Capisce? AH right, here is the news.
Turns out the autopsy report on your friend Howard Macrae
found, cue drum roll, a "puncture on the right thigh, consistent
with" - get this - "a tranquillizer dart".' Newell was
beginning to chuckle. 'Can you believe that? A tranquillizer
dart? Like they use to stun elephants in the zoo. Apparently,
they fire 'em from some big safari gun. Anyway, blood tests
confirm the guy had a shitload of sedative in his system at
ToD as well. Sorry, time of death. I'm going native, Will! I'm
talking like a cop! Help! OK, hope that works for you. Give
me a call, sometime. We should hook up. And send love to
your gorgeous wife from me.'
Will almost fell into the couch, as if knocked off his feet.
He realized now that he had never expected this theory of
his to stack up; a Brownsville hustler and a wing-nut from
Montana were almost mathematical opposites. He had
contacted Newell to confirm that the deaths of Macrae and Baxter could not possibly be linked. With that proved, he
could start looking in more likely directions.
But Yosef Yitzhok had told him to look to his work and so
he had. In the lead up to Beth's abduction, his work had
consisted of two bizarre stories at opposite ends of the continent. And yet now Will had proof that they were connected.
In life these two victims had both performed an unusually
good deed; in death, they had both been anaesthetized before
the act of murder. The method of sedation was radically
different, just as the killings had been. But it was too much
of a coincidence.
Will began to feel elated. At last he had made progress; a
hunch had been vindicated. Somewhere in the events of the
last week lay the key to Beth's kidnapping and, therefore,
her freedom. He had come this far, all he had to do was work
out the rest. He was closing in.
Will jumped to his feet, about to stride over to TO and
trumpet his breakthrough. Instead he halted after two paces.
First, he was hit anew by the memory of a few minutes ago.
Now, to add to the shame and self-disgust at his betrayal of
Beth, was embarrassment. He had made a pass at TO and
both of them would have to act as if it had never happened.
Then another thought struck him. It surely meant something
that Baxter and Macrae had been killed in a similar
fashion, but what exactly? Just because these two deaths
were apparently related, what did that have to do with Beth's
kidnap? Baxter and Macrae might have lived thousands of
miles from each other, but they both lived in different worlds
from Beth - and from the Hassidim for that matter. So YY had
told him to look to his work, but what possible connection
between these three events could there be?
As he began to pace around the room he wondered: could
his stories have served as a trigger for the Hassidim to take
Beth? She had gone missing on Friday morning, just as his
Baxter story had appeared in print. Could something in that
story have set off the plot to kidnap his wife? Was there something
in the combination of the two, Baxter and Macrae, that
spurred the Hassidim to abduct Beth?
Will spooled back to last night in Crown Heights. His story
on Baxter had been marked and laid out in the room where
he had been interrogated. The Hassidim had been discussing
it. It was not the by-line that interested them: they already
knew he was a reporter for the Times. They had emailed him
at the Times address. No, it was the story itself. Or, thought
Will for the first time, the stories.
He reached for his cell phone, finding the inbox of messages
and scrolling through the batch from YY. He counted ten,
making sure he got past the latest riddles. There it was.
Decoded, it read : 2 down: More's to cone.
At the time, both he and TO thought it was a mere confirmation
message. Like one of those computer games: Well done, you have reached level 2, the Castle of Doom. Next, prepare to enter
the Sanctum of Fire . . .
Now Will saw it differently. '2 down' referred to Macrae
and Baxter. But who were the rest?
CHAPTER THIRTY-ONE

Saturday, 7.05pm, Cape Town, South Africa
He used to come here when it was all-white. This beach, with its gentle curve of fair sand, was one of his favourite spots. When he was a student, he would come to ogle the girls and drink beers by the crateload. Back in those days, outsiders thought his country was in flames, consumed by a race war. But it did not feel like that; at least not to him. He was white and well-off and having the time of his life. He knew a couple of guys who had signed a petition, but otherwise politics did not intrude. Besides, as an Afrikaaner who had grown up in the rural heartland of the Transvaal, he was raised to believe the separation of the races, apartheid, was not offensive but natural. On the farm, rabbits and cows had their own places and did not mix, so why should blacks and whites be any different?
Now the beach looked as beautiful as ever, the water glittering in the moonlight. As he faced the Atlantic Ocean, he could hear the buzz of the bars behind him: a more mixed crowd now, black, white and what he had grown up calling coloured. He tried to tune out the noise; he wanted to listen to his own thoughts.
Was he elated by what he had just done? He was not sure. Relieved, certainly. He had been planning this moment for months. Each day, taking a different document home - sometimes
a diagram, sometimes a string of algebraic numbers until
he had built up the full set.
He breathed out heavily. He remembered those years at
university, followed by more years in graduate school, most
of them spent in a lab. He had become a research pharmacologist
by the time he was twenty-seven and had spent the
next fifteen years working on a single project, codenamed
Operation Help. It was his boss's little joke, playing on 'help'
as a synonym. For Andre van Zyl belonged to a team searching
for a cure for AIDS.
They were just a part of it, of course. The headquarters of
the research effort was in New York, with satellite teams in
Paris and Geneva. The South Africa field office was smaller
still, chosen for what the corporate literature called its 'clinical
resonance'. Translation: South Africa had a handy supply
of AIDS sufferers.
They had been testing out new remedies on groups for
years now. Andre had been at some of the trials, clinics out in the sticks taking one hundred sick men and women,
marking fifty of them as a control group and handing new
tablets to the rest. Andre had been at his computer when the
results came through. Time after time his reports had had the same conclusion: no impact; statistically negligible results; needs
further work.
But nine months ago, a set of data had come back that
could not be ignored. The sample group had shown an
improvement unlike any seen before. The symptoms were
not just held at bay; they were becoming non-existent. The
medication seemed not only to pacify the virus, but to chase
it out of the system altogether.
Within a week, scientists from the Geneva team had flown
in to see the patients for themselves. A few days later the
head of the entire project arrived from New York. He ordered
the control group be put onto the new drugs immediately, on 'humanitarian grounds'.
Andre had to laugh at that. For he knew what would
happen next. The head honcho from America would publish a paper in Nature, hailing his breakthrough and bidding for the Nobel prize that was surely his, while the US Food and Drug Administration would start testing the new tablet. Once they had given the seal of approval, it would go on sale and make the company they all worked for one of the richest in the world. They had found the holy grail of twenty-first century medicine: they had found a cure for AIDS.
The only trouble were people like Grace, the woman Andre had met on one of the earliest trials. Too poor to get the antiretroviral medicine she needed, AIDS was a death sentence
for her - not a condition that could be lived with, as it was in Europe or the US. This cure would be no cure for her or for the millions of women, men and children like her, all over the world. The new drug would never reach them
because it would be too expensive. The company had a patent on the new medicine that would last twenty years: until then, they had a monopoly and could charge what they liked. So he had gone to the FedEx office earlier that day with a large box addressed to a man he had never met in Mumbai, India. Revered and reviled as the king of the copycats, this man had made a fortune making bootleg copies of the latest western drugs and selling them to the third world for a tenth of the price. He had done it with some of the early AIDS medicines. Now, in the next day or two, he would receive a full blueprint for the cure. Andre's note issued a clear demand: 'Make this drug and distribute it to the world. Now.'
The sun was beginning to set; he could hear the waves
more easily than he could see them. He would go to a bar and chug back a beer. Who knew when he would get another chance. Tomorrow the company might discover his theft, his treachery, and have him arrested on a dozen counts. With this much money at stake, they would have to make an example of him: he could be in jail for years.
So he decided to savour this night. He drank, he flirted.
And when one beautiful girl, with long bronzed legs and a
skirt that barely stretched over her bottom, came on to him,
he rose to the occasion. She laughed at his jokes; he rested
his hand on her smooth, naked thigh.
The ride in her open-topped car was punctuated by long,
open-mouthed kisses at each traffic light. They fell into her
apartment, her clothes falling willingly to the floor. And when
she went to fix him a drink, he gulped it down gratefully,
not even noticing the powdery residue still undissolved at
the bottom of the glass.
He coughed a little; he grew dizzy and resolved to drink
less next time. As he lost consciousness and fell towards
death, he could hear the girl's voice, gently reciting what
sounded like a poem. Or perhaps a prayer.
CHAPTER THIRTY-TWO

Saturday, 11.27pm, Manhattan
If it had not been for lust and guilt, Will might never have seen him. He had not yet had a chance to tell TO of his breakthrough, the phone call from Jay Newell, when she stood on
tiptoes to reach for a book from one of her highest bookshelves. As she stretched, her thin shirt pulled away from her
jeans, revealing the taut, unmarked skin of her lower back. For all the feelings of shame, he was at it again, noticing the shape and curve of TO's body. He turned away.
To dispel any impression that he was ogling, he made a
point of looking elsewhere, starting with a glance down
at her desk. It was piled high with papers, cuttings from magazines, fine art journals mostly, but with the odd piece from the New Yorker and the Atlantic Monthly too. There were flyers promoting film seasons at art house cinemas, a couple of catalogues from clothes stores, two thick
editions of Vogue and what he could see was a handwritten letter.
At a job interview he would have called his next impulse professional curiosity, but the simpler truth was that he was nosy. He tugged at the paper, sandwiched between an edition of The New York Times Sunday magazine and a seasonal guide to the Lincoln Center, until he could glimpse the top half of the first sheet. Will jumped. The letter was written in a series of symbols
that looked like gibberish. Yet it was definitely a letter, on
personal notepaper, with a date at the top right in conventional
numbers. He frowned. Surely he would have remembered if TO was fluent in another language. Indeed, he distinctly recalled
that one of her few areas of academic deficiency was linguistic.
She always said she regretted that she had never learned French
or Spanish; despite her supercharged education, she had never
found the time.
Movement outside caught his eye. A couple were getting
out of a just-parked Volvo: perhaps they had been at the
movies or at a dinner party with friends. They might have
been himself and Beth, enjoying a normal life. The very idea
struck a sharp pain into his heart. For the hundredth time
since the phone call a couple of hours earlier, he heard her voice. Will? Will, it's Beth. He dragged his gaze away. Further up the street there was
a pair of teenage boys in oversized jeans and a middle-aged
woman carrying a single flower. Instantly Will could see and
hear Beth at the Carnegie Deli, telling him the story of Child
X and the flower he had handed Marie, the grieving receptionist.
Beth had been so touched by that action, an act of
humanity which, Will felt sure, his wife had somehow drawn
out of this wild, damaged young boy.
Directly below, on the opposite sidewalk, was the man in
the baseball cap.
Will did not recognize him straight away. Even when he
saw the blue body-warmer, he did not make an immediate
connection. But something in the man's stance, a certain
relaxation of posture that suggested he was not on his way
somewhere else, but needed to be right here, sparked a
memory.
Will instantly snapped back the curtain and took a step
away from the window. He had seen that man this very
evening; he had thought him a lonely tourist, admiring the headquarters of The New York Times, peering into the window as if he had nothing better to do. Now this same man was padng around outside TO's building. It was too much of a
coincidence.
TO, how many exits are there out of here?'
She looked up from the King James bible she had just
taken off the shelf. 'What? What are you talking about?'
'I think we've been followed and I think we're going to
have to leave right now. Except we can't walk out the front
entrance. Any ideas?'
'You're kidding. How would any--'
'TO, we don't have time for a discussion.'
'There's a fire escape at the back; it comes out onto the
alleyway, I think.'
'Too risky. There could be someone at the back as well.
Does this building have a caretaker?'
'A what?'
'You know, a super?'
'Oh, yes. Sweet guy. Lives down in the basement.'

'Do you know him? Please tell me he has a soft spot for you.'
'Kind of. Why? What are you thinking?'

'You'll see. Pack up everything you might need.'
'Might need for what?'
'For a night away from here. I don't think we can risk coming back.'
Planning their exit, Will made one hurried call, then rounded up TO's scattered Post-it notes, his mobile and BlackBerry and shoved them all into the voluminous pockets of his coat. He could hear TO rifling through drawers. At the open front door they surveyed the apartment one last time. Out of habit TO reached for the light switch; Will gripped her forearm just in time.
'We don't want to advertise our departure do we?'
That gave him an idea. Like plenty of security-conscious New Yorkers, TO had several time-switch gadgets attached to her light fittings. Most people used them when they were away, timing them to act as phantom occupants, turning on lights in the evening and off in the morning. Now, without asking, Will found the one in the living room and set it to go off at midnight. No, too neat. Ten to midnight. Next, he went into TO's bedroom - taking care not to look around too closely - and set the light to go on in there five minutes earlier and then to go off again twenty minutes later. With any luck, the peeping tom outside would conclude that Will and his female friend had turned in for the night.
With that done, they headed for the basement. Overheated and marked by a series of handleless doors, it seemed an inhuman place to live. But this was home to Mr Pugachov, the Russian super. TO knocked lightly on the door, from behind which, Will was delighted to note, floated the sounds of late-night TV. Finally the door creaked open.
To Will's surprise, the super was not some crabby old man in a holed cardigan and worn-out slippers like the school caretakers of Will's youth. Instead Mr Pugachov was a handsome man in his thirties bearing an uncanny resemblance to the onetime chess champion Garry Kasparov. And given the migration patterns from the former Soviet Union, it would be no great shock if this man, whose job was to sign for daytime deliveries of mail and fix busted water pipes, turned out to be a grandmaster.
'Miss TOI' Though Pugachov's expression flicked from pleasure to disappointment the moment he caught sight of Will. 'Hello Mr P.'
Flirtatious, thought Will. Good.
'What can I doing for you?'
'Well, it's a funny situation, Mr P. My friend and I have been planning a lovely surprise for his wife's birthday.' Nice touch, establishing that I'm not the boyfriend.
'Which is due to begin,' TO made a show of looking at her watch, 'any minute now, in fact. At midnight!' She was sounding breathless, too eager.
'So the thing is,' Will said, taking over. 'We need to leave here without her seeing us. We left her outside the building
you see. Now, I know this is going to sound crazy but I
wondered if there might be a way for you to somehow hide
us in, oh I don't know, some kind of wagon or trolley and
take us out the back way.'
Will could see that the chess champion was stumped. He
was staring, baffled, at both of them. TO was laying on a smile
you could have seen from space, but it was no good. The
super was utterly confused. Will decided to speak the international
language.
'Here's fifty dollars. Take us out of here in one of those
trash cans.' He pointed at a row of oversized plastic bins on
wheels lined up just outside the back door.
'You want me to put Miss TO in dumpster?'
'No, Mr P. I want you to put both of us in there and just
wheel us down the street. One hundred dollars. OK?'
Will decided the negotiation was over. He stuffed the money
in the super's hand and headed over to the back door. Still
shaking his head, Mr P opened up. Will pointed at the blue
bin marked 'Newspapers', gesturing for the janitor to wheel
that as close to the door as he could. It was too risky to step
outside: he might be seen. Next, Will reached out, grabbed
the handle and tilted the bin, flipping open its lid and emptying
its contents onto the floor. Magazines, listings guides and free
inserts selling home computers came tumbling out, spreading
themselves on the ground. When he saw the janitor's face
fold into a grimace, Will dug into his pocket and took out
another twenty.
Once he had got the bin almost horizontal, its top resting
on the stoop, it was not too hard to crawl in. Will did it in
a crouch, as if entering a tunnel. Then he curled himself up, lay on his side and gestured for TO to follow until the pair of them sat like two halves of a walnut, in a blue plastic shell. Will gave the nod and Garry Kasparov closed the lid. Then, with a mighty effort and a deep, low grunt, he lifted the bin so that it was vertical, tilted it and began to push. With panic, Will realized they had never discussed either a route or a destination.
Inside, TO and Will rattled and bounced, but knew better than to let out even a squeal. Their knees were touching and their faces were just an inch apart and, as they tossed upwards when Mr P hit a rut in the alleyway, the urge to giggle was strong. Their situation was so ridiculous. But the smile only had to form in Will's mind for his plight to come pressing back in. Beth.
They could feel themselves slowing down; Mr P was obviously tiring. Will lightly tapped on the side. The bin tilted back down, allowing them to creep out. The janitor had done a good job: he had covered nearly three blocks, staying with the narrow alleyway behind the apartment buildings. They were surely unseen.
They said goodbye, TO giving Mr P a brief hug which, Will suspected, was more valuable than twice his cash fee. They watched him lope back, a Russian emigre pushing an empty wheelie bin through the streets of New York at midnight. That was the beauty of a big city: nothing was ever out of the ordinary so nobody paid attention.
'OK,' Will said, looking around and getting his bearings. 'Now all we need to do is head north about six blocks. We should jog.' And off he went.
Finally TO had a chance to speak. 'What the hell is going on here, Will? You see a guy in a baseball cap and suddenly we're shoving ourselves in a trash can? And now we're running? What is this?'
'I've seen that guy before. Outside the Times building.' 'You're sure? How could you tell from six flights up? You only saw him for a second.' 'TO, believe me. It was the same man.' He was about to
explain his posture theory, but realized it would sound
unhinged. And take up too much oxygen. 'His clothes were
the same. He was there to watch me. Or us.'
'You reckon the Hassidim sent him?'
'Sure. He might even be one of them. All he'd have to do
is change clothes, then he could pass for normal.'

TO shot him a look.
'You know what I mean. He could disappear into the
crowd. What I saw at Crown Heights last week - Christ, it
was only yesterday. What I saw yesterday is that plenty of
these blokes were born into ordinary American backgrounds.'
He was beginning to pant. 'It wouldn't be hard for them to
shed all the garb and go right back into it, if that's what the
mission required.'
They had arrived at their destination: Penn Station, and
had only five minutes to wait for what Will called the 'milk
train', a Britishism referring to the sleepy services that ran
after midnight. They had the carriage all to themselves, but
for an unshaven man apparently snoozing into his neck,
obliviously drunk.
'This is the train I used to catch visiting my Dad's place,
before we got the car.' He regretted that 'we': it felt somehow
unkind to rub his married coupleness into TO's still-single
face. And that regret instantly reminded him that he and TO
had never once spent a weekend at Sag Harbor. He had taken
his cue from her, keeping their relationship a virtual secret. TO had met Will's father just once and they had never spent
any proper time together. Beth, on the other hand, had fitted
in straight away; it was one of the things that made it feel
so right.
A silence fell. It was TO who broke it, digging into her bag
to produce the item she had been holding before they left
her apartment. The Holy Bible. 'Christ, I nearly forgot.' She thumbed through the pages at top speed. 'There. The Book
of Proverbs, Chapter 10.'
'Haven't we been through this already? We found what
he wanted us to see: righteous, righteous, righteous.'
'I know, but I'm a nerd. I want to study it some more.'
'What are you looking for?'
'I don't know. But something tells me I'll know it when I
see it.'
CHAPTER THIRTY-THREE

Sunday, 3.08am, Sag Harbor, New York
The house in Sag Harbor, at least, sprung no surprises. The key was under the flower pot, as always; the place was even quite warm, testament to the efficiency of the local couple Will's father hired to keep things ticking over out of season.
He moved around rapidly, turning on lights, putting hot water on the stove, making tea. Clutching a packet of Oreos, he finally sat himself opposite TO, facing her across the vast, aged oak table that dominated Monroe Sr's stylishly rustic kitchen.
Instantly, the memories flooded back. The long winters at school, when Will could feel every one of those three thousand miles that separated him from his father. The joy when a parcel arrived in the post, often containing a delicious slice of exotic Americana - perhaps a packet of bubblegum or, never forgotten, a leather baseball. And then the thrill as he was put on a plane during the summer vacation, 'an unaccompanied minor' on his way to see his Dad. Those August
weeks in Sag Harbor, spent crabbing on the beach or eating clams on the deck, were the highlight of Will's year. He could still feel, even now, twenty years later, the pit in his stomach when September loomed and he would be taken back to the
airport - and away from his father for another year.
Will forced himself back into the moment. He had begun
on the train, but now he explained in full what he had been
bursting to tell TO since the moment he had taken the call.
It was the first TO had heard either of Jay Newell or of Will's
conversation with him earlier that evening. But she was a
quick study; once Will had told her about Jay's phone message,
she did not need him to join the dots.
'So Baxter and Macrae were both drugged before they
were killed; they were both deemed righteous by people who
knew them; and, according to YY and Proverbs 10, if your
reading of it is right, it's this righteous thing which is significant.
Which somehow explains the wider Hassidic plot. Why
they've taken Beth, why they killed the guy in Bangkok, why
they had someone follow you, or us, tonight. That's essentially
the theory here, isn't it?'
'It's a bit more than a theory now, TO. "2 down: More's
to come." "Yet more deaths soon." That's what he said. He
was addressing me directly! He's read the stories in the Times and he's telling me, "OK, you've cracked two of them, but
there are going to be more." Meaning we have to link this
with everything else that's going on! Don't you see?'
'No, no, I do see.' She chose her words carefully. 'I do see
that this must all be linked. The trouble is ... Rather, my
problem is, I personally cannot quite see how we get from
the Macrae/Baxter/righteous thing - which I admit is fascinating
and incredible - to the "more" that are supposed to be
coming.'
Will slumped in his chair.
'No, Will. Don't be like that. This is great progress. We're
nearly there, I'm sure of it. Look, let's get some sleep and
then we'll think this last bit through,' she said, placing her
hand on his shoulder, sending a pulse of memory through
them both. 'Come on, we can do this.'
Suddenly Will leapt up, walking out of the kitchen. TO chased after him. 'Will! Will! Come on, don't do this.'
She found him standing in his father's study, a room filled
from floor to ceiling with books. Row after row of leather
bound legal texts, collected case reports, volumes of Supreme
Court judgments going back to the nineteenth century. On
another wall, there were more contemporary works, lines of
hardback texts on politics, the constitution and of course, the
law. They seemed to be arranged with a librarian's zeal for
order: grouped by theme and then, within each category,
rigorously alphabetized. TO's eye landed on the Christianity
section: Documents of the Christian Church by Henry Bettenson, The Early Church by Henry Chadwick, From Christ to Constantine by Eusebius, Early Christian Doctrines by JND Kelly, all lined
up in perfect order.
But Will was ignoring the books, instead powering up the
computer on his father's desk. He scrolled down an Associated
Press story, barely reading the words, looking for something.
He moved his cursor over the text to define two words:
the name of the Hassidim's kidnap victim in Bangkok: Samak
Sangsuk. He moved up to the Google window at the top right
of the screen, pasted in the name and hit return.
Your search - samak sangsuk - did not match any documents
He was about to curse but he was silenced. Not by TO, but
by the distinct sound of a creak in the hallway. Not just one,
but several in quick succession. There was no doubt about it.
Someone else was in the house.
CHAPTER THIRTY-FOUR

Sunday, 12.12am, Manhattan
He had waited long enough. It was the lights going out that had made him suspicious. He was told this man was desperately searching for his wife: it did not make sense that he would happily go to sleep at midnight.
Besides, he feared he was arousing suspicion, pacing around outside an apartment building for hours on end. This might be Manhattan, where no one seemed to notice anything, but it was a risk.
He telephoned his superiors, asking for permission to make his move.
'All right. But keep it clean. Do you understand?'
'I understand.'
'And may the Lord be with you.'
He waited for the next new arrival at the building, a woman apparently returning from a late-night convenience store with a bag full of groceries. It took him a second to jog the few yards to the entrance, as if catching up with her. 'Oh, let me get that,' he said, holding the door once she had opened it. He followed her in.
While she checked her mailbox, he headed downstairs for the basement - pausing only to cover his face with a ski-mask. He could hear the sound of a television, seeping out from
under the door. He knocked and waited, checking once again
the cold steel of the revolver he would reveal the instant the
door opened. This would not take long.
Mr Pugachov jumped back in fright, raising his arms in an
instant surrender.
'Good. Now, y'all need to stay nice and calm. We need to
do this nice and easy. All you gotta do is take me to the apartment
on the sixth floor. The one that looks out onto the
street. The one where the pretty girl lives. You know the one
I mean. Mighty pretty girl.'
Pugachov had never heard such an accent before; this man
did not sound like the New Yorkers he knew. It took him a
while to work out what he was saying. Guessing, he reached
with his right hand behind the door.
'Hey! Hands in the air! What did I say just now, mister?'
'Excuse, excuse,' Pugachov sputtered. 'I was getting key.
Key!' He gestured behind the door, where the man in the
ski-mask could see a series of numbered hooks: spare keys
for every apartment in the building.
He shoved Pugachov out of the door and towards the back
stairway. It was late; no one was around. But it was still too
risky to take the elevator. Those were his orders: he must not
be seen.
The super opened TO's door tentatively, calling out a meek
hello. He felt the gun in his back.
The man in the ski-mask flashed on a torch, searching out the bedroom door. He pushed his hostage towards it.
'Open it.'
Pugachov turned the handle slowly but the gunman
reached over him and pushed the door hard.
'Freeze!' he shouted, shining a torch onto the bed. Seeing
nothing, he wheeled around, anticipating an ambush from
behind. Nothing. Now grabbing Pugachov by the collar, he
started flinging open cupboard doors, training his revolver
onto each new opening of dark space. When he came to the bathroom door he gave it a firm kick and jumped in, before turning around to ensure no one could pounce.
He searched the rest of the apartment, beaming the torchlight into every corner.
'Well, there's a moral to this story. Trust your hunches. I thought they'd gone and they have.'
He put on the lights and started looking around more closely, never letting Pugachov out of his sight - or out of range. He flipped open TO's computer, instantly opening up her internet browser. He asked for a 'history', generating a long list of the sites she had looked at most recently. He took out a silver pen and a black notebook and began writing down what he saw. Pugachov noticed for the first time that he was wearing tight black leather gloves.
Next he saw a half-finished pad of Post-it notes. The top sheet was blank, but he held it up to the light all the same. Sure enough, as so often, he could see the trace of words, and numbers, indented from the page above. It amazed him that people still made this elementary mistake: he would have thought Will Monroe would know better.
Next he picked up the phone, pressing the 'last number' button: 1-718-217-54771173667274341. So many digits could only mean one thing: Monroe had dialled some kind of automated service, offering a series of numerical options, rather than a personal number. The gunman wrote down the full string of numbers and hit redial.
Thank you for calling the Long Island Railroad . . .
After that it was simple: he only had to punch in the
sequence of numbers he had written down. ' 1' to use touchtone, ' 1' for schedule information, then, when asked to enter the first five letters of his starting station, 73667, and so on. It was easy. Obligingly, the automated female voice told him the times for the next three trains from Penn Station to Bridgehampton, the nearest station for Sag Harbor.
He ran his torch over the floor one more time, noticing a
yellow piece of paper that he had missed. It read: Verse 11. The mouth of a righteous man is a well of life: but violence covereth
the mouth of the wicked.
He tucked that into his pocket and turned once again to
face Pugachov.
'OK, son. It's time to shape up and ship out.' He used his
revolver to gesture towards the front door.
As Pugachov made for the handle he turned his back
slightly, so that he was sideways on to the gunman. Now he
decided, remembering the training he had received as a long
ago conscript in the Red Army, was the moment. In an
instant, he grabbed the masked man by the wrist and looped
his own arm under his shoulder, bringing him quickly to the
ground.
The gun had fallen and Pugachov reached for it, only to
be kicked, hard, in the balls. He doubled over and felt an arm
around his neck. He tried to jab back with his elbows, but
there was no movement. He was in a headlock and the man
holding him seemed to have superhuman strength. He could
feel his breath around his ear.
Somehow, and only with supreme effort, Pugachov
managed to wriggle his right arm free and aim it at the man's
head. But it did not connect. His fingers were flailing until
they finally grabbed something. It took him a second to realize
it was not hair. Out of the corner of his eye he could see
what he was holding: he had removed the gunman's mask.

Suddenly the grip was loosened. Pugachov slumped, panting heavily. He was no longer the fit, fighting machine of his youth; that stint of military duty in Afghanistan was in the faraway past. Perhaps the masked man had realized that; maybe he understood that Pugachov could inflict no serious damage and was about to let him go.
'I'm afraid you've just made a big mistake, my friend.' Pugachov looked up to see a much younger man than he was expecting. Now that the mask was off, he could see that his eyes were of the most exceptional blue, almost feminine in their beauty. They seemed to cast beams of sharp, bright light.
He did not have long to stare into them because his view was soon obscured - by the mouth of what he recognized to be a silencer, aimed right between his eyes.
CHAPTER THIRTY-FIVE

Sunday, 4.14am, Sag Harbor, New York
TO was staring at Will, stock still. The sound was too regular to be the music of an old house, the creaking of aged timber. There was no doubt about it: these were footsteps. Will grabbed the heaviest poker he could find from the fireplace, placed his finger over his lips to hush TO and edged out of the study.
He crept down the corridor, towards the kitchen. The sound seemed to have moved there. As he got closer, he could hear a rustling, as if the intruder was rifling through papers. He inched closer, until he could see the shadow of a tall man. His heart was pounding; his throat was parched.
In a single movement, Will swung around the corner, lifted the poker above his head-
'Christ, Will! What the hell are you doing?'
'Dad!'
'Will, you scared me out of my wits. I thought someone had broken in. Jesus.' Monroe Sr, clad in striped pyjamas, collapsed into a chair, clutching at his chest.
'But Dad, I didn't--'
'Hold on, Will. Give me a second to catch my breath here.
Hold on.'
When Will called out to TO, his father's bewilderment was complete. 'What on earth is going on here?'
Will did the best he could, talking his father through the events of the last few hours: the text messages, Proverbs 10, the visit to the office, the stalker, the dash for Penn Station. He listened patiently, nursing the hot tea TO had made for him, the great judge now a Dad.
'I should have told you I was here. I came yesterday evening. I hadn't heard from you and I was climbing the walls with worry. I thought it might help to hear the ocean, breathe in the sea air. Beth is your wife, Will, but she's also my daughter-in-law. She's family.' He glanced towards TO, whose face turned hot.
'I'm sorry we woke you,' she said, as if trying to change the subject. Then, yawning, 'I could really use some sleep.' 'Motion granted. Will, the garden room is made up.' That peeved Will. Was his father giving his son an order, instructing him that he must sleep separately from TO - as if suspecting that, left to their own devices, they would share a bed? Did his father really believe that Will was cheating on the daughter-in-law he loved so dearly?
Perhaps his father suspected something much darker. Was it even possible? Could he imagine his son had somehow engineered this whole episode as a way to get back with his ex? Will realized how economical with information he had been, barely letting his father in on the quest for Beth. How insistent he had been that the police remain uninvolved. It had been nearly thirty years since Will Monroe Sr had practised criminal law - but he would have forgotten none of it. What was worse, Will knew he could feel no righteous indignation: After all, a matter of hours earlier he had pressed his lips to TO's, their eyes closed, in a kiss. And not a fleeting brush either; it had been a real kiss.
He was too exhausted to say any more. He surrendered mutely to his father and headed upstairs, joining TO who was waiting for him on the landing. The way she stood, as if she were hiding herself, suggested she felt it, too: the suspicion radiating from his father and the guilty admission that it was not entirely groundless.

Sunday, 12.33am, Manhattan
'Good work, young man. And your enthusiasm is a joy to me, it really is.' The voice was clear and distinct, even on the telephone. 'No, your best move now is to hang back. I'm not worried about Sag Harbor. That's not going to be a problem. We need you there, in the city.'
'So where do you want me to post myself, sir?'
'Well. They're not going to stay in Long Island long, are they? He's going to have to come back. And that means Penn Station. Why don't we make sure you're there to greet him?' CHAPTER THIRTY-SIX

Sunday, 9.13am, Sag Harbor, New York
He had left his phone on and placed it right by his ear. But
his exhaustion was so deep, the short trill of a newly arrived
message barely woke him. Instead, it insinuated itself into his
dream. He was putting the key in the lock of his front door;
he walked in to find Beth standing in the kitchen, clasping
a child to her waist. She seemed fierce, as if she was protecting
this little boy - or girl, Will could not tell - from an intruder
about to do terrible harm. Get back, her eyes seemed to say.
She looked wild; feral. Oh I see, thought the Will of the dream. That's Child X. And, right on cue, as if heralding this realization,
a bell started to toll . . .
Like a winch pulling a diver up to the surface, his conscious
brain dredged him up and out of sleep. Reflexively, he grabbed
the phone and brought it to his face.
I new message
fOrtV
He leapt out of bed and marched down the corridor to TO's room, one of the few denied a view of the ocean, backing onto a large, English-style garden instead. The sun was streaming into the hallway, accompanied by the sound of the
waves. There was no getting away from it: his father had
chosen a gorgeous spot.
His father. Only now did Will remember their night-time
encounter. He had very nearly bludgeoned his dad. He might
have killed him. But there was no time to dwell on that.
'OK,' he said, once he had shaken TO awake and she was
propped up on one of the dozen or so pillows his father's
housekeeper routinely provided for each bed. 'There's another
one. Forty.' He was holding up the phone.
'Forty messages?' she croaked, eking the sleep out of one
eye.
'No. That's the message. Look.'
'Why's he written it so weirdly?'
'I don't know. Get cracking on that, can you? I have a
phone call to make.'
He looked at his watch. 9.30am. He checked the
BlackBerry: nothing new from Crown Heights. They surely
did not believe he had acceded to the rabbi's demand in
yesterday's phone call - that he back off and sit tight. It
was obvious they believed no such thing: after all, they had
sent a man to follow him precisely because they knew he
would keep probing.
Nine thirty. Someone from the foreign desk would be in
by now. Besides, he could not afford to leave it much later.
As he dialled the number, he scrunched his face up in virtual prayer. Please let it be Andy.
There were at least four assistants who worked on The New
York Times foreign desk; Will would struggle to name three
of them. But one he had got to know. Andy was probably
four years younger than Will and, ever since they had chatted
in the line for the canteen one lunchtime, he had latched on
to him as a kind of mentor. He was from Iowa and had a
dry, unsmiling humour that Will liked instantly; a surrogate for the sensibility he missed from home.
'Foreign.'
'Andy?'
'No less.'
'Thank God.'
'Will, is that you?'
'Yeah. Why?'
'No, nothing. Just--'
'What?'
'Dude, if I believed every evil rumour that I heard.' 'What evil rumour?'
'Word is, you got pounded by the big guy yesterday. That he found you rifling through someone else's desk? I told people, "Hey, investigative journalism's a tough business".' 'Thanks, Andy.'
'Is it true?'
'Put it this way, it's not entirely untrue.'
'Hmm. Well, it's a novel approach to career development, I'll say that for ya.'
'Look, Andy. I need a favour. I need you to give me the number for the Times correspondent in Bangkok.' 'John Bishop? Everyone's on his case today, man. He's run ragged.'
'How come?'
'Don't you watch the news? The police are all over Brooklyn. Apparently the black hats tried to kill some guy in Thailand. It's a Metro story: Walton's on it.'

'Walton?' That was all Will needed: more needling from
the notebook-thief. He would have to speak to Bishop behind
his back.
'Yeah. I hear Walton tried to wriggle out of it, being the
weekend and all. Apparently he nominated you for the story: until the desk told him you were, you know--'
'I was what?'
'You know, not available for work just now.'
'Is that how they're putting it?'
'Something like that. Listen, Will, what's the deal? Are you
sick or something? You smoke some bad weed?'
He knew Andy was trying to mock the heaviness of it all,
sending up, in particular, the absurdity of the hard-working,
married Will Monroe under suspicion as some Freak Brothers drug fiend. But it did not make Will laugh. Instead his friend's banter merely confirmed his worst anxieties: that he was
indeed effectively suspended from The New York Times and that he had become precisely the office talking point, the
topic of water-cooler conversation, he had dreaded. The fact that this was a trivial matter, barely worthy of consideration
alongside his other worries, only emphasized the desperation of his situation.
'No, Andy. No bad weed, no weed at all as it happens. But
I can see how it must look. Excellent. Tip top. Bloody marvellous.' 'I'm
sorry, dude. Is there anything I can do?'
'Yeah, that number will be a huge help. Cell phone if you
have one.'
'Sure. And remember, they're twelve hours ahead there.
It's like nearly ten at night now.'
Will did not allow himself a moment to digest the call with
Andy. As he dialled the multiple digits to reach Bangkok, he imagined how the Times's interns and young reporters would be burning up New York's cellular system, updating each other on the rise and dramatic fall of Will Monroe at this very
moment, but that was all. He tried to put it out of his mind
- and focus on the sound of a telephone ring that was now
in his ear.
'Hello.'
'Hello, John? This is Will Monroe from the Metro desk. Is this a bad time?' 'I've just been up for about thirty-six hours and I'm
about to file a story, Why would it be a bad time? How can
I help?'
'Sorry, I'll try to keep it really brief. I know you're liaising with Terry Walton, so I don't want to cut across anything he's doing--'
'Uh-uh.'
'But I'm working on a piece at this end--' Terrible lie, and one that Bishop could so easily expose, but Will figured he was up to his neck already, a few more inches would not make much difference. 'I'm trying to get more of a handle on the victim. Mr Sangsuk.'
'Mr Samak. His name was Samak Sangsuk. In Thailand, the family name comes first; you know, like Mao Tse-Tung. Anyway, I filed all that already. Foreign will have it.' Shit. Should have asked Andy to send everything over first. 'I know and that's all great. It's just a bit of a steer I've been getting from some of the Hassidim here.'
'Oh, yes? That's great, Will. What's the steer?' The tone had changed. The prospect of useful information always improved journalists' manners.
'I know this sounds odd, but I've been told to look closely at the victim's biography.'
'Just some rich guy. In business.'
'Well, I know. But my informer--' a notch above "source" and therefore much more tantalizing '--suggests if we dig a bit deeper, we might find something useful. And relevant.' 'What, was he a crook? There's a ton of corruption in this town. That wouldn't be news.'
Now Will would have to take his chance. 'No, what I hear is the opposite. I'm told that if we look hard enough, we'll find something very unusual about this man - and I don't mean unusually corrupt.'
'Well, what do you mean? What "very unusual" thing will we find?'
'I don't know, John. I'm just telling you what the Hassidim told me. Look for it, and it will explain everything. That's what my guy said. Just wanted to pass the tip on.' 'It's ten o'clock.'
'I know. But maybe some relatives of the victim, of Mr Samak, are still awake? Perhaps his friends?'
'I've got a couple of numbers I can call. I'll file whatever I get to foreign.'
They said goodbye and Will let out a lungful of air in relief. Now he was wasting senior foreign correspondents' time. He would be back at the Bergen Record within a week. If they would have him . . .
He phoned Andy, instructing him to email any new files from Bishop the second they came in. He had no idea what the Times's man in Bangkok would find out.
'Well, thanks for breakfast.'
'Shit, sorry. I've been on the phone.' TO was holding a piece of paper. 'Have you done it?'
She showed him. It just said fOrtV.
'Yeah?'
'At first I thought it was just a typing error. But this guy is very neat and precise. Everything is deliberate.' 'And?'
'And he's emphasized two letters: the second and the fifth. I started trying to say it out loud. I thought maybe it was "forty O-Y" but that makes no sense.'
'TC--'
'Anyway, it's even simpler. It's forty, second and fifth. Or, put another way, 42nd and 5th.'
'That's the public library.'
'Exactly, which means--'
Suddenly TO tensed up. Will looked round. His father had come in, wearing Sunday morning chinos.
'Is there some news?'
'Yeah, we just got another text message. Sending us to the public library.'
'Is this man suggesting he meet you there? Be careful, William, please.'
'No, he hasn't said anything yet. Just the address. Forty second and fifth. That's all we've got.'
'Well, let me at least give you a ride to the station.' There was another buzz. Another message.
Dare to be a Daniel.
Will showed it to his father and then to TO.
'Oh, I think I know what that is,' said his father, a matter of seconds later. 'What did Daniel do?'
'He entered the lions' den.'
'And the New York Public Library--'
'--is guarded by two lions. Of course. The statues.' 'Patience and Fortitude. That's what they're called. Maybe that's what he's saying you need.'
'No, I think it's simpler than that.' It was TO. 'I think he's just saying go into the library. Dare to be a Daniel, enter the lions' den. That's it.'
The phone buzzed once more.
I New Message
Will fumbled to press the right buttons. All three of them were watching and waiting.
Primers' domain discovered in the orchard
of fruit
'Christ. What the hell's that? Just when I thought we were getting somewhere.'
'It's worded like a crossword clue. Or perhaps there's a room in the library that has a painting of an orchard?' 'TO, what do you reckon?'
'Your father's right. It's a cryptic crossword clue. But I can't quite see--'
'Come,' said Monroe Sr, calling a halt to proceedings. 'You can make the next train if you hurry.'
Once on board, Will watched as TO got to work. She bit her nails, then twitched her leg, before finally stroking her eyebrow with her right index finger, over and over. She borrowed Will's notebook and made a series of scribbled attempts at codebreaking - trying to write the words backwards, forwards and broken up into pieces. Nothing.
Occasionally she broke off for more of the conversation that had consumed them since their unscheduled reunion on Friday night. They tried to untie the logical knot which events and the succession of riddles had handed them. They went back and forth, trying to tease out any clues they might have missed, again and again.
Finally, as they clattered past Flatbush Avenue and Forest Hills, TO had a breakthrough.
'It works like a clue for those crosswords I used to like doing whenever you bought the British papers.' Will had a fleeting memory of the two of them in his college room, lazing away a Sunday morning. 'When it says "discovered in", that's code for an anagram. Like when they say "messed up" or "hidden in". So the fruit orchard is somehow "discovered in" primers' domain.'
'In those two words?'
'Yep. Primers' domain is an anagram.'
'For what?'
'For Pardes Rimonim. It means "Garden of Pomegranates" in Hebrew; an orchard of fruit.' She was smiling.
'OK, but what on earth is it?'
'We're about to find out.'
CHAPTER THIRTY-SEVEN

Sunday, 2.23pm, Manhattan
Patience and Fortitude were gazing elsewhere, as always.
Apparently uninterested either in the volumes of learning
behind them or the hordes of knowledge-seekers marching
towards them, they maintained their poses: stone sentries,
silent guardians of the house of wisdom.
Will had always loved this building. As with all young
men, the discovery of his own conservatism had come as
a shock. But shortly after his arrival in America, Will found
he had a great affection - no, it was more than that - a need for old buildings. He was more English than he
realized: he needed the solidity of aged walls and stones.
He had grown up in a country where the most unremarkable
village boasted a church that was six, seven, eight
hundred years old - if not older. When it was all around
him, he had barely noticed it. But now, in a country that
was still so new and unformed, the absence of such agedness
almost made him feel queasy, like a sailor on an
unsteady ship.
New York was different. Like Boston or Philadelphia, it had
enough mature masonry to reassure Will. And the Public
Library was a perfect example, a structure that could have
been plucked from London or Oxford and dropped onto
Manhattan island from the air.
On their way in, Will's phone had buzzed once more. The
message: 3 tines I kiss the page. It seemed obvious
that this was the final instruction they needed. Pardes Rimonim was the name of the book, that much TO had worked out.
This was telling them where to look, perhaps even the page.
TO fairly galloped up the two flights of stairs to the Dorot
Jewish Division. She told the librarian which book she wanted
to see, prompting a sharp intake of breath. 'You mean the
159I manuscript of Pardes Rimonim?' TO and Will looked at
each other. 'You do appreciate that that is an extremely rare
and precious book. Only the manager of the reading room
or her deputy is authorized to bring out that manuscript.
Could you come back tomorrow?'
'I really need to see it right away.'
'I'm afraid a book such as this needs special permission.
I'm sorry.'
'Who's that woman there? The one drinking coffee.' TO
was nodding towards a back office.
'That's the deputy manager. This is her lunch break.'
'Hello! Hello!'
Will could have cringed with embarrassment. TO had all
but shoved the librarian aside and was leaning across the
counter, shouting and waving to catch the deputy manager's
attention - here, in the solemn quiet of a library. Scholars at
the reading room's five tables were craning to see the cause
of the commotion. If only to restore order, the woman in the
back office put down her mug of coffee and came over.
It worked. TO was asked to write her name and address
in the visitors' book, fill in a form and leave ID. Still huffing,
the woman disappeared to retrieve the manuscript from a
locked cabinet inside a locked room - twenty long minutes
in which Will paced, studying the faces of the weekend researchers all around him. 'Here it is,' said the woman eventually, standing over the
table where Will and TO had pitched camp. She did not hand
them the book, nor did she lay it on the table. Instead she
propped it up on a pair of wedge-shaped black Styrofoam
blocks, so that the spine did not fully open. TO pulled out
her notepad and reached for a pen.
'Pencils only, I'm afraid. No pens near a book of this quality.'
'I'm sorry. Pencils it is. Thanks very much. I'm sure we
won't be too long.'
'Oh, I'm not going anywhere. I'm staying right next to this
book until it's back in its cabinet. Those are the rules.'
TO began turning the pages with slow deliberation. The
manuscript was a relic from a vanished era; hand-crafted in
Cracow, its pages were thick with four centuries of history. TO was wary even of touching it.
Will sat at her side, staring at the latest text message.
Mindful of the woman watching over them, he whispered,
'Is that some religious thing, to kiss the page?'
'Jews do kiss their prayer books when they're closed, or if
they drop them on the floor. But not three times. And not
specific pages.' TO was speaking without looking away from
the book. She seemed to be in awe of it.
Will took out his notepad. Maybe this was an exercise in
mathematics; perhaps if it was expressed as arithmetic. Will
wrote '3 times' as '3 x'. Perhaps I was the figure 1. What
would that give him? 3 x I = 3. No good.
Then he took a second look at what he had written. Hold
on. Will's mind suddenly went back to the Wednesday afternoons he had spent as a nine-year-old boy, in Mr McGregor's
Latin class. McGregor was an old-school schoolmaster, all
black gown and hurling the blackboard eraser, but every word
he taught had stuck. Including the games he used to play
with the Lower Remove to teach Roman numerals.
Hurriedly now Will wrote out '3 times' as three x's in succession: xxx. Now for 'I kiss'. Of course. The I was an i. And how
did you denote a kiss, except with the letter x? (For only a
flash, Will remembered the first time Beth signed off a text
message with an x. Just one x, after her name, but it thrilled
Will. They were in that brief, delicious overture of a relationship,
falling in love, but not yet having said the L-word out
loud. That x of Beth's was a taster.)
Now he wrote it out: xxx for '3 times', ix for 'I kiss': xxxix.
"Turn to page thirty-nine.'
TO was slow, handling the text before her with solemn
care. Will wanted to tear at the pages so that he could just
see whatever they were meant to see right now.
'OK,' said TO finally. 'This is it.'
Before them was a page dominated by a graphic: ten circles
arranged in geometric fashion and linked by a complex series
of lines. Will had a faint memory of such drawings and it
took him a while to place it. This reminded him of the chemistry
textbooks of his youth, depicting molecular structures
in two dimensions.
Except each circle had a word written inside it. Will had
to squint to see that the script was Hebrew. It was jarring,
geometry and scientific neatness in a drawing that was
medieval.
'What are we looking at?'
He could see TO did not want to answer. She was hunched
over the image, her shoulder all but blocking Will's view. 'I'm
not sure yet. I need to look.'
'Come on, TO. I know you know what this is.' Will was
shouting in a whisper. 'Tell me.'
Self-consciously, and aware of the hovering librarian, TO
started to point and talk. 'This is the key image of kabbalah.'
'Kabbalah? As in Madonna? Red string and all that?'
TO rolled her eyes, then moulded her face into an expression
that said, where do I start? 'No. That's just some bullshit
celeb cult. It's about as close to real kabbalah as, I don't know, the Easter Bunny is to Christianity. Just listen.'
'Sorry.'
'Kabbalah is Jewish mysticism. It's a very arcane form of
Jewish study, closed off to most people. You're not meant to
look at it until you've reached the age of forty. And it's for
men only.'
'What about this picture?'
'It's like the starting point of kabbalah. It contains everything.
They call it the Tree of Life.'
'My God.'
'That's sort of what they think this is. It's a diagrammatic
representation of the key qualities of God. Each of these
circles is a Sefirah, a divine attribute.' She pointed at the
lowest circle.
'See, it starts at the bottom with Malchut, that means
Kingdom. That refers to the physical realm. Then it branches
off into Yesod, Foundation, Hod, Glory and Nezah, Eternity.
Then it progresses, into Tiferet, Beauty, Gevurah, Judgment
and Hesed, Mercy. And finally, at the top of the tree, there is Binah, which is kind of like intellectual understanding. And
on the right, Hochmah, which is Wisdom. And at the summit, Keter, the Crown. Something like the divine essence.'

'So we're looking at the image of God.'
'Or the closest we're ever going to get to it.'
Will could not say anything. A shiver had run down his spine as TO had spoken. Maybe it was all just crankish hokum, but this series of lines and circles, drawn so many hundreds of years ago and taught down the generations only to those deemed able to cope with its secrets, seemed to radiate a kind of power. TO spoke again. 'It's funny talking about the "image of God". The mystics believe that the whole reason for existence is that tiod wanted to behold God.'
Will looked bemused.
'until then, there was just God. Nothing else. Just a limitless, infinite God. The trouble was, there was no room for anything else: there was no room for God's creation, for the physical world that would mirror him. So he had to shrink a little. He had to contract, leaving a space so that a kind of mirror could exist - to reflect God back to himself. See, it says it here.' She picked up another book, one she had ordered while waiting for the manuscript, rapidly flicking through the pages until she found what she was looking for. 'until the moment of Zimzutn, contraction, "Face did not gaze upon Face". God could not see himself.'
Will was fascinated by this image and even more so by the explanation TO was supplying, but he was dispirited by it, too. This was deep theological water: how deep would he and TO have to dive before they found the connection to the here and now, to the Hassidim, to their victims and to Beth? Once again, he felt a rising indignation with Yosef Yitzhok. Why could he not just give it to them straight?
It had failed once before, but he decided to try a direct appeal again. While TO pored over the drawing, sometimes cocking her head to one side to read the text on the opposite page, he rummaged in his bag and, away from the prying eyes of the librarian, he texted YY.
We're in the library. We see the drawing. We need more.
He noticed the time on the phone display: 3.30pm. Which meant it was the dead of night in Bangkok. Will looked at the BlackBerry; nothing from the foreign desk.
'Listen,' he whispered to TO. 'I'm going outside to call the paper. I'll be back in a few minutes.'
'Bring me a soda.'
As soon as he was out of the main reading room, he started dialling the foreign desk number. Andy picked up before Will got out of the building.
'Yo, Will. How you doing? Shit, I was meant to send you that stuff, wasn't I? Sorry, been crazy here all afternoon.' 'Andy! I told you I needed it right away!'
'I know, I know. Sorry. I fucked up. Anyway, here it comes.' 'Just read it out to me now, will you? I can't wait for the BlackBerry.'
By now Will was outside the main entrance, pacing up and down at the top of that vast staircase.
'Will, we are slightly on deadline here.' The word was delivered in a mock-English accent; Andy was sending him up, which was a good sign. 'OK. Here goes. I'll have to be quick and I'll skip over the funny names, OK? From John Bishop, Bangkok. Samak Sangsuk was mourned yesterday by those who knew him best - and by a few who hardly knew him at all.
'Mr Samak, who fell victim to what appears to have been an international kidnap plot Saturday, was a member of Thailand's financial elite, earning top-dollar fees on real estate and through the burgeoning Thai tourist industry.'
Get on with it, Will was thinking.
'But he was also known to the Bangkok underclass, as the man they called Mr Funeral. Mr Samak, it seems, had a strange sideline, one he ran not for profit but for its own sake. He organized funerals for the poor.
'"Mr Samak would be in touch with all the mortuaries, all the hospitals, all the funeral homes," recalled one associate Sunday. "If a corpse came in with no family or friends, with no one to bury them, they would call Mr Samak. If there was no money to pay for a proper burial, they would call Mr Samak.'"
Will could feel the blood in his veins pumping harder. 'Will? You still with me?'
'Yeah, just keep reading.'
'In the past, Bangkok's poorest would end their days in a pauper's grave, sometimes buried a dozen at a time, without a coffin between them. Mr Samak is credited with putting an end to the practice - almost single-handedly. Not only would he pay the burial costs, locals say he would also round up a congregation for the ceremony, often by paying "mourners" a few dollars to show up. "Thanks to Mr Funeral," said one doctor, "no one was buried like a dog and no one was buried alone."'
Will had heard enough. He hung up and galloped down the stairs, enjoying the sun on his face. First, Macrae, then Baxter and now Samak. Not just good men, but unusually, strangely good men. This was no longer a coincidence. He found a store, bought a couple of bottles of iced tea and headed back up towards the library: he would have to tell TO the news and work out the connection with the drawing. Surely, this was about to slot together.
Except now he noticed a figure who until then had only lurked in his peripheral vision. Darting out of view, as if frightened that he had been seen, was a tall man, wearing jeans and a loose grey hooded sweatshirt. His age, his colour, his expression were all impossible to discern: his face was entirely obscured by the hood. Only one thing was clear: he was stalking Will.
CHAPTER THIRTY-EIGHT

Sunday, 3.51pm, Manhattan
Will headed straight for the steps, taking care not to look over his shoulder. Once inside, he walked just as briskly. But he felt them before he heard them: the click, click of footsteps behind his, clacking along the cold stone floor. He headed for the first staircase he could find, daring, as he moved up another flight, to take a glance down. As he feared, the grey hood was right behind him.
Now he broke into a jog, taking two more flights up. Once he hit a landing, he broke off, taking an instant decision to seek refuge in a room full of card-index catalogues. He dashed in, slowing to an immediate walk: even then, and silent, he felt too noisy, too sweaty for the hushed concentration of the room. He turned around: the hood.
He walked faster, under a vast painting showing a trompe I'oeil sky. Dark clouds were gathering. Spotting an opening on the back wall, Will went in, only to discover it was not an exit but a small photocopying room. He darted back out, but now the hooded man was just a few yards away. Will saw the double doors out and ran for them. Once through, he was in a throng of people enjoying a mid-work break. He weaved through them to get to the staircase on the other side and, clutching hold of the hand rail, galloped
down, two at a time. A woman carrying a computer monitor
was in his way and he had to dodge to get past her. He moved
to the left and so did she; he moved to the right and so did
she. He leapt to her side to get past, but she let out an
involuntary yelp - followed by a thud and a cymbal-crash of
broken glass. She had dropped the machine.
Now Will was in the main foyer, facing a large cloakroom.
This was where regular readers began their day. There were
lockers for bags and a long rail for coats that snaked around
the room, as if in a dry-cleaner's shop. The man in the hood
was walking towards him. Calmly.
Will had to move fast. While the attendant was looking
the other way, he vaulted over the wooden counter and
plunged into the thickness of the coats. Squeezing between
a heavy anorak and a shaggy, afghan jacket, he pressed himself
against the back wall. He could sense his stalker had stopped;
Will guessed he was by the cloakroom, peering over the
counter, searching. He tried to still his breathing.
Suddenly, he felt movement. The attendant was handling
the coats, pushing whole bunches of them aside, looking for
a number. Will held in his cheeks to make no sound. But the
man was getting closer, closer, closer - until he stopped, less
than a foot away. Will felt him pull out a jacket and return
to the counter.
Then, a flash of grey. Will was sure the stalker had walked
past. He allowed himself an exhalation; perhaps he had not
been seen. He would wait five more minutes, then come out,
find TO and get the hell out of here.
But the hand got him first - thrust in before he had seen a face, like the robotic arm on a space probe. It grabbed his shirt by the collar, in an attempt to drag him into the daylight. Even in the dark, he could see the grey sweatshirt fabric that covered the arm. Twice Will locked onto it with both hands, pulling it off himself. But each time the hand came
back, eventually smashing Will's chin in the process. Crammed behind the coats, Will just could not get the space he needed to reach beyond this single, flailing arm - and hit the man behind it.

The struggle was soon over. Will was pulled out of his hiding place like the meat from a sandwich. Now he came face to face with the man in the hood. To his complete surprise, he recognized him immediately.
CHAPTER THIRTY-NINE

Sunday, 3.56pm, Manhattan
'Why did you run away? I just want to talk.'
Talk? You just want to talk? So why were you bloody
stalking me? Christ!' Will was bending over, one hand on his
knee, the other tending to his chin.
'I didn't want to approach you while you were with, um,
that woman. Upstairs. I didn't know who she was. I didn't
know if it was safe.'
'Well, it would have been safer for me, believe me. Jesus Christ'
Will found a chair and all but fell into it, trying to catch
his breath. 'So what the hell's this about, Sandy? Or is it
Shimon?'
'Shimon Shmuel. But call me Sandy, it'll be easier.'
'Gee, thanks.'
'I'm sorry. I didn't mean to hit you, I really did not. But I
couldn't let you run away. I have to talk to you. Something
very bad has happened.'
'You're telling me. My wife has been kidnapped; I've practically
been tortured; your rabbi killed some guy in Bangkok; and now you've spent a weekend stalking me, before the grand finale of a whack on the chin.'
'I haven't spent a weekend stalking you.'
'Save it, Sandy, really. I saw you from the window last night:
the baseball cap nearly threw me, but I got it in the end.'
'I promise you, I came to find you today. Not last night. I
was in Crown Heights last night.'
'Well, someone was waiting for me outside the Times building yesterday evening. They followed me to my friend's
house and waited there too. And so far the only person I
know who does that kind of thing is you.'
'I swear that wasn't me, Will. It wasn't. I had no need to
come then.'
'What do you mean, no need?'
'It hadn't happened last night. Or at least we didn't know
about it till this morning.'
'What hadn't happened?'
It's Yosef Yitzhok.' The voice faltered enough to make Will
look, for the first time, at Sandy's face. He still had not removed
his hood - a substitute skullcap, it was doing the religious
duty of covering his head - but even in the shadow it cast,
Will could see. Sandy's eyes were red raw. He looked like he
had been weeping for hours.
'What's happened to him?'
'He's dead, Will. He was murdered, brutally murdered.'
'Oh my God. Where?'
'No one knows. They found him dead in an alleyway near
the shut It was early this morning, probably on his way to shacharis. Sorry, morning prayers. His tallis, his prayer shawl,
was red with blood.'
'I don't believe this. Who would do such a thing?'
'I don't know. None of us know. That's why Sara Leah you
met her, my wife - said I should find you. She thought
this was somehow connected with you.'
'With me? She blames me?'
'No! Who said blame? She just thinks this might be
connected to whatever happened on Friday night.'
'You told her about all that?'
'Only what I knew. But Yosef Yitzhok's wife is her sister.
We're family, Will. He's my brother-in-law. Was my brotherin-law.'
The redness of his eyes was about to deepen again.
'And Yosef Yitzhok said something to his wife?'
'Not much, I don't think. Just that he had spoken to you
on Friday night. He said you were caught up in something
very important. No, that wasn't the word. He said you were
caught up in something catastrophic. That was the word he used, catastrophic' 'Did he say anything else to his wife?'
'Just that he hoped and prayed that you understood what
was happening. And that you would know what to do.'
At that moment, Will could not have felt more helpless.
The rabbi had said it first and now Yosef Yitzhok was repeating
it, from the grave. An ancient story is unfolding, that's what the rabbi had said. Something mankind has feared for millennia. Now YY was telling him the stakes were so high that he was
praying that Will would know what to do. And yet, Will felt
as confused as ever. If anything, more confused - his head
swirling with the bizarre coincidence of Macrae, Baxter and
Samak, three noble men all dying horrible deaths; the blustering
rhetoric of the Book of Proverbs and, most recently,
the impenetrable, mystical geometry of the diagram he and TO had found in this very library.
'Shit! TO She's still upstairs. Come with me. Hurry!'
Will was scolding himself at every step, as he bounded up
stairs and along corridors, Sandy behind him, returning to
the reading room. How could he have left her alone?
Will marched towards the desk he and TO had shared
nearly an hour earlier. As he got nearer, his heart sank. A
woman was sitting there - but it was not TO. She had gone.
Will punched the desk with his fist, sending a bolt of pain
through his arm - and a look of terror across the woman's face. How can I have been such a fool! These kidnappers had
now taken two women from under his nose. He was meant to have protected them both and he had failed them. Both. Sandy was standing by him, but Will could not see him or hear him. Only one thing stirred him out of his torpor: the steady, persistent vibration he now felt on his thigh. It was his phone.
2 New Messages
He pressed the first one.
Where are you? Had to leave. Call ne. TO.
Will sighed out a chestful of air. Thank God up above for that. He opened the next message, sure it would be TO, suggesting the place they should meet up. What he saw made him take two steps back in amazement.
Fiftieth and Fifth.
Yosef Yitzhok might have been dead - but the riddles lived on.
CHAPTER FORTY
Sunday, 4.04pm, Manhattan
'And when did it arrive?'
'Just now. This second.'
'Well, the first conclusion we can draw is that Yosef Yitzhok was not our informant after all.'
'We can't be certain of that, TO. His killer may have grabbed his phone and carried on sending messages.' As he said it, Will saw the absurdity of his suggestion. What were the chances that an assailant would steal a phone, check the 'sent' file and carry on sending perfectly coded messages in the same vein? Besides, there was an easy way to check. 'Sandy, can you do me a favour? Call home and find out if anyone took Yosef Yitzhok's phone when he was killed.' Now talking back into the mouthpiece, to TO, he offered another theory. 'What if someone stole his phone in the first place?'
'Well, then it wouldn't have been YY sending the messages at all, would it?' TO was getting exasperated. Fearful of returning to her own apartment, she had fled to Central Park. To her great relief, she had run into some people she knew: married friends, with plenty of kids. As Will could hear through the phone, she had stuck herself in the middle of the group. The strollers, toddlers and picnic blankets would, she reckoned, serve as a security cordon, keeping the stalkers and kidnappers at bay. Listening to the sounds of childhood chatter, of softball games and a mother handing out cake, Will felt a pang of envy or, rather, longing - longing for a Sunday afternoon of relaxed, sun-kissed normality. 'You mean, it was someone else all along.'
'I think so, yes. YY is dead but the messages have not stopped. Ergo, he wasn't the one sending them.'
'So why would they kill him?'
'Who?'
'The Hassidim.'
'We don't know it was the Hassidim who killed him. That's just another conclusion you're jumping to. The truth is, Will, we know hardly anything. We can guess and speculate and theorize, but we know very little.'
'What about the drawing in the library. Did you see anything?'
'I think it's probably telling us something very simple. It's saying, "Think kabbalah". The image is so complex, full of so many component parts, it can't be about any one bit. It's just the general idea. That diagram is the fundamental building block of all kabbalah. It's almost like a logo.'
'Hang on. There's another one coming now. I'll call you back.' He walked as he pressed the buttons to reveal the latest message, one which he willed to be clear. Now that he did not have TO at his side, he desperately needed a little simplicity.
Behold the lord of the heavens but not of Hell.
They only had to walk a few blocks north to find the junction which the earlier message had directed them to: Fiftieth Street and Fifth Avenue. That was where they stood now. Looming over them was the gothic fortress of St Patrick's
Cathedral where, little more than a week ago, he had sat
rapt, listening to The Messiah with his father. A week ago but
a different lifetime.
His father. A spasm of guilt passed through Will: he had
barely included him in this search. It was obvious he wanted
to help; he had made that clear last night and again this
morning, even doing his bit to decipher the text messages.
Yet Will had been impatient, happy to use his father as a
glorified chauffeur and not much more. Perhaps for all the
effort of the last few years, the two of them were not as close
as Will liked to believe. Most men would probably have looked
to their fathers to be their chief ally in a crisis like this, but
Will was not most men. He had lived the bulk of his childhood,
his formative years, a continent away.
Looking at it now, Will remembered his initial impression
of the cathedral when he had first arrived in New York. It
struck him as vaguely ridiculous. Despite his love of old buildings, this vast, vaulted structure, which would have fitted in
fine in Paris, London or Rome, looked absurd in the middle
of Manhattan. Sandwiched between steel and glass skyscrapers, its arched windows, crenellated towers and heaven
piercing spires were not only out of place but out of time.
They seemed to embody a kind of futility, an attempt to hold back the onrush of modernity. This was the fastest city in the
world and the cathedral stood implacably at its centre - trying
to stop the clock.
What could it mean? Beckoning Sandy to follow him, he
waded through the tourist throng and stepped inside,
enveloped immediately in the deferential hush vast houses
of worship wreathe around themselves like fog. Will marched
forward, his eyes scanning for anything that might fit that
message. Who was lord of the heavens but not of hell?
He looked over his shoulder. Sandy had barely advanced
from the door; he was gawping at the impossibly high ceiling,
then startled by the rebounding echo. Clearly, he had never been in such a building before. The contrast with the lino-and fake-panelled gymnasium that served as the Hassidim's synagogue had overwhelmed him. Will remembered something his father had once said, that religious people had much in common, even when they did not share a faith: 'The same magic works on all of them.' There was no doubt about it: Sandy was moved to be here.
Will, who had gone to school and college in buildings older than this one, was not overawed by the cold stone floors or medieval architecture. He was on a mission, to find a lord of heaven but not of hell. He faced the Grand Organ and then the smaller Chancel Organ. He checked out the altar and the pulpit, raised like the crow's nest of a ship. He examined the narrow shelves holding glass jars for the lighting of candles, and the boxes of new ones, available free of charge. He had a look at the small, private chapel, apparently closed off for private ceremonies. He looked upward, to see two flags: the first belonging to the United States, the second to the Vatican. He had no idea what he was looking for.
He walked the length of the nave, studying the blocks of pews. He glanced up at the loudspeakers and screens attached to the pillars. There were tapestries with inscriptions, but no reference that might fit the message. There were stained-glass windows with pictures of saints, shepherds and the odd serpent. Will thought he saw an angel or two.
Hold on. Directly above, dominating the space around, was a huge crucifix, with a sculpted Jesus. It was picked out in strobing white light, as tourists queued to photograph it. Was this the lord of the heavens but not of hell? After all, the underworld was the realm of Lucifer rather than Jesus. Maybe it was as simple as that. Maybe he was meant to look at Jesus. But then what?
He wished TO was with him, another pair of eyes, another brain. Sandy was nice enough, but he did not have the kind of laser observation or brainpower Will was sure he needed right now.
Will headed for the exit, shoving a dollar bill in the glass box marked for donations - and filled with what seemed to be the coins of a thousand nations.
Outside, he dialled TO's number. 'Look, we've been inside the cathedral. I'm meant to be finding the lord of the heavens but not of hell. There's nothing that seems to connect with that. Nothing I can see. Yeah, I've walked up and down. It's just pews, crucifix--'
He could feel Sandy tugging at his elbow. He tried to shake him off, but the tug was persistent.
'What is it? I'm talking to TO
'Look.' Sandy was pointing, not back at the cathedral but directly across the street.
'TO, I'll call you back.'
They were facing the Rockefeller Center, Sandy breaking into a semi-jog so they could get a closer look. Barely checking the traffic, he crossed the street, Will behind him, until they were standing before it.
Or, rather, him. Even in shimmering metal, his stomach rippled, the lines of a perfect, mythic abdomen. His thighs were enormous, each one as thick as a bison. One leg was placed before the other, in the manner of a weight-lifter steadying himself. Except this was no ordinary weight. His arms were fully outstretched at his sides, curving slightly upward to mould themselves around his load. For there, on his shoulders, was nothing less than the universe itself, rendered as an intersecting series of circles, like the lines of latitude and longitude that girdle the globe. On each of the metal arcs were marked the names of the planets. They were looking at the Rockefeller Center's largest sculpture, the two ton statue of Atlas.
'Behold the lord of the heavens but not of hell.' Sandy was murmuring the words almost to himself.
'I can see why he's the lord of the heavens,' said Will. 'But
what's the hell thing?'
Sandy was struggling to get the words out. He was panting
with exhilaration. 'It's a famous thing about this statue. When
they did it--'
'Yes?'
'--they hadn't discovered Pluto yet. So there's no Pluto on
here.'
'And Pluto's the God of the underworld,' whispered Will. Behold the lord of the heavens but not of Hell. This was the right spot. He dialled TO's number and instantly described what he
could see.
'OK, you need to pick me up,' she said. 'And then we'll
go to your apartment.'
'Why?'
'Because I think I finally know what's going on. And Atlas
has just confirmed it.'
There was no time to be self-conscious. Even so, he could tell TO felt strange to be in this place, the home of the man she had once loved and the woman he had made his wife. He saw her stealing glances at the photographs, especially the wedding collage - perhaps two dozen pictures, pressed under glass - that hung in their kitchen.
If it was odd for TO, it was horrible for Will. He had not been back since the day Beth went missing, visiting here only in his mind. Now he saw the calendar, covered in Beth's handwriting. He saw a cardigan of hers, slung over a chair. He felt her absence so strongly, it made his eyes sting. TO, you have to tell me what's going on.' Throughout their journey from Central Park, from the moment they had ditched Sandy, he had been pressing her to talk. But she was adamant. 'Will, I'm not sure I'm right. And I know you: the moment I start talking, you'll run off and do something and it could be a big mistake. We have to get this right. One hundred per cent right. There's no room for guesswork.'
'OK, I promise I won't run anywhere. Just tell me.' 'You can't make that promise. And I don't blame you. Trust me, Will. Please.'
'So when am I going to find out?'
'Soon. Tonight.'
'You'll tell me tonight?'
'You'll find out tonight. It won't be me who tells you.'
'Look, TO. Seriously. I've just about had it with riddles. What do you mean, it won't be you who tells me?'
'We're going to Crown Heights. That's where the answer
is.'
'We? You mean, you're coming with me?
'Yes, Will. It's about time.'
'Yeah, that's true, I mean it makes sense--' Will stopped
himself. TO was staring at him expectantly. It took him a
while to realize what her expression meant. She was waiting
for him to ask another question.
'What do you mean, "it's about time"?'
'Haven't you guessed, Will? This whole weekend, everything
we've been doing? You really haven't guessed?'
'Haven't guessed what?'
She was turning away, avoiding his gaze. 'Oh, Will. I'm
really surprised.'
His voice rising: 'What are you surprised at? What are you
talking about?'
'This is very hard for me, Will. I don't quite know how to
say it. But it's about time I went, you know, back.'
'Back? To Crown Heights?'
'Yes, Will. Back to Crown Heights. I thought you'd guess
ages ago. And I've been meaning to say something, but the
moment never felt right. There's been so much to think
about, so much to work out. The Hassidim, the kidnapping
and . . . Beth. But you have a right to know the truth.
'So here is the truth. My name is Tova Chaya Lieberman.
I was born in Crown Heights, Brooklyn. I am the third of
nine children. There's a reason I know this world, Will. I've
always known it, inside out. It's my world. These crazy
Hassidim? I'm one of them.'
Will could say nothing. He sat pressed against the back of the sofa, as if pinned there by a fierce wind. He listened hard, his mind trying to absorb everything TO was saying. But it was also racing, rewinding wildly through the events of the last forty-eight hours, seeing each moment in a new light. And not just the last forty-eight hours, but the last five or six years. Every experience he and TO had shared now looked utterly, entirely different.
'You saw those families with a dozen children. That's what my family was like. I was number three and there were six more after me. Me and my older sister, we were like mini moms: cleaning and preparing meals for the babies from the day we were old enough to do it.'
'And did you, you know, look like that?'
'Oh yes. The whole business: long dresses brushing the floor, mousy hair, glasses. And my mother wore a wig.' 'A wig?'
'I never explained that to you, did I? Remember, the women with "unnaturally straight" hair you saw, and how they all seemed to wear their hair in the same style? Those were sheitls, wigs worn by married women as an act of modesty: they're only meant to show their real hair to their husbands.'
'Right.'
'I know you think it's weird, Will, but what you've got to realize is, I loved it. I lapped it all up. I would read these folk tales in the Tzena Arenna, old legends of the Baal Shem Tov--' Will turned his face into a question mark.
'The founder of Hassidism. All these stories of wise men journeying through the forest, paupers revealed as men of great piety and honoured by God. I loved it.'
'So what changed?'
'I must have been about twelve. I would doodle in my exercise books a lot. But at that age I started surprising myself with what I could do. Even I could see the drawings were becoming more elaborate and, you know, quite good. But there were so few pictures to look at. You see, ultra-orthodox Jews are not that big on graven images. There were hardly any around. And then, one day at sem - sorry, seminary; kind of the girls' school - I found one of those "Introduction to the Great Painters" books. On Vermeer. I stole it and hid it under my pillow. I'm not kidding, for months I would wait till my sisters were asleep and then, under the covers, I'd stare at these beautiful pictures. Just staring at them. I knew then that's what I wanted to do.'
'You started painting.'
'No. There was never any time. At sem, it was just study, study, study. Holy texts. At home I had to clean, cook, change diapers, play with the baby, help the younger ones with their homework. I shared my room with two sisters. I had no time and no space.'
'You must have gone out of your mind.'
I did. I'd dream every day how I could get out. I wanted to go to the Metropolitan Museum. To see the Vermeer. But it wasn't just the painting.'
'Go on.'
'I know this sounds funny, given what I'm like now, but I was really good at religious studies.'
'No, sorry, I don't find that surprising at all.'
'I was top of my class. I found it easy. The texts, all those multiple meanings and cross-references, they just seemed to open up to me. Once a rabbi told me I was as good as any boy.'
'Oh dear.'
'I was furious. It was like, girls are only meant to go so far. Once you're seventeen or eighteen you become a woman
- and that means getting married, having babies, keeping house. Men could carry on at the yeshiva forever, but girls were only allowed to acquire the basics. Then we had to stop. Those were the rules. Five Books of Moses, a bit of Gemara maybe. That's a kind of rabbinic commentary. But that was it.'
'So all this kabbalah, you never studied that.'
'Wasn't allowed. Only men over forty can even look at it, remember.'
'Christ.'
'Exactly. You know me, if there's a forbidden zone, I want to go there. I found the odd book among my father's things, but I knew I couldn't do this on my own. I needed a guide. So I asked Rabbi Mandelbaum.'
'Who?'
'The one who told me I was as good as a boy. I told him I wanted to study. I came to him with all the relevant texts that proved I had the right, as a woman, to know what was in those books.'
'And did he agree? Did he teach you?'
'Every Tuesday evening, a secret class at his house. The only other person who knew about it was his wife. She would bring a glass of lemon tea for him, a glass of milk for me and rugelach, little pastry cakes, for both of us. We did that for five years.' She was smiling.
'What happened?'
'He got worried. Not for his sake - he was too old to care what people thought - but for me. I was approaching "the age of marriage". He told me, "Tova Chaya, it would take a very strong man not to feel threatened by so learned a wife". I think he was worried that he had ruined me: that, thanks to him, I would not be happy keeping house. I wouldn't be a good wife like Mrs Mandelbaum. He had lifted my sights. In a way he was right.
'But he needn't have worried; by then I had planned my escape. I applied to Columbia; I gave a PO Box address so that no one would see the correspondence. I applied for tons of scholarships, so that I could afford a room. I presented myself as an independent adult; as far as the college were concerned, I had no parents.
'So when the day came, I gave the kids breakfast, as always, called out goodbye to my mother, as always, and I walked to the subway station.'
'And you never went back.'
'Never.'
Will's mind was speeding, spilling with questions. But he was also overrun with answers. Suddenly, he saw so much that had been hidden. TO was no toddler nickname, its origins forgotten. It was a vestige of Tova Chaya's former life. And no wonder TO's parents were such a mystery: they were from a past she had abandoned. Of course there were no pictures: that would have betrayed her secret.
'Do they even know you're alive?'
'I speak to them by phone, before the major festivals. But I haven't seen them since I was seventeen.'
In an instant, TO made sense. Of course she was brilliant but knew nothing of pop music and junk TV: she had grown up without them. Of course she spoke no French or Spanish: she had devoted her time to Yiddish and Hebrew instead. Will suddenly thought of TO's eating habits - the fondness for Chinese food, studded with jumbo prawns, the fry-up breakfasts, with generous rations of bacon. She loved all that stuff. How come? 'The zeal of a convert,' she said wryly. Now that he had been to Crown Heights himself, Will realized the scale of TO's rupture from her upbringing. He looked at her now: the tight top revealing the shape of her breasts; the exposed midriff; the navel stud. He thought back to the notice he had seen in Crown Heights.
Girls and women who wear immodest garments, and thereby call attention to their physical appearance, disgrace themselves . . . Her break from Hassidism could not have been more
complete. And he was forgetting the biggest rebellion of all: him.
People from her world did not have sex outside marriage. They rarely married people from outside their own sect of Hassidism, let alone non-Jews. Yet she had had a long, physical relationship with him - not her husband and not a Jew. For him it had been a wonderful romance. He now understood that for her it had been a revolution.
He suddenly saw TO differently. He imagined her as she would have been: a bright, studious girl of Crown Heights groomed for a life of modesty, child-rearing and dutiful observance. What a journey she had made, crossing this city and
centuries of tradition and taboo. He stood up, walked over to her and gave her a long, warm hug.
'It's a privilege to meet you, Tova Chaya.'
CHAPTER FORTY-THREE

Sunday, 6.46pm, Brooklyn
He wanted to interrogate TO for hours, about her life, about the secret she had kept for so long. Lots of Jewish people became orthodox; they were known as chozer b 'tshuva, literally 'one who returns to repentance'. She had gone the other way: chozer b'she'ela. She had returned to question. But they had no time for that conversation, no matter how much they wanted it. They had to get to Crown Heights. Yosef Yitzhok had been murdered, though neither of them had any idea why. The last messages Will had received directing him to Atlas at the Rockefeller Center - had been
sent after YY's death, proof that he had not been the informer after all. So why would anyone want him dead? Will was baffled. All he knew was that things were turning steadily more vicious. The rabbi had not been exaggerating: time was running out.
Just as pressing was TO's promise. All would become clear, she had said, once they were in Crown Heights. She could not tell Will herself what was going on. But the explanation lay there. They just had to find it.
'I'm going to need to use your bathroom. And I'm going to need to borrow some of Beth's clothes.'
'Sure,' Will said, trying hard to shrug off the potential
symbolism of that request. He led TO to Beth's closet and,
steeling himself, pulled back the sliding door. Instantly his
nostrils filled with the scent of her. He was sure he could
smell her hair; he could think himself into the aroma of that
patch of skin below her ear. He breathed in deeply, through
his nose.
TO pulled out a plain white blouse, one Beth wore for
formal work meetings, usually under a dark trouser-suit. It was cut high, Will noticed. We request that all women and girls,
whether living here or visiting, adhere at all times to the laws of
modesty . . .
She turned to Will. 'Does Beth have any really long skirts?'
Will thought hard. There were a couple of long dresses,
including a particularly beautiful one he had bought for his
wife on their first anniversary. But they were evening wear.
'Hold on,' he said. 'Let me look at the back here.' He
wondered if Beth had gotten around to throwing it out; he
knew she planned to. It was a long, drab dark velvet skirt
that Will had mocked mercilessly. He called it Beth's 'spinster
cellist number'. She put up a mock-defence, but she
could see his point: it did make her look like one of those
silver-haired lady players spotted in every orchestra. But she
felt attached to it. To Will's great relief at this moment, she
had never got rid of it.
'OK,' said TO, moving towards the bathroom. 'These will
have to go.' She cocked her head to one side to take off her
earrings. Then she pressed her face closer to the mirror and
began the complex manoeuvre of removing her nose-stud.
Finally she gazed down at her middle and unscrewed the ring
that pierced her belly button. She now had a small pile of
metal in her hand, which she placed by the basin.
'Now for the toughest job of all.' She reached into her bag
to produce a newly purchased bottle of shampoo, one specially
designed for the task at hand. She started running the tap,
grabbed a towel and slung it around her shoulders. As if bracing herself for a nasty ordeal, she bent down and lowered her head towards the water.
As Will watched she began to lather up and rinse. She had to scrub hard, but soon her effort was paying off. The water in the sink began to turn a blueish purple. The dye was coming out, a stream of it swirling around the white porcelain and away. Will was fascinated by the coloured water. It was not only removing a chemical from TO's hair; it seemed to be washing away the last decade of her life.
He left to collect a few things of his own. What had the rabbi said? 'All will become clear in a few days' time.' That was two days ago. Perhaps he was about to close in on the truth, at long last. What would it be? What was this 'ancient story' into which he and his wife had somehow fallen? Once he knew, would he be back with her? Would he hold her again? Would that be tonight?
'So, what do you think?'
Will wheeled around to see a different woman. Her hair was now dark brown, brushed straight and long into a 1990s style bob. She wore sensible black shoes, a long black skirt and a white blouse. She had borrowed a thick, quilted jacket of Beth's that, in other circumstances, might have been fashionable but which now looked only practical. Standing there
in his apartment was a woman who could have passed for any of the young wives and mothers he had seen in Crown Heights two days earlier. She looked like Tova Chaya Lieberman.
'I'm so glad for the shoes. Thank God, they fit me and that's all that counts
It took Will a moment to realize what TO was doing. She was trying out the sing-song, Yiddish-inflected accent of a New York Hassidic woman. It came to her so easily, it persuaded Will immediately.
'Wow. You sound . . . different.'
This was the music of my youth, Will,' she said, sounding like TO once more. Except there was a wistfulness in her voice he had never heard before. Then, snapping out of it: 'Now, what about you?'
Me?'
'Yes, you. We're going there together. Tova Chaya wouldn't be seen with some shaygets. You need to look the part, too. Now, come on: black suit, white shirt. You know the drill.' Will did as he was told, finding the plainest outfit he could. He had to reject a suit with a pin-stripe and a white shirt with a Ralph Lauren polo player on the chest. Plain, plain, plain.
He looked in the mirror, hoping his transformation would be as convincing as TO's. But his face gave him away. He might have passed for American, but Jewish? No. He had the colouring and bone structure of an Anglo-Saxon whose roots lay in the villages of England rather than the steppes of Russia. Still, that need not be a problem. Had he not seen the faces of Hanoi and Helsinki among the faithful on Friday night? He would say he was a convert.
He only needed one last thing. 'TO, where am I going to get a skullcap from at this time of night?'
'I already thought of that.' With a flourish, TO held up a large black disc of material. 'I borrowed it from your friend Sandy when we were in the park.'
'Borrowed?'
'Well, I knew they always carry spares. And I just happened to be glancing into one of his jacket pockets. Here, put it on.' As if in a ceremony, TO stretched onto tiptoes and placed the yarmulke onto Will's head. She dashed into the bathroom and came back with a hairclip. 'There,' she said,
attaching it just so. 'Reb William Monroe, it's a pleasure to meet you.'
Once in the cab, Will felt himself begin to twitch with excitement - and nerves. He had never so much as attempted an undercover assignment and that's what this had become. He was in costume, trying to pass himself off as somebody else. His protective armour - chinos, blue shirt, notebook was gone. He felt exposed.
In a bid for reassurance, he reached for his cell phone - a memento of his regular life. A new message, apparently from the same unknown sender he had once thought was Yosef Yitzhok.

Just nen we are, our nunber few Desoribable in digits two
We're halved if these do multiply If we few perish then all nust die.

He had no idea what it meant but it hardly mattered now. According to TO, everything was about to be explained. Habit made him check his BlackBerry next. The red light was blinking: a Guardian News Alert. Nostalgia had made him an electronic subscriber to the paper he used to read back home. Ordinarily, he rapidly deleted these email updates: he had enough to do keeping up with the news in New York and America. But that 'alert' did the trick: what breaking news might justify its own bulletin? He clicked it open.

The Robin Hood of Downing Street
Britain's hottest political scandal in decades took its most bizarre turn yet today.
The former Chancellor of the Exchequer, Gavin Curtis, who police believe took his own life last week, seems set to be transformed overnight from a disgraced hate figure into a posthumous folk hero. Treasury officials, who earlier revealed that Mr Curtis had diverted large chunks of the UK's budget into a private Swiss bank account, have this morning disclosed where that money ended up - in the hands of the world's poorest people. Instantly hailed by the tabloids as a 'real-life Robin Hood', it seems Mr Curtis spent much of his seven years at Britain's exchequer robbing from the rich to give to the poor. 'Our government grant doubled, then tripled under Mr Curtis,' said Rebecca Morris, a spokeswoman for Action on Hunger, a leading relief agency. 'We thought it was just government policy.'
It was nothing of the kind. Instead such generosity to those fighting the wars on poverty, HIV/Aids and famine was the personal decision of Mr Curtis himself- made possible by taking money out of dormant bank accounts that had laid unnoticed and unclaimed for years and then burying the details in a bafflingly complex labyrinth of Treasury data.
Some observers speculate that the Chancellor went further in recent months, finding extra funds by raiding subsidies earmarked for Britain's arms exporters. 'They got less so that the starving of Africa and the sick of the Indian Ocean could get more,' explained a ministerial ally last night. One report suggested it was this move which led to his eventual exposure. 'He must have known the risks he was taking,' Ms Morris told the Guardian. 'And yet he was prepared to do all that, just so the hungriest and weakest would have a better chance. I can't tell you how many lives Gavin Curtis must have saved. Some will call this a scandal, but I think this was the action of a truly righteous man.'
CHAPTER FORTY-FOUR

Sunday, 8.16pm, Crown Heights, Brooklyn
TO did not want to take the risk of a phone call. She feared that Rabbi Mandelbaum would be too shaken by the sound of a voice from his past. She feared, too, that he would instantly call her parents. It was likely he had been plagued by guilt during these long years: he had colluded in a secret with young Tova Chaya and look what had happened. He was bound to blame himself, for encouraging her rebelliousness when he should have curbed it. All this she imagined. So she would turn up. at his front door instead, leaving him no option. She looked at her watch: with any luck he would be back from synagogue by now. She remembered the address and, once she saw that the lights were on inside, she told the cab to wait. 'Sorry, Will. I just need a second.' She was staring out of the window, as if unable to move. It's been nearly ten years. I was a different person.'
'You take your time.'
Will stared out of the window, at streets that were preternaturally quiet. Theirs was the only car; no one was out
walking. The only sound came from the radio, playing a song. Will did not notice it at first, but one line of the lyric caught him. It was John Lennon, declaring that 'God is a concept, by which we measure our pain.' Will listened harder; the
song was moving towards its climax. 'I don't believe in magic
... I don't believe in bible ... I don't believe in Jesus . . .
I don't believe in Beatles. I just believe in me, Yoko and me,
and that's reality.'
He had never heard it before, but it made his throat dry.
It was as if Beth herself were speaking to him, as if she had,
at last, smuggled a message out of her cell. The yearning that
Will felt for his wife at that moment was so great, it was as
if he was made of nothing else.
Finally, TO gave the signal to get out of the car. They paid
the driver and walked towards the house. Will adjusted his
skullcap. Again. TO knocked on the door. It took a while, but
Will could hear activity. A slow shuffle to the door and then
a hunched, grey-bearded old man. He could have been no
younger than eighty.
'Rabbi Mandelbaum, it's Tova Chaya Lieberman. Your pupil.
I've come back.'
The eyes spoke first, brightening and moistening in an
instant. He looked and looked, without uttering a word. Then
he nodded gently and waved them in. He walked ahead of
them, allowing his left arm to lift up as he passed the door
to the dining room: his way of saying, Go in there. He carried
on in the direction of the kitchen.
Will was hit immediately by the smell of old books: the
room was crammed from floor to ceiling with the leather
bound, gilt-edged volumes he had seen in the interrogation
room on Friday night. Holy texts. The surface of the dining
room table was invisible: covered first by a tablecloth, then
a plastic sheet and finally dozens of open books. It was hard
to see; the room was lit by one weak electric light. But even
with a cursory scan, Will could tell: barely a word was in
English.
There were no paintings on the wall, only photographs. Perhaps a dozen of them, maybe more, all displaying a single
subject. The Rebbe. Dead more than two years, he stared out
from every angle, sometimes smiling, sometimes with an arm
aloft, but always gazing intently. In one photograph the Rebbe
stood with Rabbi Mandelbaum in a group. The others seemed
to be commercially produced, specially mounted on tacky, log
style slices of fake wood. It reminded Will of the souvenirs you
could buy in small Italian villages, depicting the local saint.
Rabbi Mandelbaum was back, holding an unsteady tray
with a single glass of water.
'Sit, sit,' he insisted, as he offered the tray to Will. He was
puzzled. Why was he the only one to have anything to drink? TO leaned over and whispered: 'Yom Kippur has already
begun. This evening. No food or drink.'
'So why has he given me water?'
'He's a smart guy.'
TO had positioned herself facing her old teacher.
'Mrs Mandelbaum?' she said in a voice at once hesitant
and gentle.
'Haya Hindel Rachel, aleyha hosholom.'
'I'm sorry. HaMakom y'nachem oscha b'soch sh'ar aveilei Tzion v'Yerushalayim.' May the Lord comfort you amongst all those
who are mourning for Zion and Jerusalem.
Will could only watch and listen, but he knew enough
body language to know TO was giving condolences.
'Rabbi Mandelbaum, I've come here after all these years
on a matter of life and death. I believe there is a sakono fur
diegantseh breeye.' A risk to the whole of creation. She paused,
before remembering herself.
'This is my friend, William Monroe.' The rabbi made the
slightest movement with his eyebrow, a tiny reflex that said,
'Don't think I'm naive young lady. I understand the ways of
the world. I understand that a man named William Monroe
is not a Jew, no matter how he is dressed. And I also understand
that a word like "friend" has multiple meanings.'
'His wife has been kidnapped. She is held hostage, here in
Crown Heights. Will has spoken to a rabbi - I believe it must be Rabbi Freilich.' She glanced over at Will, who was glaring at her in surprise: Why didn't you tell me you knew his name? She carried on. 'He doesn't deny that he has taken her. But he has never explained why.' No shock registered on Mandelbaum's face. He just nodded, encouraging TO to continue.
'We have been getting various messages, delivered by telephone. Text messages.' She enunciated the phrase, as if it
might be unfamiliar to the aged rabbi. But he did not seem fazed by it.
'We do not know who these messages are from. But they do seem to indicate some kind of explanation for events here and beyond. I can't be sure what they mean. But I have an idea. Which is why we're here.'
'Fregt mich a shale.' Ask your question.

'Rabbi Mandelbaum, will you explain to Will the idea of a tzaddik.'
For the first time, the rabbi conveyed an emotion. He looked quizzically at TO, as if wondering what he was about to get into.
'Tova Chaya, you know well what is a tzaddik. This much we learned together already. For this you came back?' 'I want him to hear it from you. Will you tell him?'
The rabbi stared hard at TO, as if trying to work out her motives. Finally and hesitantly, he turned to Will and began. 'Mr Monroe, a tzaddik is a righteous man. The root of the word is tzedek, which is justice. A tzaddik is not just wise or learned. For that we have different words. A tzaddik is a man of special wisdom. He embodies justice itself. The English word "righteous" is the closest you have.'
William had never heard a voice like it. The rabbi who had interrogated him so forcefully - whom he now discovered was called Freilich - had spoken with an unusual intonation, a musical lilt that bobbed up and down. But it was still a recognizably American accent. This was something else. Not German, not Eastern European exactly, perhaps a blend of the two. Was it the accent of Middle Europe Or was it, in fact, the voice of a place that no longer existed - the voice of Jewish Europe? In that sound, Will could recognize the pictures he had studied in history books of the second world war: the Jews of Poland or Hungary or Russia, their dark eyes staring out of black-and-white photographs, on the brink of a terrible fate they did not know. He heard the sorrowful, wry violins of the klezmer music he had occasionally caught on New York radio. In this one man's voice, Will Monroe imagined he could hear a lost civilization.
He pulled himself back into the present, determinedly concentrating on what the rabbi was saying.
'Our tradition speaks of two kinds of tzaddikim, those who are known and those who are hidden. The hidden are understood to be on a higher plane than those whose holiness is
public. They are righteous and yet they seek no fame or glory. They have none of the conceit that comes with public life. Even their closest neighbours have no idea of their true nature. Often they are poor. Tova Chaya will remember the folk stories she read as a child: tzaddikim who lived as if in secret, working with their hands. They might be poor or do very humble jobs. In folk tales, they are often blacksmiths or cobblers; maybe a janitor. And yet, these men perform deeds of the highest goodness. Holy deeds.'
'But no one knows who they are?' The question just popped out of Will's mouth.
'Precisely. Indeed,' and at this the rabbi allowed himself a smile, 'the tzaddik will often go to great lengths to put people off the trail, so to speak. Our writings are full of stories of tremendous paradox: the holiest men, found in the unholiest places. It's deliberate: they want to conceal their true nature behind a mask, so they disguise themselves as crude, even unpleasant men. Tova Chaya might remember the story of Rabbi Levi Yitzhok of Berditchev?'
'God's Drunkard.'
I'm glad. You have not forgotten all we studied together. God's Drunkard is indeed the story I have in mind. In that
story, the holy Rabbi Levi Yitzhok finds that when it comes
to divine grace, he is outshone by Chaim the Watercarrier an
ignoramus who is shicker from morning till night.' TO and
the rabbi chuckled together.
'So some of the most righteous men appear in the very
opposite form?'
'Yes. Consider it a kind of divine joke. Or proof that Judaism
is a profoundly democratic philosophy. The holiest are not
those who know the most, or who have the most letters after
their name. Nor is this group made up of those who pray
most energetically, fast most assiduously or observe the
commandments most diligently. The measure of holiness is
the just and generous treatment of our fellow human beings.'
'So this man, this drunkard, he was good to his fellow
man?'
'He must have been very good.' The three of them sat in
a brief silence, punctuated by the sound of the old man
breathing noisily.
'There is a story. One of the oldest.' Again the beginning
of a smile was playing on his lips. Will suddenly saw behind
the beard and the accent; he saw a rather charming man.
Now elderly and hunched, in his youth he would, Will realized,
have been quite a charismatic teacher.
Rabbi Mandelbaum was out of his chair, shuffling around
the table to reach the bookshelf just behind Will's head. 'Here,
this is from Talmud Yerushalmi, from the tractate dealing with
fast days. Tova Chaya, did we study this together?'
Will was getting lost. 'Sorry, where is this from?'
TO stepped in. 'It's from what's known as the Palestinian
Talmud: the book of rabbinic commentary written in
Jerusalem.'
'When?'
Rabbi Mandelbaum, now back in his seat and flicking
through pages, answered without looking up. 'This story
comes from the third century of the common era.' The common
era. A euphemism for 'anno domini', the year of our lord,
referring to Jesus Christ - a phrase no believing Jew could
use. 'This is probably the oldest story of its kind.' His eyes
were scanning the text. 'OK, so we don't need all the details
but in this story, Rabbi Abbahu notices that when a certain
man is in the congregation, the community's prayer for rain
gets answered. When he's not there, no rain. Anyway, it turns
out this man works in, of all places, a whorehouse! Excuse
me Tova Chaya, to speak of such things.'
'You mean,' said Will, 'he's a pimp? And yet he is one of
the righteous men?'
That's what the Talmud says.'
Will felt an ice shard slide down his back. He shuddered, his
shoulders trembling. He could not hear what TO or the rabbi
were saying. In his head there was room for only one voice.
It belonged to Letitia, the woman he had met in Brownsville.
He could hear her words loud and clear. The man they killed last night may have sinned every day of his God-given life - but he was
the most righteous man I have ever known. She had said that about Howard Macrae who, like the man in that third-century congregation,
earned his living as a pimp.
'. . . the stories almost seem to delight in this kind of paradox,' the rabbi was saying. 'Good men disguised as
humble men or even as great sinners.'
Will's head was throbbing. Pat Baxter, the militia crazy
mixing with gun-toting fanatics, yet who had never been
arrested and had given one of his own organs to a total
stranger. Gavin Curtis, despised as a corrupt politician, yet
funnelling money to the world's poorest people. Samak
Sangsuk, just another high-rolling Thai businessman, yet
quietly ensuring that the Bangkok underclass found dignity
in death.
Will could hardly keep up with his own thoughts. He
remembered Curtis's curiously humble car as he fled the press
ruck. And what had Genevieve Huntley said about the kidney donor? Mr Baxter's greatest request was anonymity. That was the
one thing he asked of me in return for what he did. All of these man had done noble deeds - and all had done them in secret.
'How many of these righteous men are there?'
The rabbi instantly looked at TO. 'This you don't know?
This you've forgotten?'
'I didn't forget, Rabbi Mandelbaum. But I wanted Will to
hear it from you. To hear it all.'
'There are thirty-six tzaddikim in each generation. You know
perhaps that in Hebrew, each letter also has a numerical value?
In Hebrew, thirty-six is expressed by the Hebrew characters lamad, and vav, which is equivalent
to the letter v in English. Lamad is thirty and vav is six. In
Yiddish, these righteous men are known as the lamadvavniks: the thirty-six just men who uphold the world.'
Will jolted, his antennae twitching the way they did when
he heard the words that would make a news story.
'Excuse me, what do you mean by "uphold the world"?'
He saw TO was nodding, a half-smile on her lips that seemed to say, At last we're getting to the heart of the matter.
'Ah, well this is the whole point of the story. I am sorry
Mr Monroe, I'm getting old. I should have mentioned this at
the start. Please, let me get past.' The rabbi was reaching for
yet another book; one of the few in the room in English. The
Messianic Idea in Judaism by Gershom Scholem. 'Someone
gave this to the seminary. I think it tries to explain these
matters to the general reader--'
Will was almost scratching at his own skin in frustration.
He nodded politely, his eyes wide, doing all he could to
encourage the rabbi to cut the academic footnotes and get
on with it.
'Ah yes, here we are. Scholem says that Jewish tradition
"speaks of thirty-six tzaddikim, or just men, on whom - though they are unknown or hidden - rests the fate of the world".' He was skim-reading further down the page. '"Already in the biblical Proverbs of Solomon, we find the saying that the just man is the foundation of the world and therefore, as it were, supports it".'
'Hold on, Rabbi Mandelbaum.' It was TO, suddenly on the edge of her seat. 'Where in Proverbs is that reference?' Slowly, the rabbi turned back a page. 'Chapter 10, Verse 25/
Instantly, TO reached into her bag and pulled out her pile of Post-it notes, written after the text message clues had led them to Proverbs 10. She thumbed through them until she found the one she wanted. She smiled and passed it to Will. Verse 25: As the whirlwind passeth, so is the wicked no more; but the righteous is as an everlasting foundation.
'A foundation,' said TO quietly. Now looking at Will: 'The righteous men are the foundation on which the world stands. Without them, the world collapses.'
'Tova Chaya has summarized it well. There is some discussion about the origin of the idea. Some scholars think it dates back to Abraham's argument with the Almighty over the people of Sodom.'
TO could tell Will did not know of any such argument and that Rabbi Mandelbaum was not about to explain it. She stepped in. 'Basically, God was about to destroy the entire city of Sodom because they had become sinful,' she said in a semi-whisper, keen to get this out of the way rather than opening up a new discussion with her old teacher. 'Abraham tries to make a deal, proposing that if he, Abraham, can find fifty good people in the town, then God should spare it. God agrees and then Abraham starts negotiating. In that case, he says, if you'd save it for fifty, then what about forty? God agrees to that, too. They keep haggling until finally Abraham has beaten God down to ten good men. OK, God says, find me ten good people and I'll save Sodom. So that establishes the principle that, so long as there are some truly righteous people around, the rest of us are OK. We're saved because they are in the world.'
Rabbi Mandelbaum picked up the thread. 'There is some dispute about the exact numbers. Some say thirty, some say forty-five. But from the fourth century or so, the number becomes settled on thirty-six. As Rabbi Abaye writes, "There are in the world not less than thirty-six righteous persons in every generation upon whom the Shekhina rests".' 'Sorry. What was that word?'
'My apologies. The Shekhina is God's radiance, the Divine Countenance.'
Still in a semi-whisper, TO said: 'It refers to the outward appearance of God. It's kind of like a divine light,' adding with what Will felt sure was pride, 'it's feminine.'
'I want to be sure I understand this correctly,' Will began, haltingly. 'Jewish teaching holds that there are thirty-six people alive at any one time who are truly righteous. They may be hidden away in obscurity, doing humdrum jobs, living flawed, even sinful lives. But, quietly and in secret, they perform acts of extraordinary goodness. And so long as they're around, we're all OK. They keep the world afloat.' Will finally understood the last clue: the statue of Atlas at the Rockefeller Center, carrying the whole universe on his shoulders. 'Which means,' he said, his voice slowing, 'that if they were not around, for whatever reason, it would, literally, be the end of the world.'
Heavily and slowly, the aged rabbi nodded. 'I'm afraid that's exactly what it means.'
CHAPTER FORTY-FIVE

Sunday, 8.46pm, Crown Heights, Brooklyn
So this was why people were dying. For nothing more than a bizarre, quasi-biblical legend. The waste of life struck Will with new force: what insanity, what cruelty, for Howard Macrae or Pat Baxter to be murdered in the name of a lunatic fantasy. The end of the world indeed! It was obviously nonsense. Who could seriously believe thirty-six people kept the world alive? Will had not breathed in the empirical, sceptical air of Oxford for nothing. He had been taught to dismiss such bunkum out of hand: it made more sense to believe in fairies at the bottom of the garden.
And yet what he thought was surely irrelevant. Someone obviously did believe it - with an intensity that made them ready to kill wholly innocent men, all over the world. If this was the killers' motive, what did it matter whether it was rational or not?
That was what Will told himself. But still something nagged. Something about this man and his books; something about the respect TO had for him. Something about TO, Tova Chaya, herself. These people were not bug-eyed maniacs. They were keepers of an ancient tradition which had endured since the city of Sodom. The story of the thirty-six had been passed down quietly, generation after generation, from the days of
Abraham through centuries of wanderings from Babylon to
eastern Europe and, now, to America. Jews were not cranks,
latching onto fantasies; not as far as he knew. His conversations
with TO had always projected the same impression: that
Judaism was not concerned with the supernatural, so much
as with the way real human beings treated each other in the
here and now. They did not seem to believe in flying saucers
or cripples throwing away their crutches. They were more
grounded than that. So if they believed in the hidden presence
of thirty-six good men, maybe there was a reason.
Something else dulled Will's usually sceptical instincts. If
he had not discovered it for himself, he would never have
believed it. But Macrae and Baxter, Samak in Bangkok and
Curtis in London had fitted the rabbi's description perfectly.
They had indeed performed acts of uncommon goodness and
had done so entirely in private. They had shunned publicity,
just as the legend demanded. (Will's strong hunch was that, until he started digging, the righteous acts of Baxter and
Macrae, at least, had been entirely unknown.) The four people
he knew about had even disguised themselves as sinners,
people who would be reviled rather than revered. A pimp
and a politician, for heaven's sake!
What if he accepted the existence of these lamadvavniks, just for the sake of argument? That allowed a new thought
to encroach. until that moment, his sole interest had been
in discovering how this strange, ancient story might lead him
back to his wife. Now he felt his hands go moist at a different
notion. If this myth had any grounding in reality, then the
pursuit of the righteous men was not just a cruel crime. It
would also bring disaster upon the world. For the first time
he understood Rabbi Freilich's words to him on the telephone the previous evening. Your wife matters to you, Mr Monroe, of
course she does. But the world, the creation of the Almighty, matters
to me.
Thirty-six, thought Will. It was so few. Just thirty-six people
on the whole of this crowded, cramped planet, teeming with,
what, six billion people? Four men were dead, he knew that.
Did that mean there were another thirty-two dead, or dying,
in far-off corners of the world, all but unnoticed?
He remembered again his conversation with Rabbi Freilich. An ancient story is unfolding here, threatening an outcome that
mankind has feared for thousands of years. So this is what he meant. The ancient story was the legend of the lamad vav, the thirty-six righteous men. The outcome feared for so long
was nothing less than the end of the world.
Whoever had been sending those text messages knew all
this, Will now realized. While Rabbi Mandelbaum stretched
for another book, Will stole a glance at his cell phone, to look
at the last message he had received. A four-line poem, a
quatrain.

Just nen we are, our nunber few Describable in digits two
We're halted if these do Multiply If we few perish then all must die.

Just men ... describable in digits two. The two digits were three
and six. If these do multiply. Three times six was eighteen, half
of thirty-six: We're halved. And the texter understood what was at stake. If we few perish then all must die.
Will tried hard to compose himself. He wanted desperately
to produce his notebook, to start ordering all this information.
Still, he had to ask some questions.
'These thirty-six? Are they all Jewish?'

'Usually in' Hassidic folk lore the tzaddikim are Jewish. But
this is more sociology than theology: who else did these yidden know? They knew only Jews. That was their entire world.
In the early rabbinic writings, there are different views on
the identity of the tzaddikim. Some believed they all lived in
the land of Israel, some said that a portion lived outside it;
others said that the righteous men emerged from the goyim, the Gentiles. There is no settled view. It could be all Jews,
all non-Jews or a mixture.'
'But they're always men?'

'Always. On that the sources all agree. No doubt about that at all. The lamadvavniks are all men.'
TO could read Will's mind. So why are they holding my Beth? The truth was, Will was disappointed. Since the rabbi had first started talking, Will had been trying to trace a path back to his wife and her abduction. Even before he came here he had accepted that Macrae and Baxter were connected, but he could not fathom their link to Beth. This theory of the thirty six seemed bizarre and far-fetched, if not completely loopy, to Will, but at least it might explain what was in the Hassidim's mind. Perhaps for some deluded reason, they had decided Beth was one of the righteous ones. Now he knew that could not be true: she was the wrong sex. He was as mystified as ever. A new question surfaced. He asked it as soon as he had thought of it.
'Who would want to do such a thing? Who would want to bring about the end of the world?'
'Only one who was in thrall to the Sitra Achra.'
Will's brow furrowed.
Rabbi Mandelbaum realized he needed to say more. I'm sorry, I'm forgetting. The Sitra Achra means literally "the other side". In kabbalah, it is the phrase used to refer to the forces of evil. Unfortunately, these are present all around us, every day and in everything.'
'A bit like the devil, like Satan?'
'No, not really. Because the Sitra Achra is not some external force we can blame for everything that goes wrong. The power of the Sitra Achra derives from the actions of human beings. It is not Lucifer who brings evil into the world. I'm afraid, Mr Monroe, it is us.'
'Why would religious people, men of God, want to do such
a thing - to kill the righteous men?'
'I cannot imagine why. You know, we Jews say that if you
save a life it is as if you have saved the whole world. So to
kill any human being is a great crime. The ultimate crime.
To kill a tzaddik? That would be a further desecration of the
name of the Almighty. To kill more than one? To aim to kill
all of them? I cannot even contemplate such wickedness.'
'No motive we can think of?'
'I suppose it's conceivable that someone very misguided
might want to test this belief to its limits. To see if it's really
true, that the lamad vav maintain the world. If the lamad vav are all gone, all not here, well then we will know, won't we?'
'Or they could believe it already,' said Will. 'Believe it so
much that they want to bring about the end of the world.'
In the silence that followed, Will was struck by something
he had half-noticed but had not thought about properly till
now. For someone who had just been confronted with such
news, Rabbi Mandelbaum looked remarkably calm. He
remained in his chair, thumbing his books. As if this was a
purely theoretical problem.
Now it was the rabbi's turn to read Will's mind.
'Anyway, no one could ever do it,' the old man said, sighing
as he adjusted himself in his seat. 'Because no one ever knows
who the lamadvavniks are. That is their power.'
Will was ashamed to realize this was the one thing he had
never thought of. Thirty-six people, living in humble obscurity
across the globe: how would anyone know who they
were? How had the killers of Macrae and Baxter found them?

'The tzaddik is hidden, sometimes even from himself; he may have no idea of his own nature. If a man does not know himself, who else can know him?'
'So no one has any idea who the thirty-six are? There's no secret list?'
The rabbi twinkled. 'No, Mr Monroe, there's no list. Tova Chaya, behind you, can you pass me the book by Rebbe Yosef Yitzhok?'
Will started. He had heard so few familiar words since he had arrived in this room, but this was a name he knew. TO caught his expression and whispered a clarification. That's the name of a previous Rebbe. YY was named after him. He died fifty years ago.'
'All right the rabbi said, now fallen back into his chair. 'This is a kind of autobiography of the Rebbe. Here he describes the tzaddikim as if they were a secret society. He doesn't refer to them explicitly as the lamadvavniks, but that's what he's talking about. He suggests these people, each stationed in a different city, were somehow the founders of Hassidism.' He turned away from the book, his eyes closed, as if reading a text written inside his eyelids. Will realized he was dredging something from his memory. 'There is also the great Rabbi Leib Sorres. From the eighteenth century. It was said of him that he was in secret contact with the hidden just men, that he even made sure they were fed and clothed. They said the same about the Baal Shem Tov, the recognized founder of Hassidism.' His eyes opened. 'But these are the exceptions. Generally, it is understood that the hidden tzaddikim remain hidden. There are stories of near misses, of tzaddikim about to meet another of their own kind, only to miss out. And it's assumed that one righteous man would have the wisdom to recognize another. You know, he would somehow "feel the glow".' The rabbi cracked the smile Will had seen earlier, the one that belonged to the playful, mischievous young man it seemed Rabbi Mandelbaum had once been. 'But generally, these men are out of view, from themselves, from each other, from the rest of us.'
'How would anyone work out where to find them?'
'Now, this is the kind of question Tova Chaya used to ask
- a question Rabbi Mandelbaum cannot answer!' The two exchanged warm smiles, like an old man with a favourite granddaughter. 'I wish I knew, Mr Monroe, but I don't. For
this, you would need to talk to others. Those who have penetrated
the deepest secrets of the kabbalah.'
Will could see the rabbi was getting tired. And yet, Will
did not want to let their conversation end. In the last thirty
minutes he had got more answers than he had had in the
previous forty-eight hours. At last he understood not only
the barrage of clues that had arrived by text message, he now
could see the wider picture, the ancient story unfolding. Surely
this wise old man held the key to why Beth was a captive.
If only Will could think of the right question.
There was a buzzing sound, the low vibration of a cell
phone. TO, so used to wearing combat trousers with multiple
pockets, seemed flummoxed by the realization she was now
in a long, pocket-less skirt: she did not know where to look.
Eventually she remembered. She had borrowed a smart
leather handbag of Beth's - more grown-up than anything TO owned herself. The phone was in there. Mouthing an
apology, she stepped out of the room to answer it.
Will was scrambling to absorb everything he had just heard.
Wild theories about the end of the world, dire warnings of a
cataclysm foretold. He put his head in his hands. What on
earth was he caught up in here?
Suddenly there was a hand on his shoulder.

'It is a terrible thing for a man to be without his wife. Mrs Mandelbaum has been dead three years and I carry on with my life. I still study, I still pray. But if, occasionally, I dream of her at night - ahhh, now that's a shabbos.'
Will felt his eyes soaking with tears. To break the moment he cleared his throat and collected himself to ask a question. He did not know if it would help him find Beth, but he wanted to know everything he could. 'What counts as good? What counts as such a good deed that it marks you out as righteous?'
I'm not sure it's as simple as this. One has to think of the soul of the tzaddik. This is a soul of such purity, of such goodness,
that it cannot help but express itself. The deeds are
merely the outward manifestation of a goodness that is
within.' The rabbi began to haul himself out of his chair as
if on a book-hunting expedition. 'The key Hassidic text is
known as the Tanya. In that book, there is a definition of the tzaddik. It explains that in each person there are two souls:
a divine soul and an animal soul. The divine soul is where
we have our conscience, our urge to do good, our desire to
learn and study. The animal soul is where we have our
appetites, for food, for drink; lust. This is all from the animal
soul.
'Now, these two souls are usually in conflict. A good person
works hard to control his animal soul. To restrain his desires,
not to give into every longing. That's what it is to be a regular,
good person - to struggle!' He gave a creased smile, as if in
recognition of the frailty of man. 'But a tzaddik is different.
A tzaddik does not just tame his animal soul. He transforms it.
He changes his animal soul into something else, turning it
into a force for good. Now he is firing on two cylinders, so
to speak! It's as if he has two divine souls. This gives him a
special power. It equips him to save the world.'
'And would one act be enough?'
'How do you mean?'
'Well, if a man had performed one act of extraordinary
goodness, would that be enough to say he was a tzaddik.'
'Perhaps you have some example in mind, yes? My answer
is that it may seem to us as if the tzaddik performed just one
holy act. But remember, these men hide their goodness. The
truth may be that this is the only act we know about.'
'And what might such an act look like?'

'Ah, this is a good question. You know, in that story about Rabbi Abbahu and the man in the whorehouse--' 'The story from the third century?'

'Yes. In that story, the tzaddik has done something very small. I forget the details, but he makes some small sacrifice
to preserve the dignity of a woman.'
Will heard himself gulp. Just like Macrae.
'And this seems to be the common thread. Sometimes it
is an act on a very large scale--' Will thought of Chancellor
Curtis in London, diverting precious millions to the poor '-- perhaps a tzaddik will save an entire city from destruction.
Sometimes it is a tiny gesture to one individual: a meal when
they are hungry, a blanket when they are cold. In each case,
the tzaddik has treated a fellow human being justly and generously.'
'And
in that way, even a small gesture might redeem a
whole life?'
'Yes, Mr Monroe. The tzaddik may have lived as if he was
drenched in sin. Think of Chaim the Watercarrier, drinking
himself to oblivion. But those acts of righteousness, they
change the world.'
'So goodness is not about rules. Or wearing a hair shirt.
Or praying hard. Or knowing every word in the Bible. It's
about how we treat each other.'
'Being adam v'adam. Between man and man. That is where
goodness, even divinity resides. Not in the heavens, but right
here on earth. In our relations with each other. It also means
we have to be careful. We have to treat everyone we meet
with great respect because, for all we know, this man driving
a cab or sweeping the streets or begging on a street corner,
he might be one of the righteous.'
That's pretty egalitarian, isn't it?'
The rabbi smiled. 'The equal value of every human life.
This is the preoccupation of Torah. This is what Tova Chaya
studied each day at the seminary. And what she studied here
with me, before . . .' The rabbi looked wistful and, suddenly,
very old. He did not finish his sentence.
Will felt guilty. Not personally - he knew he was not to
blame for TO's leaving all those years ago. But he felt guilty
as - he struggled to articulate it - as a representative of the
modern world. That was it. It was modernity, America, that
had lured young Tova Chaya away from the routines and
rhythms that had shaped Jewish lives for centuries, whether
in rural Russia or Crown Heights. It was Manhattan, shimmering
glass buildings, K-ROC on the radio, tight-fitting jeans,
Domino's Pizza, blockbusters at the Cineplex, The Gap, HBO, Glamour magazine, Andy Warhol at MOMA, rollerblading in
Central Park, AmEx cards, one-click shopping, Columbia
University, sex outside marriage - it was all that that had
drawn TO away. How could the medieval conformity of
Hassidic life compete? The drabness of the clothes, the regimented
calendar, the countless limits - on what you could
eat, what you could study or read or draw, on who you could
love. No wonder TO had had to escape.
And yet, Will could see that TO had lost something by
leaving. He could hear it in Rabbi Mandelbaum's voice and
he had seen it in TO's eyes. He had experienced it for himself
in those few hours before he was grabbed and grilled on
Friday night. This place had something Will had hardly
known, either growing up in England or living as an adult
in America. The bland word for it was 'community'. People
fantasized about that often enough. Back home, the myth
of the English village, where everyone knows everyone else,
still exerted a powerful hold, though Will had never seen it
for real. In America, suburban picket-fence neighbourhoods
liked to think they were communities - with their car pools
and block parties - but they did not have what Will had seen
in Crown Heights.
Here, people were as involved with each other as one large,
extended family. An elaborate welfare system meant that
each provided for the other as if they were drawing from a
common pot. Children were in and out of each other's houses.
No one seemed to be strangers. TO had explained that the
claustrophobia could be choking: she had had to get out to
breathe. But she also described a warmth, a shared life, she had never known again.
Rabbi Mandelbaum had his head down, turning the pages of yet another book. 'There is one more thing. I don't know if this will be useful or not. According to several legends, one of these thirty-six men is even more special than the others.' 'Really? What kind of special?'
'One of these thirty-six is the Messiah.'
Will leaned forward. 'The Messiah?'
'"If the age were worthy of it, he would reveal himself as such." That's what the scholars say.'
'The candidate,' Will said softly.
'Someone explained this to you already?'
'TO told me that in every generation there is a candidate to be Messiah. If now were the Messianic time, then that man would be it. If it's not the time, then nothing happens.' 'We have to be worthy. Otherwise, the opportunity is lost.' Almost involuntarily, Will looked at the photographs of the Rebbe, gazing out from every wall and every angle. Dead more than two years, his eyes still shone.
'Exactly,' said Rabbi Mandelbaum, following Will's eyes. And the two men looked at each other.
The door opened. TO was standing there, clutching her phone. There was no colour in her face; her eyes were glassy, like an animal stunned for slaughter.
She bent down and whispered in Will's ear. 'The police are after me. I'm wanted for murder.'
CHAPTER FORTY-SIX

Monday, 2.20am, Darwin, Northern Australia
The music had stopped, that was why he had gone in. He kept this up throughout his shift, whether it was day or night
- tip-toeing into the room to take out the finished CD and replace it with a new one. The bedside cupboard was full of them, Schubert mainly, left there by the old man's daughter. The family had not asked Djalu to do it, but he knew it was what they wanted.
He put on the record. He could hear wailing from the next room along; he would have to be there in a second. But he wanted to stay a while with this resident, Mr Clark, the man who loved music. Djalu had only seen him awake for an hour or two each day; the sedative kept him asleep the rest of the time. But in those conscious minutes, Mr Clark seemed healed by the sounds of violins and cellos which uncoiled from the CD and into the room like stretches of fine thread. His aged lips parted as if to taste the melodies; his mouth sometimes made the same tiny movement even when he was in deep slumber.
Djalu would seize on those moments to take the small sponge, mounted on a stick, dip it into the bedside glass of water and brush it onto Mr Clark's mouth. The old man, nearly eighty-five, could no longer eat or drink, not without vomiting. So this was the only way to give him sustenance. He was dying, like so many of the people in this place, not from the disease that had assailed him for months but of starvation and eventual dehydration. Once it was clear that the patient could never be cured, the organs would be allowed to pack up, one by one until death finally arrived.
It seemed a cruel way to let a person die. Djalu's father denounced it as typical of 'white man's' medicine, all science and no spirit. Sometimes Djalu thought he was right; after all, he had seen some terrible things in this place. Old women lying in pools of their own urine; men crying out for hours to be helped to the toilet. Some of the nurses quickly lost patience, shouting at the residents, telling them to shut up. Or addressing them by their first names, as if they were babies.
In his first few months, Djalu had gone with the flow. He did not want to draw attention to himself, one of only two aborigine care assistants in the home. His position was hardly secure, not with a resume which included two spells in jail
- one for burglary, the other for shoplifting. So he said nothing when the senior staff would hear moans or screams from down the corridor - and would turn up the TV to drown out the noise.
Even now he said nothing. He made no complaints to the matron or the manager; he wanted no fuss and no hassle. Sometimes he even joined in the jokes about the 'crinkly old buggers'. But he did what he could.
So when he heard a resident crying out, he ran. He was part of what the nursing home called Team Red, responsible for about two dozen beds. But if he saw a light flashing for a resident in Blue or Green, he went anyway - often sneaking in, hoping none of the staff would see him. He made sure Mr Martyn sipped some water or that Miss Anderson was turned over. And if they had soiled themselves, he would clean them up, wiping them gently, afterwards stroking their hair, trying to soothe away their shame.
He heard how some of the residents referred to him. 'Matron, I don't want that boong touching me,' one had said when Djalu had first appeared at his bedside. 'It's wrong.' But Djalu put that down to their age. They did not know any better.
Mr Clark had not been much friendlier. 'Which one are you?' he had asked.
'Which one, Mr Clark?'
'Yes, there's that other abo, whatisname? Which one are you?' But Djalu could not feel angry, not with a man who was in the last days of his life. So he brought tea and biscuits when Mrs Clark visited; brought her a tissue when he found her quietly sobbing; and when she fell asleep in the chair by the bed, he draped a blanket over her.
Maybe his father was right that European medicine was a cold, metallic discipline. So he, Djalu, would give it a warm, human face - even if that face seemed to scare so many of these dying white folks.
This was his favourite time to work, late at night when he could have the corridor to himself. He would not need to explain his presence in the rooms, would not need to make up excuses for why he was reading the newspaper out loud to a woman on the second floor, not on the Red list, or simply holding the hand of a man who craved the touch of another human being.
So he jumped when he saw the door to Mr Clark's room creak open. The woman who came in had her finger to her lips, hushing Djalu. Her eyes were smiling, as if she were planning on giving Mr Clark a surprise and did not want Djalu to ruin it.
'Good evening, Djalu.'
'You gave me a fright. I didn't realize you were working tonight.'
'Well, you know death. It never sleeps.'
Djalu leapt to his feet. 'Did someone die tonight?'
'Not yet. But I expect it.'
'Who? Maybe I should--'
'Djalu, don't get excited. OK?' Calmly, the woman bent down and pulled out several of the CDs in the bedside cabinet, letting them fall to the floor.
'Hey, miss. That's Mr Clark's music. I'm looking after it--' 'Here it is.' She had reached behind the discs for what looked like a bandage. Now she lay it on the bed, on the square of mattress next to Mr Clark's chest, which was rising and falling like a set of bellows. The old man was fast asleep. She opened up the bandage, pulling one flap of material to the left, the other to the right, to reveal a hypodermic needle alongside a vial of clear serum.
'Is the doctor coming? No one told me.'
'No, the doctor is not coming.' She snapped on a pair of latex gloves.
'You giving Mr Clark a shot? What you doing?'
'I'll show you if you like. Come closer.'
'Don't hurt him.'
'Relax, Djalu. Now come over here and you can see. A bit closer.'
The woman held the needle up to the window, where it made a silhouette against the moonlight. 'Now, Djalu, if you can place your hands on Mr Clark's shoulders. That's it, just bend slightly.'
Cleanly, the woman jabbed the needle into Djalu's neck, her thumb pushing the plunger hard, sending the drug swimming into his veins within an instant. Djalu had a second to turn around, his face frozen in astonishment. A second later, he fell forward, landing heavily on Mr Clark's heaving chest. His killer had to use all her strength to haul Djalu off and lay him smoothly on the floor. She laid a blanket over him, stopping only to close his eyes with the palm of her hand. 'I apologize, Djalu Banggala, for what I have done. But I
have done it in the name of the Lord God Almighty. Amen.'
She packed the needle and the empty vial back into the
bandage, tucked it into her pocket and headed out, noiselessly.
Mr Clark did not stir. If he heard anything, it was only
music - the insistent strings of one of Schubert's most famous pieces. Death and the Maiden.
CHAPTER FORTY-SEVEN

Sunday, 10.10pm, Crown Heights, Brooklyn
TO was leading the way, fast and determined. She was not
to be diverted. She last walked these streets a decade ago,
but she had not forgotten where Rabbi Freilich lived.
Rushing to keep up, Will was firing out questions. But TO
was staring straight ahead. 'They found the body a couple of
hours ago. On the floor of my apartment. Apparently no one
realized he had gone missing till this morning.'
'Christ. How long do they think he'd been dead?'
'Since last night. He was killed in my apartment, Will.' TO's voice wavered for the first time.
Will thought of the super's face: the Garry Kasparov of the
basement. If he had been killed last night, it could only have
been minutes after he had helped Will and TO escape. That
was surely why he had been murdered. An image jumped into Will's mind. The man in the baseball cap.
First Yosef Yitzhok, now Pugachov. Two people who had
come to Will's aid had paid for it with their lives. Who would
be next? Rabbi Mandelbaum? Tom Fontaine?
Ever since Friday morning Will had felt as if he was falling
down a mineshaft, getting further and further away from the
light. He could see nothing clearly. The rabbi had explained
what was surely going on, but how on earth did it involve
him and Beth? What had they got to do with this mystical
prophecy, a kabbalistic legend which now appeared to be
fuelling an international killing spree? He was falling and
falling.
And just when he thought he had hit rock bottom - hearing
of the killing in Bangkok or of YY's death - he would fall
some more. Now Pugachov was dead and TO was in dire
trouble.
'Janey says the police knocked on every door, asking after
the occupant of Apartment 7. Thank God she was in. She
told them my name and said she hadn't seen me since
yesterday afternoon, which is good. Luckily, she was smart
enough to say she didn't know my cell number. They just
left and she phoned me right away, to give me a heads-up.'
'And they definitely regard you as the suspect?'
'Janey says she got that impression. Why else was the guy
in my apartment? Like, he went in there alive and now he's
dead. I'm gone. What else does it look like?'
TO was still striding forward, her breath forming instant
clouds. Her cheeks were beginning to glow. 'Apparently, they
asked lots of weird questions.'
'What kind of weird questions?'
'About me and Pugachov. Did we have a sexual relationship?
Was he obsessed with me? Was he a stalker?'
Now Will understood what the police were thinking.
Pugachov, the psycho super, gets himself into TO's apartment
after midnight. Tries to rape her. TO reaches for her gun, kills him and flees the scene. 'It won't take long for them to get your cell number. The
police must have access to all that.'
'Hence this.' TO held up the carcass of a cell phone, minus
its battery. Once the police had her number, they would doubtless
be able to track it. Will had covered a couple of investigations
where detectives reconstructed someone's movements
using phone records. These not only revealed the numbers
the suspect had dialled, but each time they had come within
range of a transmitter. Police could draw a map showing
where someone had been and when. Unless the phone was
completely without power: no signal, no trace.
'When did you last have it on?'
'Mandelbaum's.'
'It won't take them long to get there. Will he talk?'
TO slowed down and turned her eyes to meet Will's. 'I
don't know.'
They had come to Rabbi Freilich's house, no grander than
any of the others in Crown Street. The paint was peeling on
the front door, but that was not what Will noticed. Rather it
was the bumper sticker that had been placed just above eye level: Moshiach is coming. If these were student digs, it would not have looked incongruous.
But this was the home of a grown-up, a man of
standing. The sticker sent a tremor through Will. It said one
thing: fanatic.
TO had already knocked on the door and now Will could
hear movement. Through the opaque glass, he could see the
outline of a man's head and shoulders.
'Ver is? Vi haistu?'
Yiddish, Will imagined.
'S'is Tova Chaya Lieberman, Reb Freilich. I've come because of the great sakono.' 'Vos heyst?' What do you mean?
'Reb Freilich, a sakono fur die gantseh breeye.' The same warning she had given Rabbi Mandelbaum: a threat to all creation.
The door opened, to reveal the man Will had talked to at
some length but had never seen. He was neither tall, nor
physically commanding but his face had stern, firm features
which, Will could see, conveyed a quiet authority. His beard
was brown rather than white or grey and it was short and
well-kempt. He wore neat, rimless glasses. In a different
context, Will could see him as the CEO of a moderate-sized
American company. As he saw and recognized Will, he
hesitated, then gave a dip of the head, a gesture Will chose
to interpret as contrition.
'You'd better come inside.'
They were ushered once again around a dining table white
tablecloth, plastic sheet - in a room filled with holy
books. This room, though, was large, airy and tidy. In a
corner, Will spotted a pile of editions of The New York Times. He could also see a magazine rack stuffed with the Atlantic
Monthly, The New Republic and a variety of Hebrew newspapers. Making the instant assessment that was part of his
trade, Will wrote a four-word headline in his head to describe
Rabbi Freilich: Man of the World.
'Rabbi, you know Will Monroe.'
'We've met.'
'I know how strange this must seem, Rabbi Freilich, me
turning up like this after all these years. I promise you, I
never thought I'd come back, truly I didn't. But Will is an
old friend of mine. And he asked for my help when his wife
went missing. He didn't know about my . . . my background.'
She paused, to collect herself. 'But now we know what's
going on. We've pieced it together. It's taken some time and
it's not been easy but we are certain.'
Rabbi Freilich held TO's gaze and said nothing.
'Good men are dying. First it was Howard Macrae in
Brownsville, then Pat Baxter in Montana. Then Samak
Sangsuk in Bangkok. And now this British politician. Someone
is killing the lamadvavniks, aren't they, Rabbi? Someone is
killing the righteous of the earth.'
'Yes, Tova Chaya. I'm afraid they are.'
Will drew breath, a tiny gasp. He had expected a battle
with Freilich, a round of game-playing as the rabbi played
dumb, forcing TO and Will to produce all their evidence. But
he was denying nothing. A dread thought surfaced. What if
the rabbi had already realized that these two had indeed
exposed his murderous plot and had therefore decided there
was no alternative but to silence them? They would have
walked straight into his hands! No need for the man in the
baseball cap, Pugachov's killer: Will and TO had done his job
for them. How could they have been so stupid? They had
not even planned a strategy for this encounter. TO had just
stormed over there . . .
'A plot is indeed underway to murder the thirty-six hidden
just men. For some reason, this plot is taking place now,
during the Ten Days of Penitence - the holiest time of the
year. The killing started on Rosh Hashana and it has not
stopped. Whoever is behind this must have decided that these
are the judgment days, that a righteous man murdered in
this period will not be instantly replaced by the birth of
another. Perhaps they have seen something in our texts we
never saw, the existence of a kind of limbo period between
the New Year, when people are inscribed in the Book of Life,
and the Day of Atonement, when the Book of Life is sealed.
During these ten days maybe the world is especially vulnerable. Whatever their reasoning, they have set out to kill the lamad vav and they seem determined to do it by sunset
tomorrow, by the end of Yom Kippur.' He faltered. 'I didn't
think anyone else would find out.' He turned towards Will,
though not quite meeting his eyes. 'Tova Chaya was always
an exceptional student. And you, you have shown admirable
persistence.'
Thanks for nothing, thought Will.
'We have known about it only for a few days. But I tremble
for the world at the very thought of it. Some will say this is
only a legend, only a fairy story. But it has deep roots, ones
that go back to Avraham Avinu, to Abraham our father. It has
endured for millennia. Whoever is doing this is gambling that
the story is just a story. That it is not a true statement about
the way the world has worked since the beginning of time.
But what if they are wrong? They are testing this idea to
destruction. It will be the destruction of everything.' The rabbi
was drumming his fingers on the table. If he was faking anxiety, thought Will, he was doing a very good job.
'You keep saying they,' Will said suddenly, his confidence
taking even himself aback. 'But I'm not sure there is a they. I think there's a you.' 'I don't understand.'

'Oh, I think you do, Rabbi Freilich. So far there are no
suspects in any of these cases, except you and your, your . . .
followers.' He knew it was the wrong word. The only leader
these people followed was the man whose photograph hung
on every wall. And he was dead. 'You more or less admitted
killing Samak Sangsuk to me.' The muscle around the rabbi's
left eye gave a slight twitch. 'And I know you are holding
my wife, though what she has to do with any of this still no
one has explained to me.' On those last words, he had raised
his voice, betraying an anger he could not conceal. He stopped,
to bring himself back under control. 'The only people we know have been engaged in criminal activity are you and the
people who work with you.'
'I can see how it looks.'
'So can I. And I'm sure the police, who have you in their
sights already, would get the picture very quickly if they knew
half of what we know. I don't think I need to mention Mr
Pugachov, the super at TO's, sorry, Tova Chaya's, building, do
I? Killed last night by that goon in a baseball cap you had
chasing us?'
'I'm sorry, I don't know what you're talking about.'
'Oh, come on. We really can't play these games much
longer, Rabbi. Don't you see? We know what's going on.'
'Will, that's enough.' It was TO, speaking in her normal accent.
'I have no idea about any Mr Pugachov. And I know nothing
of any man in a baseball cap.'
'I don't believe this. This is ridiculous! You sent a man to
follow me yesterday. We saw him, we got away and the man
who helped us is now lying dead in her apartment.' He could
hardly bring himself to use the name Tova Chaya again. It
sounded strange enough the first time.
'Will, please.' TO was imploring him to stop. But he could
not help himself. The pressure of the last few days had been
coiled up for too long.
The rabbi's face was tensing. 'I promise you, I know of no
man in a baseball cap. I did not send anyone to follow you.
I have not lied to you. Not once. When you confronted me
about the man in Bangkok, I did not deny it. I told you that
a terrible mistake had occurred. When we,' he paused for the
right word, 'met on erev shabbos - excuse me - when we met
on Friday night, I even conceded that we are indeed holding
your wife. I have not lied. And I am telling you the truth
now: what you tell me happened in Tova Chaya's building
was nothing to do with me.'
'So who do you think did it, then? Eh? If you didn't kill
that man, who did?'
'I don't know. Which should worry you infinitely more. It
suggests that whoever is behind this dreadful scheme is now
aware of you.'
'Rabbi Freilich, I think you have to tell us what's going
on.' TO was sounding like Tova Chaya again. 'You know
things, we know things. We all know time is running out. It
is already the Day of Judgment. Whoever is doing this wants
to finish the job before the Ten Days of Penitence are over.
We don't have time to fight each other. So far, handling this
alone, what have you done? Have you stopped the killing?'
The rabbi had his head bowed, his right palm flat on his
forehead. It moved up onto his scalp, tucking under his
yarmulke, and back down again. Whatever TO was saying, it was striking a nerve. The man looked weighed down with
worry. He muttered a barely audible 'no'.
TO sat forward, trying to close the deal. 'The killing is still going on. In twenty-four hours they might have killed the last of the lamadvavniks. And who knows what will happen then. You can't do this alone. We can help you and you have to help us. You must do it. For the sake of HaShem.' For the sake of the Name, for the sake of God himself. It was the ultimate argument, the one no believer could refuse. Was TO deploying it because she knew which buttons to press? Or was Tova Chaya speaking sincerely, genuinely fearing for the sake of the world if they did not act? Will was not sure. But if he had to guess one way or the other he would, to his great surprise, declare for the latter. For all her scepticism, for all her ten years away from Crown Heights, for all her bacon breakfasts and body piercings, she was not acting merely to find Will's wife, nor even for the sake of the remaining righteous men. At that moment Will realized that TO was driven by nothing less than fear for the fate of the world.
'Tova Chaya, we have so little time.' Rabbi Freilich was looking up. He had removed his glasses, revealing a face etched in anguish. 'We have tried everything. I don't know what more there is you can do. But I will tell you what we know.'
Unexpectedly, he rose to his feet and made for the front door. He put on his trilby and his coat and, without another word, gestured for TO and Will to follow him.

Outside was a quiet Will had never experienced in a city. The streets were desolate. No cars travelled because the Yom Kippur restrictions prohibited all driving. A few knots of young men walked together, wearing their prayer shawls. Even though the evening was warm and people were out together, the atmosphere was not festive. Instead Crown Heights seemed to be under a blanket of contemplation and silent thought; it was as if the whole neighbourhood was a single, roofless synagogue. Will felt grateful for his costume, so that he could move through this extraordinary atmosphere without breaking the spell.
They were, Will now understood, moving towards the synagogue. Once again, he wondered if he and TO were walking voluntarily into the wolf's lair - with the wolf as their guide.
But they did not go inside the main entrance. Instead they entered a building next door, one that seemed entirely out of place in this neighbourhood. It looked like a redbrick annexe to an Oxford college, ancient by New York standards. Outside were crowds of men, spilling out from the lobby. They did not have to wade through the throng: people stepped out of the way the moment they recognized the rabbi. Will could see some raised eyebrows. He assumed they were directed at him, a face they did not know. But when he saw TO looking down at her feet, he understood: they were shocked to see a woman in this usually male terrain.
TO managed to whisper an explanation. They were entering the Rebbe's house. This was the home the late leader had lived in and which had doubled as his office.
Will stared. He had been here before, forty-eight hours earlier.
Soon they had reached a staircase. The crowds were thinning now. They moved up another flight, to a corridor empty of people. Straight into his trap, thought Will.
Rabbi Freilich led them through one door, which revealed another. But he did not go in. Instead he turned around, to offer an explanation to TO.
'I want you to know that what you are about to see is a mark of our desperation. It is a violation of Yom Kippur that has never before occurred in this building and, please God, will never happen again. We are doing it for--'
'Pikuach nefesh.' TO had interrupted him. 'I know. It is a matter of saving lives.'
The rabbi nodded, grateful to TO for her understanding. Then he turned around, breathing in sharply through his nostrils as if bracing himself for the secret he was about to reveal. Only then did Rabbi Freilich dare open the door. CHAPTER FORTY-EIGHT

Sunday, 11.01pm, Crown Heights, Brooklyn
This place, Will realized, would normally be still on such a
holy evening: no lights on, no machines in use, no phones
answered, no eating, no drinking. Even Will could tell that
the scene before him was an act of mass sacrilege.
It looked like the control room of a police station. Perhaps
a dozen people at computers, surrounded by in-trays spilling
over with paper and, on a back wall, a large wipe-board,
covered with names, phone numbers, addresses. Down one
side, Will could see a list of names. In a quick scan, he spotted
Howard Macrae and Gavin Curtis - a line through each of
them.
'No one knows about this room apart from the men working
in it - and now you. We have been working in here day and
night for a week. And today we lost the man who knew it
best, the man who set it up.'
'Yosef Yitzhok,' said Will, noticing a pile of maps - one of
them for Montana - and a stack of guide books, for London, for Copenhagen, for Algiers.
'All of this was his work. And today he was murdered.'
'Rabbi Freilich?' It was TO. 'Do you think you could start
at the beginning?'
The rabbi led them to the front of the room, where a desk had been set out as if for a teacher to invigilate an exam. The three of them sat around it.
'As you know, the Rebbe in his later years spoke often about Moshiach, about the Messiah. He gave long talks at our weekly farbrengen touching on this theme. Tova Chaya will also know how we preserved those talks for posterity.' TO took her cue. 'Because he spoke on the sabbath, the Rebbe could not be tape-recorded or filmed. That's not allowed. So we relied on an ancient system. In the synagogue would be three or four people chosen for their amazing memories. They would stand just a few yards away from the Rebbe, usually with their eyes closed, listening to every word, memorizing what he said. Then, the minute the sabbath was over
they would gather together and kind of spew out their memories, while one of them would scribble it all down. They
would get it out of their heads as quickly as they could. While they were doing it, they would check what they remembered against each other, adding a word here, correcting a word there. I can still picture it: these guys were incredible. They could listen to a three-hour speech by the Rebbe and recite it off by heart. They were called choyzers, literally "returners". The Rebbe would say it, they would play it back. They were human tape recorders.'
'And, Tova Chaya, do you remember who was the most brilliant choyzer of them all?'
TO's eyes suddenly widened, as a long-buried memory came back. 'But he was just a boy.'
'It's true. But he became a choyzer soon after he had reached the age of Bar Mitzvah. He was just thirteen when he began relaying the words of the Rebbe. He had a special gift.' Freilich faced Will. 'We are speaking about Yosef Yitzhok.'
'He could memorize whole speeches, just like that?'
'He always said he could not memorize whole speeches. Only the words of the Rebbe. When the Rebbe spoke, he would make himself, his own thoughts, disappear. He would try to insert himself into the mind of the Rebbe, to become an extension of him. That was his technique. No one else could do it the way he could. The Rebbe had a special affection for him.' Rabbi Freilich rolled back into his seat, his eyes closed. Will could only guess, but this grief looked genuine.
'As I said, in the last few years, the Rebbe began to speak more and more about Moshiach. Telling us to prepare for the coming of Messiah, reminding us that Messiah was a central belief in Judaism. That it was not some abstract, remote point of theology but that it was real. He wanted us to believe it, that Moshiach could be with us in the here and now. 'No one knew this teaching of the Rebbe's better than Yosef Yitzhok. He heard it week after week. But it was more than hearing. It was absorbing. He was ingesting this material, taking it into himself. And then, in the last days of the Rebbe, Yosef Yitzhok - who was a brilliant scholar in his own right noticed something.
'He thought back to all the talks the Rebbe had given on the theme of the Messianic age and he discerned a pattern. Very often the Rebbe would quote a pasuk--'

'A verse.'
'Thank you, Tova Chaya. Yes, the Rebbe would quote a
verse from Deuteronomy. Tzedek, tzedek tirdof.'
'Justice, justice shall you pursue,' TO murmured.
'The English translation the books give is, "Follow justice
and justice alone, so that you may live and possess the land
the Lord your God is giving you". But it was that word, tzedek, that caught Yosef Yitzhok's attention. To use it so often, and
always in the same context. It was as if the Rebbe was
reminding us of something.'
'He wanted you to remember the tzaddikim. The righteous
men.'
'That's what Yosef Yitzhok thought. So he went back
through the texts, examining them intensely. And that's how he saw something else, something even more intriguing.' Will leaned forward, his eyes boring into the rabbi's. In close proximity to the quotation - tzedek, tzedek tirdofhe would offer another quotation. Not the same one every time, but from the same two sources. Either he would cite the Book of Proverbs--'
'Chapter ten?'
'Yes, Mr Monroe. Chapter ten. That's right. You knew all this already?'
'Think of it as an informed guess. Don't let me interrupt you; please, continue.'
'Well, as you say, the Rebbe would either quote a verse from Proverbs, Chapter 10, or he would quote from the prophets. Specifically, Isaiah, Chapter 30. Now that got Yosef Yitzhok very excited. Because kabbalists know one important thing about Isaiah, Chapter 30, Verse 18. It ends with the word lo, the Hebrew for "for him". The full phrase is "blessed are all they who wait for Him". But the real significance of the word--'
'--is the way it is spelled.'
'Tova Chaya has beaten me to it. The word lo is made up of two characters, Mr Monroe. Lamad and vav. It spells thirty six. Now the Rebbe was a careful speaker. He did not say things by accident. He did not pull quotations out of the air. Yosef Yitzhok was convinced there was a deliberate intent. 'So he went through every transcript. And, sure enough, the Rebbe spoke of tzedek, followed immediately by a verse from one of those two chapters, thirty-five times. By that method, he left us with thirty-five different verses.' 'But--'
'I know what you're thinking, Mr Monroe, and you are right. There are thirty-six righteous men. We'll come to that. For the moment, Yosef Yitzhok has thirty-five verses, staring at him from the page. He wonders what they could mean. And then he remembers the stories that children like him and like you, Tova Chaya, were raised on. Stories of the founder of Hassidism, the Baal Shem Tov; stories of Rabbi Leib Sorres.'
Then of such greatness, they were privileged to know the whereabouts of the righteous men.' Will looked at Tova Chaya as she spoke: she had, he was sure, worked it all out. 'Exactly. Few men knew the mind of the Rebbe as intimately as Yosef Yitzhok, and he also knew the Rebbe's worth. He knew that he was one of the great men of Hassidic history. Some of the very greatest had been let in on this divine secret. It was not absurd to imagine the Rebbe would be one of them.'
'So Yosef Yitzhok reckoned the Rebbe knew who the thirty six were. And he goes further: he thinks these thirty-five verses he quoted are clues to their identity?'
'Exactly, Will. Yosef Yitzhok has this thought in the very closing days of the Rebbe's life, when the Rebbe is too ill to answer any questions. He can barely speak.'
'So what does he do?'
'He stares at the thirty-five verses for days on end. He is sure the Rebbe wants them to be understood, that he is passing this information on for a reason. So he is determined to break them open, so to speak, to find out what is inside. He looks at them from every angle. He translates the letters into numeric values; he adds; he multiplies. He reproduces them as anagrams. But of course there is a logical problem. 'How could the identities of the righteous men be contained in those verses? The identities change in every generation. Yet the verses stay stubbornly the same. Even if, say, verse twenty included the name of tzaddik number twenty for this year, where would we find the name of tzaddik number twenty for the year 2020 or 2050 or, in the past, 1950 and 1850? How could the names of men who are alive today be concealed in a text that remains static?
'And that's when Yosef Yitzhok's remarkable powers truly
shone through. He remembered the answer.'
'You mean the Rebbe had already told him?'
'Not directly, of course. But the Rebbe had given him the
answer. Yosef Yitzhok had heard it. All he needed to do was
to remember it. And do you know what it was? It was the
last line of the last talk at the last farbrengen the Rebbe ever
addressed. "Space depends on time. Time reveals space". Those
were his last words in public'
There was a pause.
'Incredible,' said TO.
'You've lost me, I'm afraid,' said Will, suddenly the dunce
of the class.
'Don't worry. Yosef Yitzhok was baffled too. These were
beautiful sentences. But they were an enigma. Space depends
on time. Time reveals space. What does that mean? That's when
Yosef Yitzhok came to me, letting me in on his theory. The
Rebbe often spoke in riddles, in elliptical sentences that might
take many hours - many years even - to study and interpret.
Yosef Yitzhok spent a long night working away at these
sentences. And then he had what you would call a brainwave
and what I would call a helping hand from HaShem.
'You may know that the Rebbe was a very close follower of
science and technology. He read Scientific American and Nature and a whole variety of journals. He was always up to date on
the latest developments, in neuroscience, in biochemistry. But
he had a special interest in technology. He loved gadgets! He
never owned them: he was the least materialistic man you
could ever know. But he liked to know about them.
'Yosef Yitzhok knew that about the Rebbe. And that's what
gave him his idea. Here, I'll show you.'
Rabbi Freilich reached for a worn, leather-bound book and
thumbed rapidly through the pages. He found the page and
then the verse he was looking for.
'Now what is the year?'
Will was about to answer when TO got there first. 'Five
thousand seven hundred and sixty-eight.'
Will frowned. 'What?'
'It's the Hebrew calendar,' TO explained. 'It dates back to
creation. Jews believe the world has been in existence for
less than six thousand years.'
'OK,' said the rabbi. 'The year is 5768. And here is a verse
from Chapter 10 of the Book of Proverbs. In fact this is a
crucial verse. Verse 18. This is what Yosef Yitzhok tried out.
We count along the line and mark the fifth letter.' The rabbi's
finger stopped at the selected character. 'Then the seventh
from there.' It stopped again. 'Then the sixth from there. And
then the eighth. You see: 5-7-6-8. And we keep doing that
till we get to the end of the line. So in this case, the fifth
letter is a yud. The seventh letter after that is a hay. The sixth
is a mem. And the eighth is also a mem. You keep on like that until you have a string of letters.'
'Which then convert into numbers.' Will was guessing.
'Precisely so. A string of numbers. Here, I'll show you one
of the very earliest ones Yosef Yitzhok worked out.'
The rabbi stood up, leading Will and TO over to a second
wipe-board. There, neatly written in a black marker pen, was
a long series of digits: 699331, 5709718, 30.
'Don't tell me that's a phone number.'
'No, it is not. We wondered about that, too. We even tried
a few. No, this is where the Rebbe's eye for the latest advances
in technology was so important.'
TO was staring at the figure, as if the sheer penetration of
her gaze would crack it open.
'It is--' and at this the rabbi could not deny himself a little
smile of amused pride, as if he had still not got over the brilliance
of it all '--a GPS number. Or rather, contained in this
number are the co-ordinates of longitude and latitude that give
you a GPS number, co-ordinates for the Global Positioning
System.'
'I don't believe it,' said Will. 'You mean that whole satellite navigation thing?' It sounded preposterous.
'That's it. A system that maps the entire globe, watched from space, and which gives precise co-ordinates for any spot on earth. The Rebbe must have read about it. Or maybe he just knew.'
'You're telling me that contained in those thirty-five biblical verses are the co-ordinates for thirty-five righteous men?' 'We did not believe it either, Mr Monroe. One verse gave us a number for a remote hillside in Montana: according to the map, nobody lived there. But we sent the man who runs our centre in Seattle to take a closer look and he saw a log cabin. With a man inside, living alone. Like something from our folk tales, Tova Chaya: a simple man in the forest.' Pat Baxter, thought Will. The very cabin he had gazed at just a few days ago.
'Another number was an empty space in the middle of the Sudan. Again, no one was meant to live there. But then we saw from satellite pictures that a refugee camp had sprung up on that spot during the last few months, saving people who were fleeing for their lives. It was maintained by one man: the international agencies were not even sure who he was. So we began to realize that we were right. That the Rebbe was right.'
'What about this number?' asked Will, pointing at the wipe-board. 'What did this come out as?'
'I'll show you.' The rabbi walked the few paces to where one of the young men was working away at a computer. TO and Will caught up, watching the technician over his shoulder. The rabbi pointed at the number on the wipe-board and murmured an instruction.
The young man punched in the digits, waited a few seconds and then watched as the computer came back with an answer. 10 Downing Street, London, SW1 2AB, UK.
'So this was the verse for Gavin Curtis?'
The rabbi nodded.
Will needed to sit down and, ideally, drink something.
Though nothing was around. These men would use computers
and work hard, even though it was Yom Kippur, because lives
were at stake. Pikuach nefesh. But they would break no rules
they did not have to.
Now TO was speaking. 'So that was what the Rebbe was trying to say. Space depends on time. Time reveals space. The location
depends on time. If you know the time, the year - if
you use the number 5678 - then you will know the space.
You'll work out the location.' She was shaking her head in
wonder at the ingenuity of it. 'And I suppose if you try the
same verses with different years, you get different places.
Different people.'
'Well, our texts are good at guarding their secrets, Tova
Chaya. Yosef Yitzhok wanted to do as you say. He worked
with people here to devise a computer programme, to do
what we just did with that one verse: stopping at every fifth
or seventh character. He did it for different years. And then
he ran it through the GPS system and, sure enough, he
started getting place names. But what use is a place name,
Kabul or Mainz, for 1735? How are we to know who lived there then? Besides, Yosef Yitzhok always wondered if that
was too easy.'
'If what was too easy?'
'He wasn't sure it would necessarily be the same verses for
all time. Those were the verses the Rebbe had mentioned for his generation. But maybe the other great sages who had
somehow been let in on this secret in the past - the Baal
Shem Tov or Rabbi Leib Sorres - maybe they knew of the
righteous men of their time in a different way. They didn't
have this GPS, did they? This method wouldn't have made
much sense to them, would it? They would have had their
own ways - different verses, or maybe a different method
entirely.
This, I now realize, is what lay behind the Rebbe's interest
in technology. I think he understood that even the most
enduring, ancient truths could outwardly change very fast,
that they would find new forms. Hassidim had to know about
the modern world, because this too is HaShem's creation. He
is found here, too.'
Will and TO were silent. Awestruck, even: it was not just
the lives of the thirty-six that were keeping Rabbi Freilich
working around the clock, even now on the solemnest night
of the Jewish year, when all work was prohibited. This man,
who spoke with erudition and in calm, rational paragraphs,
clearly believed he had less than twenty-four hours to save
the world. Will tried to blot that out, to focus on his own,
immediate need: Beth.
'OK,' he said, like a police captain calling his squad to
order. 'So that's how the system works. The crucial question
is, who else knows about this? Who else might know the
identity of the righteous men?'
By now they were back at the table, where the rabbi had
all but fallen into his chair. Will could see the exhaustion in
his face.
'You were our best hope.'
'I'm sorry?'
'When you came here on shabbos. On Friday night. We
thought you were some kind of spy. From the people who
are doing this, I mean. You were asking questions, you were
an outsider. Maybe you were trying to find out about the lamad vav. That's why we, why I, treated you so harshly. Then
we discovered you were--' Will could see the rabbi did not
want to name him as the husband of their hostage '--you
were something else.'
Will could feel the anger rising within him again. Why did
he not just shake this man and force him to reveal where
Beth was? Why was he putting up with this? Because, a voice
inside him began, if these people were fanatical enough to
kidnap Beth for no apparent reason, they were fanatical enough to hold on to her. Rabbi Freilich might have looked weak and exhausted, but there were a dozen men in here who were stronger. If Will lunged, they would soon have him pinned down.
'All right, so it's not me. Who else knows?'
The rabbi sunk lower. 'That's just it. No one knows. No one outside this community. And not even this community has any idea what's going on: there would be mass panic if they did. If they knew that the lamadvavniks are being murdered, every day more of them killed, there would be chaos here. They would believe the end of the world was coming.'
'You believe that, don't you?' It was said in Tova Chaya's gentlest voice.
The rabbi looked up at her, his eyes wet. 'I fear that what the Rebbe spoke of is coming to pass. Di velt shokelt zich und treiselt zich. That's what he used to say, Tova Chaya. The world is trembling and shaking. I fear for what judgement this day is about to bring upon us.'
Will was pacing. 'So no one outside this small group has any idea of this. Just you, Yosef Yitzhok and a few of your best students.'
'And now you.'
'And you're sure no one breathed a word?'
'To whom? Who even knew about this whole subject? Why would anyone ask? But when Yosef Yitzhok was found dead. Well, then
'Then, what?'
'It confirmed that somebody knows what we know and wanted to know more. until then, I thought maybe it was a strange coincidence that the tzaddikim were dying. Maybe this was the work of HaShem, for a purpose beyond our understanding. But Yosef Yitzhok being murdered, that's not a plan
of HaShem's.'
'You think someone was pressing him for information?' 'Just before you came tonight, I had a visit. The police. They think Yosef Yitzhok was tortured before he was killed.' Will and TO both recoiled.
'What did they want from him that they didn't know already?'
'Ah, this you tried to ask me about before. Remember, I told you about the verses the Rebbe quoted in his talks? The ones Yosef Yitzhok had memorized? Well, there was something missing.'
'There were only thirty-five.'
'That's right. Only thirty-five. You can use the method I just showed you, converting letters into numbers and turning those numbers into co-ordinates, but you would still have only thirty-five righteous men. Isn't it obvious what the men who killed Yosef Yitzhok wanted to know? They wanted the identity of number thirty-six.'
CHAPTER FORTY-NINE

Sunday, 11.18pm, Crown Heights, Brooklyn
Will's first impulse was to ask Rabbi Freilich the name of this thirty-sixth man. It was crucial. If he and TO knew that, they could work out where the killers were heading next: whoever he was, they were bound to be on his trail.
But the rabbi would not budge. For one thing, he said, the death of Yosef Yitzhok suggested the murderers were still not in possession of this vital fact. Had YY cracked under torture? The rabbi was convinced he had not. 'I know this man. His intellect, his soul. He would not betray the word of the Rebbe.'
He was sure the secret was safe. If he shared it with TO and Will, it could only bring harm to them. Better that they did not know. (Will was sceptical: if the torturers came after him, they were hardly likely to inquire politely whether he had any useful information and then, once assured he did not, beat a polite retreat.)
Will tried' another approach. 'This thirty-sixth righteous man? Is he still alive?'
'We think so. But I really will not say any more, Mr Monroe. I cannot say any more.'
'Is he the only one alive?'
'We're not certain. Our sources of information are very patchy. We have had to scramble people to the furthest corners of the world to find these tzaddikim. Each time we have been getting there too late.'
'You mean, you didn't work out these names until this week?'
'No, Yosef Yitzhok made this breakthrough a few months ago. And, as I told you, we sent people to take a look, just to see who these tzaddikim were. We planned to keep an eye on them, no more. Maybe give them food or money if they were in trouble. But, to answer your question, we did not know they were dying until this week. We're not sure, but it only seems to have started a few days ago.'
'On Rosh Hashana,' said TO, her mind turning over visibly. 'That's when Howard Macrae was murdered.'
'I'm afraid we didn't know about that until days after it happened. When the news about the others started coming through. Was it even in the papers?'
'Yes,' said Will, pushing the air out of his nostrils in a sound of wry resignation. 'It was in the papers.' That was the trouble with page B3 of Metro; people could sail right past it. 'Anyway, it was the high holy days. We were not reading the newspapers. We were living our lives. We had no idea anything was happening. But then some of our people started hearing things. Our emissary in Seattle saw the cabin he had visited on the television news. The man who runs our centre in Chennai was reading through the local paper when he saw that the tzaddik in that town - one of our youngest - had been found dead. One report after another.'
'How many have gone?'
'We don't know. Remember, Yosef Yitzhok only began working on this a few months ago. Our list was barely complete; we hadn't been able to confirm everyone. This man, for example--' the rabbi gestured back towards the wipe-board with the Chancellor's number on it '--it took us a long time to find him. It turns out the GPS system is slightly different there, in England; it takes a different key. The WGS84 datum, apparently. We didn't know that then, so when Yosef Yitzhok first ran the numbers, they indicated, of all things, a prison. A Belmarsh jail. It seemed unlikely. But we didn't dismiss such a possibility. We know the tzaddikim delight in concealing their true nature.
'But when we readjusted the figures the result was instant. Downing Street! And not the famous house, Number Ten. But the house next door. The map was very clear. At the time, this man, Curtis, was in some trouble. A scandal, I think. Another disguise.'
Will was getting impatient. Enough lectures, he thought. He wanted simple, hard facts - stripped of their mystical overtones. 'So, sorry, I just want to be clear on this. Do you have
the full list or not?'
'We think we do.'
'And of those, how many are dead?'
'We think at least thirty-three.'
'Jesus!'
'You mean, they may only have to kill three more people? It's nearly midnight now. Yom Kippur ends in about nineteen hours!' TO, usually so calm, sounded genuinely panicked. 'Rabbi, whoever's doing this seems to be pretty clued up on Jewish religious custom, wouldn't you say?' Will began. 'I mean, who else but religious Jews know all this stuff about the righteous men, about the Days of Awe? They're
following it all to the letter. And you say that no one
outside this very small group even knew of Yosef Yitzhok's discovery.'
'What are you saying, Mr Monroe?'
'I'm saying, Rabbi, that you may not be behind this, despite the fact that I know you're a proven kidnapper. But somebody inside this . . . organization or community or whatever it is, almost certainly is. I reckon this is what the police would call an inside job. If I were you, I'd start looking at the people here very closely.'
'Mr Monroe, it's late and time is running out. I don't have the time or the strength to start fighting you. What Tova Chaya said before is right: we need to work together. So I'm going to trust you, even if you cannot trust me. I'm going to let you do something that will prove we are not behind this terrible wickedness.'
'Go on.'
'I'm going to send you to the next victim.'
CHAPTER FIFTY

Monday, 12.10am, Manhattan
Will had been to the Lower East Side a few times, to visit friends chic and savvy enough to buy up and renovate properties in the now-gentrified pockets north of East Broadway. He had seen the old-time delis, drunk coffee in the retro-chic cafes on Orchard Street. But he had not wandered beyond the safely fashionable areas. He had glided past the old tenement buildings, seeing them as cinematic backdrop. He had never looked properly.
Now he was among them, shivering from cold and exhaustion in the night air. Scrunched in his hand, safely hidden inside his pocket, was the scrap of paper with the address he was meant to find.
Rabbi Freilich had led Will and TO back to the computer whiz who had given them the earlier demonstration. He talked them through the process. First, feed the computer the Hebrew sentence: Verse 16 of Isaiah 30. Then ask it to stop at the right intervals, and it will spit out a number. Feed that number through the GPS websites and you get co-ordinates for a place: a specific address on a specific street on the Lower East Side in Manhattan.
'Hang on a minute,' Will had said. 'Isn't this a bit unlikely? You've got thirty-six righteous men out of six billion people on the planet - and two are in New York? Howard Macrae and now this guy? It sounds a bit convenient to me.' It had not yet congealed into a full allegation, but Will's scepticism was turning into suspicion.
The rabbi explained that they too had wondered at such a coincidence. But then they had read deeper into Hassidic folklore. It turned out a truly great tzaddik radiated a 'glow'
- the same word Rabbi Mandelbaum had used - that might draw in others. Their calculated guess was that the Rebbe's goodness had been so powerful that a couple of tzaddikim had been pulled near. Think of them as satellites,' the rabbi had said.
But there was a problem. The address now balled up in Will's fist was an apartment building, home to dozens of people. Which one was the tzaddik? The Hassidim had gone down there once to check it out soon after Yosef Yitzhok had first cracked the Rebbe's code, but they had not been able to identify him. The man in this building remained one of the most hidden of the hidden righteous men.
'You will have a better chance of finding him than us,'
Freilich had said.
'Why?'
'Look at us, Mr Monroe. We cannot go where you go, we cannot ask what you can ask. We are too visible. You are a reporter from The New York Times. You can go where you like and talk to anybody. You found Mr Macrae, zechuso yogen aleinu, and Mr Baxter, zechuso yogen aleinu.' May his righteousness protect us. 'Find this man. Go find our tzaddik.'
So shortly before midnight, Will took off his skullcap and went back out into the world. As he set off, TO decided to do the same.
'I'm going to call the police. I can't hide from them forever. We've done what we needed to do.'
'What will you say?'
'That my phone's been dead all day and I've only just heard
what happened. Wish me luck. Or at least visit me in jail.'
'This is so not a joke.'
'I know. But you can see what it looks like: a dead man
in my apartment and I'm AWOL. I might be charged with
murder by the morning.'
'This is all my fault. I sucked you into this insane mess.'
'No, you didn't. You asked for my help. I could have said
no. I knew what I was getting into.'
'Did you?'
'Not really, no.'
And with that, Will leaned over to give TO a kiss on the
cheek - only for her to pull back the moment he came close.
There was a magnetic field of resistance around her face. Of
course. She was not allowed to touch a man, let alone be
kissed by one, not in the heart of Crown Heights. Will made
do with a plain goodbye.
Now watching his breath form clouds before him, Will
turned the corner so that he was at Montgomery and Henry.
Behind him was a small triangle of park. In front, the tenement
building he was looking for. He held back, wanting
to gaze at it a while. He could see one, two, three lights still
on.
Now what? He had barely considered what he would do
once he got here. He could not exactly start knocking on
doors, claiming to be doing a vox pop for The New York Times after midnight. What could he do?
He would have to get into the building. That would be a
start. Then he could look at the mail boxes, get some names,
Google a few of them on his BlackBerry. He would think of
something. '
Oh, good. Someone coming out. Perfect: that would give him his chance to slip in. Except this person was moving too fast,
almost running. It was hard to make him, or her, out; it was
too dark and the light above the entrance too dim. But when
he stepped forward, looking nervously left and right, Will saw enough.
Most striking was the piercing brightness of his eyes, a chill, glassy blue. But it was the posture Will recognized. A physical confidence, as if this man was used to using his body. The clothes were slightly changed, but there was no mistaking him - with or without his baseball cap.
CHAPTER FIFTY-ONE

Monday, 12.13am, Manhattan
Will's first instinct was to observe. He was used to watching,
seeing how things unfolded. So it took a beat and then another
before Will realized that he could not just watch. He would
have to stalk the stalker.
He was wary. Hardly anyone was around; he would be
noticed. So he kept far back, walking as quietly as he could.
He cursed the black leather shoes he was wearing: they made
too much noise. He tried to prevent his heels making contact
with the sidewalk, to dampen the sound.
But the man in front seemed to be in a hurry as he charged
down Henry Street. Not running, but a brisk walk that allowed
no time for looking back. That emboldened Will; he walked faster, taking pains to keep just less than a block between
them.
The stalker was carrying a black leather bag at his side, the
strap worn like a sash crossing over to his opposite shoulder.
He was neat and self-contained, moving nimbly. Will was no
expert, but he would have been surprised if this guy did not
have some connection with the military.
By now he had crossed Clinton and Jefferson. Where was
he going? To meet a getaway car? If so, why had he not been
picked up earlier? Maybe he was walking towards a subway station. Will cursed his limited knowledge of New York: he had no idea if there was a station near here.
Without warning, the man suddenly looked back. Will saw the movement of his head and, without even thinking, moved off the sidewalk towards the steps of the tenement block he was passing. At the same time he reached into his pocket and pulled out his keys. What the stalker would have seen was a man entering his own apartment building. He walked on; Will let out a deep sigh. He had been holding his breath.

By now the man ahead was turning a sharp right. Will
tried to position himself so that he would not be caught in
his field of vision.
'Yo, Ashley! You got my phone?'
Will had not seen them coming, but there they were, right
in front of him. Three African-American teenage girls, filling
up the sidewalk. Will tried to slide past, but they were in the
mood for some fun.
'What's the hurry, handsome? You don't like how we look?
You don't think we look fine?' At this the other two were
screeching with laughter. He looked over their heads, to see
the stalker heading down a side street towards East Broadway.
He was hard to make out.
'Yo, I'm over here, honey!' It was the leader of the pack,
now waving her hand in Will's face. If he had been born in
New York, he was sure he would have shoved them aside with a curt, 'Get the fuck out of my way.' But even here, on
a mission to prevent a murder in the dead of night, he was
still an Englishman.
'Excuse me, I have to get past. Please.'
With that, he weaved around Ashley and company, hearing
more whooping and calling behind him. 'My friend says you
can have her number!'
Will now broke into a run, desperate to catch up. He reached
the junction and turned right, scanning the street up and
down in search of his quarry. There was a couple making out on a stoop. But no sign of the stalker.
He could see only two non-residential buildings; the man might have fled into either one of them. He certainly could not yet have reached East Broadway or else Will would have caught sight of him. Will slowed down, checking over his shoulder, aware that this was exactly how to walk into an ambush. After fifteen paces, Will gave up: he had clearly lost the man he had needed to follow. He must have escaped into one of these two buildings, on opposite sides of the street. Will was near enough now to see what they were. One was the Church of the Reborn Jesus, but the other was a synagogue - affiliated to the Hassidim of Crown Heights. CHAPTER FIFTY-TWO

Monday, 12.28 am, Manhattan
Should he try to break into one or both of these places, to
find the man he had followed? A true man of action would
do just that. But as he was sizing up the first building, a police
car sped past, lights flashing. He stepped back. That was all
he needed: to be arrested for breaking into a synagogue in
the small hours of Monday morning. And on Yom Kippur of
all days. What believable grounds for following this man did
he even have? He had seen him come out of an apartment
building on the Lower East Side. Oh, and he had seen him out of TO's window yesterday. He had seen him commit no
crime. As Harden would say, 'You've got a notebook full of
nothing.' Nothing except a grim suspicion that was becoming
firmer every minute.
He retraced his steps towards the building on Montgomery
Street. He and Rabbi Freilich had discussed what he should
do in only the sketchiest terms. 'Just call me,' the rabbi had
said. 'Even if you're not sure it's him, call.'
'And then what?'
'We'll come and we'll help.'
Will was not quite sure what that meant.
He crossed the street and took a few furtive steps towards
the entrance of the tenement. A gleam of light drew his eye
to the door-lock: it was not fully shut! The stalker must have
left it ajar, perhaps to avoid making even that small noise.
Will creaked it open and slipped inside.
Perez, La Pinez, Abdulla, Bitensky, Wilkins, Gonzales, Yoelson, Alberto. The mailboxes offered no clues.
There was a rickety elevator, but that was no use. He needed
to check each floor, every apartment. He ran quietly up the
stairs, stopping at each landing: but all he could see were
shut doors, shabby doormats, the odd sodden umbrella left
outside. Will realized the futility of this expedition. What was
he looking for? A plaque announcing, 'Mr Righteous Tzaddik lives here. Available for weddings, birthdays and bar mitzvahs'?

By the third landing, he was poised to call Freilich and press him for more information. Anything else they had which might narrow it down. But the last apartment on the third floor stopped him dead.
The door was open.
Will crept towards it, lightly tapping it with his knuckles as he moved past and inside. 'Hello,' he called out, almost in a whisper. No lights were on, just the silver shadow of the moon, coming through the window that faced the street. He looked to his left. A galley kitchen, small and made up of 1950s units. Not as some retro fashion statement, but the real thing: a bulky, curved fridge; a stove with oversized knobs. This was the home, Will concluded, of an old person. Then he looked to his right. He could see a big radio on a table; a couple of wooden chairs, whose seats were cushioned in thin, fake leather; one was spilling out its stuffing. Then a couch-
Will gasped, jumping back. There was a man lying on it, flat on his back. Silhouetted in the light were the bristles on his chin. He had a small, squirrel-like face framed by clunky, chunky spectacles. The rest of him looked shrunken with age, in a too-big cardigan. He seemed to be sleeping.
Will took a step forward, then another one, until he was crouched over him. He placed his hand in front of the man's mouth and waited to feel a breath.
Nothing.
Then Will touched him, placing a hand on his forehead. Cold. He put a finger on his neck, searching for a pulse. He knew there would be none.
Will moved backwards, as if to take in the enormity of what he could see. As he did, he felt a crunch of glass. He looked down to see that he had just stepped on a syringe. He was bending down to get a closer look when the room flooded with light.
'Put your hands in the air and turn around. NOW!' Will did as he was told. He could barely see; he was dazzled by the three or four torches aimed directly at his eyes. 'Step away from the body. That's good. Now walk towards me. SLOWLY!'
His eyes were not yet adjusted but he could make out the small circle dancing before him, right next to the ring of torch light. It was the barrel of a gun - and it was aimed at him. CHAPTER FIFTY-THREE

Monday, 12.51am, Manhattan
In a way, it helped that he was so exhausted. In normal circumstances, his heart would have been banging loud enough to wake the neighbourhood. Instead, his fatigue acted as a kind of defensive shield, slowing down his reactions and even his emotions. His default mental state had become weary resignation.
He was now in handcuffs in the back of a squad car, jammed up against an officer of the New York Police Department. In front, the radio traffic was constant - and all about him. He was, it was clear, a murder suspect.
The men in the car were giving off an odour that Will
recalled from his adolescence: testosterone and adrenalin, the smell of a locker room after a big win. These men were high on success, and he was the prize. They had caught him all but red-handed, looming over his victim, his fingerprints on his neck. The officers in this unit could almost touch the police medals they were bound to receive.
'I did not kill that man,' Will heard himself say. The scene was so absurd, so remote from the rest of his life experience, that the voice sounded disembodied, unconnected. It was like listening to the radio, one of the BBC afternoon dramas his mother was hooked on.
'I know what it looks like, but I assure you that's not what
happened.' Suddenly a bolt of inspiration. 'But I could lead
you to the man who did do it! I followed him out of that building less than an hour ago. I know where he's hiding! I
can even give you a description.'
The officer in the front passenger seat turned around to give Will an ironic smile. Sure you can, son. And I'm gonna pitch
for the Yankees next Tuesday.
At the seventh precinct station, Will maintained his defiance.
'I just found that body!' he said, as they led him upstairs.
I'd seen the man leave the building, I followed him and then
I went back. I thought he had killed someone and I was right!'
Even as the words came out of his mouth, he knew they
sounded ridiculous. The cop who had been guarding Will
from the start stared at him contemptuously. 'Will you shut
the fuck up?'
For the first time since the police had picked him up, Will
began to panic. What the hell was he doing here? He needed
to get to Beth. He needed to be out on the streets, in Crown
Heights or wherever else, searching for his wife - not chained
up as a prisoner of the New York Police Department. He was
not even thinking about the prospect of being charged with
murder; merely losing vital hours battling the bureaucracy of
the New York criminal justice system was nightmarish enough.
Every minute spent here was another minute not finding
Beth. Besides, the Hassidim had been emphatic: there was
no time to lose; the fate of the world was to be decided in
the coming hours and minutes. Yet here he was, doing
nothing; his hands literally tied.
They took him to the sergeant's desk, where someone was
waiting for him: the detective he had seen at the apartment
building. He had inspected the scene while they kept Will in
the car. 'I got a prisoner to log in,' he said, addressing the
clerk and ignoring Will. Whippet-faced and in his late thirties,
the rising star of the homicide department, Will guessed.
'OK, let's empty his pockets.' The cop who had played bodyguard stepped forward. He had already frisked Will hard at
the apartment: after the police had seen the syringe, they
were taking no chances. They also took his cell phone and
BlackBerry: no calling of accomplices. Now they took the rest:
coins, keys, notebook.
'Let's get all this stuff vouchered,' the detective said. Each
item was put in a clear, plastic zip-loc bag and sealed. The
detective made a note, witnessed by the desk sergeant.
As they opened his wallet, Will was prompted to make one
of his biggest mistakes of the night. In among the plastic was his press card: Will Monroe, New York Times.
'OK, I'll admit it. The real reason I was in that building
was that I was on assignment for the Times. It was undercover.
I've been writing a series on crime in the city and that's
what I was doing.'
The detective looked at him for the first time.
'You work for The New York Times?'
'Yes. Yes, I do,' said Will, glad just to have got a response.
The detective looked away and the clerk went back to her
work.
Will was led to another desk, where he was asked to place
his right index finger on the electronic device in front of him,
hold still, and then do the same with his left. Then the rest
of his fingers and his thumbs. It beeped, as if he was a package at a supermarket. Next, Will was taken towards a room marked 'interview
suite'. On the way the detective handed a copy of Will's
details to a colleague: 'Jeannie, can you do a name-search
on this for me?'
Now they were inside. Just a table, with a chair on either
side and a phone in the corner. Nothing on the walls but a
calendar: New York, the Empire State.
'OK, my name is Larry Fitzwalter and I'm going to be your
detective for the evening. We're going to begin like this.' He
produced another form. 'You have the right to remain silent. Do you understand?'
'I do understand, but I would really like to explain--' 'OK, you understand. Can you initial here, please?' 'Look, I was in there because I followed a man in there--' 'Can you initial here, please? That means you understand that you have the right to remain silent. OK. Anything you say can and will be used against you in a court of law. Do you understand?'
'This is a simple mistake--'
'Do you understand? That's all I'm asking right now. Do you understand the words I am saying? If you do, then initial the goddamn form.'
Will said no more as Fitzwalter got to the end of the form, telling him his rights. Once it was initialled, the detective pushed it to one side.
'OK, now that you know your rights, do you wish to talk to us?'
'Don't I get to make a phone call?'
'It's the middle of the night. Who you gonna call?'
'Do I have to tell you?'
'No,' said the detective, taking the phone from the back table and stretching its cord to place it on the desk between them. 'Just tell me the number you want me to dial.' Will knew there was only one person he could possibly call but the idea was appalling. How could he, with this news? He looked at his watch. 2.15am. Fitzwalter was getting impatient. Will dictated the number. The detective dialled it, then handed him the phone - staying firmly in his seat. It was clear he was going to listen in on every word. Finally, Will heard the voice he was wanting and dreading to hear. 'Hello? Dad?'
CHAPTER FIFTY-FOUR

Monday, 3.06am, Manhattan
'I have good news and bad news for you, Mr Monroe.' It was
Fitzwaiter. 'Which would you like first?'
Will lifted his eyes slowly. He had spent only forty minutes
in this cell, but it felt like forty nights. His father had told
him to invoke the first of the rights he had been read and to
say nothing. Once Fitzwalter was certain Will was not going
to crack, and that the interview was over, he had him locked
up.
'The good news is that His Honour Judge William Monroe
Senior has telephoned to say he is on his way in from Sag
Harbor.'
His father's voice floated back into Will's head now, as
audible as it had been when he made that call. Sleepy, then
shocked, then stern, then disappointed, then purposeful. Since
Will had spent his youth three thousand miles away from his
father, he had never gone through that teenage rite of passage:
announcing' to your father that you have in some way betrayed his trust. Dad, I trashed the car. Dad, I got caught smoking dope. These were sentences he had never had to utter. He had
never heard his father say, as all his contemporaries had,
'Son, you've let me down.' So to hear it now - not the words,
but that tone - was an extra ordeal, to be piled on top of all
the others.
'Mr Monroe, are you listening to me?'
'Sorry?'
'You've had the good news. Don't you want to hear the
bad news?'
'Not really, no.'
'The bad news is, I've just come off the phone with the
duty lawyer at the Times. He's made some calls and guess
what? They don't think you're on assignment for them at all.
In fact, what they say is that you're taking a few days "rest".
By order of the editor himself. Sounds like you got yourself
in a whole pile of trouble, my friend.'
Will cupped his hands over his eyes. What a basic error:
to offer a lie that could so easily be disproved. His legal
defence was already compromised. He had made that cardinal
mistake of all guilty men: he had changed his story. As for his career, that was surely over. He would be suspended 'in
order to defend himself on these grave charges' - and then
quietly dropped.
The door slammed shut. In some strange way, Will almost
felt grateful to be in this cell. Ever since Friday morning, he
had been on the move, feverishly rushing from one place to
another, from one new plan to the next. He had criss-crossed
the city, in and out, either to Brooklyn or Long Island or back
again, trying to think, to focus, to act. Even when sitting
down, he had been willing the train or cab to go faster, to
get there now, or praying for the phone to ring or an email
to arrive.
Now there was nowhere he could go and nothing he could
do. The scheming and thinking and frantic calculating were
at an end. His jailers had not even allowed him a pencil and
paper.
The pause let in the realization he had been resisting for
days. Any time it had broken surface in the last nearly seventy
two hours, Will had pushed it back down. But now he had
no strength for the task.
Everything was falling apart. That was the conclusion he
had refused to face, but which was now too strong to resist.
His wife was missing, a captive of men whose fanaticism ran
deep. He was about to be charged with murder, facing a pile
of circumstantial evidence that would be hard to refute.
Worse still, he had fallen for a classic set-up.
After all, who had sent him to that building in the middle
of the night? Was he really meant to believe it was just a
coincidence that a brutal murder was in progress the minute
he appeared on the scene? And how strange that the killer
should almost certainly have taken refuge in, of all places, a
Hassidic synagogue.
All that guff about fearing for the end of the world. They
were bringing it about themselves! Will and TO had cottoned
onto their plot, so Freilich had had to come up with some
bullshit about 'whoever is behind this' blah, blah. Will's first instinct had been right. There was no 'they'. The Hassidim
had found the identities of these righteous men and now, for
some warped reason of their own, they wanted them dead.
Will was getting in the way. What better way to take him
out of circulation than to have him picked up not by them,
but by the police! Will had to hand it to them: it was masterful.
How funny to think that a matter of days ago the central
force in his life had been his career. His career! It was now
in shreds: he had been caught engaged in gross misconduct
by the editor himself. And now he had lost all standing in
the eyes of the only man whose opinion really mattered: his
father. He saw that now with great clarity. Of course it was
bound to have affected him, growing up all those years
without a dad. He felt it every day. Cricket games, when other
boys were getting cheered from the boundary. Sports days,
when he had no one to cheer in the fathers' race. People
used to ask if his dad was dead.
He had gone through all the phases. He had been angry with his father; he had resented him; he had, on occasion, joined forces with his mother in hating him. But mainly he had missed him. He had missed the thing he had seen other boys get every day from their fathers: a hand on the shoulder, a tousle of the hair, a gesture that constituted male approval. Now, in this prison cell, unfogged by ambiguity and nuance, he saw more starkly than ever before why he had crossed the Atlantic and changed his life. He had come to seek his father's approval. It was not going to find him sitting in London; he would have to come to America to get it for himself.
He had had a plan too. He would be the bright young man in a hurry, Will Monroe, Oxford star, come to make a splash in New York City. He had imagined the day, perhaps ten years from now, when he would wear black tie, lean into a microphone positioned a few inches too low for a man of his
height, and thank the Pulitzer judges for their belief in him. This very week - on the front page, twice - it had even seemed within reach. Yet now he was an exhausted wreck. The woman he loved, and the future he dreamed of, had vanished.
Even as he engaged in this mental audit, he could feel a nagging intrusion - one more thought demanding to break the surface. Will had been pushing it below the waves more vigorously than the rest; he was hoping it would sink. It forced itself up. What if the Hassidim are right? What if the moment the thirty-six men are killed, the world is no longer upheld? Everything about this wild theory had stacked up so far. The Chancellor really had performed an act of stunning goodness. So had Baxter. And they were disguised just as Mandelbaum said they would be. Could all the detail be right, but the idea itself be wrong?
Tonight he had witnessed, or just missed, the murder of a man who may well have been a tzaddik, one of thirty-six righteous ones. If that's who this man was, then it would be
one more confirmation that the Hassidim were telling the
truth - or at least part of it. It would also mean the killers
of the lamad vav were getting very close to their goal. He
looked at his watch: from what TO had told him, Yom Kippur
would be over in about sixteen hours. They had so little time.
He had to know: was the man in that building a tzaddik, as the Hassidim had predicted? For the first time in hours,
Will had an idea.
Some time later, the cell door opened again. Will braced
himself to see his father. But it was Fitzwalter.
'Come with me.'
'Where am I going?'
'You'll see.'
Will was led downstairs, into a room with bright fluorescent
lights. There were seven or eight other men there. At
least three of them looked to be stoned; he guessed several
were homeless. The door was slammed shut.
'OK, gentlemen,' said a voice over a loud-speaker. 'If you
can all take your places against the back wall.' Two of the
men in the group seemed to know exactly what to do, casually
walking to the back, then standing and staring straight
ahead. It was then Will saw the markings on the wall, indicating
height. This was a line-up, an identity parade.

On the other side of the one-way mirror Mrs Tina Perez of the Greenstreet Mansions apartment building stared at the men arrayed before her.
'I know it's been a long night, Mrs Perez,' Fitzwalter was saying. 'So you just take your time. When you're ready, I have two questions to ask.'
'I'm ready.'
'I want you to look really hard and tell me whether you've seen any of these men before and, if you have, where you've seen them. OK? Is that clear?'
'The answer's no. I haven't seen any of these men before. The man I saw had eyes you couldn't forget.'
'You're absolutely certain, Mrs Perez?'
I'm certain. He had his hands around poor Mr Bitensky's neck and he looked up at me with those eyes. Those terrible eyes--'
'It's OK, Mrs Perez. Please don't distress yourself. Jeannie, you can take Mrs Perez home now. Thank you.'
'OK, show in Mrs Abdulla.'

Will was spared the encounter with his father he had feared. Twenty minutes after the line-up, Fitzwalter had come into the cell.
'More good news and bad news. The bad news for me is that two witnesses say you were not the man they saw in Mr Bitensky's apartment. One of them did recognize you in the line-up. She places you at the apartment building standing outside at the time of the killing. So the good news for you is that I'm going to have to let you go. For now.' There were forms to fill in, so that Will's things could be released. He pounced on his cell phone first, powering it up. Instantly it began vibrating: a voice message. TO. 'Hi, guess what. As predicted, I am in police custody. They're questioning me about the murder of Mr Pugachov. It seems he was shot, at point-blank range. Can you believe this? In my apartment? That sweet, gentle man. And I can't bear to think it's all because . . .What? Oh God, I'm sorry. Sorry, Will, that's Joel Brookstein. Do you remember him? He was at Columbia. Anyway, he's agreed to be my lawyer. He's telling me to shut my mouth. Let me know where you are and what's happening. Not sure if they'll let me keep this phone on.' Her voice faded, as if she needed to talk over her shoulder. 'All right, I'm coming. One minute! Will, I'm going to have to go. Call me as soon as you can. We don't have much time.'
As he listened to her voice - which now seemed to oscillate between TO and Tova Chaya - he heard a double beep. A text message. He pressed the buttons.
Paul, sort the letters of no Christian! (1, ?, 29)
In the bombardment of the last few hours, Will had almost forgotten about the phantom texter. In his mind, he still associated these messages with Yosef Yitzhok, even though he
knew, rationally, that was impossible. This latest text was definitive proof: someone else had been giving Will these coded clues all along. But who?
The meaning of this latest message seemed almost within reach. Forty-eight hours of communication with this man had given Will some sense of the workings of his mind. This must be how crossword addicts do it, Will thought: after a while, they insert themselves into the head of the crossword setter.
And this did indeed look like a crossword clue. Surely, the literal meaning was irrelevant. He knew how such clues worked, with instructions in one part relating to the rest. But who was Paul? And why did the solution include a word twenty-nine letters long?
He would start with the most obvious bit, following the instruction to 'sort the letters', to reorder, 'no Christian'. With the recklessness of a newly free man, he grabbed a pen from the desk clerk's table and scribbled on the back of the receipt she had just handed him.
On Ian Christ. That did not work. Con this rain. That was not much better.
And then he saw it, smiling his first smile in hours. How perfect that this message should arrive just as he was alone, without TO. The one area where he would have greater knowledge than her.
He picked up the phone to call his father. To tell him the good news that he had been released without charge and ask him to stop on his way, maybe at a hotel, and pick up the one thing that Will realized he would need: a bible. CHAPTER FIFTY-FIVE

Monday, 4.40am, Manhattan
For a minute, he thought about asking the desk sergeant. Then he reconsidered. It would not look great, a dishevelled murder suspect, alternately ranting about the identity of the true killer - 'He has piercing blue eyes!' - and then demanding to read the bible. Fine if Will was guilty and pursuing a 'diminished responsibility' defence; not so great for a man who wanted to walk out of the seventh precinct having convinced the police he was both innocent and sane.

Instead he waited for his father pacing outside, desperate to get away. Finally William Monroe Sr, dressed in a battered sailing jacket, appeared. He looked exhausted, his eyes ringed in red. Will wondered if he had been crying.
'Thank God, William,' he said, hugging his son, his hand cupping the back of his head. 'I wondered what on earth you'd done.'
'Thanks for that vote of confidence, Dad,' said Will, pulling away. 'No time to talk. Do you have the thing I asked you to bring?'
His father nodded, a gesture of sad surrender, as if he was humouring a son who was babbling about the voices in his head or demanding a hundred bucks for another fix of crack. 'Here.' Will pounced on the bible. 'OK, Dad. You know those text messages I've been getting? Well, here's the latest.' Will held up his cell phone.
Sort the letters of no Christian! (1, 7, 29)
'What could that mean?'
Hurriedly, Will explained. 'No Christian is an anagram for Corinthians. The figure I refers to Paul's first letter to the Corinthians - and it must be Chapter 7, Verse 29. Which is why I wanted a bible. And here it is.'
What I mean, brothers, is that the time is short. 'He's getting desperate.'
'Will--'

'Hold on, Dad. I just want to prove something to you. Now, I know how bizarre this will sound, but at the heart of this whole, fucked-up business seems to be a Jewish religious theory. It centres on men of exceptional goodness.' He could see his father's face moving from pity to impatience.
'Will, what on earth are you talking about? The police brought you here on suspicion of murder tonight. Do you have any idea of the trouble you're in?'
'Oh yes, Dad, believe me. I know that I am in the deepest shit imaginable. Deeper than you think. But please hear me out on this. The Hassidim who are holding Beth say that someone - it may even be one of them for all I know - is killing good people. Extraordinarily good people. Not just here, but all over the world. What happened tonight is that I came this close to witnessing one of those killings. If the Hassidim's theory is right, the man who was murdered tonight will be a so-called righteous man. Which is why I wanted you to see this.'
He took his BlackBerry out of the police zip-loc bag, clicked on the internet browser and selected Google. Then he punched in the words 'Bitensky and Lower East Side'. Google was searching, not fast on this handheld machine. Finally, a page of search results. A biomedical website, something about a classical pianist. And then a link to Downtown Express, 'the weekly newspaper of lower Manhattan'. He clicked on it, waited an age for the page to load and then scrolled down. It was an archive item from a couple of years ago. He prayed for it to be something of substance, something which might prove to Monroe Sr that his son was not completely deranged.

Residents of the Greenstreet area endured a chilly start to the Passover season this week, when their apartment building was evacuated for a fire alert Tuesday.
It was after midnight when scores of residents filed together into the park, as fire crews examined the building before declaring it was safe to re-enter.
While most folks were clothed only in pyjamas and robes, one group were fully dressed - since they had been taking part in the traditional seder that often continues until the early hours. They were guests ofJudah Bitensky, one of the the last Jewish residents of a building that was once a hub for the East Broadway Jewish community. It appears that Mr Bitensky, janitor at one of the area's remaining synagogues, hosts an annual seder meal at his home - inviting all those who have no other home to go to.
'It's kind of a tradition,' said Irving Tannenbaum, 66 and a regular. 'Every year Judah opens his door to people like us. Some of the crowd are elderly and live alone. Some are, you know, street people. It's quite a scene in there.'
Riwy Gold, 5I and homeless, added, 'It's the best meal I get all year. This is the one night I feel like I have family.' Downtown Express counted twenty-six people heading back into Mr Bitensky's tiny apartment - including three in wheelchairs and two on crutches. Reluctant to give an interview to a reporter, Mr Bitensky was asked how he was able to feed so many, despite living on a meager income himself. 'Somehow I manage,' he said. I don't quite know how.'
CHAPTER FIFTY-SIX

Monday, 2.25pm, Brooklyn
Will maintained his perch by the window, regularly peeling
back the curtain to look out onto the street. He knew it was
foolhardy. If anyone was following him, there could hardly
be a better way to attract their attention. He flapped the material
back and forth so often, he looked as if he were sending
a coded message.
He had said goodbye to his father only minutes after they
had met up. Monroe Sr had looked at him blankly when Will
called up the Bitensky story on the BlackBerry, as if the
whole business was just too deranged to take seriously. He had made a gesture with his face and hands - let's put all this
nonsense aside - and asked Will to come back home with him.
There he would have a chance to shower, sleep and generally
calm down. Linda would look after him. For his own
part, he had an important case to prepare for that morning,
but he would be back in the evening. Then father and son
could put their heads together and work out how they were
going to get Beth back. It was a tempting offer, but Will
declined. He had wasted enough time already. With thanks
he sent his father back to his car - and fired off a text message
to TO.
To his great relief she called back. She had been released at nine that morning. Police had just viewed the CCTV tapes from her building. The footage from Saturday night included a sequence shot by the camera above the back entrance: it showed Pugachov helping TO and an unnamed man into a large bin and wheeling them out of sight. It then showed him re-entering the building a few minutes later. Not only did it confirm the admittedly strange story she had told detectives
- it also showed that when TO had left Mr Pugachov, he was alive and well.
There was something in the dead man's trousers which helped, too. In his right pocket was the spare key for TO's apartment. He would surely only have needed to use that if she was not in and the door had been locked. With that second alibi, the police released TO. They even thanked her for her time - doubtless, thought Will, with a scripted paragraph from the NYPD customer care manual.
It was Will's idea to meet at Tom's, in what was a straightforward calculation. Both his and TO's apartments had been
monitored; here, they had at least a chance to meet undetected. Besides, TO had a plan - just a hunch, she said - that
required major computing brainpower. Now she was standing over Tom's shoulder as he stabbed at the keyboard.
'So you're certain of the domain name?' he was saying. 'All I can tell you is what it says on the card I took.
Rabbi.Freilich@Moshiachlives.com.'
'OK, OK, that's what I'll try. Spell Mosh--, you know, for me again?'
'For the third time: M-0-S-H-I-A-C-H.'
Will glanced back out of the window. As much as Tom loved Beth, he could not stand TO. At Columbia Will had always put it down to jealousy, the difficulties of being a three. Now he reckoned it was more like organic combustion: Tom and TO were phosphorus and sulphur. They could not meet without sparking up.
In a novel form of coping strategy, Tom chose not to talk to TO at all. He talked to himself instead.
'OK, so what we need to do is run a host domain name.' He punched those last three words into the 'shell', a kind of empty window on the screen he had created. A few seconds later, a string of numbers appeared. 192.0.2.233 'All right, who is 192.0.2.233?' He said the words as he typed them.
Back came an answer. Among a whole lot of blurb about 'registrants' and 'administrative contacts' was the address of the Hassidim's headquarters in Crown Heights. The very building Will and TO had been in last night.

'Good, now let's talk to Arin.'
'Arin? Who the hell is Arin?'
'ARIN is the American Registry for Internet Numbers, the organization which allocates IP addresses - you know, the string of numbers we had before.'
'But I thought you already had that for this, you know, domain.'
'I had one of the numbers. ARIN will give us all the numbers allocated to this company or organization. We will have the number for every machine they have. Once we have that, we can get to work.'
Soon the screen was filled with numbers, dozens of them. This, TO realized, was the entire Hassidic computer network, expressed in numerical form.
'All right, this is the range we'll scan.'
'What does that mean, "scan"?'
'I thought you didn't want me to get too technical. "Save the geek stuff, Tom." Remember?'
'So what do we do now?'
'We wait.'
TO headed for the couch, laying herself flat out, using Tom's overcoat as a blanket, before falling into exhausted sleep. Tom was working away on a different computer, hammering at the keys. Will alternated between staring out of the window and at a photograph on the wall: a picture of himself, Tom and Beth, wrapped up in thick winter gloves, scarves and coats in what looked like a ski resort. In fact it was the centre of Manhattan, early on a Sunday morning after a night-long blizzard. The smile on Beth's face seemed to register something more than laughter: there was, what was the word, appreciation, for the fact that life, despite everything, could be wonderful.
An hour and a half later, the computer beeped; not the
trill of a new email but a simpler sound. Will turned around to find Tom jumping back to the machine he had left running. 'We're in.'
Now all three were gathered round, staring at a screen that only made sense to one of them.
'What's this, Tom?' It was Will, deciding to get the question in first - and phrase it politely - before TO had a chance to bark.
'These are the system logs for the machine we've just hacked into. This way we should be able to tell who's been in and out.'
TO was biting her nails, willing everything to happen faster. Will was scanning not the screen but Tom's face, looking for any sign of progress. He did not like what he saw: Tom seemed puzzled. His lips were pursed; when he was on the brink of a breakthrough, they would part, in readiness for a smile.
'Nothing there. Damn.'
'Look again,' said TO. 'You might have missed something. Look again.'
But Tom did not need to be told. He inched closer to the screen, now slowly going through each line that appeared in front of him.
'Hold on,' he said. 'This might be nothing.'
'What? What?'
'See, that line in the log. There. Time service crashed. 1.58 this morning. It might be nothing. Programmes often crash and restart automatically. No big deal.'
'But?'
'It could indicate something else.'
'Yes?'
Tom was not doing well under TO's interrogation. Will stepped in. 'Sorry, Tom. For a know-nothing like me: what's a time service?'
'It's just a bit of the networking set-up that some people forget about. They don't turn it off so it just sits there, keeping track of the time of day.'
'So?'
'The important thing is, people forget it's there. So they don't give it the tender loving care they give to the rest of the system. Old security holes that may have been closed elsewhere in the system sometimes get left in the time service bit.'
'You mean, it's like a hole in the garden fence, round the back where no one notices?'
'Exactly. What I'm wondering is whether this time service crashed through, you know, natural causes - or whether somebody bust right through it. If you know what you're doing, you can send in a buffer overflow, a huge bunch of data in a specific sequence, which totally screws up the time service. If you really know what you're doing, you can not only make it crash but kind of bend it to your will.'
'How do you mean?' asked Will.
'You can make it run your commands, which effectively gives you access to the server.'
Is that what happened here?'
'I don't know. I need to see the time service's own access log. That's what I'm waiting for now . . . whoa, hold on. This is good. See that, right there?'
He was pointing at a string of numbers by the time, 1:58am. 'Hello, stranger.'
It was a new IP address, a string of numbers different from
all the others allocated to the Hassidim and their network.
This was the signature of an outsider.
'Can you see who it is?'
That's what I'm asking right now.' He typed: whois
89.23325.09?
'And here is our answer.'
Tom was pointing at the line on the screen. It took Will a
second to focus on the words. But there they were, words which changed everything. Neither he nor TO could make a
sound. The three of them stood in silence, looking at the
address in front of them.
The organization which had hacked into the Hassidim's
computer - reading everything they were reading, looking
over their virtual shoulder to see every one of their calculations,
including those that revealed the exact locations of the
righteous men - was based in Richmond, Virginia and there,
on the screen, was its full name.
The Church of the Reborn Jesus.
CHAPTER FIFTY-SEVEN

Monday, 5.13pm, Darfur, Sudan
The night of the thirty-fifth killing was almost silent. In this heat, and with so little food, people were too listless to make much noise. The call to prayer was the only loud sound to be heard all day; the rest was moans and whispers. Mohammed Omar saw the heat-wave shimmering on the horizon and reckoned sunset would be only a few minutes away. That was the way it was in Darfur: the sun would sneak up without warning in the morning and disappear just as quickly at night. Maybe it was like that everywhere in Sudan, everywhere in Africa. Mohammed did not know: he had never travelled beyond this rocky desert.

It was time for his evening tour of the camp. He would check in first on Hawa, the thirteen-year-old girl who had, too young, become a kind of mother to her six sisters. They had fled to the camp two weeks ago, after the Janjaweed militiamen had torched their village. The little girls were too scared to talk, but Hawa told Mohammed what had happened. In the middle of the night, terrifying men had arrived on horseback, waving flaming torches. They had set everything alight. Hawa had scooped up her sisters and started running. Only once they got away did she realize that her parents had been left behind. They had both been killed.
Now, in the corner of a hut made of straw and sticks, she held her three-year-old sister in her arms. By the doorway, on the ground, stood a battered pot. Inside, a meagre ration of porridge.
Mohammed walked on, steeling himself for the next stop on the tour: the 'clinic', in reality another frail hut. Kosar, the nurse, was there and her face told him what he did not want to hear. 'How many?' he asked.
Three. And maybe one more tonight.' They had been losing three children a day for weeks now. With no medicine and no food, he did not know how he could stop the dying. He looked around. An empty corner of desert, sheltered by a few scrubby trees. He had not meant to start a refugee camp here. What did he know of such things? He was a tailor. He was not a doctor or an official, but he could see what was going on. There were columns of desperate people, often children, walking through the desert, searching for food and
shelter. They spoke of village after village destroyed by the Janjaweed, the men who burnt and killed and raped while government aeroplanes circled overhead. Somebody had to do something - and, without ever really thinking it through, that somebody had been him.
He had started with a few tents, two of them stitched
together on his old Singer machine. He collected a few axes and gave them to the men to get firewood. They struggled. One, Abdul, was desperate to help but the burns on his hands were so bad he could not hold an axe. Mohammed saw him, his hands so scorched he could not even wipe away his own tears.
Still, they chopped enough wood to start a fire and, once it burned, it worked as a beacon. More refugees came.

Now there were thousands of people here; there was no time to count them precisely. They pooled what meagre resources they had. These people were farmers; what little could be conjured from the earth, they somehow teased out. But there was not enough.
Mohammed knew what he needed: outside help. In the few hours of sleep he snatched each night, he would dream of a convoy of white vehicles arriving one bright morning, each one loaded with crates of grain and boxes of medicine. Even with just five vehicles - just one - he could save so many lives.
It was then he saw the headlights, shining through the dusk. Strong and yellow, they were coming his way, their light wobbling in the heat haze. Mohammed could not help himself. He began jumping up and down, waving his arms in a wild semaphore. 'Here!' he was shouting. 'Here! We are here!' The truck slowed down until Mohammed could get a better view. This was not an aid team, but just two men.
'I come in the name of our Lord, Jesus Christ,' the first man began in English, rapidly translated by the second. 'Welcome, welcome,' said Mohammed, grabbing his visitors with both arms in gratitude. 'Welcome, welcome.'
'I have some food and drugs in the back. Do you have people to unload it?'
A crowd had already assembled. After the interpreter had spoken, Mohammed nominated two of the strongest teenagers, a boy and a girl, to take the boxes off the truck. He then summoned a couple of men he could trust to stand guard: the last thing he wanted was a food riot, as hunger and desperation sparked a stampede.
'Do you think we could talk?' the visitor asked. Mohammed answered with a gesture, ushering his guest towards an empty hut. The man followed, carrying a slim, dark briefcase. 'It's taken me a long time to find you, sir. Am I right that you are in charge? This is a camp you started?'
'Yes,' Mohammed said, unsure whether to look at the translator or his boss.
'And you have done this all by yourself? No one is paying you to do this? You don't work for any organization? You did this purely out of the goodness of your own heart?' 'Yes, but this is not important,' Mohammed said through the interpreter. 'I am not important.'
At that, the visitor smiled and said, 'Good.'
'People are dying here,' Mohammed continued. 'What help can you give them? Urgently!'
The visitor smiled again. 'Oh, I can promise them the
greatest help of all. And it won't be long to wait. Not long at all'
He then clicked the two side-locks of his briefcase and produced a syringe. 'First, I want to say what an honour it is for me to meet you. It is an honour to know that the righteous truly live among us.'
'Thank you, but I don't understand.'
'I'm afraid I need to give you this. It's important that a man such as yourself should feel no pain or suffering. No pain or suffering at all.'
Suddenly the interpreter was gripping Mohammed's arm, forcing him onto the ground. Mohammed tried to escape, but he was too weak and this hand too strong. Now, towering over him, was the visitor, holding the syringe up to the light. He was speaking in English, lowering himself closer to Mohammed. As he did so, the interpreter was whispering directly into his ear.
'For the Lord loves the just and will not forsake his faithful ones. They will be protected forever, but the offspring of the wicked will be cut off.'
Mohammed was writhing, struggling to break free. And still the voice was speaking, its breath hot.
'The wicked lie in wait for the righteous, seeking their very lives; but the Lord will not leave them in their power or let them be condemned when brought to trial. The salvation of the righteous comes from the Lord; he is their stronghold in time of trouble.' Finally he felt the needle break the skin of his arm and, as the sky darkened, he heard the words of a prayer, until the voice grew distant and all was silent.
CHAPTER FIFTY-EIGHT

Monday, 2.50pm, Brooklyn
Now it was Will's turn to take charge. He all but pushed Tom out of his chair, and instantly returned to twenty-first century journalism's base camp: Google.
'Church of the Reborn Jesus' brought up a page of entries, but they were thin. To Will's surprise, the group did not have a website of its own.
He clicked the first entry, a link to a paper delivered at a University of Nebraska conference.

Though never large in number, the Church of the Reborn Jesus achieved great influence at its height a quarter century ago, especially among young Christian intellectuals. Central to its teaching was a radical brand of replacement theology, the belief that Christians had replaced the Jews as God's chosen people . . .

Maddeningly, the article said nothing more, rambling off into a wider discussion of campus Christianity in the 1970s. But Will was on a roll. He could tell TO was keeping up, yet both knew, intuitively, there was no time to waste on discussion. He went straight to Wikipedia, the online encyclopaedia and typed in 'replacement theology'.
It took a few seconds, during which Will's right foot pulsated
- partly in anxiety, partly in excitement. A half-buried memory was nagging away at him. The Church of the Reborn Jesus: he
had seen that name before, somewhere at the office . . .
Then a page appeared, headlined Supersessionism. It was
defined as 'the traditional Christian belief that Christianity is
the fulfilment of Biblical Judaism, and therefore that Jews
who deny that Jesus is the Jewish Messiah fall short of their
calling as God's chosen people.'
Will skimmed to the next paragraph. 'It argues that Israel
has been superseded ... in the sense that the Church has
been entrusted with the fulfilment of the promises of which
Jewish Israel is the trustee.'
The entry noted that while several liberal Protestant groups
had renounced supersessionism, ruling that Jews and
'perhaps' other non-Christians could find God through their
own faith, 'other conservative and fundamentalist Christian
groups hold supersessionism to be valid . . . the debate
continues.'
And I bet I know where it continues, thought Will. He went back to Google, now narrowing his search to 'Church of the
Reborn Jesus and replacement theology'. Three references,
the first an article from The Christian Review.
'. . . Replacement theology became increasingly unfashionable
in this period, discredited by the politically correct crowd,
said its defenders. A few years earlier, it had enjoyed a vigorous
revival chiefly through a cerebral grouping known as the
Church of the Reborn Jesus. According to this group,
Christians had, by their recognition of Jesus as the Messiah,
not only inherited the Jews' status as the elect, but inherited
Judaism itself. The Jews had, the Reborn Jesus movement
argued, ignored God's direct wishes and therefore forfeited
all that they had learned from Him. They had disinherited
themselves from their role as the chosen people but - and
this is what set the Church of the Reborn Jesus apart - the
Jews had also abandoned their own traditions, customs and
even folklore. From now on, those were to be regarded as
the possessions of committed Christians.'
'Stop.' It was TO, white-faced. 'That's the key point, right there. Their own traditions, customs, even folklore. This group believes that Judaism contains the truth, not for Jews but for
Christians. Even the folklore. Don't you see? They've taken it
all. The mysticism, the kabbalah, everything.'
'The story of the righteous men,' said Will.
'Yes. They don't think this is some weird Hassidic tradition.
They think this belongs to them. They believe it's true.'
He clicked on the next Google result. It was a link to an
evangelical discussion group. Somebody calling themselves
NewDawn had written a long posting, apparently in reply
to a question about the origins of the Church of the Reborn
Jesus.

In its day it had quite an impact - kind of the smart end of the whole Jesus freak, sandal-wearing movement. It was centred on this very charismatic preacher who was then a chaplain to Yale, Rev Jim Johnson.

Will looked up at TO. 'I know that name,' he said. 'He
founded some evangelical movement in the seventies. Died a few years ago.' But TO was reading on.
'Apparently Rev Johnson influenced a whole generation of elite Christians. They called him the Pied Piper on campus, because he enjoyed such a dedicated following.'
I can vouch for that, said the posting below. 7 was at Yale in that period and Johnson was a phenomenon. He was only interested in the A-list, top-flight students - editors of Law Review, class president, those guys. We called them the Apostles, hanging around
Johnson like he was the Messiah or something. For anyone interested, I've scanned in a picture from the Yale Daily News which
shows Johnson and his followers. Click here.
Will clicked and waited for the picture to load. It was grainy, in drab, 1970s colour and it took a while to fill the frame. Slowly it came into view. At the centre, wearing a broad grin, like the captain of a college football team, was a man in his late thirties, wearing an open-necked shirt and large glasses with the curved, rectangular frames that were then regarded as super-modern. He wore no dog-collar, no dark suit. He was, Will concluded, what the Victorians would have called a muscular Christian.
Surrounding him were young, serious-looking men, exuding that born-to-rule confidence that radiated out of Yale or Harvard yearbooks. The hair was long or bulky, the shirt collars and jacket lapels wide. The faces seemed to shine with possibility. These men were not only going to rule the world. It was quite clear they believed they would do it with Jesus's blessing.
'I think you need to hurry,' said Tom, now taking up Will's previous position by the curtain. There's a car outside. Two guys are getting out and coming into the building.' But Will was hardly listening. Instead he was pushed back into his seat with surprise: he had recognized one of the faces in the photograph. He was only able to because he had seen another, different picture of this same man in his youth recently. The paper had run it when he was appointed. There, at Jim Johnson's side, was none other than Townsend McDougal - the future editor of The New York Times. 'I don't believe it,' Will said.
'It's him, isn't it?'
Will was confused. How would TO recognize McDougal? 'I didn't want to say, because I wasn't sure. But it really couldn't be anyone else.'
Will looked up at her, crinkling his eyebrows to register his puzzlement. 'Who are you talking about?'
'Will! They're coming up. You've got to go!'
'Look,' said TO, taking her finger to the far left of the back row of the picture - an area Will had barely examined. TO stopped at a lean, handsome young man with a full head of thick hair. He was unsmiling.
'Maybe I'm wrong, Will. But I think that's your father.' CHAPTER FIFTY-NINE

Monday, 2.56pm, Brooklyn
Tom had fairly wrenched Will from the chair and out the window, sending him plunging down the fire escape. He nudged TO the same way and was about to follow himself when he looked back. The computer screen was still alight with information. It would be too terrible, thought Tom, if his machine, always such a loyal ally, were to end up giving them all away.
He rushed TO out, then moved over to the desk and started frantically closing down programmes. It was while he was shutting down the internet browser that the door flung open.
He heard it before he saw it, a splintering crash, as two men shouldered their way into the apartment. Tom looked up and saw one of them: tall, thick-armed and with the clearest, sharpest blue eyes. In an instant, Tom decided to do the one thing his every instinct rebelled against. He reached for the powers cord and pulled it out of the wall, shutting down his computer and everything connected to it.

But the move was too sudden for his uninvited guests. They interpreted a man stretching downwards the way they had been trained to, as someone reaching for a weapon. As he pulled on the white flex, the bullet pierced his chest. He crumpled to the ground. The screens went dark.
Will charged down the back ladder, taking two then three rungs at a time. His head was throbbing. Who was chasing him? What had happened to TO and Tom? Where should he go?
But even as he thundered downwards, storey after storey, his mind was racing with what he had just seen. The face was unmistakable; TO had seen it straight away. What Freudian impulse had led his eye away from it? The eyes, the jaw, the firm nose: his father.
And yet, the one thing he knew for certain about William Monroe Sr was that he was an avowed rationalist, a coolly secular man whose scepticism about religion might well have thwarted his highest ambition, to serve as a justice of the United States Supreme Court. Could he really have once been a bible-thumper, and such a serious one?
Three more storeys to go, and now he could feel the iron handrail vibrating. He looked up, to see the soles of shoes descending just as fast as his. One more level to go: Will all but jumped it.
Now he started sprinting down Smith Street, dodging people as they came out of the Salonike diner. He looked over his shoulder: a commotion behind him, caused by a man dashing through a crowd. 'Hey, watch it asshole!'

Will body-swerved round the corner, clasping hold of a pretzel wagon to steady himself. In front of him was Fourth Avenue, with six lanes of traffic, all moving fast. At the first gap, he plunged in.
He was standing on the dotted white line separating two streams of heavy traffic. Drivers started blasting their horns; they clearly thought Will was some kind of psycho. He looked back. There, just a lane of cars away, was the stalker, the man he had nearly caught in the act of murder less than twenty four hours ago. As if protected by the traffic, Will stared at him. What came back was a laser-beam eye that seemed to bore right through him.
He wheeled around and spotted another gap in traffic just a beat and he would miss it. Will leapt across, turning around to see that his pursuer had made the same move. They were still just the width of a single car apart. He could see a bulge around the man's hip, what Will assumed to be a holster.
He looked ahead: the light was still green. But for how much longer? Soon it would be red: the traffic would slow down and he would be able to cross to the other side, but so would the man with the gun. He would be within pointblank range. But there was no gap. The cars were moving too fast.
Will had only one option. Instead of crossing the road, he sprinted to his left, as if trying to catch up with the traffic. He ran faster, never taking his eye off the lights. He would act the second he saw a glimmer of red. Come on, come on. He looked around. The man was still just one lane away, but hardly moved from his previous position. Now was the moment.
As green turned to red, the traffic slowed, the cars bunching up behind each other: Will had only to dart between them, keeping himself low. Three, four, five lanes and he was nearly there.
Once across, he had to burst through a family waiting at the crossing; he knocked the balloon out of a child's hand. Will looked back to see it soar - and to realize Laser Eyes was now just a sprint away from him.
At last, Atlantic Avenue subway station. Will hurtled down the stairs, cursing the wide woman blocking his way. Down and down, vaulting over the turnstile, hoping his ears would not fail him. Years of travelling on the Underground in London had given him a sixth sense for the mix of wind, light and humming sounds that indicated a train was coming. Will was sure he could hear it on the opposite platform. He would have to get up the stairs and across the bridge in just a few seconds. He could hear the thudding of footsteps; the stalker was just behind him.
Only moments separated them, but as Will crossed the bridge he could see the train that had just pulled in. An instant later, he was sliding down the stairs, shoving people out of the way. There was the beep-beep-beep and hiss of air that announced the train was about to move off. Just one more second . . .
Will dived from the bottom stair and across the platform in what felt like a single leap. The door had almost closed behind him when it stopped - held back by four fingers of a hand. Through the glass, Will could see his face: the eyes almost translucent, fixed in a stare that turned Will's guts to ice. The door was inching back.
'What you doing? You just gonna have to wait for the next train like everyone else!' It was a woman passenger, no younger than seventy, using her walking stick to whack the knuckles protruding through the door. As the train began to move off, she rapped harder - until one by one, they disappeared. The man with the glass eyes was left on the platform, getting smaller and smaller.
'Thank you with all my heart,' said Will, gasping for air as he fell into the nearest seat.
'People need to have more respect,' she said.
'Yes, that's right,' Will wheezed. 'Respect. I couldn't agree more.'
As the air came back into his lungs, and the oxygen returned to his brain, he could see only one image. When he closed his eyes, it was there, imprinted under his eyelids. His father, aged twenty-one - a comrade in the army of Jesus. And not just the army, but the vanguard. A handpicked elite who believed they knew the secrets of the true faith.
What were they exactly? Christians, certainly. But with a strange edge of arrogance. It was they, not the Jews, who were the chosen people. They, not the Jews, who could regard Judaism itself as their birthright. They, not the Jews, who would quote the Old Testament and all its prophecies, they who would see the promises made to Abraham as promises made to them.
Will looked out the window. DeKalb Avenue station. He got out and jumped on another train. Keep Laser Eyes and his friends guessing.
TO had seen the significance straight away. According to this strict brand of replacement theology, if Judaism was theirs, that meant all of it. The story of Abraham's bargain with Sodom would be part of their inheritance - and so would the fruit of that story, the mystical Jewish belief that the world was maintained by thirty-six righteous men. For some reason, they had taken that belief as their own - and now, it seemed, they had added a new twist. They were determined to kill these good men one by one. But if it was this bizarre Christian sect who were behind the killings, why on earth had the Hassidim kidnapped Beth?
It was too much. Will needed to think, calmly. He looked at his watch. 3.45pm. So little time. He called TO's number, praying she had somehow got away.
'Will! You're alive!'
'Are you OK? Where are you?'
'I'm in the hospital. With Tom. He was shot.'
'Oh my God.'
'I was on the roof. I heard a shot, I ran downstairs and he was lying there, bleeding. Oh, Will--'
'Is he alive?'
'They're operating on him now. My God, who did this, Will? Why would anyone do this?'
'I don't know, but I'm going to find them, I promise. I'm going to find the people behind this whole fucking mess. And I know I'm close.'
CHAPTER SIXTY

Monday, 3.47pm, Manhattan
TO, I know they're here. In New York City'
'How can you be so certain? They're killing righteous men
all over the world - why would they be here?'
For one thing, everything they know, they've got from
the Hassidim. They've got all they can from hacking into their
computers. Now they need to be here in person; to complete
the process. That's why they killed Yosef Yitzhok. They're
desperate to find number thirty-six. And they're convinced
the Hassidim know who he is. And they're right. Besides, I
reckon they want to be here.'
"What do you mean?'
'Don't you see? Tonight is the climax. It's the moment it
all comes together. They'll want to be in the place where all
this prophecy becomes real. Because this is where it all ends, TO. The Sodom of the twenty-first century. New York City!
It's here the world finally loses its bargain with God. Just
thirty-six righteous men; so long as they're alive, the world
goes on. Without them, it's all over. These people will want
to be here to see it happen. The end of the world.'
'Will, you're scaring me.'
'And there's one other thing.' He stopped himself. 'Look,
there's no time. I've got to go.' He hung up and dialled a number at The New York Times.
'Amy Woodstein.'
'Amy, it's Will. I need you to do something for me.'
'Will!' She was whispering. 'I shouldn't even be talking to
you. Are you getting some help?'
'Right now I need your help, Amy. There's a flyer on my
desk, for a convention of the Church of the Reborn Jesus.
Could you just read it out to me?'
Amy sighed in audible relief. 'Hold on.' Seconds later she was back. 'OK: The Church of the Reborn Jesus, valuing families
through family values. Spiritual Gathering, Javits Convention Center, on West 34th Street ... oh, hold on, its today.'
'Yes!' He sounded as if he was punching the air.
'Oh, Will, I'm so glad you're finding some comfort in your
faith. I know many people facing challenges--'
'Amy, love to chat, got to go.'

Thirty minutes later, he was there. The Javits Convention Center. He could see a delegates' counter, staffed by bright eyed volunteers. That would not work. Ah, a press desk. 'Excuse me, I'm from the Guardian, a London newspaper, and I fear I'm not yet on your list. Is there any way you might be able to accommodate me?'
'Sir, I'm afraid accreditation has to be done through our Richmond office. Did you pre-accredit?' Pre-accredit. Just when Will thought he had heard every coinage corporate America could possibly come up with.
'No, I'm sorry, I just couldn't get through on the phone. But my editors would be so disappointed if I couldn't cover this wonderful celebration of family values. We have nothing like this in Britain, you see. And I know there is a real hunger back home for this kind of spiritual example. Is there any way you could let me in, just for half an hour or so, so that I could at least tell my bosses I saw it with my own eyes?' He had pushed every button. In the years since he had arrived in America, this kind of patter had got him into NASA for a space launch, Graceland for an Elvis tribute night and a presidential candidates' debate in Trenton, New Jersey. He hoped his eyes glowed with eagerness.
But the woman on the desk, identified by her label as Carrie-Anne, Facilitator, was not about to relent. I'm going to need you to speak to Richmond.'
Damn.
'Sure, what's the number I need to dial?'
Will wrote it down carefully - then, using his cell phone, he dialled his home number.
'Hello. This is Tom Mitchell from the Guardian in London. It's about today's convention. I just wondered if there's any chance . . .That's right.' At the other end, he could hear his own voice, announcing that he and Beth were away from the phone right now. He tried to block out the sound and carry on talking. 'So I need to look at the programme. OK--' Will put his hand over the receiver and then mouthed to
Carrie-Anne, 'She says I need to see the press pack.' Without hesitation, she passed one over.
'OK, so I should go through that now, see what interests me ... all right, that's a very big help. Thanks so
much.'
As he was talking to his own answering machine, Will's eye ran down the list of sessions.
The Holden Suite: Putting togetherness back together. Parenting after divorce with Rev Peter Thompson.
The Macmillan Room: How would Jesus do it? Seeking the saviour's advice.
Will could not find what he wanted. He looked up; Carrie Anne was smiling as she handed press badges to a TV reporter and her cameraman. Silently, Will wheeled around and headed for the conference rooms - his press pack held high as a surrogate credential.
He looked back at the list. Lunch breaks, creche facilities, workshops. Then his eye stopped.
The Chapel: Entering the Messianic age. Speaker to be confirmed. CLOSED SESSION.
Will looked at his watch; it had already begun. But where in this vast complex of suites, corridors and stairwells was the Chapel? He rifled through his press pack until he saw an internal map. Third floor.
There were so many doors; but finally he saw one with a sign, a diagram of a stick-man kneeling, at prayer. Will pressed his ear close to the door:
'. . . how many centuries have we waited? More than
twenty. And sometimes our patience has worn thin. Our faith has faltered.'
Will heard the ding of an elevator. Out came three men, around Will's age, dressed in neat dark suits - just like the one he was still wearing from his late-night trip to Crown Heights. Each held a bible and they were heading, purposefully, towards him.
As they got nearer, Will saw that at least one was out of breath. They were late. This was his chance.
'Don't worry,' said Will as they reached him. 'I think we can still sneak in at the back.'
Sure enough, one opened the door, allowing the whole group to enter - the embarrassment divided by being shared. Will was simply one of the group; he even carried his own bible.
Jammed in at the back, Will tried to survey the room. To his surprise, it was large; the size of a banqueting hall. There must have been more than two thousand people inside. It was hard to tell who they were; all heads were dipped in prayer. Will did not dare raise his eyes.
Finally an amplified voice broke the silence.
'We repent, O Lord, for our moments of doubt. We repent for the pain and hurt we have inflicted on each other, on the planet your Father entrusted to us and on your name. We repent, O Lord, for the centuries of sin that have kept you from us.'
In unison, the congregation replied, 'On this Day of
Atonement, we repent.'
Will looked up, trying to work out who was speaking. A man was standing at the front, but he had his back to the room. It was impossible to see if he was young or old: most of his head was covered with a white skullcap.
'But now, O Lord, the Day of Reckoning is upon us. At long last Man will be held accountable. The great Book of Life is about to be slammed shut. Finally, we are to be judged.' In unison: 'Amen.'
The man turned around: about Will's age, studious looking. Will was surprised. He seemed too young to be a leader and that voice too strong to have come from him.
'Your first people, Israel, strayed from your teaching, O Lord.' The voice was continuing, even though the man Will had identified as the leader was not speaking. Only now did Will take in the huge screen at the front of the room. It bore just two words, black on white: The Apostle. At last Will realized the voice filling this room did not belong to anyone
inside it. Perhaps it was on a tape; maybe it was relayed live from the outside. It had an odd, metallic quality. Either way, the Apostle was nowhere to be seen.
'The first Israel were frightened of your word. It fell to others to honour your covenant. As it is written, "And if you are Christ's, then you are Abraham's offspring, heirs according to the promise.'"
The congregation responded: 'We are Christ's and so we are Abraham's. We are heirs according to the promise.' Will felt himself shudder. So this was the Church of the Reborn Jesus, updated for the twenty-first century. And this was the doctrine that had once captivated his father, Townsend McDougal and who knew how many others. The men in this room - and, Will realized now, they were all men - believed it too. They were the inheritors of the Jews' place in the divine scheme. They had taken the teachings of the Jews as their own.
'But now, Lord, we need your help. We pray for your guidance. We are so close, yet the final knowledge eludes us.' Number thirty-six, thought Will.
'Please bring us to completion, so that we may finally let God's judgment rain upon this benighted earth.'
Will was surveying the room, when a man in the front row swivelled around to do the same. He saw Will, did a small double-take, then looked across the room, made eye contact with someone else and gestured with his head in Will's direction.
Will did not see the hand that reached out and grabbed his neck. Nor did he spot the leg that kicked him below the knee and made him buckle. But as he fell to the ground, he caught a glimpse of the man standing over him. His eyes were so blue, they almost shone.
CHAPTER SIXTY-ONE

Monday, 5.46pm, Manhattan
He had woken up, he knew that, but it was still dark. He
tried to touch his eyes - sending a sharp, searing pain to his
shoulder. His hands were tied. His arms, his legs, his stomach,
they all seemed to have had a layer of tissue removed: he
pictured them as raw, red flesh.
He twitched his eyelids; he could feel something that was
not skin. His eyes were covered by a blindfold. He tried to
speak but his mouth was gagged; he began to cough.
'Take it off.' The voice was firm; in authority. Will started
to retch; the sense-memory of the gag was still choking him.
Finally he spat out a few words.
'Where am I?'
'You'll see.'
'Where the hell am I?'
'Don't you dare shout at us, Mr Monroe. I said, you'll see.'
Will could hear two, maybe three others close by. 'Take him
now.'
'Where am I going?'
'You're going to get what you came here to get. All that
lying seems to have paid off, Mr Tom Mitchell of the Guardian: you're going to get your big interview after all.'
In the darkness, he felt a thick, flat hand at his back: he was being shoved forward. He walked a few paces, then two more hands grabbed his shoulders and pivoted him to the right. Will could feel carpet under his feet. Was he still in the convention centre? How long had the beating lasted? How long had he been unconscious? What if it was night-time? It would be too late! Yom Kippur would be over. In the black of his blindfold, Will imagined the gates of heaven, slamming shut.
'Sir, he's here.'
'Thank you, gentlemen. Let us remove those bonds.' Even in regular speech, this man seemed to be quoting scripture. 'Let's take a good look at you.'
Will felt hands working at his wrists until they were free. Then, at last, the blindfold came off - flooding him with light. He stole a glance at his watch. There was still time. Thank God, thought Will.
'Gentlemen, leave us please.'
In front of Will, at a plain, hotel-room desk, sat the man he had seen earlier in the chapel. His complexion had the earnest shine of an inner-city vicar, the kind of well-meaning do-gooder Will remembered running the Christian Union at Oxford.
'Are you the Apostle?' Will winced. The effort of speaking sent a tremor of pain shooting down his spine.
'I had hoped your suffering would be easing. We took great care to bind your wounds.'
Will suddenly became aware of bandages and plasters covering his arms and legs, even his chest.
'Please accept my apologies for the somewhat heavy handed treatment you had meted out to you. "But those who suffer he delivers in their suffering; he speaks to them in their affliction." The Book of Job.'
'You didn't answer my question. Are you the Apostle?' A modest smile. 'No, I am not the Apostle. I only serve him.' 'I want to speak to him.'
'And why should I let you do that?'
'Because I know what he, what all of you, are up to. And I will go to the police.'
'I'm afraid that is not going to be possible. The Apostle does not meet anybody.'
'Well, in that case, I'm sure the police will be very interested to hear what I know.'
'And what exactly do you know, Mr Monroe?'
The thin-lipped calm of this man infuriated Will. He strode forward, his legs aching with each movement. I'll tell you what I know. I know that the Jews believe there are always thirty-six righteous men in the world. And that so long as those people are alive, then the world is OK. I also know that in the last few days these men have started dying very mysterious deaths. Murdered, to be precise. One in Montana, maybe two in New York. One in London and God knows where else. And I strongly suspect that this group are the ones behind it. That's what I know.'
'I don't think "strongly suspect" will cut much ice, Mr Monroe. Not coming from a man who was in a prison cell himself just a few hours ago.'
How the hell did he know that? Will suddenly thought back to the desk clerk at the seventh precinct and the crucifix around her neck. Maybe this cult had people everywhere. Worse, the vicar was right. Will had nothing firm, just wild speculation. He had no leverage over this guy or the so-called Apostle he served. He felt his shoulders slump.
'But let's say this theory of yours is right. Purely hypothetically, of course.' The man was twirling a pencil between his fingers, letting it fall from one hand to the other. Will wondered if he was nervous. 'Let us say there was such an effort to identify the thirty-six and to ... bring them to their final rest. And let us say that a holy group were involved in this. I strongly suspect, to use your own phrase, that you would have a divine obligation to get out of their way, wouldn't you? I think you would understand the wounds to your flesh as some kind of sign. A warning if you like.' 'Are you threatening to kill me?'
'No, of course not. Nothing so crude. I am threatening you with something much worse.'
Will felt an ice in this man that terrified him. 'Worse?' 'I am threatening you with the reality of the holiest teachings ever given to mankind. The hour of redemption is upon us, Mr Monroe. Salvation will come to those who have brought the hour closer. But those who sought to delay it, to thwart the divine promise, those souls will be tormented for all eternity. A thousand years will be like the passing of just one day, and there will be a thousand more and a thousand more after that. So think carefully, Mr Monroe. Do not stand in the path of the Lord. Do not stand in the way of our Father. Do not aid those who seek to frustrate Him. Try instead to light the way.'
Will was attempting to absorb all this man was telling him when he realized the meeting was over. From behind, he felt hands once again grabbing his arms and replacing his blindfold. He was led out of the room and into what sounded like a service elevator. It shook when it had plumbed what Will calculated was five floors. The doors moved apart and he was shoved out. By the time he had removed the blindfold, to see he was in an underground car park, he was alone.

Upstairs, the man who had spoken to Will a few minutes earlier checked to make sure it had all come through loud and clear on the speaker-phone. 'I think we have given him enough,' he said to the older man at the end of the line. 'Yes, you have done well. Now all we can do is wait.' If Will had heard the voice he would have recognized it. For it was the voice of the Apostle.
CHAPTER SIXTY-TWO

Monday, 7.12pm, Crown Heights, Brooklyn
It had been black; tonight it was white. The synagogue seemed to glow with whiteness, moonlight reflected on snow. There were as many men in here as Will had seen on Friday night, except now they were dressed not in black suits but clothed almost entirely in white.
They wore what seemed to be thin white bathrobes over their dark suits, covering them from their ankles to their shoulders. Instead of the regulation black leather shoes, their feet were now in white trainers. Many of the prayer shawls were all white, as were the skullcaps of those not wearing hats. And they were packed together, a swaying mass of white, a swaying mass of prayer.
This, TO had told him in the briefest of calls from the hospital, was ne'eilah, the concluding segment of what would have been a marathon, day-long service. Tradition demanded that the congregation - denied food or water for the previous twenty-four hours - stand for the duration, in recognition of the gravity of the moment. For this was the final hour of Yom Kippur, the Day of Atonement, the day of reckoning. In this hour, the gates of heaven were closing. Repentance was urgent. As TO described it, Will imagined it: the last minute penitent slipping through the crack in the door, just
as it thundered shut. Those who had not atoned, or left it
too late, were left outside.
All day, this vast hangar of a space had echoed with ancient
incantations, as several thousand voices sang together:
B 'Rosh Hashana yichatayvun . . .
On the first day of the year it is inscribed and on the Day of
Atonement it is sealed. How many shall die and how many shall be
born; who shall live and who shall die, who at the measure of man's
days and who before it. . .
The heaviness of the hour descended on Will as soon as
he walked in. Faces were funeral-serious; acknowledging each
other, but unsmiling. Most men had eyes only for the prayer
books they held as they bobbed back and forth in supplication.
Sha
'arei shamayim petach . . .
Open the gates of heaven . . . Save us, oh God
'Excuse me,' said Will, trying to squeeze his way through
this football crowd of a throng. It was too packed, his progress
was too slow. He needed to get to Rabbi Freilich as quickly
as possible if he was going to have any chance of striking a
bargain. He would reveal the real pursuers of the righteous
men and, in return, they would release Beth. He looked at
his watch. He had perhaps thirty minutes to act. Will had
calculated that he had to move now, while the threat remained
at its highest. If he waited till after Yom Kippur, and if the
thirty-sixth man remained safely hidden, the Hassidim might
conclude that the danger had receded. Will's leverage would
vanish.
He began to ask. 'Excuse me, do you know where Rabbi Freilich is? Ratbbi Freilich?' Most ignored him. Occasionally,
a hand would wave him left or right - while the eyes stayed
fixed on the page ahead or, just as often, firmly shut.
It was like wading through water. All these unfamiliar
faces. He looked at his watch: twenty-three minutes.
Then a hand on his shoulder, sending a bolt of pain through his back. He turned around, his hand balled into a fist in readiness.
'Will?'
'Sandy! You frightened me. Jesus. Sorry.'
'What are you doing here?'
'No time to explain. Listen, I need to speak to Rabbi Freilich. Now.'
Sandy did not reply, but grasped Will's wrist and dragged him first right, then back and finally around the tables where Will had seen the men studying so hard three days earlier. There, rocking backwards and forwards, his eyes closed and facing towards the heavens, was Rabbi Freilich.
'Rabbi? It's Will Monroe.'
The rabbi lowered his head and then opened his eyes, as if from sleep. His face betrayed great weariness. Then, seeing the bruises on Will's face, it registered shock.
'Rabbi, I know who's killing the righteous men. And I know why they're doing it.'
The rabbi's eyes widened.
'I will tell you and I will tell you right away, while you still have time to stop them. But first you have to do something for me. You must take me to my wife. This instant.' Freilich's brow tensed. He took off his glasses and rubbed the bridge of his nose. He looked at his watch: twenty minutes to go. Will could see he was weighing up the right course of action.
'All right,' the rabbi said finally, though he still looked anguished. 'Come with me.'
It was easier to walk out of the shut than it had been to walk through it; the crowd parted in deference to Rabbi Freilich, even if a few curious glances were directed at the rabbi's battered companion.
They emerged into the dusk, the sound of the prayer within filling the air. The rabbi walked fast, turning left at the first corner. Will looked at his watch: fourteen minutes left. Each step hurt his calves and thighs, but he was almost running. Suddenly Rabbi Freilich stopped, turned and faced a small brownstone house.
'Are we here?'
'We are here.'
Will could hardly believe it. It was just around the block from the synagogue; he must have passed this house several times. He had been so close to Beth without even knowing it.
His heart began to pound. So much had happened, it felt as if so much time had passed, since he had seen his wife. The need to hold her tight was so intense, he could barely contain it.
The rabbi knocked on the door. A woman's voice called out, in a language Will did not understand. The rabbi replied with what Will guessed was a password, in Yiddish. Finally, the door opened to reveal a woman in her mid thirties, wearing one of those twin-sets his mother might have worn twenty years ago. Her hair was styled the way all the women of Crown Heights had their hair - which meant it was not hers at all, but a wig. Will let out a sigh; he realized he had expected to see Beth straight away.
'Dos is ihr man. Bring zie ahehr, biteh.' This is her husband. Bring her here, please.
The woman disappeared upstairs. Will could hear doors opening, then footsteps, then the sound of two people coming down.
He looked around, to see a long dark skirt descending the stairs. More disappointment. But as the woman walked lower, he recognized her hips and her posture. And then he saw her face.
He had no control over his eyes. They filled the instant he saw her. Only at that moment did he realize just how deeply he had missed her, how his whole body had ached for her. He jumped the two remaining stairs and clasped her right there, on the staircase. His vision was too blurred to see her face clearly, but as he held her tight he could feel her shake and he knew she was trembling with tears. Neither could say anything. He was squeezing her so hard, but it was not tight enough. He wanted there to be no space between them.
At last he peeled himself away, to look at her properly for the first time. Her eyes met his, with a kind of bashfulness he had not seen before. It was not modesty but something else: it was awe, awe for the enormity of the love they felt for each other.
Finally she spoke, through her tears. 'You see, I told you. I told you I believed in you. Remember the song, Will? I knew you would come and find me. I knew it. And look. Here you are.'
He brought her head to his chest, the two of them clinging fast, unaware of the woman who had opened the door, unaware of Rabbi Freilich standing at the foot of the stairs, unaware that each one of them had shed their own tears at the sight of this couple back, at last, in each other's arms. 'Mr Monroe, I am sorry,' the rabbi began, as if clearing his throat. 'Mr Monroe.'
'Yes,' said Will, using the back of his shirt cuff to wipe the tears from his cheeks. 'Yes, of course.' He turned to Beth. 'Have they told you about all this--'

'She knows nothing,' the rabbi interrupted. 'And there isn't time. Now please.'
Will hardly knew where to start. A tiny Christian sect that believed it had inherited Jewish teaching, all of it, even the doctrine of the lamad vav. How they had picked up on the Messianic fervour of Crown Heights and had started hacking into its computer network, eventually discovering the identities of the righteous men. How they had used their people all over the world to kill them, one by one - timing the murders for the Days of Awe, the Ten Days of Penitence. 'Which,' Will added, 'will be over in twelve minutes.'
'But why?'
'I can't be certain. At the service, this voice, the Apostle,
was explaining it but that's when they started beating me. He and the other man, the younger one, talked about redemption and judgment and salvation, but I couldn't make any
real sense of it. I'm sorry.' Will glanced at Beth and took her hand: she looked completely baffled.
'Can someone tell me what on earth is going on here?' No one said anything. Will gave a small shake of the head. No time. Later. By now Rabbi Freilich was sitting, stroking his beard, deep in thought. 'And you have seen this group with your own eyes?'
'I was with them an hour ago. They're here in New York.
I'm convinced it's them. And I'm convinced they're here to finish the job. The Apostle said that "the final knowledge eludes us". I think they still don't know the name of the
thirty-sixth righteous man. But they are determined to find him - and to kill him. You have to protect him. Where is he? Is he safe?'
'He is in the safest place in the world.'
'You must tell me. Otherwise, we can't be sure they won't find him.'
Rabbi Freilich looked at his watch again and allowed himself a small smile. 'He is right here.'
CHAPTER SIXTY-THREE

Monday, 7.28pm, Crown Heights, Brooklyn
The sounds of ne'eilah were drifting through, not just from the synagogue but from houses along the street - intense prayer at this, the most climactic hour of the holiest day of the year.
'Here?' Will said. 'You mean . ..' He stared at Rabbi Freilich himself.
'No, Will, it's not me.'
Will looked around. There were no other men in the room; no other men in the house. His stomach began to turn over. Was it even possible? 'No, it can't be. You can't mean--' 'No, Will,' said the rabbi, his smile stretching wider. 'It's not you.' And then, with only the slightest tilt of his head, he nodded towards Beth.
'Beth? But I thought the thirty-six were all men. You told me they were all men.

'They are. And your wife is carrying inside her the thirty sixth righteous man. She is pregnant, Will, with a boy.' 'You've made a mistake. We've been trying--' Will stopped himself when he saw Beth's face. She was smiling and crying at the same time.
'It's true, Will. I finally got to use that tester I've carried around in my bag for so long. It's true. We're going to have
a baby.'
'You see,' said Rabbi Freilich. 'Your wife didn't know she
was pregnant. But the Torah knew. The Torah told us. It was
the Rebbe's last message, given to Yosef Yitzhok in his dying
hours. Nobody realized it at the time but his last words led
us to the thirty-sixth verse - from the Book of Genesis, the
book of new beginnings. This one verse - the tenth verse of
the eighteenth chapter - was kept separate from all the others;
not written down in any of the Rebbe's papers or speeches.
No one could have picked it up from our computers. But we
counted off the letters in the usual way and it brought us a
location: your home. At first we assumed that meant the tzaddik was you. But then Yosef Yitzhok looked closer at the
words themselves. That verse describes the moment when
God speaks to Abraham and tells him his wife, Sarah, is to
have a son. She had been childless so long, yet she was to
have a child. Yosef Yitzhok understood what the Rebbe was
telling us. We weren't to look at you, but your wife. We found
the hidden of the hidden, Will. And he is your son.'
Will pulled Beth towards him. But as they hugged, he felt
something dig into his chest through the bandages. He heard
the words of the vicar, repeated in his ears. We've bound your wounds. I hope your pain is easing.
Will ripped open his shirt and tore off the bandages underneath.
He cursed himself. How could he have been so stupid!
He had followed the script exactly as the vicar had laid it out
for him. Try instead to light the way - and that was exactly what
he had done. Sure enough, there it was, concealed between
the bandages: a simple wire, tipped at one end by a microphone
and at the other by a tiny transmitter.
A second, maybe two, passed before they knocked down
the door. As it smashed against the wall, Will saw a blur with
only two distinct features: a pair of laser-blue eyes and the
barrel of a revolver, sheathed in a silencer. Instinct rather
than judgment made Will shield Beth. He stole a glance at his watch. Nine minutes to go.
Rabbi Freilich and the woman of the house froze, petrified. Laser Eyes barely looked at them.
Thank you, William. You did what we asked.'
The voice was not the gunman's, but belonged to the figure behind him, now stepping into the room. The sound of it made Will's brain flood. He realized he was looking at the head of the Church of the Reborn Jesus, the man behind the murder of thirty-five of the most virtuous people on earth, the man who wanted to bring about nothing less than the end of the world. And yet the face he was staring at was one he had known forever.
CHAPTER SIXTY-FOUR

Monday, 7.33pm, Crown Heights, Brooklyn
'Hello, William.'
Will could feel his head pounding. The room seemed to spin. Beth, cowering behind him, grabbed his wrist and gasped. Rabbi Freilich, the woman - everyone was frozen.
'What? What are you ... I don't understand.'
'I don't blame you, Will. How could you possibly understand? I never explained any of this to you. Nor to your
mother either. Not in any way she could understand.' 'But, I don't, I don't...' Will was stammering. Nonsensically he said, 'But you're my father.'
'I am, Will. But I am also the leader of this movement. I am the Apostle. And you have just rendered us the greatest possible service, as I knew you would. You have brought us to the last of the just. For that alone, you have earned your place in the world to come.'
Will was blinking, like a fugitive dazzled by headlights. He could not compute what he was seeing or hearing.
His father. How could his father, a man of the law and justice, be the architect of so many cruel, needless deaths? Did his father, a stern rationalist, really believe all that replacement theology, all that stuff about becoming God's chosen people, about the end of the world? Of course he must believe it:
but how had he hidden it all these years, convincing the
world that he was a man whose only god was the legal code
and the United States Constitution? Had his father really
drawn up a plan to strangle and shoot three dozen good men,
the last best hope of humanity?
For less than a second, an image popped into his head. It
was the face of someone he had not seen in years. It was his
grandmother, serving tea in her garden back in England. The
sun was shining, but all he could focus on was her mouth,
as she uttered the words which had intrigued him at the time and ever since: Your father's other great passion. So this was it. The force that came between his parents, both so young. It
was not another woman nor even his father's dedication to
the law. It was his faith. His fanaticism.
Will had so many questions, but he asked only one.
'So you knew all along, all this time, about Beth?' As he
said it, his arms went backward, shielding his wife from both
sides.
'Oh, I had nothing to do with that, William. That was your
Jewish friends' initiative, theirs alone.' Monroe Sr gestured
towards Rabbi Freilich. 'But once you told me Beth was
kidnapped, I had my suspicions. Once you had tracked her
captors down to Crown Heights, I knew for certain. It took
me a while to work it out. At first, I wondered if it was
somehow meant to stop you working on the story. You were
doing so well - first Howard Macrae, then Pat Baxter - it
seemed you were about to discover everything. But then I
realized that the Hassidim had not taken Beth to stop you.
That would make no sense. They had taken her to stop me. And there could only be one explanation. They needed to
give her shelter because she was shelter - the shelter of the
thirty-sixth righteous man.'
'You knew what was going on, but you didn't help me,
you didn't--'
'No, William. I wanted you to help me. I knew you would not rest until you had found Beth and, in so doing, you would bring us to her. And I was right.'
Will was struggling to stay standing. The room was beginning to turn. His lungs seemed to be emptying of air. He could only manage a few words. 'This is madness.'
'You think this is madness? Do you have even the first idea of what's going on here?'
'I think you're murdering the righteous of the earth.'
'Well, I wouldn't use those words, William. I surely would not. But I want you to look more widely, to see the whole picture.' It was a tone Will had never heard before, or not until an hour ago at any rate. It was the voice of a strict teacher who expected to be obeyed. Whatever electronic voice distortion had been used in the Chapel at the convention centre, it had not concealed this tone: the authority of the Apostle. 'You see, Christianity understands what Judaism never could: what the Jews stubbornly refused to understand. They did not see what was staring them in the face! They believed that, so long as there were thirty-six just souls in the world, all would be well. They took comfort from the idea. They did not realize its true power.'
'And what is its true power?' It was Rabbi Freilich.
'That if these thirty-six men uphold the world, then the opposite must be true! The instant the thirty-six are gone, the world is no more.' Monroe Sr turned back to face his son. 'You see, that didn't interest the Jews. They thought if the world ended, then that would be that. It would all be over: death, destruction, the end of the story. But Christianity teaches us something else, doesn't it William? Something glorious and infinite! For we Christians are blessed with a sacred knowledge: we know that the end of the world spells the final reckoning. And now we discover that all we have to do to make that happen - to make absolutely sure that happens - is to end the lives of thirty-six people.
'If we can do that before the Ten Days of Penitence are complete, the true Judgment Day will be upon us. It's as simple and beautiful as that.'
Will could not quite believe these words were coming from his father's mouth. It was a mismatch, as if he had become a ventriloquist dummy for a madman. With dread, Will realized that maybe this was the real William Monroe. Perhaps the father he had known was the fake. He forced himself to speak. 'And why would you want to bring about "the true Judgment Day"? Why would you want this final reckoning?' 'Oh come on, William. Don't play the fool. Every Sunday school child in Christendom knows the answer to that. It's all there in the Book of Revelation. The end of the world will bring about the return of Christ the Redeemer.'
Will rocked on his heels, as if the words themselves were a physical force. 'So you're trying to bring Christ back into the world by killing thirty-six innocent people?' Will was conscious of the gun pointed directly at him. 'And these men are not just innocent. They are men of remarkable goodness. I know that for a fact.'
'Don't look at me as if I'm some common murderer, William. You must see the genius of this plan. Only thirty six. Just thirty-six men need die. You should read the scriptures, my son. It was assumed that millions would have to lose their lives in the battle of Armageddon, the final conflagration hastening the Second Coming. The dead piled on the dead, oceans of blood. "Every island fled away and the mountains could not be found".
'But this avoids all that. This finds a new way to paradise, via a path neither strewn with bones, nor drenched in tears.' Will's father was closing his eyes. 'This is a just, peaceful way to bring about heaven on earth. Think of it, William: no more suffering, no more bloodshed. The Messianic days, brought about by the sacrifice of only thirty-six souls. That's fewer than die every minute on the roads; fewer than die needlessly in house fires or train wrecks. And those deaths are for nothing. But these - these lives are given so that others, the rest of humanity, may live forever. In paradise. Isn't that what these righteous men would have wanted? 'And these were not brutal murders, William. Each one was carried out with love and respect for the blessed soul within. We gave them anaesthetic so they would feel no pain. Of course, sometimes we had to disguise what we were doing. Sometimes that meant a more violent end than we would have liked.' Will thought of Howard Macrae, stabbed and stabbed again, so that his death might look like a gang killing. 'But we tried to give them a measure of dignity.' Will remembered the blanket laid over Macrae's corpse. The woman he had interviewed a thousand years ago in Brownsville - Rosa - had insisted that the only person who could have done that was the killer himself, and it turned out Rosa was right.
His father was still talking, his voice softer now. 'Imagine it, William. Let yourself imagine it. A world without war. A world of peace and tranquillity, not just for now or next week, but for ever and ever. And you could make all that a reality, not by the sacrifice of millions but by sacrificing three dozen righteous souls. If you could do that, William, wouldn't you do it? Wouldn't you have to do it?'
The Apostle stopped preaching, letting his words hang for a while. Will could feel his head aching. All this talk of the end of days, of the second coming, of redemption and Armageddon, was too vast. It seemed to engulf him. Out of nowhere, an image of his past floated before his eyes. He was six years old, jumping the waves on a beach in the Hamptons, clinging onto his father's hand. But now there was no hand to hold.
Everything rational told Will his father had lapsed into a kind of insanity. How long he had been like this, Will had no idea. Perhaps ever since he started following Jim Johnson at Yale. But insanity was what it was. An international killing
spree to bring back Jesus? It was certifiable.
But another voiced tugged at Will. It certainly sounded
crazy, but the evidence was hard to deny. The Hassidim of
Crown Heights yearned for Messiah; so did Christians the
world over. Could all those hundreds of millions of people
be wrong? A world without violence or disease, a world of
peace and eternal life. His father was a clever, serious man his
intellect was as formidable as any Will had ever known.
If he believed the truth of this prophecy, that this might really
bring about heaven on earth, was it not gross arrogance for
Will to insist he knew better?
Besides, it was too late to save the righteous men themselves.
At least thirty-five of them were dead; that damage had already been done. And the decoding of ancient texts finding
these men by converting letters into numbers and
then numbers into co-ordinates on the map - all that sounded
loopy, but it had been vindicated. Those men were indeed
righteous. Will had seen that for himself. Could he be so sure
that he was right and his father wrong?
Suddenly Laser Eyes was gesturing at his watch, pressing
Monroe Sr to hurry. 'Yes, yes. My friend is right. We have
so little time. But Will, it's important you know something.
How I worked it out, how I understood that Beth is the mother
of a tzaddik.' Will flinched. The word sounded strange, unnatural
in the mouth of his father.
'Because I saw the beauty of it. The pattern. Don't you see
it, Will? None of it is a coincidence, none of it. Not the stories
you wrote for the newspaper, not this.' He gestured towards
Beth. 'Not you, not me. It's not a coincidence at all. The rabbi
here can tell us all about that. You'd call it beshert, wouldn't
you, Rabbi? "What is meant to be." Destiny.
'Time is running out, William. And it's time for you to face
your destiny. You've been chosen for this holiest of roles.
Don't you see how perfect it is? How God wants to end
everything the way it all began? It started with Abraham and the request God made of him. You know what God wanted Abraham to do, don't you William?'
Will swallowed hard. Cold realization seeped through his veins. His tongue felt glued to the roof of his mouth. 'To sacrifice his son.'
'Exactly. To sacrifice the son he and his wife had wanted for so long.' Monroe Sr turned to the blue-eyed man, who suddenly produced a long, gleaming knife. Will's father handled it gingerly. With respect.
'That's why it has to be you, William. Abraham was willing to slay his beloved Isaac merely to prove his faith. But I'm asking you to do this for the sake of every human being that ever lived, including all those now long dead. Let them rise again, William! Let the Kingdom of heaven reign on earth!' Will's nervous system seemed to flood with rage. 'And would you do it. Dad? Would you murder your own son? Would you murder me to bring about the end of the world?' 'Yes I would, William. I would do it in a heartbeat.'
Will needed to sit down, to close his eyes. He felt dizzy. Suddenly, just on the edge of his field of vision, he could see a haze of movement. It was the woman, charging towards Laser Eyes with some kind of stick: Will realized it was a loose wooden upright, pulled from the banister. With barely a turn, the man aimed his gun directly into the woman's face. He shot twice, sending a cascade of blood and bone across the room. The body slumped to the ground. There was a second or two of silence. And then Will could hear and feel Beth behind him, moaning. His own hands were trembling. 'We need to act fast, William. We cannot tolerate any more delays. The Almighty has designated a time and even a person to take this last step. The time is now and the person is you.' Will guessed there could only be a couple of minutes to go. Outside he could hear a chorus of voices, now swelling. Avinu Malkeinu Chatmeinu b 'sefer chaim . . .

All Our Father, Our King, seal us in the book of life . . .
Even muffled by the walls, the intensity of their plea was unmistakable. He did not understand the words, but he knew their meaning. They were praying, in the fifty-ninth minute of the eleventh hour, for salvation.
The blade was glinting now, as bright and fierce as the flame in his father's eye. He spoke calmly, but his eyes were on fire. 'Take this knife, Will and do what is right. Do what God has commanded you. Now is the time.'
Will glanced at the rabbi, who finally spoke, his voice querulous. Will saw his face was splattered with the blood of the woman who had been murdered in front of them. He seemed to be panting. 'Your father is right, Will. This is the moment for you to act. That is what God himself, in his wisdom, has given to us all: free will. He gives us choice. And now this choice is yours. You must decide what to do.'
Will gave one last look at his watch. If he could just spin this out a few moments longer . . .
But the next second took the decision away. With a cry of 'Enough talk!' Laser Eyes aimed his gun towards Will, his eye squinting as he took aim. Will could see that the gunman's real target was not him at all: he was shooting at Beth and the baby she was carrying.
Uselessly he held up his hands to cry, 'No!' But the word barely came out. Instead, Will felt himself shoved from the side. As he toppled over, he heard first one gunshot, then another - and saw the falling, almost flying, figure of Rabbi Freilich. The rabbi had leapt up and pushed Will out of the way, smothering Beth with his own body. The rabbi had made his own decision: to take the bullets aimed at Will's unborn son.
Will seized the moment, charging at Laser Eyes, rushing at his gun hand. The man squeezed the trigger, but he had been knocked off balance: the shot went through the glass of the street-facing window. Will had to get the gun from him. But now he could see his father, the blade bright in his hand, moving towards the corpse of Rabbi Freilich - looking for Beth.
Finding a strength he had never known, Will was now gripping the assassin's gun arm, trying to pull it behind his back: the Nelson arm-lock he had learned at school. The man began to squeal, his hold on the weapon weakening. Will got a finger on the handle, but it was not enough. With one eye, he could see his father had nearly pulled Freilich free: in a matter of seconds, he would be able to plunge the knife into Beth.
Will wanted to pull away from Laser Eyes and stop his father but he knew it would be no good: he would be shot before he had crossed the room. He had to get the gun. He gave one more pull on the man's arm in a desperate attempt to wrench the pistol away, but it did not work. The gun did not fall from his hand. Instead the assassin instinctively tightened his grip, inadvertently squeezing the trigger.
Will heard the noise and looked down at his hands,
expecting to see them blown away. He was covered in blood but, he realized a second later, it was not his own. Laser Eyes had shot himself in the back.
Now there was a clear line of sight to his father, who had briefly turned away from his task at the sound of the gunshot. For a moment, Will caught his eye. He turned back, his face flushed, as he finally shoved Freilich's lifeless body to one side. He raised his knife high, ready for the plunge into Beth's stomach.
Will flew at him, the same rugby-tackle motion his father had taught him perhaps twenty years earlier. It knocked the older man down, away from Beth but still with the knife in his hand. Now Will was on top of him, staring straight into his face.
'Get off me, Will,' he rasped, his neck muscles engorged. 'We have so little time.' His father's strength shocked him. It took a supreme effort to keep his arms pinned to the floor; his own wrists were straining. Monroe Sr's neck was swelling with the effort to throw Will off. And still he kept the knife in his hands.
Suddenly, Will felt a new pressure. His father was using his knees to spring Will off him and it was working; Will was being pushed back. With one more kick, he threw Will off and jumped to his feet. Still with knife in hand, he took three purposeful strides towards Beth, who was now backed against the side wall.
Will could see his father draw back his hand, ready at last to stab Beth's womb. But Beth grabbed Monroe Sr's wrist with both hands, using all her strength to push it back. The knife hovered for a second - held in suspension by the equal strength of a true believer's desire to bring about heaven on earth and a mother's determination to protect her unborn child. The two forces were a match for each other. Will realized he had seen this fire in his wife's eyes once before: it was the same feral determination he had glimpsed in his dream. Then too Beth had been defending a child from terrible harm.
Now the man's greater muscle began to show. His hand was advancing, the knife cutting wild arcs in the air, just in front of Beth's belly. The blade made contact - scoring a deep gash in the cloth of her skirt.
Will was filled with a sudden hot burst of adrenalin, the adrenalin of the truly desperate. Staggering towards the slumped body of Laser Eyes, he uncurled the assassin's fingers, still rigidly gripping the weapon, and wrenched the gun away. Standing parallel with Beth, he aimed precisely at his father's head and squeezed the trigger.
EPILOGUE

Six months later
Will always liked the office ritual of a cake. A group email would go around the office, or at least one part of it, announcing that someone was marking a birthday, celebrating a landmark anniversary or, most often, leaving.
These little ceremonies - a speech from the department head, a response from the honoree - always gave Will a warm pleasure. Mainly it was because he was still new enough to the Times to enjoy the sense of membership of a grand old institution - and these occasions ladled out that sentiment by the bucketload.
'Farewell to Terry Walton. 4.45 at the Metro Desk.' It hardly mattered that Will was no fan of Walton's; it would still be fun. Not that he had seen him much in the six months since everything happened; Walton had scarcely been around. Maybe he was winding down for his retirement or the job running a local paper in Florida or whatever else it was he was going to do next.
Six months. It felt longer. Everything about that week felt long ago, even far away - as if it had happened on a distant planet or in a different age.
He had had so many hard conversations, the hardest with Tom, at his bedside, explaining why exactly he had taken a
bullet. There was no good reason, Tom had concluded, coolly
logical even in the intensive care ward. Just as there was no
good reason why the bullet had missed his heart by a few
inches, lodging in his shoulder bone instead. 'If I'd been
shorter, I'd be dead,' Tom had said, woozily. 'Or do I mean
taller? You see what I mean? There is no logical reason for
any of it. We live in the absence of reason.' After that, he
had fallen back to sleep.
TO and Will visited him often in those first few days, but
neither of them was guest of honour. That place was reserved
for Beth. When she walked in, Tom managed a wide beam,
rather than a watery smile. She bent over for a mini-hug and
told him he had helped save her life and the life of her child.
He said: 'Any time.'
Will had had to recount the events of that night and that
week over and over again. First to detectives and lawyers,
explaining that he had killed his father in defence of himself,
his wife and his unborn son - an account that was soon born out by forensic examination of the house in Crown Heights
and subsequent inquiries into the Church of the Reborn
Jesus. The police could also see the terrible fate that had
befallen Rabbi Freilich and Rachel Jacobson. Both Will and
Beth spent hours reliving that dreadful night, giving statement
after statement, until they were exhausted.
When they were on their own, Beth described how she
had been well treated, how Mrs Jacobson had mothered her
in that house - constantly apologizing for her captivity, promising
that soon all would be explained. Beth had been first
scared, then furious and finally desperate to get word to Will
that she was safe. But, she said, she never once doubted that
she would survive. The Hassidim swore they would not harm
her and for a reason she had never quite understood, she
believed them.
So they went together, Will and Beth, to the funerals of
Rabbi Freilich and Mrs Jacobson which, following Jewish custom, were held quickly, as soon as the coroner released their bodies. There were huge crowds, perhaps three thousand for Rabbi Freilich, a mighty show of collective grief. Only then did Will appreciate Freilich's position among the Hassidim: he had been their surrogate father, guiding them ever since they had lost their Rebbe.
A handful of people at the funeral approached Beth, making a small bow of their head as they came close. Will understood they were showing respect not to her or him, but to their unborn child, destined to be one of the lamad vav. Will saw a familiar face and he headed over immediately. 'Rabbi Mandelbaum, I need to ask you something.' 'I think I know what you want to ask, William. Perhaps you'll allow me to give you some advice. Don't think too deeply about what we discussed that night. It would not be good for you. Or your child.'
'But--'

'It does seem as if the Rebbe understood that your son will
have a special responsibility, that he is to be one of the righteous
men. That is a great honour. But the other matter we
discussed, I think this is best left alone.'
'I'm not sure I understand.'
'I told you that our tradition suggests one of the lamad vav is the candidate to be the Messiah. If the time is right, if
mankind is worthy, then that person will be the Messiah. If
the time is not right, they will live and die like anyone else.'
'But in the last hours of the Day of Atonement, the child
my wife is carrying was the only one left. All the other righteous
men had been killed--'
'But now that moment has passed - and the world is still
standing. Which means there are thirty-six in the world once
more. A new group of tzaddikim. Any one of them could be
the candidate.' Rabbi Mandelbaum gazed deeply into Will's
eyes. 'Any one of them.'
'You see,' said Beth, drawing her husband away, 'we don't have to dwell on all that. There are other things to think about.' She had been urging Will not to focus on the distant future but on the immediate past - specifically his father. For she knew that Will would be experiencing a triple trauma. First, he had to cope with the shock of what he had done. Whatever Freud said about CEdipal fantasies, to kill one's own father was to shake the psyche to its foundations. Beth warned her husband that he would need years to absorb what he had been through. Second, she said, he was experiencing a son's grief. No matter how insane the circumstances, Will had lost a parent and he needed to acknowledge that. But third, and perhaps hardest, he had to mourn the father he thought he had known. That man would have been lost even if William Monroe Sr had lived.
For that man had been a fiction. To the world he had presented a front - the secular judge, the ultimate man of reason - so that no one would ever suspect him of his true beliefs or real intentions. It was a sustained lie, one that was doubtless plotted years in advance. It had cost him dearly, almost certainly denying him the seat on the Supreme Court he coveted so badly. Or, Will thought now, maybe that ambition too was a fraud. Probably such earthly goals meant
nothing to his father. He dreamed, it seemed, only of heaven. In the days that followed that night in Crown Heights, there was a series of arrests across the globe; missionaries and church activists charged from Darfur to Bangkok - all with connections back to the Church of the Reborn Jesus. The suspect in the Howard Macrae case turned out to be a local pastor who had known the victim for years. In Darwin, Australia the chaplain of a hospice was charged with murdering an aboriginal care assistant. In South Africa, police arrested a former glamour model who had joined the sect once she left the industry: she had killed an AIDS researcher she had picked up on the beach.
It turned out that only a relatively small group around the man the newspapers now referred to as the Apostle knew of his plot against the righteous men. The movement's new leadership announced that the doctrine of replacement theology would be 'under review', and that they hoped all their members would soon come into line with the 'majority of the modern Christian family who have only respect and reverence for the validity of Judaism as a path to God'. Townsend McDougal issued a statement, declaring that he had cut his links with the Church of the Reborn Jesus nearly a quarter of a century earlier - and that he had no idea that Monroe Sr had maintained his secret involvement. He sent Will a note, with condolences, an apology for the suspension
- 'a hasty decision' - and a promise that his desk was waiting for him whenever he was ready.
Will looked at the piles of paper in front of him, still unsorted. The light was flashing on his phone: two messages. 'Hi, Will, it's Tova. Looking forward to tonight. Tell me if there's anything you want me to bring.'
He had forgotten; TO was coming over for dinner. Beth had it all mapped out: she had invited some gorgeous, single doctor from the hospital and two other decoy singles. Will had opposed the move: far too blatant, he had said.
He wondered how TO would handle such a set-up. Her life had changed as much as his that week. She had been the first person, after the police, to come to the house in the minutes after Yom Kippur was over. She had been calling and texting Will frantically and when she got no response, she had headed straight for Crown Heights. She followed the flashing lights. Later she told Will: 'I know you were determined to get your wife to meet me, but there must have
been an easier way than that.'
Will had told her to go home and get some rest, but she said no. 'There are some things I need to do here,' she said, as they hugged goodbye on the street corner. 'Some people I need to see.' Surrounded by police and flashing red lights, Will wished her luck.
'Oh and Will?'
'Yes?'
'Can I ask you to do something for me? I've been thinking. I'm not really Tova Chaya any more. And TO doesn't really sound like me either. Too much like a disguise. So. Will you call me Tova?'
Six months ago.
'OK, people, listen up.' It was Harden, snapping the newsroom to attention and Will out of his daydream. 'It's time to
boot out of the door one of our number, so please gather
round in loving memory of Terence Walton!'
Soon thirty or so people were huddled around the Metro
desk as Harden offered a galloped tour of Walton's career on the Times.
'Well, you gotta hand it to this guy for sheer versatility.
He's done just about every job on this paper: police reporter, City Hall reporter, business desk, National editor, Delhi correspondent
- you name it, Walton's done it. Would you believe
that for two years, this guy edited the puzzle section at the back of the magazine? Even wrote the goddamned crossword clues. Well, now he has decided that he has had enough of our fair city and is going to share his talents with the good people of India. He's off to train journalists there so that they can pick up all his bad habits. But we're grateful to him and so, let's all raise a paper plate laden with cheap cake and say, To Terry!'
'To Terry!' they chorused, followed rapidly by the demand for a speech. Walton obliged with a roll call of former
colleagues, many long since gone and unknown to Will, and a few barbed jokes at the management's expense. Finally, he began to wrap it up.
'Well, if my Yale education taught me anything, it's better a short address than a long lecture. And, as the good book says, "brothers, time is short". I fly to Delhi this very night.
So I'll conclude. It's been a pleasure and a privilege . . .'
The room broke into warm applause; even Amy Woodstein
allowed herself a little cheer - though maybe that was just
relief to see Walton gone. Will tucked into his cake, shook
hands and wished his desk-neighbour all the best.
Maybe it was the reference to Yale that did it, but five
minutes later Will was seized by a thought. He sat back at
the computer, still nibbling at the icing on the carrot cake.
He typed in Church of the Reborn Jesus, scrolled and clicked until he found the talkboard with the picture showing the
Rev Jim Johnson and his acolytes.
Now Will's eye went straight to his father. So serious, even
then. Will's eye shot across to Townsend McDougal and then,
methodically, started at the right of the back row. Face, face,
face . . .
He increased the magnification on the image. There he
was, in the middle row, four away from McDougal. With
long, hippy hair he was almost unrecognizable: Will had
certainly glided right past him the first time he had looked.
But the supercilious smile was unchanged: Terence Walton.
Suddenly a shiver ran across Will's shoulders. He could
hear Walton's voice from just a few moments ago: As the good
book says, 'brothers, time is short'. He knew it was familiar: it
was the message the texter had sent when Will was in jail,
from Paul's letter to the Corinthians.
Will sat back in his seat, a wry smile breaking on his lips.
What had Harden said? Walton had done every job on the
paper, including a stint editing the puzzle section: he even
wrote crossword clues.
I'll be damned,' said Will out loud. It was him.'
A founder member of the Church of the Reborn Jesus with
a knack for riddles: suddenly Will had no doubt. Don't stop; the ten proverbs; Just men we are, our number few. Walton
knew it all and wanted to pass it on. He must have been
scared. Too scared to tip anybody off directly. If the Apostle
or his heavies had discovered his betrayal, they would not
have hesitated to kill him. No wonder he had had to resort
to code.
But why Will? Why had he picked him to receive all those
clues? He must have seen Will's stories in the paper and realized
he was onto the killing of the righteous men. Don't stop. It did not refer to finding Beth; it referred to the story of the lamad vav. Don't stop at Macrae and Baxter: move's to come. No wonder he had stolen Will's notebook: he wanted to know
what Will knew. He might even have been keeping it safe.
Then a doubt surfaced. If Walton was the informant, a mole
inside his father's circle, why had he taunted Will after the
Macrae story? Surely he should have encouraged him?
And then Will remembered their conversation after his
story had hit the front page. He had bullied him about beginner's luck: Very hard to pull off that trick twice, he had said. And yet that was exactly what Will had done, by recounting
the life and death of Pat Baxter. Walton had all but drawn a
map - and Will had followed it.
Once he saw the Baxter piece, Walton must have realized Will was the man to expose the Church of the Reborn Jesus. To expose his own father. Or had Walton's plan been hatched even earlier; had he even engineered the Baxter story? What
had Harden said when he despatched Will out west? scraped the bottom of the barrel and offered them Walton, who was all set
to go, but now, at the eleventh hour, he's cried off with some lameassed excuse. Was it even possible? Had Walton ducked the
assignment, knowing that Will would go instead - and walk
right into the Baxter story? And that flyer for the Church of
the Reborn Jesus, mysteriously lying on Will's desk. Had
Walton put it there?
Will would ask him direct, right now. He swivelled around
to see the next desk even clearer than usual. Will called to
Amy. 'Hey, where's Terry?'
'He's already gone. Straight to the airport apparently.'
It was too late. Will slumped back into his seat, deflated.
He would have liked to thank Walton and to ask him a
hundred questions. Now he would never have the chance.
'Shame, I wanted to say goodbye properly.'
'Didn't he leave you a gift? He gave me a book,' she said, holding it up. 'The Juggler: How to Balance Work and Family. Thanks a lot, Terry.'
Will had not spotted it until then: a neatly-wrapped box,
balanced on the partition between their desks.
He brought it down and tore off the paper, to reveal a
brown carton, no more than six inches square. He opened
the lid: bubble wrap. Underneath, Will pulled out what seemed
to be a desk-toy, perhaps a gyroscope. It was only once he
got it fully out of the box that Will understood what Walton had given him. It was a model of Atlas, the statue outside Rockefeller
Center. A man carrying the universe on his shoulders, holding
up the world. There was a note:
An ancient Jewish teaching holds that to save a life is to save the
whole world. I know you did one; you may even have done both.
Good luck, T.
Will put it down on his desk, next to the Saddam Hussein
snowdome he had stolen from Walton and never returned.
It was not yet on the Woodstein scale, but Will was developing
his own, personalized corner of office real estate. Pride
of place went to a framed photograph of Beth, now showing
the full curve of pregnancy. Next to it was a picture of Will
and his mother. And next to that was an empty space, ready
for a picture of the boy he already loved.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS

Any book, I have discovered, is a collaborative effort and this
one is no exception. I owe thanks to a variety of people who
guided me through what was a new and complex process.
First thanks must go to the Hassidic community of Crown
Heights, Brooklyn. The late Gershon Jacobson and his wife
Sylvia welcomed me into their home during a reporting assignment
in 1991 - and made me welcome again nearly fifteen
years later. Their guidance, along with the warmth and
wisdom of their sons Rabbi Simon and Rabbi Yosef Yitzhok,
was vital. Along with Rabbi Gershon Overlander of London,
they ushered me into what was an entirely new world - one
I continue to admire greatly. I am also indebted to Dr Tali
Loewenthal, who acted as tutor on some of the finer points of Jewish and Hassidic doctrine. It goes without saying that
any errors on this score are mine alone.
I owe a debt, too, to the staff of The New York Times who
showed me some of the workings of that great newspaper.
Warren Hoge was especially generous, enlisting the essential
help of Bill Keller and Craig Whitney as well as the editors
of the Metro and Foreign sections. Lest there be any confusion, The New York Times of the Righteous Men is a work of
the imagination.
Specific guidance came from Alex Bellos and Hilary Cottam on life in a Latin American slum, Peter Wilson on Australia and Stephen Bates on the Church. The Yiddish appears courtesy of the redoubtable Anna Tzelniker. Lee de-Beer literally walked the streets of New York on my behalf, tracing some of the more awkward steps of Will Monroe and his pursuers. Eleanor Yadin and her team at the New York Public Library could not have been more helpful. Sharyn Stein proved a crucial source on both the law and police procedure of New York.
Tom Cordiner and Steven Thurgood allowed me to dip into their enormous expertise on computing and technology. Monique El-Faizy deserves special thanks for advising on matters New York, spotting details both large and small. Kate Cooper at Curtis Brown proved a zealous advocate of the book - and a perceptive reader. Chris Maslanka showed why he is the king of the puzzlemasters, coming up with one ingenious riddle after another to confound Will and TO. I am in awe of his skill.
My parents read early drafts and gave sage advice as well as moral support: their influence can be spotted in several places in this book. My in-laws, Jo and Michael, once again allowed me to turn their Suffolk home into a writer's retreat
- while Michael proved an eagle-eyed reader. A special mention should go to my late great aunt, Yehudit Dove, whose very real righteousness inspired this story.
At Harper Collins, Jane Johnson proved herself to be a model editor, worthy of her towering reputation. Not only did she root for this book but, backed by the hugely able Sarah Hodgson, improved it at every stage. She is a writer's editor and I was lucky to work with her.
Three people should be singled out. Jonathan Cummings did more than just research; he devoted boundless brainpower and energy to this project. He is a genuine comrade.
I owe Jonny Geller a great deal. He is not just a world-class agent but a true friend, a man who believed a late-night
conversation could become a novel - and whose belief, support
and insight never flags. It is no exaggeration to say this book
would not have happened without him.
Finally my wife Sarah shared in the excitement of this
project from the very beginning. She managed not only to
be a wonderful mother to our children, Jacob and Sam, but to provide shrewd advice, a fine eye and constant love.
Marriage is one of the themes of this book - and I am loving
every day of ours.
AUTHOR'S NOTE

The Righteous Men is a work of fiction - but it is rooted in several
key facts. First, the legend of the lamad vav, of thirty-six exceptional
individuals whose virtue upholds the world, is a thread
that runs through Jewish tradition. The books and essays Rabbi
Mandelbaum cites in his conversation with Will are real - and,
for those whose interest has been piqued, worth consulting.
The obvious starting point is Gershom Scholem's The Messianic
Idea in Judaism (Schocken, New York, 1971), especially the
chapter, The Tradition of the Thirty-Six Hidden Just Men'.
Scholem tells the story recounted by Mandelbaum, one
which appears in the Palestinian Talmud and dates back to
the third century. It speaks of the rabbi who notices that,
when a certain man is in the congregation, the community's
prayers for rain get answered. That man is known as
Pentakaka, a Greek-derived name whose literal meaning is
five sins: he rents out whores, he even dances and drums in front of them. And yet when a woman offers to become a
whore in order to raise bail for her jailed husband, Pentakaka
prefers to sell his own bed and blanket rather than see her
suffer that indignity. In other words, Howard Macrae is not
entirely an invention: his act of righteousness is documented
- and at least 1700 years old.
Jean-Claude Paul's good deed in Haiti - creating a secret chamber that preserves the anonymity of both the givers and receivers of charity - has even deeper roots. The 'chamber of secrets', as it was known, existed in the Temple of Solomon which stood, as Judaism's holiest site, in Jerusalem from 953 BC until its destruction in 586 BC. It was the physical embodiment of a core principle: that the act of giving should entail neither glory nor humiliation for those involved, but should instead be a simple act of justice.
It is also a matter of fact that there is a large Hassidic
community in Crown Heights, one that still mourns for the Rebbe it lost a few years ago and which continues its outreach efforts across the globe. The Rebbe of the Lubavitch or Chabad movement was a remarkable figure, whom some of his followers hailed as the Messiah. Some still do.

Finally, replacement theology and supersessionism are no inventions. Many Christians do indeed hold that the Jews have forfeited their role as the chosen people, a status which has been passed on to those who follow Jesus Christ. The Wikipedia entry Will reads on the topic is not made up but quoted directly.
That much is fact. As for the rest, who can know for sure?